Should it really be that hard to model the chirality induced spin selectivity effect?

Basic Information

• Paper ID: 2510.11240
• Title: Should it really be that hard to model the chirality induced spin selectivity effect?
• Author: Jonas Fransson (Uppsala University)
• Classification: cond-mat.mes-hall cond-mat.str-el
• Publication Date: October 14, 2025
• Paper Link: https://arxiv.org/abs/2510.11240

Abstract

The chirality-induced spin selectivity (CISS) effect remains a theoretical modeling challenge. While numerous studies over the past decade have been based on independent electron models, these models have completely failed to reproduce experimental results. The key lesson from these efforts is that correct modeling must incorporate electron-electron interactions. When discussing this phenomenon, one inevitably encounters questions regarding Onsager reciprocity and time-reversal symmetry, and whether the observations violate these fundamental concepts or whether we have failed to identify factors that render these concepts redundant in this context. The experimental fact is that electrons become spin-polarized for some reason when traversing chiral molecules. The experimental apparatus is sufficiently simple to permit effective modeling; however, overcoming the major failures of theoretical efforts to date and establishing a theory based on microscopic modeling appears to be a challenge.

Research Background and Motivation

Importance of the Problem

1. Critical Role in the Origin of Life: The CISS effect may have played a crucial role in the homochiral origin of life on Earth, particularly in the chiral purification of RNA precursor molecules, ribose-aminooxazoline (RAO), through interaction with magnetite (Fe₃O₄).
2. Broad Application Prospects: The effect has significant application value in electrocatalysis, oxygen reduction and oxygen evolution reactions, stabilization of molecular spin configurations, spin current effects, and enhancement of thermal and magnetic stability of ferromagnetic metals.

Limitations of Existing Approaches

1. Failure of Independent Electron Models: Theoretical research based on independent electron models over the past decade has completely failed to reproduce experimental results, indicating that simple non-interacting theories are insufficient to capture the CISS effect.
2. Challenges to Fundamental Physical Principles: The effect appears to violate fundamental physical concepts such as Onsager reciprocity and time-reversal symmetry, raising questions about the applicability of these principles in this context.
3. Terminological Confusion: The use of the term "spin polarization" has caused confusion, as transport measurements actually reflect anisotropic response to external magnetization reservoirs, more closely resembling magnetoresistance than true spin polarization.

Core Contributions

1. Clarified the Necessity of Electron Interactions: The paper emphasizes the importance of including electron-electron interactions for correct modeling of the CISS effect, providing an important summary of theoretical failures over the past decade.
2. Proposed a Theoretical Framework Based on Vibration-Assisted Interactions: Established a model incorporating electron-nuclear vibration coupling, demonstrating how the CISS magnetoresistance effect can arise through interactions.
3. Revealed the Mechanism of Time-Reversal Symmetry Breaking: Argued that at the molecular-reservoir interface, the combined action of electron interactions and environmental coupling can spontaneously break time-reversal symmetry.
4. Established Connection Between Microscopic Theory and Macroscopic Phenomena: Through microscopic modeling, explained the experimentally observed CISS magnetoresistance phenomenon, providing a theoretical foundation for understanding spin-selective transport in chiral molecules.

Detailed Methodology

Theoretical Model Construction

Molecular Hamiltonian

The author constructed a helical molecular model with M lattice sites at position coordinates:

r_m = (a cos φ_m, a sin φ_m, c_m)

where a is the radius, φ_m = 2π(m-1)/(M-1), and c_m = c(m-1)/(M-1).

The single-electron Hamiltonian is:

H₀ = Σ_{m,s=±1} (-t₀δ_{m,m+s} + iλ₀v_m^(s)·σδ_{m,m+2s})

Here t₀ is the nearest-neighbor hopping, λ₀ is the next-nearest-neighbor mixing rate, and v_m^(s) describes curvature-dependent spin-orbit coupling.

Electronic Correlations

Electronic correlations are introduced through electron-vibration coupling:

H₁ = Ψ† Σ_ν H_ν Q_ν Ψ + H_vib

where Q_ν = b_ν + b_ν† is the nuclear displacement operator, and H_vib contains harmonic oscillator and anharmonic correction terms.

Coupling to Reservoirs

The molecule couples to left and right reservoirs through the interface Hamiltonian:

H_T = Σ_{k∈L} ψ_k† u_{k1} ψ₁ + Σ_{k∈R} ψ_k† u_{kM} ψ_M + H.c.

Key Physical Mechanisms

Formation of Spin Density Wave States

Through perturbation theory, the author derives the charge and spin density at lattice site 1:

⟨n₁⟩ = ⟨n₁⟩^(0) - (128/Γ_L) p_L·v₁^(+) / (1-p_L²)² Σ_ν T_ν coth(βω̃_ν/2)

⟨s₁⟩ ≈ ⟨s₁⟩^(0) + (32/Γ_L) (v₁^(+)/(1-p_L²) + (p_L·v₁^(+)/(1-p_L²)²)p_L) Σ_ν T_ν coth(βω̃_ν/2)

Time-Reversal Symmetry Breaking

The key physical insight comes from the coupling between spin-orbit coupling and level broadening:

(Γ_χ/2) v_m^(s)·σ (σ₀ + p_χ·σ) = (Γ_χ/2) v_m^(s)·(p_χ + σ)

This coupling term contains two important contributions:

1. Chirality-induced Zeeman splitting: v_m^(s)·σ
2. Dependence on reservoir spin polarization: v_m^(s)·p_χ

Experimental Verification and Predictions

Computational Results

The paper verifies theoretical predictions through numerical calculations:

1. Spin Density Wave Structure: L and D enantiomers display mirror-symmetric spin distributions, with zero total magnetic moment but non-trivial local spin polarization.
2. CISS Magnetoresistance: The calculated CISS magnetoresistance remains approximately constant over a wide range of voltage bias, consistent with experimental observations.
3. Reservoir Position Effect: When the ferromagnetic reservoir switches from the left to the right side, the CISS magnetoresistance changes sign, in agreement with recent experimental results.

Comparison with Experiments

• Photoelectron Emission Spectroscopy: Directly measures spin polarization of electrons emitted from chiral molecules
• Transport Measurements: Indirectly measures the response of charge current in molecular junctions to ferromagnetic reservoir magnetization

Chemical Application Prospects

Oxygen Reduction/Evolution Reactions

The paper discusses in detail the application of the CISS effect in catalytic reactions, particularly oxygen reduction reactions:

1. Angular Momentum Matching: O₂ molecules have a triplet ground state, while products such as H₂O are singlets, presenting a spin angular momentum mismatch problem
2. Chiral Catalysis: By providing spin-polarized electron pairs, the CISS effect may help overcome this angular momentum constraint
3. Simultaneous Bielectronic Transfer: Chiral molecules may promote simultaneous transfer of electron pairs with the same spin

Related Work

The paper reviews the historical development of CISS effect research:

1. Early Independent Electron Models (2009-2020): Including helical potential models, spin-orbit coupling theories, etc., but all failed to reproduce experimental results
2. Rise of Interaction Theories (2019-): Beginning to recognize the importance of electronic correlations
3. Current Controversies: Discussions regarding Onsager reciprocity, time-reversal symmetry, and spin-orbit coupling strength

Conclusions and Discussion

Main Conclusions

1. Necessity of Interactions: Independent electron theory cannot explain the CISS effect; electron interactions must be included
2. Symmetry Breaking: Coupling between molecules and macroscopic reservoirs can spontaneously break time-reversal symmetry
3. Nonlinear Response: The CISS effect is inherently a nonlinear phenomenon and cannot be described by linear response theory

Limitations

1. Model Simplification: The helical model used is overly simplified and cannot directly correspond to real molecules
2. Parameter Selection: Model parameter choices are based more on physical reasonableness than quantitative fitting
3. First-Principles Calculations: Current ab initio methods cannot yet quantitatively reproduce the CISS effect

Future Directions

1. Nonadiabatic Effects: Include nuclear motion as an effective magnetic field in electron wavefunctions
2. Chiral Phonons: Study the influence of chiral vibrational modes on electron spin
3. Quantitative Theory: Develop first-principles methods capable of quantitatively predicting the CISS effect

In-Depth Evaluation

Strengths

1. Theoretical Depth: Provides deep physical understanding of the CISS effect, particularly regarding the roles of interactions and symmetry breaking
2. Experimental Connection: Theoretical predictions are highly consistent with multiple experimental observations
3. Interdisciplinary Perspective: Connects physics, chemistry, and biology, demonstrating the broad significance of the CISS effect
4. Critical Thinking: Provides profound reflection on theoretical research over the past decade

Weaknesses

1. Mathematical Rigor: Some derivation processes lack complete mathematical details
2. Quantitative Predictions: The theory is primarily qualitative, lacking precise quantitative predictions
3. Experimental Verification: Requires more direct experimental verification to support theoretical predictions

Impact

This paper may have significant impact on CISS effect research:

1. Theoretical Shift: Promotes transition of research focus from independent electron models to interaction theories
2. Experimental Guidance: Provides theoretical guidance for designing new experiments
3. Application Extension: Provides theoretical foundation for applications of the CISS effect in catalysis and biological systems

Applicable Scenarios

This theoretical framework is applicable to:

1. Electron transport research in chiral molecules
2. Design of molecular spintronics devices
3. Study of chiral catalysis mechanisms
4. Analysis of spin effects in biological systems

References

The paper cites 91 references, covering experimental discoveries, theoretical developments, and various applications of the CISS effect, providing readers with comprehensive background knowledge and directions for further research.