Lepton Flavor Violation and Local Lepton Number

Basic Information

• Paper ID: 2510.11774
• Title: Lepton Flavor Violation and Local Lepton Number
• Authors: Hridoy Debnath, Pavel Fileviez Pérez (Case Western Reserve University)
• Classification: hep-ph (High Energy Physics - Phenomenology)
• Publication Date: October 15, 2025
• Paper Link: https://arxiv.org/abs/2510.11774

Abstract

This paper investigates predictions for lepton number violating processes in a minimal neutrino mass theory based on spontaneous breaking of local lepton number. Within this framework, the symmetry is broken at low energy scales, leading to the existence of a viable dark matter candidate. The new fermions required for anomaly cancellation mediate lepton number violation at the one-loop level. The authors provide detailed calculations of the most relevant processes, including μ→eγ, μ→3e, and μ→e conversion in nuclei. Parameter space regions excluded by current experimental limits are identified, and the interplay between collider observables and charged lepton flavor violation signals is emphasized as a crucial test of this minimal neutrino mass theory.

Research Background and Motivation

1. Core Problem: The discovery of neutrino oscillations established the non-conservation of lepton flavor, representing the first confirmed example of physics beyond the Standard Model. While neutrino flavor violation has been established, charged lepton flavor violation (LFV) remains unobserved.
2. Importance of the Problem:
   • In the Standard Model with massive Dirac neutrinos, the rates of processes such as μ→eγ, μ→3e, or μ→e conversion in nuclei are extremely suppressed, far below any foreseeable experimental sensitivity
   • Any observation of LFV in the charged lepton sector would be a clear signal of new physics
3. Limitations of Existing Approaches:
   • The Standard Model cannot provide observable LFV signals
   • Theoretical frameworks beyond the Standard Model are needed to predict measurable LFV processes
4. Research Motivation:
   • Theories based on gauged total lepton number provide a simple and predictive framework for addressing the origin of neutrino mass and dark matter
   • The minimal implementation of this theory requires only four new fermionic fields, one of which can serve as a viable dark matter candidate

Core Contributions

1. Proposed a minimal theoretical framework for local lepton number based on the gauge group SU(3)C ⊗ SU(2)L ⊗ U(1)Y ⊗ U(1)ℓ
2. Performed detailed calculations of key LFV processes, including μ→eγ, τ→e(μ)γ, μ→3e, τ→3e(μ), and μ→e conversion in nuclei
3. Established correlations between LFV bounds, dark matter phenomenology, and collider signals, providing a comprehensive testing scheme for the theory
4. Determined parameter space regions excluded by current and future experimental constraints, providing theoretical guidance for experimental searches
5. Provided complete one-loop calculations, including all relevant Feynman diagram contributions and exact analytical expressions

Methodology Details

Task Definition

Investigation of various lepton flavor violating processes mediated by new fermions and scalar fields through one-loop processes within the local lepton number theory framework, and comparison with experimental limits to constrain the theoretical parameter space.

Model Architecture

1. Gauge Group Structure:

• Fundamental gauge group: SU(3)C ⊗ SU(2)L ⊗ U(1)Y ⊗ U(1)ℓ
• New fermionic fields:
  • ΨL ∼ (1,1,-1,3/4), ΨR ∼ (1,1,-1,-3/4)
  • χL ∼ (1,1,0,3/4), ρL ∼ (1,3,0,-3/4)

2. Scalar Field Sector:

• S ∼ (1,1,0,3/2): Responsible for spontaneous breaking of U(1)ℓ
• ϕ ∼ (1,1,0,-1/4): Enables decay of ΨL field at the renormalizable level

3. Yukawa Interactions:

-L ⊃ λρTr(ρᵀLCρL)S + λΨΨ̄LΨRS + λχχᵀLCχLS* + λeΨLeRϕ + λRχLνRϕ + H.c.

Technical Innovations

1. Minimal Field Content: Anomaly cancellation is achieved with only four new fermionic fields, representing the minimal possible setup

2. Unified Framework: Simultaneously addresses neutrino mass, dark matter, and LFV issues

3. Predictability:

• Upper bound on symmetry breaking scale: MZℓ ≲ 30 TeV (from dark matter relic density constraints)
• Neutrino predictions as Dirac particles

4. Completeness of One-Loop Calculations: Includes all relevant Feynman diagram contributions, with exact calculations verified using Package-X

Experimental Setup

Data Sources

Current and expected experimental limits are employed:

Current Limits:

• μ→eγ: BR < 1.5×10⁻¹³ (MEG II)
• τ→eγ: BR < 3.3×10⁻⁸ (BABAR)
• τ→μγ: BR < 4.2×10⁻⁸ (BABAR)
• μ→3e: BR < 1.0×10⁻¹² (SINDRUM)

Future Expectations:

• μ→eγ: BR ∼ 6.0×10⁻¹⁴ (MEG II upgrade)
• μ Al→e Al: BR ∼ 10⁻¹⁷ (Mu2e, COMET)

Evaluation Metrics

• Branching ratio as the primary observable
• Excluded parameter space regions
• Ratio relationships between different processes

Theoretical Parameters

The model has five key free parameters:

• λe, λμ, λτ: Yukawa coupling constants
• MΨ, Mϕ: New particle masses

Experimental Results

Main Results

1. μ→eγ Process:

• Decay width: Γ(μ→eγ) = (e²λₑ²λμ²)/(16π) × m₅μ|AL|²
• When λe = λμ = 1, regions with mass up to approximately 30 TeV are excluded
• This forms a strong correlation with the upper bound from dark matter constraints

2. μ→e Conversion in Nuclei:

• Main contributions arise from photon-mediated processes
• Conversion rate: BRμ→e ≈ 10⁻⁴ × BR(μ→eγ)
• The Mu2e experiment will be able to probe levels of BR ∼ 10⁻¹⁷

3. Three-Body Decays:

• BR(μ→3e) ≈ 10⁻³ × BR(μ→eγ)
• BR(τ→3μ) ≈ 10⁻³ × BR(τ→μγ)
• BR(τ→3e) ≈ 10⁻² × BR(τ→eγ)

Parameter Space Constraints

Strong Coupling Regime (λe = λμ = 1):

• μ→eγ limits exclude regions with MΨ < 30 TeV
• Highly consistent with dark matter cosmological constraints

Moderate Coupling Regime (λe = λμ = 0.1):

• Exclusion of MΨ < 300 GeV (μ→3e)
• Exclusion of MΨ < several TeV (μ→eγ)

Collider-LFV Correlation

• Collider searches provide stronger constraints in certain parameter regions
• When BR(Ψ→τϕ) is large, collider limits exclude MΨ < 400 GeV
• When λe, λμ are large, LFV limits become more important

Related Work

Main Research Directions

1. Local Lepton Number Theories: Foundational work by Fileviez Pérez and collaborators
2. LFV Phenomenology: Extensive research on LFV predictions in various beyond-Standard-Model scenarios
3. Neutrino Mass Mechanisms: Including seesaw mechanisms, radiative mechanisms, etc.

Advantages of This Work

1. Minimality: Achieves all objectives with the fewest new fields
2. Completeness: Provides comprehensive analysis from theory to phenomenology
3. Testability: Establishes correlations among multiple experimental signals
4. Precision: Provides complete one-loop calculation results

Conclusions and Discussion

Main Conclusions

1. Theoretical Predictions: The minimal local lepton number theory produces observable LFV signals at the one-loop level
2. Experimental Constraints: Current LFV experimental limits impose strong constraints on the theoretical parameter space, particularly from μ→eγ searches
3. Future Prospects: Forthcoming experiments (such as Mu2e) will be able to probe or exclude much of the parameter space of this theory
4. Multi-Signal Correlations: Strong correlations exist between different LFV processes, collider signals, and dark matter constraints, providing comprehensive tests of the theory

Limitations

1. Parameter Dependence: Predictions strongly depend on the values of Yukawa couplings, which are free parameters in the theory
2. One-Loop Approximation: Calculations consider only one-loop contributions; higher-order corrections may be important
3. Dark Matter Assumption: The upper bound on the theory depends on specific dark matter candidate assumptions

Future Directions

1. Precision Calculations: Inclusion of two-loop and higher-order corrections
2. Collider Phenomenology: Detailed study of signals at future colliders (such as muon colliders)
3. Cosmological Constraints: More detailed dark matter and cosmological analysis
4. Flavor Structure: Investigation of the origin of flavor structure in Yukawa couplings

In-Depth Evaluation

Strengths

1. Theoretical Consistency: Provides a minimal and consistent framework addressing multiple fundamental problems simultaneously
2. Computational Completeness: One-loop calculations are detailed and accurate, verified using professional software packages
3. Phenomenological Richness: Establishes clear connections between theory and multiple experimental signals
4. Predictive Power: Provides concrete, testable predictions and ratio relationships

Weaknesses

1. Parameter Space: The theory still contains numerous free parameters, limiting the definiteness of predictions
2. Experimental Coverage: Experimental verification of certain predictions requires improvements in future experiments
3. Theoretical Motivation: Insufficient discussion of theoretical motivation for Yukawa coupling values

Impact

1. Field Contribution: Provides new theoretical framework and computational tools for LFV phenomenology
2. Practical Value: Provides concrete theoretical targets for current and future LFV experiments
3. Reproducibility: Provides detailed calculation formulas and parameters for independent verification

Applicable Scenarios

1. Experimental Guidance: Provides theoretical expectations and parameter space for LFV search experiments
2. Model Building: Serves as reference for constructing unified neutrino-dark matter theories
3. Phenomenological Research: Acts as a concrete theoretical example for studying LFV processes

References

The paper cites important works in the field, including:

• Latest results from MEG, BABAR and other experimental collaborations
• Foundational work on local lepton number theories by Fileviez Pérez and collaborators
• Classical review articles on LFV phenomenology
• Related collider phenomenology studies

Overall Assessment: This is a high-quality theoretical physics paper that systematically investigates LFV phenomenology within the local lepton number theory framework. The paper has solid theoretical foundations, detailed and accurate calculations, and close connections with experiments, providing valuable contributions to both theoretical and experimental research in this field. While certain theoretical degrees of freedom exist, the overall framework is convincing and testable.