Investigating subnucleonic structures via new measurements of incoherent J/ψ photoproduction in ultra-peripheral Pb--Pb collisions with ALICE

Basic Information

• Paper ID: 2510.11120
• Title: Investigating subnucleonic structures via new measurements of incoherent J/ψ photoproduction in ultra-peripheral Pb--Pb collisions with ALICE
• Author: Vendulka Humlová (on behalf of the ALICE Collaboration)
• Classification: nucl-ex, hep-ex
• Publication Date: October 13, 2025 (arXiv preprint)
• Paper Link: https://arxiv.org/abs/2510.11120

Abstract

Ultra-peripheral heavy-ion collisions provide a unique environment for studying nuclear gluon structure through photon-induced reactions. In particular, incoherent photoproduction of the J/ψ vector meson is sensitive to event-by-event fluctuations of gluon fields at the nucleon and subnucleonic scales. This paper reports new measurements of incoherent J/ψ production by the ALICE collaboration in Pb-Pb collisions at √sNN = 5.02 TeV, with differential analysis as functions of photon-nucleus energy and Mandelstam-|t|. At low |t|, the cross section rises with increasing photon-nucleus energy, while at larger |t|, the growth is suppressed relative to the low |t| trend. This measurement represents the first study of incoherent photoproduction at the LHC simultaneously as a function of both WγPb,n and |t|.

Research Background and Motivation

Core Questions

This research aims to address the experimental verification of gluon saturation phenomena in quantum chromodynamics (QCD), particularly regarding gluon density behavior in the small Bjorken-x region.

Significance of the Problem

1. Theoretical Expectations: Deep inelastic scattering experiments indicate that in the small Bjorken-x region, the parton structure of hadrons is dominated by gluons, whose density increases approximately as a power law with energy.
2. Saturation Phenomenon: QCD predicts that this growth will eventually be balanced by gluon recombination—the saturation phenomenon.
3. Experimental Challenge: Finding clear experimental signals of saturation is one of the major challenges in high-energy nuclear physics and a core motivation for future facilities such as the Electron-Ion Collider.

Limitations of Existing Approaches

• Traditional coherent photoproduction processes primarily probe average nuclear density
• Lack of sensitivity to event-by-event fluctuations at the nucleon and subnucleonic levels
• Previous absence of multiple differential measurements simultaneously as functions of energy and momentum transfer

Research Motivation

Incoherent J/ψ photoproduction provides a unique probe:

• Sensitive to gluon density
• Capable of probing event-by-event fluctuations
• Through the Fourier transform relationship between Mandelstam-|t| and impact parameter, enables study of the transverse spatial distribution of gluons at different scales

Core Contributions

1. First Multiple Differential Measurement: First measurement at the LHC of incoherent J/ψ photoproduction simultaneously as a function of photon-nucleus energy (WγPb,n) and Mandelstam-|t|.
2. Discovery of New Physical Phenomena: Observation of suppression of cross section growth at high |t| relative to low |t|.
3. Experimental Evidence for Gluon Saturation: Provides experimental evidence for gluon saturation effects at the subnucleonic scale.
4. Model Validation: Systematic comparison of different theoretical models, finding that saturation-based models better describe the data than traditional shadowing models.

Detailed Methodology

Experimental Setup

Data Acquisition

• Collision System: Pb-Pb ultra-peripheral collisions
• Collision Energy: √sNN = 5.02 TeV
• Data Sample: Integrated luminosity of approximately 533 μb⁻¹ collected in 2018

Detector Systems

1. Muon Spectrometer:
   • Coverage in pseudorapidity region -4 < η < -2.5
   • Includes hadronic absorber, five tracking stations in a dipole magnetic field, and two trigger stations
   • Used for reconstruction of J/ψ → μ⁺μ⁻ decay
2. Zero Degree Calorimeters (ZDCs):
   • Detect forward neutrons in the beam direction
   • Classify photon emission direction through neutron detection (0nXn or Xn0n)
   • Distinguish low-energy (WγPb,n ~ 20, 30 GeV) and high-energy (WγPb,n ~ 633 GeV) interactions
3. Veto Detectors:
   • V0A and AD scintillator detectors
   • Provide veto against hadronic activity, ensuring selection of diffractive processes

Kinematic Reconstruction

Calculation of key kinematic variables:

• Four-momentum Transfer: |t| ≈ p²T (in the analyzed kinematic region)
• Photon-nucleus Center-of-Mass Energy: W²γPb,n = MJ/ψ√sNN e±y
• Where MJ/ψ is the J/ψ mass, √sNN is the nucleon-nucleon center-of-mass energy, and y is the rapidity

Signal Extraction Method

1. Mass Spectrum Fitting: Unconstrained extended likelihood fit to the dimuon invariant mass distribution
2. Signal Function: Bilateral Crystal Ball function
3. Background Function: Exponential function
4. Contamination Correction: Determination of coherent J/ψ and ψ(2S) feed-down contributions through transverse momentum distribution fitting

Experimental Results

Main Findings

Energy Dependence

• The incoherent J/ψ photoproduction cross section rises with increasing energy
• At high |t|, the cross section growth is suppressed relative to low |t| values

Quantitative Analysis

Measurements performed in three |t| intervals:

• 0.09 < |t| < 0.36 GeV²
• 0.36 < |t| < 0.81 GeV²
• 0.81 < |t| < 1.44 GeV²

Suppression Effect

At WγPb,n = 633 GeV, the cross section ratio between the highest and lowest |t| intervals is 0.52 ± 0.13, deviating from unity by more than three standard deviations, demonstrating significant reduction in cross section growth when probing smaller spatial gluon configurations.

Theoretical Model Comparison

Shadowing Model

The shadowing-based model by Guzey et al., while able to reproduce high-energy coherent J/ψ production, fails to describe the incoherent data.

Saturation Models

Two saturation-based models provide better descriptions:

1. Energy-Dependent Hot Spot Approach by Cepila et al.:
   • Suppression arises from increased overlap of gluon hot spots at high energy
   • Reduces the variance of fluctuations
2. Approach by Mäntysaari et al.:
   • Predicts decreasing power-law exponent with increasing |t|
   • Results in slower cross section growth
   • Provides better description of the data

Physical Significance and Discussion

Evidence for Gluon Saturation

The experimental results indicate that gluon saturation plays an important role when probing smaller spatial scales, providing crucial insights for understanding QCD behavior in the high-energy limit.

Spatial Resolution

Through the Fourier transform relationship between Mandelstam-|t| and impact parameter, this measurement enables study of the transverse spatial distribution of gluons at different scales, providing a new experimental tool for understanding the internal structure of nucleons.

Conclusions and Prospects

Main Conclusions

1. First realization of multiple differential measurements of incoherent J/ψ photoproduction
2. Observation of suppression of cross section growth at high |t|
3. Provision of experimental evidence for gluon saturation effects
4. Saturation-based theoretical models better describe the data than traditional shadowing models

Future Prospects

1. Statistical Enhancement: Increased statistics expected during LHC Run 3 and 4
2. Detector Upgrades: New forward detectors (such as FoCal) will extend coverage
3. Smaller x Values: Extension of studies to smaller Bjorken-x values
4. Continued Tool: Incoherent production will continue to serve as a powerful tool for studying fluctuations in nuclear gluon fields

In-Depth Evaluation

Strengths

1. Experimental Innovation: First double differential measurement, representing an important technical breakthrough
2. Significant Physical Implications: Provides direct experimental evidence for gluon saturation, a fundamental QCD phenomenon
3. Rigorous Methodology: Systematic error analysis and comparison of multiple theoretical models
4. High Data Quality: Use of advanced ALICE detector systems ensures measurement reliability

Limitations

1. Statistical Precision: Current data statistics limit observation of finer structures
2. Theoretical Uncertainties: Predictions from different saturation models still show discrepancies
3. Systematic Errors: Systematic uncertainties such as muon trigger efficiency remain a major limiting factor

Impact

1. Disciplinary Contribution: Provides important experimental data for the intersection of nuclear and particle physics
2. Guidance for Future Facilities: Offers important reference for physics objectives of future facilities such as the Electron-Ion Collider
3. Advancement of Theory: Promotes further development of QCD saturation theory

Applicable Scenarios

This methodology is particularly suitable for:

• Gluon structure studies in high-energy nuclear physics experiments
• Experimental verification of QCD nonlinear effects
• Probing the spatial structure inside nucleons

References

The paper cites multiple important theoretical and experimental works, including deep inelastic scattering results from HERA, various QCD theoretical predictions, and related measurements from the ALICE collaboration, providing a solid theoretical and experimental foundation for this research.