A note on the Penrose process in rotating regular black holes

Basic Information

• Paper ID: 2510.11364
• Title: A note on the Penrose process in rotating regular black holes
• Authors: Anjan Kar, Ayan Dey, Sayan Kar
• Classification: gr-qc (General Relativity and Quantum Cosmology)
• Publication Date: October 13, 2025 (arXiv preprint)
• Paper Link: https://arxiv.org/abs/2510.11364

Abstract

This paper investigates the Penrose energy extraction process in rotating regular black holes. For Neves-Saa class regular black hole solutions (which include Bardeen, Hayward, and Fan-Wang spacetimes as special cases), the energy extraction efficiency is bounded by the known values for Kerr spacetime. However, for a new class of rotating regular black holes (which do not possess a Schwarzschild singular limit at zero rotation), the energy extraction efficiency can become very large.

Research Background and Motivation

Research Questions

This paper aims to investigate the energy extraction efficiency of the Penrose process in rotating regular black holes, particularly how regularization parameters affect the efficiency of this process.

Significance of the Problem

1. Theoretical Significance: Regular black holes are considered a potential solution to the spacetime singularity problem in Einstein's general relativity
2. Distinguishing Mechanism: The energy extraction efficiency of the Penrose process may serve as a method to theoretically distinguish regular black holes from singular black holes
3. Astrophysical Applications: From an astrophysical perspective, black holes are expected to possess spin; therefore, studying rotating regular black holes has practical significance

Limitations of Existing Research

• Most research has focused on the Penrose process in Kerr black holes
• Systematic studies of the Penrose process in regular black holes are relatively limited
• Comparative analysis of energy extraction efficiency across different types of regular black holes is lacking

Core Contributions

1. Systematic Analysis: First systematic study of the Penrose process in Neves-Saa class regular black holes
2. Novel Black Hole Construction: Construction of a new class of rotating regular black holes that do not possess a Schwarzschild limit at zero rotation
3. Efficiency Bound Discovery: Proof that energy extraction efficiency in Neves-Saa class regular black holes is bounded by Kerr values
4. Super-efficiency Mechanism: Discovery that newly constructed regular black holes can achieve energy extraction efficiency exceeding that of Kerr black holes
5. Parameter Dependence: Detailed analysis of how regularization parameter g, rotation parameter a, and other factors influence energy extraction efficiency

Methodology

Task Definition

Investigation of rotational energy extraction through the Penrose process in rotating regular black holes, analyzing the variation of maximum energy extraction efficiency δE_max with regularization parameter g.

Theoretical Framework

1. Rotating Regular Black Hole Metric

Type-I rotating regular black hole geometry is employed, with line element:

ds² = -(1 - 2m(r)r/Σ)dt² - 4m(r)ra sin²θ/Σ dtdφ + Σ/Δ dr² + Σdθ²
     + sin²θ(r² + a² + 2m(r)ra² sin²θ/Σ)dφ²

where:

• Σ = r² + a²cos²θ
• Δ = r² - 2m(r)r + a²
• m(r) is the mass function

2. Neves-Saa Class Mass Function

m(r) = Mr^p/(r^q + g^q)^(p/q)

where g is the regularization parameter, M is the ADM mass, and p, q are additional parameters.

3. Penrose Process Analysis

The Hamilton-Jacobi method is used to analyze geodesics:

2∂S/∂λ = g^μν ∂S/∂x^μ ∂S/∂x^ν

Maximum energy extraction efficiency is achieved near the event horizon:

δE_max = 1/2(√(1 + a²/(r_h²E₀²)) - 1)E₀

Technical Innovations

1. Generalized Framework: Establishment of a unified analytical framework for the Penrose process in Neves-Saa class regular black holes
2. Novel Black Hole Construction: Construction of new rotating regular black holes based on mass function m(r) = (1/2)b₀²r³/(r² + g²)²
3. Systematic Comparison: Systematic comparison of energy extraction characteristics across different regular black holes through parameter space scanning

Experimental Setup

Objects of Study

1. Bardeen Black Hole (p=3, q=2): m(r) = M(r²/(r² + g²))^(3/2)
2. Hayward Black Hole (p=3, q=3)
3. Fan-Wang Black Hole (p=3, q=1): m(r) = Mr³/(r + g)³
4. New Regular Black Hole: m(r) = (1/2)b₀²r³/(r² + g²)²

Analysis Parameters

• Regularization parameter: g/M ∈ 0, 1
• Rotation parameter: a/M ∈ 0, 1
• Neves-Saa parameters: p ∈ 3, 9, q ∈ 1, 6

Computational Methods

1. Solution of horizon equation Δ = 0 to determine outer horizon location
2. Calculation of static limit surface to determine ergosphere region
3. Analysis of Penrose process on equatorial plane (θ = π/2)
4. Computation of maximum energy extraction efficiency δE_max

Experimental Results

Main Results

1. Efficiency Bounds for Neves-Saa Class Black Holes

• Bardeen Black Hole: Efficiency at finite g values is lower than at g=0 (Kerr case), with maximum efficiency 0.207
• Fan-Wang Black Hole: Similar behavior, with efficiency decreasing as g increases
• Parameter Dependence:
  • At fixed a and p, efficiency decreases with increasing q
  • At fixed g and q, efficiency increases with increasing a

2. Super-efficiency Phenomenon in New Regular Black Holes

Multiple parameter combinations achieve energy extraction efficiency exceeding Kerr black holes:

Ablation Studies

Parameter Impact Analysis

1. q Parameter Impact: Increasing q values leads to lower efficiency upper bounds, but permits larger g value ranges
2. p Parameter Impact: Smaller p values (p≥3) correspond to more pronounced efficiency growth rates
3. Rotation Parameter Impact: In all cases, efficiency increases with increasing a

Case Studies

Ergosphere Region Characteristics

• Larger rotation parameters result in wider ergosphere regions
• Regularization parameter g significantly affects ergosphere shape and size
• New regular black holes exhibit unique ergosphere structures

Related Work

History of Penrose Process Research

1. Classical Studies: Penrose and Floyd (1971) first proposed the energy extraction mechanism in rotating black holes
2. Variant Studies: Magnetic Penrose process, collisional Penrose process, and others
3. Non-Kerr Geometries: Penrose process research in other spacetimes

Regular Black Hole Research

1. Pioneering Work: Bardeen (1968) first proposed the concept of regular black holes
2. Modern Developments: Multiple regular black hole models by Hayward, Fan-Wang, and others
3. Rotating Generalizations: Construction of rotating counterparts using Newman-Janis algorithm

Conclusions and Discussion

Main Conclusions

1. Efficiency Bound Theorem: The Penrose process energy extraction efficiency in Neves-Saa class regular black holes never exceeds the corresponding Kerr black hole value
2. Super-efficiency Mechanism: New-type regular black holes without Schwarzschild limits can achieve significantly higher energy extraction efficiency than Kerr black holes
3. Distinguishing Mechanism: Penrose process efficiency can serve as a theoretical tool for distinguishing different types of regular black holes

Limitations

1. Theoretical Nature: Research is limited to theoretical analysis, lacking observational verification
2. Energy Conditions: Rotating regular black holes violate the weak energy condition
3. Parameter Constraints: The parameter space admitting event horizons is relatively limited

Future Directions

1. Observational Features: Investigation of other observable characteristics of regular black holes
2. Stability Analysis: Analysis of stability in high-efficiency energy extraction processes
3. Quantum Effects: Consideration of quantum corrections to energy extraction efficiency

In-Depth Evaluation

Strengths

1. Strong Systematicity: First systematic study of the Penrose process in multiple classes of regular black holes
2. Theoretical Innovation: Construction of novel regular black holes and discovery of super-efficiency phenomena
3. Numerical Completeness: Provision of detailed parameter space analysis and specific numerical results
4. Physical Insights: Revelation of profound effects of regularization on energy extraction efficiency

Weaknesses

1. Physical Mechanism: Insufficient depth in explaining the physical mechanism of super-efficiency phenomena
2. Stability: Lack of discussion regarding physical stability in high-efficiency parameter regions
3. Observational Connection: Absence of connection to actual astrophysical observations

Impact

1. Theoretical Contribution: Provides new research perspectives for regular black hole theory
2. Methodological Value: Established analytical framework applicable to other regular black hole models
3. Distinguishing Tool: Proposes new methods for distinguishing regular and singular black holes

Applicable Scenarios

1. Theoretical Physics: Black hole physics and gravitational theory research
2. Numerical Relativity: Numerical simulation studies of regular black holes
3. Astrophysics: Energy extraction mechanisms in extreme gravitational environments

References

The paper cites 75 important references, covering:

• Classical black hole physics (Chandrasekhar, Wald, et al.)
• Penrose process research (original work by Penrose & Floyd and subsequent developments)
• Regular black hole theory (models by Bardeen, Hayward, Fan-Wang, et al.)
• Rotating black hole construction (work related to Newman-Janis algorithm)

Overall Assessment: This paper represents high-quality theoretical physics research, making important contributions to the study of the Penrose process in regular black holes. The discovery of super-efficiency phenomena in particular provides new research directions for the field. Despite certain theoretical limitations, its scientific value and innovation merit recognition.