Evolution With(out) Time: Relational Holography & BPS Complexity Growth in $\mathcal{N}=2$ Double-Scaled SYK

Basic Information

• Paper ID: 2510.11777
• Title: Evolution With(out) Time: Relational Holography & BPS Complexity Growth in $\mathcal{N}=2$ Double-Scaled SYK
• Author: Sergio E. Aguilar-Gutierrez (Okinawa Institute of Science and Technology Graduate University)
• Classification: hep-th (High Energy Physics - Theory), quant-ph (Quantum Physics)
• Submission Date: October 13, 2025
• Paper Link: https://arxiv.org/abs/2510.11777

Abstract

This paper investigates how to describe non-trivial bulk measurements relative to an observer when both the observer and the probed system may or may not undergo time evolution in supersymmetric theories. The author addresses this problem in the $\mathcal{N}=2$ double-scaled SYK model and its conjectured bulk dual by: (i) establishing a holographic program in the language of quantum reference frames, dressing bulk observables with "clocks" parameterized by boundary time and R-charge; (ii) proposing a novel Krylov complexity measurement that uses R-charge in the boundary theory to probe zero-energy BPS states. Holographically, this proposal reproduces relational bulk observables—BPS wormhole lengths.

Research Background and Motivation

Core Problem

The central problem addressed in this paper is: how to describe non-trivial relational measurements of systems that may not evolve in time, particularly for zero-energy BPS states in supersymmetric theories. This problem is especially significant within the framework of holographic duality.

Research Motivation

1. Development needs of relational holography: Existing holographic dictionaries primarily handle systems with non-trivial time evolution, but encounter difficulties in treating zero-energy states (such as BPS states)
2. Limitations of Krylov complexity: Traditional Krylov complexity definitions depend on Liouvillian or Hamiltonian evolution, becoming trivial for systems without time flow
3. Chaos measurements in supersymmetric theories: New methods are needed to quantify chaotic behavior in BPS states, where traditional time-correlated measurements fail

Limitations of Existing Approaches

• The Page-Wootters (PW) mechanism primarily applies when there is non-trivial observer time
• Existing quantum reference frame (QRF) methods have not been sufficiently explored in supersymmetric theories
• Traditional spread complexity loses meaning in zero-energy states

Core Contributions

1. Established a relational holographic framework: In the language of quantum reference frames, developed a gravitational dressing program for systems with or without boundary time evolution
2. Proposed BPS spread complexity: Introduced a novel Krylov complexity measurement based on R-charge "evolution," applicable to zero-energy BPS states
3. Extended the holographic dictionary: Demonstrated that the new complexity measurement precisely reproduces the expectation value of total string number in BPS states and matches wormhole length in $\mathcal{N}=2$ JT supergravity in the semiclassical limit
4. Comparative analysis of different states: Systematically studied Krylov complexity differences between BPS and non-BPS Hartle-Hawking states

Methodology Details

Task Definition

Investigation of how to define and compute in the $\mathcal{N}=2$ double-scaled SYK model:

• Complexity growth of zero-energy BPS states
• Gravitational dressing of relational bulk observables
• Spread complexity under different reference states

Theoretical Framework

1. Super-chord Hilbert Space

The super-chord Hilbert space of $\mathcal{N}=2$ DSSYK is constructed as: $H_{\text{super-chord}} = \{|\Omega, j\rangle, |n,XO, j\rangle, |n,OX, j\rangle, |n,XX, j\rangle, |n,OO, j\rangle\}_{n\in\mathbb{N}, j\in\mathbb{Z}}$

where $|\Omega, j\rangle$ denotes the maximally entangled state with fixed R-charge $j$, and other states are constructed from different combinations of X and O nodes.

2. BPS Hartle-Hawking States

BPS states are defined through supercharge constraints: $\hat{Q}_{L/R}|\Psi, j\rangle = \hat{Q}_{L/R}^{\dagger}|\Psi, j\rangle = 0$

The solution takes the form: $|\Psi, j\rangle = \sum_{n=0}^{\infty}(\alpha_n |n,XO, j\rangle + \beta_n |n,OX, j\rangle)$

The coefficients satisfy recurrence relations expressible in terms of q-Hermite polynomials.

3. Relational Holographic Program

Establishes kinematical bulk Hilbert space $H_{\text{kin}} = H_S \otimes H_R$, where:

• System space: $H_S = \{|\Omega, j\rangle, |L,XO, j\rangle, |L,OX, j\rangle, |L,XX, j\rangle, |L,OO, j\rangle\}_{L\in\mathbb{R}, j\in\mathbb{Z}}$
• Reference space: $H_R = \{|t, j\rangle\}_{t\in\mathbb{R}, j\in\mathbb{Z}}$

Clock states are defined as: $|t, j\rangle := e^{-it\hat{H}_{\text{bdry}}}|\Omega, j\rangle$

Technical Innovations

1. Definition of BPS Spread Complexity

For BPS states, an effective Hamiltonian based on R-charge is proposed: $\hat{H}'_{\text{eff}}|B_n\rangle = \left((q^3 - q^{2\hat{n}-1})e^{i\hat{P}} + e^{-i\hat{P}}\right)|B_n\rangle$

Through the Choi-Jamiolkowski isomorphism mapping: $\hat{L}: \langle\pm j_R|B_n\rangle \rightarrow |\pm j_R, B_n)$

The BPS complexity operator is defined as: $\hat{C}_d = \sum_{n=0}^{\infty} n|B_n, B_n)(B_n, B_n|$

2. Gravitational Dressing Program

Relational observables are realized through G-twirl: $\hat{O}^{(t=\xi,j)}_R(\hat{a}) := \prod_{k=-\infty}^{\infty}\int_{\mathbb{R}}d\eta e^{-i\hat{H}_{\text{WDW}}\eta}(\hat{a}\otimes |t=\xi, j\rangle\langle t=\xi, j|)e^{i\hat{H}_{\text{WDW}}\eta}$

Experimental Setup

Theoretical Verification Methods

1. Semiclassical limit analysis: Verifying correspondence with JT supergravity through the $\lambda \rightarrow 0$ limit
2. Recurrence relation solving: Using q-special functions to exactly solve BPS state coefficients
3. Path integral methods: Computing complexity evolution under saddle-point approximation

Comparative Analysis

• Complexity behavior of BPS vs. non-BPS states
• Differences between $\mathcal{N}=2$ and bosonic DSSYK
• Effects of different reference state choices

Experimental Results

Main Results

1. Correspondence Between BPS Complexity and String Number

BPS spread complexity precisely reproduces the expectation value of the total string number operator in BPS states: $C_d = \langle\Psi_j|\hat{C}_d|\Psi_j\rangle = \langle\Psi, j|\hat{n}|\Psi, j\rangle$

2. Holographic Correspondence of Wormhole Length

In the semiclassical limit, BPS complexity corresponds to BPS wormhole length in $\mathcal{N}=2$ JT supergravity: $\ell(j) = 2\lambda\langle\Psi, j|\hat{n}|\Psi, j\rangle = -\left(\psi_{q^2}\left(\frac{1}{2}-j\right) + \psi_{q^2}\left(\frac{1}{2}+j\right) + 2\log(1-q^2)\right)$

3. Complexity of Non-BPS States

For orthogonal bosonic subspaces and maximally entangled states, the semiclassical limit recovers the same results as bosonic DSSYK: $C(t) = \frac{2}{\lambda}\log\left(\frac{\cosh(J\sin\theta t)}{\sin\theta}\right)$

Key Findings

1. Importance of quantum corrections: Although the semiclassical limit yields results identical to the bosonic case, quantum corrections contain supersymmetric information
2. Critical role of R-charge: R-charge parameterization provides the unique "evolution" parameter in BPS states
3. Extension of holographic dictionary: Successfully extends the concept of complexity growth to zero-energy states

Related Work

Main Research Directions

1. Double-scaled SYK models: Foundational work by Berkooz et al. establishing the model framework
2. Krylov complexity: Operator growth hypothesis proposed by Parker et al. and spread complexity by Balasubramanian et al.
3. Holographic complexity: Susskind's complexity=volume conjecture and its implementation in AdS/CFT
4. Quantum reference frames: Perspective-neutral methods developed by Höhn et al.

Unique Contributions of This Work

• First application of quantum reference frame methods to supersymmetric theories
• Proposes complexity measurements applicable to zero-time-evolution states
• Establishes holographic correspondence between BPS state complexity and wormhole geometry

Conclusions and Discussion

Main Conclusions

1. Establishment of relational holographic framework: Successfully extended the Page-Wootters mechanism to supersymmetric systems incorporating R-charge
2. Definition of BPS complexity: Proposed novel complexity measurement based on R-charge evolution, resolving the complexity problem for zero-energy states
3. Enrichment of holographic dictionary: Demonstrated precise correspondence between new complexity measurement and bulk wormhole length

Limitations

1. Model specificity: Main results are based on the $\mathcal{N}=2$ DSSYK model; generalization to other theories requires further investigation
2. Semiclassical approximation: Some results depend on the semiclassical limit $\lambda \rightarrow 0$
3. Uncertainty in bulk theory: The exact bulk dual of $\mathcal{N}=2$ DSSYK remains incompletely determined

Future Directions

1. Extension to higher dimensions: Extending methods to higher-dimensional supersymmetric theories
2. Finite-N effects: Investigating complexity behavior in non-ensemble-averaged cases
3. Experimental verification: Seeking experimentally verifiable predictions
4. York time: Investigating possible evolution of BPS states in York time

In-Depth Evaluation

Strengths

1. Strong theoretical innovation: First systematic treatment of complexity for zero-time-evolution states
2. Mathematical rigor: Uses exact q-special functions and recurrence relations, avoiding unnecessary approximations
3. Clear holographic correspondence: Establishes explicit correspondence between boundary complexity and bulk geometry
4. Methodological contribution: Application of quantum reference frames to supersymmetric theories has universal significance

Weaknesses

1. Computational complexity: Some results require intricate q-function calculations, potentially limiting practical applications
2. Physical interpretation: The physical meaning of R-charge as "time" requires deeper elucidation
3. Experimental verifiability: Most results are theoretical, lacking direct experimental verification pathways

Impact and Significance

1. Academic value: Provides new research directions for holographic duality and complexity theory
2. Methodological significance: The established framework may apply to other supersymmetric systems
3. Interdisciplinary potential: Quantum reference frame methods may find applications in quantum information and condensed matter physics

Applicable Scenarios

• Research on supersymmetric black hole microstates
• Complexity growth problems in quantum gravity
• Construction of new observables in AdS/CFT correspondence
• Manifestations of quantum chaos in supersymmetric systems

References

The paper includes abundant references spanning multiple fields including double-scaled SYK models, Krylov complexity, holographic duality, and quantum reference frames, providing readers with comprehensive background sources.