Charged wormholes can be long-lived

Basic Information

• Paper ID: 2510.11406
• Title: Charged wormholes can be long-lived
• Authors: Jose Luis Blázquez-Salcedo, Luis Manuel González-Romero, Fech Scen Khoo, Jutta Kunz, Pablo Navarro Moreno
• Classification: gr-qc (General Relativity and Quantum Cosmology)
• Publication Date: October 14, 2025
• Paper Link: https://arxiv.org/abs/2510.11406

Abstract

Ellis-Bronnikov wormholes exhibit unstable radial modes. This paper investigates the evolution of unstable modes in charged wormholes. The study demonstrates that instability persists in the presence of electric charge but exhibits a very rapid decay toward zero, suggesting that wormholes approaching near-extremal metrics may be long-lived. For so-called supercritical wormholes, two purely imaginary unstable modes merge at a critical point and subsequently exhibit degenerate imaginary parts with opposite real parts. By analogy, we conjecture that rotating wormholes will exhibit similar behavior.

Research Background and Motivation

Problem Definition

This research primarily addresses the stability problem of Ellis-Bronnikov (EB) wormholes. EB wormholes are traversable Lorentzian wormholes in general relativity that require exotic matter (such as phantom scalar fields) to violate energy conditions.

Research Significance

1. Theoretical Importance: Wormholes, as bridges connecting different regions of spacetime, hold significant importance in theoretical physics
2. Observational Relevance: Since rotation is ubiquitous in the universe, studying the stability of charged and rotating wormholes has observational implications
3. Stability Issues: Static EB wormholes exhibit notorious radial instability, which limits their physical viability

Limitations of Existing Approaches

• Static EB wormholes possess radial instability
• Stability analysis of rotating EB wormholes remains challenging, requiring complex numerical methods
• Lack of deep understanding regarding the long-term evolution behavior of charged wormholes

Research Motivation

The authors adopt a strategy of studying charged wormholes as an analogy for rotating wormholes because charged EB wormholes admit closed-form solutions facilitating analysis, whereas numerical analysis in the rotating case remains a challenge.

Core Contributions

1. Revealed stability characteristics of charged EB wormholes: Demonstrated that instability persists in the presence of electric charge but exhibits rapid decay characteristics
2. Discovered long-lived properties of near-extremal wormholes: When the wormhole metric approaches the extremal Reissner-Nordström black hole, the imaginary part of unstable modes rapidly approaches zero
3. Revealed mode bifurcation behavior in supercritical wormholes: Two purely imaginary unstable modes merge at a critical point and subsequently exhibit identical imaginary parts with opposite real parts
4. Provided analogous predictions for rotating wormhole behavior: Based on the analysis of the charged case, reasonable conjectures regarding the stability behavior of rotating wormholes are formulated

Methodology Details

Theoretical Framework

The research is based on the Einstein-Maxwell-scalar action:

$S = \frac{1}{16\pi} \int d^4x \sqrt{-g} [R - F^2 + 2(\nabla\phi)^2]$

where R is the Ricci scalar, F is the electromagnetic tensor, and φ is the phantom scalar field.

Classification of Wormhole Solutions

González et al. classify charged wormhole solutions into three categories:

• Subcritical case: Λ > 0
• Critical case: Λ = 0
• Supercritical case: Λ = iμ (μ is a positive real number)

The metric function G(r) varies accordingly in these cases.

Radial Perturbation Analysis

Perturbation fields take the form: $g_{\mu\nu} = g^0_{\mu\nu} + \delta g_{\mu\nu}, \quad A_\mu = A^0_\mu + \delta A_\mu, \quad \phi = \phi^0 + \delta\phi$

Perturbations evolve in time as $e^{-i\omega t}$, where $\omega = \omega_R + i\omega_I$ is the complex frequency. Unstable modes are characterized by $\omega_I > 0$.

Numerical Method: Spectral Method

Chebyshev polynomial expansion is employed: $F_i(x) = \sum_{k=0}^{N_p-1} C_{i,k} T_k(x)$

The problem is transformed into a quadratic eigenvalue problem: $(M_0 + M_1\omega + M_2\omega^2)C = 0$

Experimental Setup

Parameter Space

Wormholes are characterized by three parameters: electric charge $Q_e$, $Q_s$, and scale $r_0$. Physically meaningful quantities are mass M, charge $Q_e$, and throat radius $r_T$.

Numerical Precision

Using Matlab combined with the Advanpix arbitrary-precision computing toolbox, mode calculations achieve precision of $\sim 10^{-6}$ or higher.

Boundary Conditions

Solutions are required to behave as outgoing waves far from the throat: $F_0(r) \sim re^{i\omega r_*}, \quad F_2(r) \sim e^{i\omega r_*}, \quad u(r) \sim r^{-1}e^{i\omega r_*}$

Experimental Results

Subcritical and Critical Wormholes

• One purely imaginary unstable mode exists: $\omega = i\omega_I$
• Instability decreases monotonically with increasing mass
• As the extremal Reissner-Nordström black hole is approached, the mode rapidly approaches zero
• The critical mode follows the relation: $\omega_I \propto (1 - M/r_T)^{-3.1}$

Supercritical Wormholes

• Two purely imaginary modes exist at small masses
• At critical mass, the two modes merge and undergo bifurcation
• After bifurcation, two modes with identical imaginary parts but opposite real parts emerge
• As the extremal limit is approached, the imaginary part similarly decays rapidly to zero

Decay Time Analysis

Taking a critical wormhole with $r_T = 10$ km as an example:

• Uncharged case: $\tau_0 = 28$ μs (extremely short)
• $Q_e/r_T = 0.95$: $\tau_0 = 0.13$ s
• $Q_e/r_T = 0.9999$: $\tau_0 \approx 1.1$ years

Related Work

Theoretical Foundations of Wormholes

• Morris and Thorne's traversable wormhole theory
• Ellis-Bronnikov static spherically symmetric solutions
• Perturbations and rapid rotation studies of rotating wormholes

Stability Analysis

• Radial instability of static EB wormholes (Shinkai & Hayward, et al.)
• Stability analysis of slowly rotating EB wormholes
• Mode merging phenomena in five-dimensional rotating EB wormholes

Conclusions and Discussion

Main Conclusions

1. Charged EB wormholes retain radial instability, but the instability rapidly vanishes as the extremal limit is approached
2. Supercritical wormholes exhibit complex mode bifurcation behavior
3. Highly charged wormholes can achieve arbitrarily long decay times, becoming "long-lived" wormholes

Predictions for Rotating Wormholes

Based on analogy with the charged case, the authors conjecture that rapidly rotating wormholes may similarly exhibit long-lived characteristics when approaching the extremal Kerr solution.

Future Directions

• Perform non-perturbative numerical analysis of rapidly rotating wormholes
• Study stability of other charged wormhole solutions (such as solutions in Einstein-Maxwell-Dirac theory)
• Explore other possible stabilization mechanisms

In-Depth Evaluation

Strengths

1. Methodological Innovation: Cleverly employs the study of charged wormholes as an analogy for the rotating case, circumventing complex numerical challenges
2. High Numerical Precision: Advanced spectral methods and arbitrary-precision computation ensure reliable results
3. Deep Physical Insight: Discovery of long-lived characteristics near extremality provides new perspectives on wormhole physical viability
4. Comprehensive Analysis: Systematically investigates stability characteristics of three types of wormholes

Limitations

1. Limitations of Analogy: While the analogy from charged to rotating cases is reasonable, it lacks rigorous theoretical proof
2. Single Perturbation Type: Only radial perturbations are considered; other types of instabilities may persist
3. Extremal Limit: The near-extremal regime may involve other physical effects requiring more careful analysis

Impact

1. Theoretical Contribution: Provides new theoretical tools and insights for wormhole stability research
2. Methodological Value: Application of spectral methods provides technical reference for similar problems
3. Predictive Value: Predictions regarding rotating wormhole behavior point directions for future research

Applicable Scenarios

This research applies to:

• Wormhole stability analysis in theoretical gravitational physics
• Quasinormal mode research in black hole physics
• Perturbation theory applications in general relativity

References

The paper cites 27 important references covering classical and recent research in key fields including wormhole theory, stability analysis, and numerical methods, providing a solid theoretical foundation for this research.