A SHIFT of Perspective: Observing Neutrinos at CMS and ATLAS

Basic Information

• Paper ID: 2510.11816
• Title: A SHIFT of Perspective: Observing Neutrinos at CMS and ATLAS
• Authors: Alfonso Garcia-Soto (Instituto de Física Corpuscular, CSIC-UV), Jeremi Niedziela (Deutsches Elektronen-Synchrotron DESY)
• Classification: hep-ph (High Energy Physics - Phenomenology), hep-ex (High Energy Physics - Experiment)
• Publication Date: October 13, 2025 (arXiv preprint)
• Paper Link: https://arxiv.org/abs/2510.11816

Abstract

This paper investigates the physics potential of the SHIFT@LHC project, which proposes installing a gas fixed target in the LHC tunnel as a novel detectable neutrino source. Through simulations of proton-gas collisions, hadron propagation, and neutrino interactions, the authors estimate that $O(10^4)$ muon neutrino and $O(10^3)$ electron neutrino interactions will occur in the CMS and ATLAS detectors using 1% of the LHC Run-4 integrated luminosity, with energies ranging from 20 GeV to 1 TeV. This unique configuration enables detection of hadron production processes in the pseudorapidity range 5<η<8, complementary to existing LHC detectors. If realized, this would mark the first detection of neutrinos in general-purpose LHC detectors, opening new avenues for studying neutrino production and interactions directly relevant to atmospheric neutrino experiments.

Research Background and Motivation

Problem Definition

Since the 1980s, it has been recognized that hadron colliders operating at TeV energy scales naturally provide intense and highly collimated forward neutrino beams. Recent FASER and SND@LHC experiments have for the first time observed neutrinos from LHC proton-proton collisions, initiating a rich physics research program.

Research Significance

1. Filling Detection Gaps: Existing LHC neutrino experiments (FASER, SND@LHC) primarily detect high-energy neutrinos, while SHIFT@LHC can detect intermediate-energy neutrinos from 20 GeV to 1 TeV
2. Complementary Studies: Provides unique detection capability for hadron production processes in the pseudorapidity range 5<η<8, a region inaccessible to existing LHC detectors
3. Atmospheric Neutrino Relevance: Provides important input for atmospheric neutrino experiments such as KM3NeT-ORCA, IceCube-DeepCore, DUNE, and Hyper-Kamiokande

Limitations of Existing Methods

• FASER and SND@LHC primarily detect higher-energy neutrinos (peak at several TeV)
• Traditional fixed-target neutrino experiments (e.g., MINOS, NOMAD) use dense target materials and magnetic focusing systems, differing from the low-pressure gas target configuration in this study
• General-purpose detectors such as CMS and ATLAS have never previously detected neutrinos

Core Contributions

1. First feasibility study of neutrino detection in general-purpose LHC detectors
2. Established complete simulation chain: from proton-gas collisions to hadron propagation to neutrino interactions
3. Quantitative predictions of neutrino event rates: estimated $O(10^4)$ neutrino interactions observable at 1% Run-4 integrated luminosity
4. Provided new pseudorapidity detection window: covering 5<η<8 range, filling gaps in existing detectors
5. Provided theoretical support for atmospheric neutrino experiments: directly relevant energy ranges and interaction types

Methodology Details

Task Definition

Investigate the interaction rates and physics characteristics of neutrinos produced by gas fixed targets in the SHIFT@LHC configuration within the CMS and ATLAS detectors. Input: 6.8 TeV proton beam colliding with stationary proton targets; Output: neutrino interaction events in the detectors.

Simulation Architecture

1. Hadron Production Simulation

• PYTHIA8 used to simulate 6.8 TeV proton collisions with stationary proton targets
• Default settings employed, events generated in bins by hard process transverse momentum ($\hat{p}_T$)
• Fixed target location: approximately 160 meters upstream from CMS/ATLAS interaction point

2. Hadron Propagation Simulation

Three main scenarios considered:

• (a) Parent particles produce neutrinos before reaching rock: no material suppression
• (b) Hadrons decay in rock producing neutrinos: GEANT4 simulation of standard rock, all hadrons stopped within <1 meter
• (c) Muons decay in rock: due to longer lifetime, no muon decay within decay volume

3. Neutrino Interaction Simulation

• GENIE used to simulate neutrino propagation and interactions
• Focus on charged-current (CC) interactions above 20 GeV
• G18_02a tuning for 20 GeV-1 TeV, GHE19_00b tuning for >1 TeV
• Requirements: outgoing charged lepton energy >3 GeV, hadronic shower energy >10 GeV

Technical Innovations

1. Optimized Geometric Configuration: 160-meter distance balances decay path length and material effects
2. Multi-detector Analysis: simultaneous consideration of different calorimeter components in CMS and ATLAS
3. Pseudorapidity Mapping: parent hadron pseudorapidity inferred from neutrino interaction vertex position
4. Material Effect Modeling: detailed consideration of rock surrounding LHC tunnel effects on hadron propagation

Experimental Setup

Simulation Parameters

• Proton Beam Energy: 6.8 TeV
• Target Material: stationary protons (low-pressure gas)
• Target Location: 160 meters upstream from IP5/IP1
• Integrated Luminosity: 1% of LHC Run-4 (7.15 fb⁻¹)
• Energy Thresholds: neutrino energy >20 GeV, lepton >3 GeV, hadron >10 GeV

Detector Geometry

• CMS: Hadronic Endcap (HE, HB) and Electromagnetic Calorimeter (EE, EB)
• ATLAS: Forward Calorimeter (FCAL), Hadronic Endcap (HEC), Tile Barrel Calorimeter, Electromagnetic Calorimeter (EMEC, EMB)

Evaluation Metrics

• Number of neutrino interaction events
• Energy distributions
• Flavor distributions (νμ, νe, ντ)
• Pseudorapidity coverage range
• Radial distributions

Experimental Results

Main Results

Event Rate Predictions (Table I)

CMS Detector:

• Muon neutrinos: 5,445 interactions (νμ: 3,951, ν̄μ: 1,230, others: 264)
• Electron neutrinos: 291 interactions (νe: 220, ν̄e: 71)
• Tau neutrinos: 4 interactions

ATLAS Detector:

• Muon neutrinos: 12,874 interactions (νμ: 9,584, ν̄μ: 3,290)
• Electron neutrinos: 786 interactions (νe: 573, ν̄e: 213)
• Tau neutrinos: 12 interactions

Energy Distribution Characteristics (Figure 2)

• Energy range: 20 GeV - several TeV
• Peak region: 20-100 GeV
• Main contributions: kaon decay (dominant), pion decay (<15 GeV)
• Muon neutrinos dominate

Geometric Distribution (Figures 1, 4)

• Hadron decay vertex exponentially decreasing along beam axis
• Neutrino interaction vertex showing clear radial dependence
• CMS pseudorapidity coverage: 5<η<6.5 (maximum sensitivity)
• ATLAS pseudorapidity coverage: 5<η<8 (broader coverage)

Position Dependence Analysis (Figure 3)

• Target position moved 30 meters away from IP: event rate increases ~30%
• Target position moved 30 meters closer to IP: event rate decreases ~30%
• Reason: longer decay path increases neutrino production rate

Comparison with Other Experiments (Figure 5)

SHIFT forms energy complementarity with FASER/SND@LHC:

• SHIFT: 20 GeV - 1 TeV (peak 20-100 GeV)
• FASER/SND: several hundred GeV - several TeV (peak several TeV)

Related Work

Historical Background

• 1980s: First recognition of neutrino production potential at TeV hadron colliders
• Recent Breakthroughs: FASER and SND@LHC first observe LHC neutrinos
• Traditional Experiments: CCFR, NOMAD, CHORUS, NuTeV, MINOS and other fixed-target neutrino experiments

Technical Comparison

• SMOG/SMOG2@LHCb: has verified feasibility of gas fixed-target technology
• Traditional Neutrino Beams: use dense target materials and magnetic focusing, higher flux but lack pseudorapidity information
• CMS High-Granularity Calorimeter: expected to observe small number of W boson decay neutrinos during high-luminosity running

Innovation

This study is the first to combine gas fixed-target technology with general-purpose LHC detectors, providing unique pseudorapidity-energy correlation information.

Conclusions and Discussion

Main Conclusions

1. Technical Feasibility: SHIFT@LHC configuration can produce observable neutrino signals in CMS/ATLAS
2. Event Rates: Using 1% Run-4 luminosity can observe $O(10^4)$ neutrino interactions
3. Physics Value: provides unique detection capability in pseudorapidity range 5<η<8
4. Experimental Significance: will mark first observation of neutrinos in general-purpose LHC detectors

Limitations

1. Reconstruction Efficiency: simplified position-dependent detection efficiency
2. Background Estimation: requires effective separation of neutrino signal from muon background
3. Pileup Effects: need to evaluate impact of concurrent pp collisions
4. Material Modeling: requires more detailed LHC tunnel geometry simulation

Future Directions

1. Precise Simulation: including detailed hadron propagation and tunnel geometry
2. Detector Response: evaluate CMS/ATLAS reconstruction performance under actual LHC conditions
3. Design Optimization: determine optimal target location to maximize neutrino production rate
4. Physics Applications: provide input for atmospheric neutrino experiments, study nuclear effects

In-Depth Evaluation

Strengths

1. Strong Innovation: first systematic study of neutrino detection in general-purpose LHC detectors
2. Complete Methodology: established complete simulation chain from collision to detection
3. Physics Significance: fills pseudorapidity detection gap, provides support for atmospheric neutrino research
4. Technical Feasibility: based on proven SMOG technology, has implementation potential
5. Quantitative Analysis: provides detailed event rate and distribution predictions

Weaknesses

1. Simplified Assumptions: oversimplified treatment of detection efficiency and reconstruction algorithms
2. Background Analysis: lacks detailed discussion of muon background separation
3. Systematic Uncertainties: insufficient discussion of simulation uncertainties and systematic errors
4. Experimental Challenges: insufficient discussion of technical difficulties in actual experiments
5. Cost-Benefit Analysis: lacks analysis of advantages and disadvantages relative to dedicated neutrino detectors

Impact

1. Academic Value: opens new directions for LHC neutrino physics
2. Practical Value: provides important theoretical input for atmospheric neutrino experiments
3. Technology Advancement: promotes application of general-purpose detectors in neutrino physics
4. Reproducibility: clear methodology facilitates verification by other research groups

Applicable Scenarios

1. Atmospheric Neutrino Experiments: provides benchmark for GeV-scale atmospheric neutrino experiments
2. Hadron Production Research: detects hadron production mechanisms in forward pseudorapidity regions
3. Neutrino Cross-Section Measurements: measures neutrino-nucleon cross sections on different nuclear materials
4. New Physics Searches: searches for new physics signals in unique geometric configurations

References

The paper contains 54 references covering important works in neutrino physics, LHC experiments, simulation tools and related fields, providing solid theoretical and experimental foundation for the research.

Overall Assessment: This is an innovative theoretical physics research work that systematically explores the possibility of observing neutrinos in general-purpose LHC detectors for the first time. While further refinement is needed in experimental details, it opens new directions for LHC neutrino physics and atmospheric neutrino research, possessing significant academic value and practical significance.