Towards polarization-enhanced PET: Study of random background in polarization-correlated Compton events

Basic Information

• Paper ID: 2510.11504
• Title: Towards polarization-enhanced PET: Study of random background in polarization-correlated Compton events
• Authors: Ana Marija Kožuljević, Tomislav Bokulić, Darko Grošev, Siddharth Parashari, Luka Pavelić, Marinko Rade, Marijan Žuvić, Mihael Makek
• Classification: physics.ins-det physics.med-ph
• Publication Date: October 17, 2025
• Paper Link: https://arxiv.org/abs/2510.11504

Abstract

Positron Emission Tomography (PET) is a medical imaging technique utilizing positron-emitting isotopes (such as Ga-68 and F-18) for diagnostic purposes. When positrons annihilate with electrons in surrounding tissue, two 511 keV photons are produced with opposite momentum and orthogonally polarization-entangled states. When each photon undergoes Compton scattering, the azimuthal scattering angle difference reflects the orthogonality of the initial polarization, peaking at ±90°. This correlation has not been exploited in conventional PET scanners but may provide an energy-independent method for background suppression. These correlations can be measured via Compton polarimeters, particularly suitable for single-layer polarimeters compatible with traditional PET architecture. This study compares the signal-to-random-background ratio (SBR) of polarization-correlated Compton events with conventional single-pixel hit events across clinical-relevant source activities of 200-378 MBq, finding consistently higher SBR for the former approach.

Research Background and Motivation

Problem Definition

Conventional PET imaging relies on the 511 keV energy and opposite momentum of annihilation photons for image reconstruction. However, due to finite time windows, random coincidence events—detection of two unrelated photons that do not correspond to actual annihilation sites—degrade image quality.

Research Significance

1. Quantum Entanglement Exploitation: The polarization entanglement of annihilation photons provides an additional information dimension for background suppression
2. Clinical Needs: Improving the signal-to-noise ratio in PET imaging is crucial for clinical diagnosis
3. Technological Innovation: Development of polarization-enhanced PET represents a new direction in medical imaging

Limitations of Existing Methods

Conventional PET utilizes only energy and momentum information, insufficiently exploiting quantum entanglement properties, resulting in random coincidence background limiting imaging quality.

Research Motivation

To explore the feasibility of background suppression using polarization correlations of annihilation photons, providing theoretical and experimental foundations for developing next-generation PET systems.

Core Contributions

1. First Detailed Comparative Study: Systematic comparison of random background characteristics between single-pixel hit events and polarization-correlated Compton events
2. Clinical-Relevant Activity Verification: Validation of polarization-enhanced PET effectiveness across 200-380 MBq clinical activity range
3. SBR and Polarization Modulation Factor Relationship: First discovery and quantification of correlation between signal-to-random-background ratio and polarization modulation factor μ
4. Background Suppression Advantage Verification: Demonstration that polarization-correlated events exhibit 23% higher SBR compared to conventional single-pixel events

Methodology Details

Experimental Setup Design

Detector Module:

• Two 16×16 GAGG:Ce crystal matrices
• Crystal dimensions: 3×3×20 mm³
• SiPM readout (Hamamatsu S13361-0808A)
• Energy resolution: 8.1±1.1% and 9.3±2.2% (at 511 keV)

Geometric Configuration:

• Detector separation: 430 mm
• Rotating gantry: 12 positions at 15° intervals
• Ga-68 source positioned at center

Data Acquisition System

Readout System: TOFPET2 ASIC system

• Coincidence trigger: at least one pixel trigger per module
• Time window: 100 ns event grouping
• Coincidence time resolution: ±2.5 ns (±3σ)

Event Selection Strategy

Single-Pixel Events:

• Only one pixel triggered per detector module
• Full energy deposition: 400-600 keV

Polarization-Correlated Compton Events:

• Two pixels triggered per module
• Total energy: 400-600 keV
• Minimum single-pixel energy: 120 keV

Physical Quantity Calculations

Compton Scattering Angle: $\theta = \arccos\left(\frac{m_e c^2}{E_{px1} + E_{px2}} - \frac{m_e c^2}{E_{px2}} + 1\right)$

Azimuthal Scattering Angle: $\phi = \arctan\left(\frac{\Delta y}{\Delta x}\right)$

Polarization Modulation Factor: $\mu = G(\theta_1)G(\theta_2)$

where $G(\theta_i) = \frac{\sin^2\theta_i}{(2-\cos\theta_i)^2}$

Background Suppression Principle

According to Pryce-Ward theory, the differential cross-section for polarization-correlated Compton scattering is: $\frac{d^2\sigma}{d\Omega_1 d\Omega_2} = \frac{r_0^4}{16}[F(\theta_1)F(\theta_2) - G(\theta_1)G(\theta_2)\cos(2\Delta\phi)]$

The azimuthal angle difference distribution, after acceptance correction, is fitted as: $N_{cor}(\phi_1 - \phi_2) = M[1 - \mu\cos[2(\phi_1 - \phi_2)]]$

Experimental Setup

Radioactive Source

• Isotope: Ga-68
• Initial Activity: ~378 MBq
• Measurement Range: 200-380 MBq
• Decay Process: Experiments conducted over ~1 hour, utilizing natural decay to obtain different activities

Data Acquisition Parameters

• Number of Positions: 12 at 15° intervals
• Acquisition Time: 240-447 seconds (adjusted by activity)
• Energy Window: 400-600 keV (full energy peak)
• Minimum Pixel Energy: 120 keV

Event Classification

1. Angle Selection:
   • Primary sample: 72° < θ < 90°
   • Comparison sample: 60° < θ < 80°
2. Topology Selection:
   • All pixel pairs
   • Excluding nearest neighbors (d > 4.6 mm)
3. Azimuthal Angle Selection:
   • High correlation region: 70° < Δφ < 110°
   • Low correlation region: -20° < Δφ < 20°

Experimental Results

Main Findings

SBR Advantage:

• Polarization-correlated events consistently exhibit higher SBR than single-pixel events
• Optimal selection (72° < θ < 90°, 70° < Δφ < 110°) maintains SBR ratio above 1.1
• At highest activity, SBR ratio reaches 1.23

Activity Dependence:

• SBR significantly improves with decreasing source activity
• Polarization modulation factor μ increases ~28% as activity decreases from ~387 MBq to ~200 MBq
• Samples excluding nearest neighbors show ~40% increase in μ value

Polarization Modulation Factor Variations

μ Values for Different Angle Ranges:

• 72° < θ < 90° (all pixel pairs): maximum μ ~14%
• 72° < θ < 90° (excluding nearest neighbors): higher μ values with better precision
• 60° < θ < 80°: maximum μ ~8.5%, consistent with theoretical expectations

SBR and μ Correlation

Key Finding:

• Clear positive correlation between SBR and polarization modulation factor μ
• Within μ variation range of 10.5%-14%, SBR improves approximately 2-fold
• This correlation indicates μ can serve as an estimator for random background

Impact of Azimuthal Angle Selection

High Correlation Region vs. Low Correlation Region:

• 70° < Δφ < 110° (theoretically high correlation region): highest SBR
• -20° < Δφ < 20° (theoretically low correlation region): lowest SBR
• Validates theoretical predictions of polarization correlation spatial distribution

Related Work

Theoretical Foundation

• Pryce-Ward Theory: 1947 theoretical foundation for annihilation photon polarization correlations
• Quantum Entanglement: Recent advances in quantum entanglement research in MeV energy region
• Compton Polarimetry: Development of single-layer Compton detector technology

Experimental Progress

• Proof of Concept: Preliminary verification by multiple research groups under laboratory conditions
• Detector Optimization: Application of GAGG:Ce crystals and SiPM technology
• System Integration: Efforts toward clinical application and technology transfer

Uniqueness of This Work

This study is the first to systematically compare background suppression performance of polarization-enhanced PET versus conventional PET across clinical-relevant activity ranges, filling the gap between proof-of-concept and practical application.

Conclusions and Discussion

Main Conclusions

1. Background Suppression Advantage: Polarization-correlated Compton events demonstrate higher SBR than single-pixel events across all tested topologies
2. Activity Dependence: Polarization enhancement effects are more pronounced at lower activities, providing important reference for clinical applications
3. Indicative Role of μ Factor: First establishment of quantitative relationship between SBR and polarization modulation factor; μ can serve as a new tool for background estimation
4. Technical Feasibility: Validates practical potential of polarization-enhanced PET under clinical-relevant conditions

Limitations

1. Detector Geometry: Current planar geometry limits clinical application; development of ring geometry needed
2. Statistical Precision: Small detector array limits statistical precision and spatial resolution
3. Increased Complexity: Dual-pixel event processing increases system complexity and computational burden
4. Environmental Factors: Positron emission environment may affect polarization correlation measurements

Future Directions

1. System Integration: Development of complete polarization-enhanced PET scanner prototype
2. Algorithm Optimization: Development of more efficient polarization-correlated event reconstruction algorithms
3. Clinical Validation: Verification of technical advantages in actual patient imaging
4. Multimodal Fusion: Exploration of combined applications with other imaging techniques

In-Depth Evaluation

Strengths

1. Strong Innovation: First systematic study of random background characteristics in polarization-enhanced PET, opening new research directions
2. Rigorous Experimental Design: Use of clinical-relevant activity ranges with experimental conditions approaching practical applications
3. Theory-Experiment Integration: Excellent combination of quantum mechanics theory and practical measurement techniques
4. Comprehensive Data Analysis: Multi-angle analysis of different event selection strategies
5. Technical Practicality: Construction using commercial components with good reproducibility

Weaknesses

1. Sample Size Limitations: 16×16 pixel array relatively small, limiting statistical precision
2. Geometric Limitations: Dual-module planar geometry differs from clinical PET ring geometry
3. Insufficient Theoretical Analysis: Physical mechanisms underlying SBR-μ correlation not deeply explained
4. Lack of Comparative Benchmarks: Absence of direct performance comparison with commercial PET systems
5. Missing Cost-Benefit Analysis: No discussion of trade-offs between increased system complexity and performance improvement

Impact

Academic Value:

• Provides important experimental baseline data for polarization-enhanced PET field
• Establishes new background assessment methods and metrics
• Advances application research of quantum entanglement in medical imaging

Practical Value:

• Provides technical roadmap for next-generation PET system design
• Potential advantages in high-background imaging environments
• May improve imaging quality with low-activity tracers

Reproducibility:

• Use of commercial components with relatively low technical barriers
• Detailed experimental parameters and analysis methods facilitate verification
• Open-source analysis software (ROOT, Python) enhances accessibility

Applicable Scenarios

1. Research Environment: Nuclear medicine physics research, medical imaging technology development
2. Clinical Applications: Low-dose PET imaging, high-background environment imaging
3. Industrial Applications: Nuclear material detection, security screening requiring high signal-to-noise ratio
4. Educational Training: Teaching demonstration of quantum physics and medical imaging integration

References

This paper cites important literature in the field, including:

• Pryce & Ward (1947): Theoretical foundation of annihilation photon angular correlations
• Kuncic et al. (2011): Early work on polarization-enhanced X-ray imaging
• Watts et al. (2021): Experimental verification of MeV-region photon quantum entanglement
• Moskal et al. (2025): Non-maximal entanglement demonstration using plastic PET scanner

Overall Assessment: This is an experimentally significant research paper in the polarization-enhanced PET field. Despite certain technical limitations, its innovative research approach, rigorous experimental design, and valuable findings make important contributions to field development. Particularly, the discovery of SBR-polarization modulation factor correlation provides new theoretical basis for future system optimization.