The information content of points on lines and $k$-plane extensions

Basic Information

• Paper ID: 2510.11645
• Title: The information content of points on lines and $k$-plane extensions
• Author: Jacob B. Fiedler (University of Wisconsin-Madison)
• Classification: math.CA (Classical Analysis and ODEs), math.LO (Logic)
• Publication Date: October 13, 2025 (arXiv preprint)
• Paper Link: https://arxiv.org/abs/2510.11645

Abstract

This paper establishes new lower bounds on the algorithmic information content of points on lines in $\mathbb{R}^n$. Specifically, the author proves that for any line $\ell$ and a typical point $z$ on it, at each precision $r$ the following holds: $K_r(z) \geq \frac{K_r(\ell)}{2} + r - o(r)$ In other words, a randomly chosen point on a line possesses at least half the complexity of the line plus the complexity of its first coordinate. The author applies this effectivity result to establish classical bounds on the growth of Hausdorff dimension when unions of positive-measure subsets of $k$-planes are replaced by entire $k$-planes.

Research Background and Motivation

1. Core Problem: This research addresses a fundamental question in algorithmic information theory regarding the complexity relationships of geometric objects—how much information about a line should be contained in a point on that line?
2. Problem Significance:
   • From an information-theoretic perspective, two points determine a line, so points on a line should contain partial information about the line
   • Through the point-to-set principle, such complexity bounds can be translated into classical problems in geometric measure theory
   • Connects deep relationships between algorithmic information theory and fractal geometry
3. Limitations of Existing Approaches:
   • Although random-direction lines through the origin have high complexity, they contain extremely simple points
   • Lack of quantitative characterization of typical point complexity
   • Traditional methods struggle with uneven distribution of complexity across different precisions
4. Research Motivation:
   • Establish quantitative relationships between line complexity and point complexity on that line
   • Apply tools from algorithmic information theory to classical problems in geometric measure theory
   • Extend the proxy point technique of Cholak-Csörnyei-Lutz-Lutz-Mayordomo-Stull

Core Contributions

1. Main Algorithmic Result: Proves Theorem 1, establishing a new lower bound on the complexity of typical points on lines: $K_r(z) \geq \frac{K_r(\ell)}{2} + r - o(r)$
2. Geometric Application: Uses the algorithmic result to prove Hausdorff dimension bounds for $k$-plane extensions: $\dim_H(F) \leq 2\dim_H(E) - k$
3. Technical Innovation: Modifies and extends the proxy point technique to handle uneven distribution of complexity across different precisions
4. Theoretical Insight: First quantitatively characterizes information relationships between geometric objects and their constituent parts within the algorithmic information theory framework

Methodology Details

Task Definition

Input:

• Set $A \subseteq \mathbb{N}$ (as an oracle)
• Line $\ell$ in $\mathbb{R}^n$
• Real number $s \in \mathbb{R}$ (random relative to $A$)

Output: Lower bound on the complexity of point $\ell(s)$

Constraints:

• $s$ is random relative to $A$
• $K^A_r(\ell|s) \geq K^A_r(\ell) - O(\log r)$

Core Theorem Architecture

Theorem 1 (Main Algorithmic Result)

Let $A \subseteq \mathbb{N}$, $\ell$ be a line in $\mathbb{R}^n$, and $s \in \mathbb{R}$. Assume $s$ is random relative to $A$ and $K^A_r(\ell|s) \geq K^A_r(\ell) - O(\log r)$ Then $K^A_r(\ell(s)) \geq \frac{K^A_r(\ell)}{2} + r - o(r)$

Theorem 2 (Geometric Application)

Let $E \subseteq \mathbb{R}^n$ and $F$ be the union of $E$ and all $k$-planes that have positive-measure intersection with $E$. Then either $E = F$ or $\dim_H(F) \leq 2\dim_H(E) - k$

Proof Strategy

Proof Outline for Theorem 2

1. Point-to-Set Principle Application: Uses the point-to-set principle for effective dimension to transform the problem into single-point complexity estimation
2. Radial Slice Argument: Applies Fubini's theorem to select lines with positive-measure intersections
3. Complexity Transfer: Establishes complexity bounds using the symmetry of information principle and Theorem 1

Core Proof Techniques for Theorem 1

Application of Proxy Point Technique:

1. Problem Setup: Assume the conclusion is false, i.e., there exist $\ell$ and $s$ such that $K^A_r(\ell(s)) < \frac{K^A_r(\ell)}{2} + r - \varepsilon r$
2. Key Set Definitions:
   • $L = \{d \in D(A(n,1), r) \cap B_1(\ell_x) : K^A(d) \leq K_r(\ell) + C_1\log r\}$
   • $N_v = \{d \in L : K^A_r(d(v)) < \frac{K^A_r(\ell)}{2} + r - \varepsilon r + C_5\log r\}$
3. Combinatorial Argument:
   • Proves that "many" $N_v$ have large cardinality
   • Applies Lemma 5 (combinatorial lemma from Cholak et al.)
   • Finds a proxy pair $(u,v)$ satisfying specific complexity conditions
4. Derivation of Contradiction:
   • On one hand: $l(u)$ and $l(v)$ have low complexity (by assumption)
   • On the other hand: the line they determine has high complexity
   • Uses information symmetry to derive a contradiction

Technical Innovations

1. Extension of Proxy Point Technique: Compared to the original technique in 4, this paper requires the proxy pair $(u,v)$ to also determine a large amount of information independent of $\ell$, resulting in the additional "+r" term
2. Precision Control: Introduces parameter $t = \frac{\varepsilon r}{2n}$ to precisely control complexity relationships across different precisions
3. Exploitation of Computability: Cleverly utilizes the computability properties of relevant sets to establish complexity lower bounds

Experimental Setup

This paper is purely theoretical research with no numerical experiments. All results are obtained through rigorous mathematical proofs.

Theoretical Verification Methods

• Constructive proof techniques
• Proof by contradiction and derivation of contradictions
• Combinatorial mathematical arguments
• Standard techniques from algorithmic information theory

Related Work

Foundations of Algorithmic Information Theory

• Kolmogorov Complexity Theory: Built on work by Kolmogorov, Chaitin, and others
• Effective Dimension Theory: The point-to-set principle by J. Lutz and N. Lutz serves as a core tool

Applications in Geometric Measure Theory

1. Keleti's Work: Proved that Hausdorff dimension does not increase when line segments are replaced by complete lines in the plane, and conjectured this holds in $\mathbb{R}^n$
2. Falconer-Mattila Results: Proved that extensions of positive-measure subsets of hyperplanes cannot increase Hausdorff dimension
3. Contributions by Héra-Keleti-Máthé: Concerning Hausdorff dimension bounds for unions of affine subspaces
4. Connection to Kakeya Conjecture: Keleti and Máthé proved that the Kakeya conjecture implies the line segment extension conjecture

Proxy Point Technique

• Cholak-Csörnyei-Lutz-Lutz-Mayordomo-Stull 4: First introduced the proxy point technique, applied to exceptional set estimation for projections
• Modifications in This Paper: Extends the technique to handle more complex geometric constraints

Conclusions and Discussion

Main Conclusions

1. Algorithmic Level: Typical points on a line must contain at least half the complexity of the line plus the full complexity of one coordinate
2. Geometric Level: The Hausdorff dimension growth of $k$-plane extensions has a clear upper bound of $2\dim_H(E) - k$
3. Methodological: The proxy point technique has broad applicability in geometric applications of algorithmic information theory

Limitations

1. Randomness Assumption: Theorem 1 requires $s$ to be random relative to oracle $A$, which may be difficult to verify in practical applications
2. Precision Dependence: The $o(r)$ term in the results may produce significant effects at finite precision
3. Dimension Types: Theorem 2 only concerns Hausdorff dimension, while the author's previous work has established stronger packing dimension results

Future Directions

1. Technical Extensions: Apply the proxy point technique to other problems in geometric measure theory
2. Dimension Theory: Study relationships between different dimension concepts
3. Computational Complexity: Explore applications of effective methods in computational geometry

In-Depth Evaluation

Strengths

1. Theoretical Depth: Establishes deep connections between algorithmic information theory and geometric measure theory
2. Technical Innovation: Successfully extends the proxy point technique, solving the technical challenge of uneven complexity distribution
3. Result Unification: Unifies seemingly unrelated information-theoretic bounds and geometric dimension bounds within a single framework
4. Proof Rigor: Mathematical arguments are rigorous with careful handling of technical details

Weaknesses

1. Limited Application Scope: Results are primarily theoretical with limited direct practical value
2. Constant Estimation: The proof involves multiple unspecified constants that may affect practical applicability
3. Assumption Verifiability: The verifiability of the randomness assumption in practical situations is questionable

Impact

1. Theoretical Contribution: Provides new examples of applications of algorithmic information theory in geometry
2. Methodological Value: The extension of the proxy point technique may inspire further related research
3. Interdisciplinary Significance: Deepens understanding of connections between different mathematical branches

Applicable Scenarios

• Dimension estimation problems in fractal geometry
• Geometric applications of algorithmic information theory
• Complexity analysis in computational geometry
• Effectivity problems in measure theory research

References

The paper cites 22 important references, covering:

• Foundational theory of algorithmic information theory
• Classical results in geometric measure theory
• Effective dimension theory
• Work related to the Kakeya conjecture
• Original literature on the proxy point technique

Overall Assessment: This is a high-quality theoretical mathematics paper that successfully applies tools from algorithmic information theory to classical problems in geometric measure theory. The technical innovations are significant and the proofs are rigorous. While direct practical applications are limited, it provides important theoretical foundations and methodological contributions for interdisciplinary research in related fields.