Method to search for the triple-neutron state in an electron scattering experiment

Basic Information

• Paper ID: 2510.11731
• Title: Method to search for the triple-neutron state in an electron scattering experiment
• Authors: Tianhao Shao, Jinhui Chen, Yu-Gang Ma, Josef Pochodzalla
• Classification: physics.ins-det nucl-ex nucl-th
• Publication Date: October 2025
• Paper Link: https://arxiv.org/abs/2510.11731

Abstract

An electron scattering experiment to search for the trineutron state $^3n$ by reaction ${\rm ^4He}(e,~e'p\pi^{+})^{3}n$ is designed for the A1 facility at Mainzer Microtron. The detailed principles, setup, and simulation of this experiment are presented. With the momenta of the scattered electron, the produced proton and $\pi^+$ from the reaction measured by three spectrometers with their triple coincidence, the missing mass spectrum of $^3n$ can be obtained. The production rate of $^3n$ based on the cross section of the reaction and a MC simulation is estimated to be about 1.5 per day, which can provide a confidence level of the signal greater than 5$\sigma$ with a beam time longer than 16 days. According to a MC simulation that evaluates the energy losses of particles in materials and the performance of three spectrometers, the estimated resolution and the predicted shape of the missing mass spectrum are presented. This work provides a new experimental concept for the search for multineutron states in future experiments with an electron beam.

Research Background and Motivation

Core Research Problem

This study aims to search for the trineutron state ($^3n$), a theoretically predicted but experimentally unverified multineutron system. Multineutron systems, composed solely of neutrons, serve as ideal platforms for testing nuclear forces and constraining neutron star models due to the absence of Coulomb interactions.

Significance of the Problem

1. Fundamental Physics: Exploring the boundaries of the nuclear chart is a fundamental task in nuclear physics, and the existence of multineutron states is crucial for understanding strong interactions
2. Theoretical Verification: Different theoretical calculations provide contradictory predictions regarding the existence of $^3n$, requiring experimental validation
3. Astrophysical Applications: Research on multineutron systems helps constrain neutron star models

Limitations of Existing Methods

1. Traditional Nuclear Reactions: Reactions such as $^3H(n,p)^3n$ and $^3H(t,^3He)^3n$ have yielded no evidence for $^3n$ from the 1960s to present
2. Pion Double Charge Exchange: The $^{3,4}He(\pi^-,\pi^+)^{3,4}n$ reactions have also shown no positive evidence
3. Initial State Correlation Problem: In certain reactions, observed signals may originate from initial-state neutron correlations in the target nucleus rather than genuine multineutron states

Research Motivation

The A1 collaboration recently successfully produced the neutron-rich hydrogen isotope $^6H$ using electron scattering experiment $^7Li(e,e'p\pi^+)^6H$, providing a new experimental concept for searching for multineutron states using electron beams. Based on similar principles, this paper designs an electron scattering experiment to search for $^3n$.

Core Contributions

1. Proposed a Novel Experimental Method: Designed an electron scattering experiment based on the $^4He(e,e'p\pi^+)^3n$ reaction to search for the trineutron state
2. Complete Experimental Design: Provided detailed experimental principles, apparatus configuration, and simulation analysis
3. Production Rate Estimation: Based on reaction cross sections and Monte Carlo simulation, estimated the production rate of $^3n$ to be approximately 1.5 per day
4. Systematic Performance Assessment: Evaluated energy losses, spectrometer performance, and missing mass spectrum resolution through simulation
5. Framework for Future Experiments: Provided a new experimental concept for future experiments searching for multineutron states using electron beams

Detailed Methodology

Experimental Principle

The experiment is based on the reaction $^4He(e,e'p\pi^+)^3n$, with the physical process including:

1. Delta Particle Production: An 855 MeV electron beam scatters and excites a proton in $^4He$ to the $Δ^+(1232)$ resonance state
2. Delta Particle Decay: $Δ^+(1232) \rightarrow n + \pi^+$
3. Neutron-Proton Scattering: The neutron produced from decay undergoes elastic scattering with another proton in the nucleus
4. Proton Escape: The scattered proton acquires momentum and escapes the nucleus, leaving the $^3n$ system

Experimental Apparatus

Three spectrometer systems at the MAMI-A1 facility are employed:

• SpekA: Angle -24.0°, central momentum 432 MeV/c, detects protons
• SpekB: Angle 15.1°, central momentum 422 MeV/c, detects scattered electrons
• SpekC: Angle 59.2°, central momentum 267 MeV/c, detects π⁺

Missing Mass Reconstruction

The missing mass is reconstructed by measuring the momenta of the scattered electron, produced proton, and π⁺ using triple coincidence technique:

$m_{miss} = \sqrt{(E_e + M_{^4He} - E_{e'} - E_p - E_{\pi^+})^2 - (\vec{p}_e - \vec{p}_{e'} - \vec{p}_p - \vec{p}_{\pi^+})^2}$

Technical Innovations

1. Avoidance of Initial State Correlations: Since $^4He$ contains only two neutrons, the third neutron originates from Delta decay, avoiding interference from initial-state neutron correlations
2. Triple Coincidence Technique: Employing coincidence measurements from three high-precision spectrometers significantly improves signal-to-noise ratio
3. Comprehensive Energy Loss Correction: Detailed consideration of particle energy losses and multiple scattering effects in various materials

Experimental Setup

Target and Beam Parameters

• Electron Beam Energy: 855 MeV
• Beam Intensity: 2 μA
• Target: Cylindrical $^4He$ gas target, diameter 80 mm, density 40 mg/cm³
• Areal Density: 0.32 g/cm²

Spectrometer Configuration

Detector Systems

• VDCs: Vertical drift chambers, momentum resolution ~0.1%, angular resolution ~3 mrad
• Scintillators: dE and TOF layers for particle identification and time measurement
• Cherenkov Detectors: Distinguish electrons from pions

Experimental Results

Production Rate Estimation

Based on reaction cross sections calculated using the MAID2007 model: $\frac{d^5\sigma}{dE'd\Omega_{e'}d\Omega_{\pi^+}} = 0.185 \frac{nb}{MeV \cdot sr^2}$

After considering various geometric and physical factors:

• Total Cross Section: $\sigma_{total} \approx 1.05 \times 10^{-6}$ nb
• Event Production Rate: ~15 events/day (within missing mass spectrum acceptance)
• $^3n$ Production Rate: ~1.5 events/day (assuming $^3n$ energy in the 0-10 MeV range)

Resolution Assessment

Experimental resolution evaluated through Monte Carlo simulation:

• Missing Mass Resolution: ~0.4 MeV (FWHM)
• Vertex Reconstruction Resolution: ~1 mm
• Systematic Uncertainty: 0.4-0.5 MeV

Statistical Significance

• Required Beam Time: Longer than 16 days
• Expected Confidence Level: >5σ
• Statistical Uncertainty: Hundreds of keV scale

Energy Loss Correction

Simulation demonstrated energy losses of various particles in experimental materials:

• Electrons: 0-1 MeV range, primarily in air
• Protons: 0-5 MeV range, broader distribution
• π⁺: 0-1 MeV range, correction effective

Related Work

Theoretical Studies of Multineutron States

• Supporting Existence: ab initio no-core Gamow shell model predicts $^3n$ energy ~1.3 MeV with width ~0.9 MeV
• Opposing Existence: Multiple theoretical calculations exclude the existence of $^3n$ resonance state

Experimental Search History

• Traditional Methods: Neutron-proton transfer reactions have yielded no evidence from the 1960s through 2024
• Pion Methods: Double charge exchange reactions show no positive results
• Correlation Functions: Momentum correlation function studies provide indirect evidence

A1 Collaboration Breakthrough

• $^6H$ Discovery: First production of $^6H$ in electron scattering experiment
• Method Verification: Demonstrated feasibility of electron scattering method for exotic nuclei

Conclusions and Discussion

Main Conclusions

1. Method Feasibility: The electron scattering experiment $^4He(e,e'p\pi^+)^3n$ provides a new pathway for searching for $^3n$
2. Experimental Parameters: Under MAMI-A1 facility conditions, 16 days of beam time can achieve 5σ confidence level
3. Technical Advantages: Avoids initial-state correlation problems and provides a clean experimental environment

Limitations

1. Low Production Rate: The production rate of 1.5 events/day requires extended beam time
2. Background Interference: Precise control of random coincidence background is necessary
3. Energy Resolution: The 0.4 MeV resolution may affect observation of narrow resonance states

Future Directions

1. High-Intensity Facilities: Higher production rates can be achieved at high-intensity electron beam facilities such as SXFEL
2. Tetraneutron Search: Extension to $^4He(e,e'\pi^+\pi^+)^4n$ reaction for searching tetraneutron states
3. Photon Beam Experiments: Utilization of $^4He(\gamma,p\pi^+)^3n$ reaction to simplify detection requirements

In-Depth Evaluation

Strengths

1. High Innovation: First comprehensive experimental proposal for searching $^3n$ using electron scattering
2. Comprehensive Analysis: Detailed analysis from theoretical principles to technical details
3. Sufficient Simulation: Monte Carlo simulation considers various physical effects and experimental conditions
4. Reliable Method: Method feasibility verified based on successful $^6H$ experiment

Weaknesses

1. Theory Dependence: Production rate estimation depends on theoretical models, actual results may deviate
2. Background Assessment: Relatively simple background evaluation, may underestimate complexity
3. Systematic Errors: Analysis of certain systematic error sources requires deeper investigation

Impact

1. Disciplinary Contribution: Provides new experimental tools for multineutron physics research
2. Technology Promotion: Serves as a paradigm for electron scattering research on exotic nuclei
3. International Collaboration: Promotes technical exchange and cooperation among different laboratories

Applicable Scenarios

1. Basic Research: Suitable for fundamental research on exotic nuclear structures such as multineutron states
2. Facility Upgrades: Provides new scientific directions for existing electron accelerator facilities
3. Future Experiments: Provides reference for experimental planning of next-generation high-brightness electron beam facilities

References

This paper cites 46 relevant references, covering multineutron state theory, experimental techniques, accelerator physics, and other aspects, providing a solid theoretical and technical foundation for the research.

Overall Assessment: This is a high-quality experimental physics paper proposing an innovative method for searching the trineutron state with important scientific significance and technical value. The paper provides comprehensive analysis, feasible methodology, and opens new experimental pathways for multineutron physics research.