Spinons, solitons and random singlets in the spin-chain compound copper benzoate

Basic Information

• Paper ID: 2510.11551
• Title: Spinons, solitons and random singlets in the spin-chain compound copper benzoate
• Authors: Ying Chen, Guijing Duan, Yuejiu Zhao, and multiple co-authors
• Classification: cond-mat.str-el (Condensed Matter Physics - Strongly Correlated Electron Systems)
• Submission Date: October 13, 2025 to arXiv
• Paper Link: https://arxiv.org/abs/2510.11551

Abstract

This study successfully identifies and characterizes three exotic excitations in S=1/2 antiferromagnetic Heisenberg chains within a single material through nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR) measurements on high-quality copper benzoate single crystals: spinons, solitons, and random singlets. At low magnetic field (0.2 T), the spin-lattice relaxation rate ($1/T_1$) remains constant over more than a decade in temperature, confirming the existence of spinons. Below 0.4 K, an additional relaxation channel emerges, manifesting as $1/T_1 \propto T$ and spectral weight growing as $-\ln(T/T_0)$, marking a random singlet ground state induced by weak quenched disorder. At magnetic fields above 0.5 T, a field-induced spin gap $\Delta \propto H^{2/3}$ is observed, indicating the presence of soliton excitations.

Research Background and Motivation

Problem Background

1. Theoretical Importance: The S=1/2 antiferromagnetic Heisenberg chain (HAFC) is a canonical model for one-dimensional quantum magnetism, and its exact Bethe ansatz solution provides the theoretical foundation for understanding one-dimensional quantum magnets.
2. Exotic Excitations: The system is expected to host multiple exotic excitation states:
   • Spinons: fractionalized excitations in the continuous excitation spectrum
   • Solitons: field-induced gapped excitations
   • Random singlets: disorder-induced paired singlet states

Experimental Challenges

The main challenges faced by existing research:

1. Simultaneously realizing and distinguishing these three types of excitations in a single material is highly challenging
2. Earlier NMR studies reporting power-law temperature dependence ($1/T_1 \sim T^{-0.25}$) are inconsistent with simple spinon descriptions
3. Extremely low temperatures and precise magnetic field control are required to observe different excitation modes

Research Significance

The importance of this study lies in:

• Providing experimental verification for one-dimensional quantum integrability theory
• Revealing the interaction mechanisms between disorder and correlation effects
• Establishing an experimental platform for studying one-dimensional quantum magnets

Core Contributions

1. First identification of three excitations in a single material: Through precise NMR measurements, spinons, solitons, and random singlet excitations are simultaneously observed and distinguished in copper benzoate.
2. Establishment of H-T phase diagram: A complete magnetic field-temperature phase diagram is constructed, clearly delineating the dominant regions of the three excitation modes.
3. Verification of theoretical predictions: Experiments confirm the constant $1/T_1$ behavior of spinons, logarithmic divergence of correlation length for random singlets, and $H^{2/3}$ gap scaling for solitons.
4. Development of experimental techniques: Inverse Laplace transform analysis (ILTA) successfully separates different relaxation channels, providing new methods for studying complex quantum states.

Detailed Methodology

Experimental Design

Material Preparation: High-quality copper benzoate Cu(C₆H₅COO)₂·3H₂O single crystals are grown using chemical diffusion method, with dimensions of 2.5×0.4×3.0 mm³.

Measurement Conditions:

• Temperature range: 0.03-100 K (using dilution refrigerator for ultra-low temperatures)
• Magnetic field range: 0.2-10 T (along the crystal b-axis)
• NMR technique: ¹H nuclear magnetic resonance, employing spin-echo and inversion-recovery methods

Core Measurement Techniques

1. Spin-Lattice Relaxation Rate Measurement

Nuclear magnetization recovery is measured via inversion-recovery method: $M(t) = M(\infty) - ae^{-t/T_1}$

At low temperatures, biexponential behavior is observed: $M(t) = M(\infty) - a_f e^{-t/T_{1f}} - a_s e^{-t/T_{1s}}$

2. Inverse Laplace Transform Analysis (ILTA)

Tikhonov regularization-based ILTA is employed to analyze relaxation curves, obtaining the relaxation rate distribution function $P(1/T_1)$, enabling quantitative separation of different relaxation channels.

3. Knight Shift Measurement

Knight shift is determined through resonance frequency: $K_n = (f/\gamma H - 1) \times 100\%$

Theoretical Analysis Framework

Spinon Theory

Based on the scaling relation $1/T_1 \sim T^{\eta-1}$, for S=1/2 HAFC with correlation exponent $\eta = 1$, $1/T_1$ is expected to be temperature-independent.

Random Singlet Theory

Disorder-induced correlation length divergence: $\xi \propto -\ln(T/T_0)$ Spectral weight growth: $w_2 \propto -\ln(T/T_0)$

Soliton Theory

Field-induced staggered magnetization produces a sine-Gordon model with gap scaling: $\Delta = 1.85J(h/J)^{2/3}$

Experimental Setup

Sample Characteristics

• Crystal Structure: Monoclinic I2/c space group, Cu²⁺ ions forming one-dimensional chains along the c-axis
• Exchange Coupling: Intrachain exchange coupling J ≈ 18 K, extremely weak interchain coupling
• Néel Temperature: TN ≈ 0.8 mK

Measurement Parameters

• NMR Frequency: Adjusted according to magnetic field strength
• Pulse Length: π/2 pulse approximately 2 μs
• Nuclear Sites: Focus on H(1), H(2) (protons in water molecules) and H(3)/benzoate group protons

Numerical Simulations

• Quantum Monte Carlo (QMC): Simulating one-dimensional HAFC with random bond disorder
• tanTRG Method: Computing hyperfine fields at finite temperatures

Experimental Results

Main Findings

1. Spinon Excitations (Low Field 0.2 T)

• Temperature-independent relaxation: $1/T_1$ remains essentially constant over the range 1.4-0.03 K
• Theoretical agreement: Verifies theoretical prediction of $\eta = 1$
• High-quality evidence: Constant behavior maintained over more than one order of magnitude in temperature

2. Random Singlets (Below 0.4 K)

• Biexponential relaxation: Two relaxation components (fast and slow) emerge
• Linear temperature dependence: Slow component $1/T_{1s} \propto T$
• Logarithmic divergence: Spectral weight $w_2 = -a\ln(T/T_0)$, where $T_0 = 0.4$ K, $a = 25$
• Correlation length: QMC simulations confirm $\xi/a \propto -\ln(T/T_0)$

3. Soliton Excitations (High Field >0.5 T)

• Knight shift: Significant rise and saturation at low temperatures, consistent with thermally activated behavior $K_n = ae^{-\Delta/k_BT} + b$
• Relaxation rate: Significant decrease at high fields, indicating gap opening
• Gap scaling: $\Delta \propto H^{2/3}$, perfectly matching theoretical prediction $\Delta = 1.85J(h/J)^{2/3}$

Numerical Verification

• tanTRG calculations: Confirm that the low-temperature rise in Knight shift primarily originates from field-induced staggered magnetization
• Multi-technique consistency: NMR, specific heat, and neutron scattering measurements show highly consistent gap values

Related Work

Theoretical Background

• Bethe ansatz solution: Provides exact theoretical foundation for one-dimensional quantum magnets
• Spinon theory: Faddeev and others clarified that continuous excitation spectra originate from fractionalized excitations
• Random singlets: Ma-Dasgupta-Hu theory predicts disorder-induced singlet pairing

Experimental Precedents

• KCuF₃: Neutron scattering first confirmed one-dimensional continuous excitations
• Earlier copper benzoate studies: Specific heat and thermal conductivity show one-dimensional spinon characteristics, but NMR results were controversial

Advantages of This Work

• Single-material platform: First observation of three excitations in the same material
• Extreme experimental conditions: Ultra-low temperature of 0.03 K and ultra-low field of 0.2 T
• High-quality single crystals: Avoids complications from polycrystalline samples

Conclusions and Discussion

Main Conclusions

1. Complete excitation spectrum: Successfully identifies and characterizes all major excitation types of one-dimensional quantum magnets in copper benzoate.
2. Phase diagram establishment: A complete H-T phase diagram is constructed, clearly delineating the dominant regions of different excitations.
3. Theoretical verification: Experimental results are highly consistent with theoretical predictions, validating one-dimensional quantum integrability.
4. Disorder effects: Reveals the important role of weak disorder at ultra-low temperatures.

Physical Mechanisms

• Spinons: Originate from intrinsic excitations of one-dimensional Heisenberg chains
• Random singlets: Long-range singlet pairing induced by weak quenched disorder
• Solitons: Gapped excitations produced by field-induced staggered magnetization

Limitations

1. Finite field effects: Random singlet theory strictly applies to zero field, yet its characteristics are observed at 0.2 T
2. Temperature range: Some phenomena are only observable at ultra-low temperatures
3. Sample dependence: High-quality single crystals are required to separate different excitation channels

Future Directions

1. Breather excitations: Explore other excitations predicted by sine-Gordon model
2. Two-dimensional extension: Apply research methods to two-dimensional quantum spin liquids
3. Technical development: Further refine analysis methods such as ILTA

In-Depth Evaluation

Strengths

1. Sophisticated experimental technique: Ultra-low temperature NMR measurement technology reaches international advanced levels
2. Tight theory-experiment coupling: Experimental design highly matches theoretical predictions
3. Innovative data analysis: ILTA method successfully separates complex relaxation processes
4. Strong result convincingness: Multiple measurement techniques mutually verify the reliability of results

Technical Innovations

1. Multi-channel separation: Successfully separates contributions from spinons and random singlets
2. Extreme conditions: Ultra-extreme experimental conditions of 0.03 K and 0.2 T
3. Numerical verification: Integration of advanced numerical methods such as QMC and tanTRG

Scientific Significance

1. Fundamental physics: Provides important experimental support for one-dimensional quantum many-body theory
2. Methodology: Establishes experimental paradigm for studying complex quantum states
3. Application prospects: Guides quantum material design

Shortcomings

1. Material specificity: Results primarily based on a single material system
2. Theory gap: Random singlet theory under finite field requires further development
3. Technical threshold: Experimental conditions are extremely demanding, reproducibility may be limited

Impact Assessment

This work has significant implications for condensed matter physics and is expected to:

• Advance research on one-dimensional quantum magnets
• Provide new methods for studying exotic quantum states such as quantum spin liquids
• Promote integration of theory and experiment in quantum materials

References

The paper cites 49 important references, covering a complete literature system from Bethe ansatz theoretical foundations to cutting-edge experimental techniques, reflecting the systematic and frontier nature of the research.

Summary: This is a high-quality condensed matter physics experimental paper that, through precise NMR measurements, simultaneously observes three important one-dimensional quantum excitations in a single material for the first time, providing important experimental verification for theoretical physics with significant scientific value and methodological significance.