2025-11-10T03:01:56.242813

Note on Kaniadakis Holographic Dark Energy

Sheykhi, Asvar, Ebrahimi
It is well-known that any modification to the entropy expression not only change the energy density of the holographic dark energy, but also modifies the cosmological field equations through thermodynamics-gravity correspondence. Here we revisit the Kaniadakis holographic dark energy (KHDE) in the background of the modified Kaniadakis cosmology by incorporating the effects of Kaniadakis entropy into the Friedmann equations. We choose the Hubble radius, $L=H^{-1}$, as system's IR cutoff and determine the cosmological implications of this model. We first consider a dark energy (DE) dominated universe and reveal that this model mimics the cosmological constant with $w_{DE}=-1$. This implies that the theoretical origin of the cosmological constant, $Λ$, may be understood through KHDE in the context of Kaniadakis cosmology. Remarkably, we observe that in the absence of interaction between DE and dark matter (DM), and in contrast to HDE in standard cosmology, our model can explain the current acceleration of the cosmic expansion for the Hubble radius as IR cutoff. When the interaction between DE and DM is taken into account, we see that the total equation of state parameter (EoS), $w_{tot}=p_{tot}/ρ_{tot}$ can cross the phantom line at the present time. We also analyze the squared speed of sound, $v_s^2$, for this model and find out that $(v_s^2<0)$ for interacting KHDE. Investigating the statefinder, confirms the distinction between KHDE and $Λ$CDM model. It is seen that the statefinder diagram move away from the point of $\left\lbrace r,s\right\rbrace= \left\lbrace 1,0\right\rbrace$ with increasing the interaction parameter.
academic

Note on Kaniadakis Holographic Dark Energy

Basic Information

  • Paper ID: 2510.11569
  • Title: Note on Kaniadakis Holographic Dark Energy
  • Authors: A. Sheykhi, A. Asvar, E. Ebrahimi (Shiraz University, Iran)
  • Classification: gr-qc (General Relativity and Quantum Cosmology)
  • Publication Date: October 13, 2025
  • Paper Link: https://arxiv.org/abs/2510.11569

Abstract

It is well-known that any modification to the entropy expression not only alters the energy density of holographic dark energy but also modifies the cosmological field equations through the thermodynamic-gravitational correspondence. This paper revisits Kaniadakis holographic dark energy (KHDE) within the framework of modified Kaniadakis cosmology, incorporating the effects of Kaniadakis entropy into the Friedmann equations. The Hubble radius L=H−1L=H^{-1} is chosen as the infrared cutoff of the system, and the cosmological implications of this model are determined. First, a dark energy-dominated universe is considered, and it is found that the model simulates a cosmological constant with the dark energy equation of state parameter wDE=−1w_{DE}=-1. This suggests that the theoretical origin of the cosmological constant Λ\Lambda may be understood through KHDE in the Kaniadakis cosmological framework.

Research Background and Motivation

Problem Background

  1. Cosmic Acceleration Problem: Since the discovery of cosmic acceleration through Type Ia supernovae observations in 1998, the introduction of dark energy with negative pressure has been necessary to explain this phenomenon.
  2. Challenges of the ΛCDM Model: Although the cosmological constant Λ\Lambda is the most accepted dark energy candidate, it faces issues including fine-tuning, coincidence problem, and cosmological tensions (such as H0H_0 and σ8\sigma_8 tensions).
  3. Limitations of Holographic Dark Energy: In standard cosmology, the holographic dark energy model with the Hubble radius as the infrared cutoff cannot explain cosmic acceleration without interaction.

Research Motivation

  1. Consistency of Thermodynamic-Gravitational Correspondence: Existing research only modifies the energy density of holographic dark energy while maintaining the standard Friedmann equations, which is inconsistent with the thermodynamic-gravitational conjecture.
  2. Application of Kaniadakis Statistics: Kaniadakis entropy emerges from relativistic statistical theory, providing a new theoretical framework for investigating modified holographic dark energy models.

Core Contributions

  1. Theoretical Framework Innovation: For the first time, the KHDE model is systematically studied within the modified Kaniadakis cosmological framework, ensuring consistency between entropy modification and field equation modification.
  2. Theoretical Origin of the Cosmological Constant: In a dark energy-dominated universe, the KHDE model naturally yields wDE=−1w_{DE}=-1, providing a thermodynamic-based theoretical explanation for the cosmological constant.
  3. Feasibility of Hubble Radius Cutoff: It is demonstrated that in Kaniadakis cosmology, even without interaction, selecting the Hubble radius as the infrared cutoff can achieve cosmic acceleration.
  4. Comprehensive Cosmological Analysis: The model's cosmological properties are systematically analyzed, including equation of state evolution, stability, and state finder parameters.

Methodology Details

Definition of Kaniadakis Entropy

Kaniadakis entropy is a single-parameter generalization of classical entropy: SK=−kB∑iniln⁡{K}niS_K = -k_B \sum_i n_i \ln_{\{K\}} n_i

where ln⁡{K}x=(xK−x−K)/(2K)\ln_{\{K\}}x = (x^K - x^{-K})/(2K), and the parameter KK quantifies the deviation from standard statistical mechanics (−1<K<1-1 < K < 1).

KHDE Energy Density

Based on modified Kaniadakis entropy, the energy density of KHDE is: ρDE=3c2Mp2H2+3αMp2H−2\rho_{DE} = 3c^2 M_p^2 H^2 + 3\alpha M_p^2 H^{-2}

where α=K2π2/(2G2)\alpha = K^2\pi^2/(2G^2) and cc is an arbitrary constant.

Modified Friedmann Equations

In Kaniadakis cosmology, the modified Friedmann equations are: 3Mp2(H2−αH−2)=ρm+ρDE3M_p^2(H^2 - \alpha H^{-2}) = \rho_m + \rho_{DE}−2Mp2H˙(1+αH−4)=ρm+pm+ρDE+pDE-2M_p^2\dot{H}(1 + \alpha H^{-4}) = \rho_m + p_m + \rho_{DE} + p_{DE}

Experimental Setup and Analysis

Three Cosmological Scenarios

  1. Dark Energy-Dominated Universe: Neglecting matter contribution, pure dark energy evolution
  2. Non-Interacting Case: Independent evolution of dark energy and dark matter
  3. Interacting Case: Energy exchange between dark energy and dark matter

Key Parameters

  • Density parameter: ΩDE=c2+αH−4\Omega_{DE} = c^2 + \alpha H^{-4}
  • Interaction term: Q=3b2H(1+r)ρDEQ = 3b^2H(1+r)\rho_{DE}
  • Evolution equations for equation of state parameter

Experimental Results

Dark Energy-Dominated Scenario

  • Hubble parameter as constant: H=[2α/(1−c2)]1/4H = [2\alpha/(1-c^2)]^{1/4}
  • Equation of state parameter: wDE=−1w_{DE} = -1 (perfectly simulating cosmological constant)
  • Theoretical expression for cosmological constant: Λ=3πK2G1+c21−c2\Lambda = \frac{3\pi K}{2G}\frac{1+c^2}{\sqrt{1-c^2}}

Non-Interacting Case

  • Equation of state parameter: wDE=2ΩDE(c2−ΩDE1+ΩDE−2c2)w_{DE} = \frac{2}{\Omega_{DE}}\left(\frac{c^2-\Omega_{DE}}{1+\Omega_{DE}-2c^2}\right)
  • Condition for accelerated expansion: c2<ΩDE2(5−ΩDE3−ΩDE)c^2 < \frac{\Omega_{DE}}{2}\left(\frac{5-\Omega_{DE}}{3-\Omega_{DE}}\right)
  • At ΩDE≈0.7\Omega_{DE} \approx 0.7, requires c2≲0.654c^2 \lesssim 0.654

Interacting Case

  • Modified equation of state: wDE=2ΩDE(c2−ΩDE−b2/61+ΩDE−2c2)w_{DE} = \frac{2}{\Omega_{DE}}\left(\frac{c^2-\Omega_{DE}-b^2/6}{1+\Omega_{DE}-2c^2}\right)
  • Total equation of state can cross the phantom divide (wtot<−1w_{tot} < -1)
  • Phase transition of deceleration parameter occurs at higher redshifts

Stability Analysis

  • Sound speed squared: For interacting KHDE, vs2<0v_s^2 < 0, indicating instability
  • Model stability decreases with increasing interaction parameter b2b^2

State Finder Analysis

  • State finder parameters {r,s}\{r,s\} approach {1,0}\{1,0\} (ΛCDM values) in the future
  • At the present epoch, KHDE model differs significantly from ΛCDM
  • Increasing interaction parameter shifts the state finder diagram away from the ΛCDM point

Related Work

Holographic Dark Energy Models

  • Fundamental HDE model proposed by Cohen-Kaplan-Nelson
  • Various choices of infrared cutoffs: future event horizon, Granda-Oliveros cutoff, Ricci scalar, etc.

Holographic Dark Energy with Modified Entropy

  • Tsallis holographic dark energy: based on Tsallis generalized entropy
  • Barrow holographic dark energy: considering quantum gravity effects on black hole horizon geometry
  • Kaniadakis holographic dark energy: based on relativistic statistical theory

Innovation of This Work

The main distinction from previous studies 30-32 is that this work investigates KHDE within the modified Kaniadakis cosmological framework, rather than merely modifying the energy density expression.

Conclusions and Discussion

Main Conclusions

  1. Theoretical Consistency: By studying KHDE within modified Kaniadakis cosmology, consistency between entropy modification and field equation modification is achieved.
  2. Origin of Cosmological Constant: KHDE provides a thermodynamic-based theoretical explanation for the cosmological constant, with Λ∼K\Lambda \sim K.
  3. Feasibility of Hubble Cutoff: In Kaniadakis cosmology, the Hubble radius as infrared cutoff can achieve cosmic acceleration even without interaction.
  4. Rich Cosmological Phenomena: The model can exhibit quintessence-like, phantom, or phantom-crossing behavior.

Limitations

  1. Stability Issues: The interacting KHDE model exhibits sound speed instability (vs2<0v_s^2 < 0).
  2. Parameter Constraints: Constraints such as c2<1c^2 < 1 and K≪1K \ll 1 are required.
  3. Observational Verification: More observational data are needed to validate the reasonableness of model parameters.

Future Directions

  1. Detailed comparative analysis with observational data
  2. Theoretical improvements to address stability issues
  3. Applications in other modified gravity theories

In-Depth Evaluation

Strengths

  1. Theoretical Rigor: Correctly addresses the consistency between entropy modification and field equation modification, representing important progress in the field.
  2. Physical Insight: Provides a new theoretical explanation for the cosmological constant with significant theoretical significance.
  3. Systematic Analysis: Comprehensively analyzes various cosmological properties of the model, including evolution, stability, and state finder parameters.
  4. Numerical Verification: Theoretical predictions are verified through detailed numerical calculations and graphical presentations.

Weaknesses

  1. Stability Issues: Instability in the interacting case may limit the physical viability of the model.
  2. Insufficient Observational Comparison: Lacks detailed comparative analysis with latest observational data.
  3. Limited Parameter Space Exploration: Systematic exploration of the parameter space is not sufficiently comprehensive.

Impact

  1. Theoretical Contribution: Provides a correct theoretical framework for modified holographic dark energy models.
  2. Practical Value: Offers new perspectives for understanding the nature of dark energy and the cosmological constant problem.
  3. Reproducibility: Theoretical derivations are clear and numerical results are reproducible.

Applicable Scenarios

This methodology is applicable to research on modified gravity theories, dark energy models, and cosmological problems requiring consideration of entropy modification effects. It has important implications for understanding the evolution of both the early and late universe.

References

The paper cites 51 relevant references covering dark energy observations, holographic principle, modified entropy theory, and cosmological models, providing a solid theoretical foundation for the research.