Aspects of Holographic Complexity and Volume of Black Holes

Basic Information

• Paper ID: 2510.11833
• Title: Aspects of Holographic Complexity and Volume of Black Holes
• Authors: Suraj Maurya, Sashideep Gutti, Rahul Nigam, Swastik Bhattacharya (BITS Pilani Hyderabad Campus)
• Classification: gr-qc (General Relativity and Quantum Cosmology), hep-th (High Energy Physics - Theory)
• Publication Date: October 14, 2025 (preprint)
• Paper Link: https://arxiv.org/abs/2510.11833

Abstract

This paper investigates the complexity growth rates of BTZ, Schwarzschild, Reissner-Nordström, and Kerr black holes, verifying Susskind's conjecture that complexity growth rates are proportional to the product of black hole horizon temperature and entropy (TS/ℏ) using both the Complexity-Volume (CV) and Complexity-Action (CA) dualities. The study further explores the behavior of complexity growth rate variations δĊ under various physical processes, including the Penrose process, superradiance, particle accretion, and Hawking radiation, revealing nontrivial behaviors of δĊ. Under the Penrose process and superradiance, δĊ always increases; under particle accretion, δĊ may increase, remain zero, or decrease depending on the direction of the incident particle's angular momentum.

Research Background and Motivation

1. Core Problems

This research aims to verify and deepen understanding of the duality between holographic complexity and black hole interior geometry, specifically:

• Verifying Susskind's conjecture that complexity growth rate ~ TS/ℏ
• Exploring the impact of different physical processes on black hole complexity growth
• Understanding the relationship between black hole interior volume and quantum complexity

2. Significance

• Theoretical Importance: Complexity is considered a key quantity encoding black hole interior properties, connecting quantum information theory with gravitational theory
• Holographic Duality: In AdS/CFT correspondence, the complexity of the boundary CFT has deep connections with the interior geometry of the bulk black hole
• Black Hole Information Problem: Provides new perspectives for understanding black hole interior structure and information storage mechanisms

3. Limitations of Existing Methods

• Non-universality of CV Duality: Requires introduction of geometric length scales; proportionality constants depend on black hole type
• Arbitrariness in Maximal Slice Selection: The choice of maximal spatial slices is not unique
• Limited Applicability: Applicability to non-AdS, non-static, or singular spacetimes remains unestablished

4. Research Motivation

• Systematically verify the validity of CV and CA dualities across different black hole backgrounds
• Study the impact of dynamical processes on complexity growth
• Compare the universality and limitations of the two duality approaches

Core Contributions

1. Verification of Susskind's Conjecture: For BTZ, Schwarzschild, Reissner-Nordström, and Kerr black holes, complexity growth rates are indeed proportional to T_H S_H
2. Revealed Universality of CA Duality: CA duality exhibits better universality than CV duality, with a unified proportionality constant
3. Discovered Nontrivial Behavior of Complexity Growth Rate: δĊ exhibits different signs and behavior patterns under different physical processes
4. Provided Correction Terms: Correction terms for complexity growth rate relationships in Kerr and Reissner-Nordström black holes
5. Identified Limitations of Equilibrium Assumptions: When δĊ < 0 during particle accretion, contributions from black hole "hair" and horizon dynamics must be considered

Methodology Details

Task Definition

Study the behavior of black hole complexity growth rates within the CV and CA duality frameworks, verify their relationships with thermodynamic quantities, and analyze the impact of various physical processes on complexity changes.

CV Duality Method

1. Basic Relations

For large black holes (AdS background):

C ~ V/(ℏGℓ)

For small black holes:

C ~ V/(ℏGr₊)

2. Improved Formula

The improved version proposed by Couch et al.:

C ~ V/(ℏGτf)

where τf is the maximal proper time.

3. Volume Calculation

Using the Reinhart radius r_R to maximize black hole interior volume:

• Schwarzschild: r_R = 3M/2
• BTZ: r_R = ℓ√(M/2)
• Kerr: r_R(θ) = 3M/2 - a²(14-sin²θ)/(36M)

CA Duality Method

1. Basic Relations

C = A/(πℏ)

where A is the gravitational action on the Wheeler-DeWitt patch.

2. Action Calculation

Total action comprises three parts:

A = A_EH + A_EM + A_GHY

• A_EH: Einstein-Hilbert bulk action
• A_EM: Einstein-Maxwell action
• A_GHY: Gibbons-Hawking-York boundary action

3. Complexity Growth Rate

dC/dt = (1/πℏ) × dA/dt

Technical Innovations

1. Angle-Dependent Reinhart Radius: First correct calculation of θ-dependent maximal hypersurface location for Kerr black holes
2. Systematic Comparison: Simultaneous use of CV and CA dualities to study multiple black hole types
3. Dynamical Analysis: Detailed analysis of four different physical processes' effects on complexity changes
4. Correction Term Calculation: Provided higher-order corrections to complexity relationships for rotating and charged black holes

Experimental Setup

Research Objects

Four typical black holes:

1. BTZ Black Hole: (2+1)-dimensional rotating AdS black hole
2. Schwarzschild Black Hole: Spherically symmetric static black hole
3. Reissner-Nordström Black Hole: Spherically symmetric charged black hole
4. Kerr Black Hole: Axially symmetric rotating black hole

Physical Processes

Analysis of four dynamical processes:

1. Penrose Process: Energy and angular momentum extraction from black hole ergosphere
2. Superradiance: Energy extraction through wave scattering
3. Particle Accretion: Particles falling into the black hole
4. Hawking Radiation: Black hole evaporation process

Computational Methods

• Natural units: ℏ = c = 1
• BTZ black hole: G = 1/8
• 4-dimensional black holes: G = 1
• Small angular momentum approximation: a/M ≪ 1

Experimental Results

Main Results

1. CV Duality Results

Relationships between complexity growth rates and T_H S_H for various black holes:

2. CA Duality Results

CA duality exhibits better universality:

3. Dynamical Process Analysis

For Kerr black holes, complexity growth rate variation:

δĊ ~ 8[(δM - Ω_H δJ) - 0.74Ω_H δJ]

Behavior in each process:

• Penrose Process: δĊ > 0 (always increases)
• Superradiance: δĊ > 0 (always increases)
• Particle Accretion:
  • δJ < 0: δĊ > 0
  • δJ > 0: Sign of δĊ depends on comparison of δJ with δM/(1.74Ω_H)
• Hawking Radiation: Sign of δĊ uncertain, requires more detailed analysis

Important Findings

1. Universality of CA Duality: CA duality exhibits better universality than CV duality with smaller variation range in proportionality constants
2. Non-monotonic Complexity Growth: In certain particle accretion scenarios, δĊ may be negative
3. Limitations of Equilibrium Assumptions: When δĊ < 0, contributions from black hole "hair" and non-equilibrium effects must be considered

Related Work

Main Research Directions

1. Holographic Complexity Theory: Complexity-geometry duality framework established by Susskind et al.
2. Black Hole Interior Volume: Research on black hole interior volume by Christodoulou-Rovelli et al.
3. AdS/CFT Correspondence: Holographic duality theory established by Maldacena et al.

Relationship to Related Work

• Verifies Susskind's complexity growth conjecture
• Extends Christodoulou-Rovelli's volume studies to rotating black holes
• Systematically compares CV and CA dualities

Relative Advantages

• First correct angle-dependent Reinhart radius for Kerr black holes
• Systematic study of dynamical process effects on complexity
• Reveals universality advantages of CA duality over CV duality

Conclusions and Discussion

Main Conclusions

1. Verification of Susskind's Conjecture: All studied black hole types satisfy the relationship dC/dt ∝ T_H S_H
2. CA Duality More Universal: CA duality exhibits better universality and uniformity than CV duality
3. Rich Behavior of Complexity Changes: Different physical processes lead to different complexity growth rate variation patterns
4. Non-equilibrium Effects Important: Black hole "hair" and horizon dynamics must be considered in certain cases

Limitations

1. Small Angular Momentum Approximation: Kerr black hole analysis restricted to a/M ≪ 1
2. Equilibrium Assumption: Particle accretion analysis assumes black hole remains near equilibrium
3. Incomplete Hawking Radiation Analysis: Requires more detailed angular momentum spectrum information
4. CV Duality Slice Selection: Maximal slice choice still contains some arbitrariness

Future Directions

1. Extension to Large Angular Momentum: Study cases approaching extremal Kerr black holes
2. Non-equilibrium Analysis: Consider black hole "hair" and membrane paradigm effects
3. Complete Hawking Radiation Study: Detailed analysis of outgoing particle angular momentum spectrum
4. Other Black Hole Types: Extension to Kerr-Newman, higher-dimensional black holes, etc.

In-Depth Evaluation

Strengths

1. Strong Systematicity: Simultaneous use of two duality approaches to study four different black hole types, providing comprehensive comparison
2. Technical Innovation: First correct calculation of angle-dependent Reinhart radius for Kerr black holes
3. Deep Physical Insights: Reveals universality advantages of CA duality and nontrivial complexity change behavior
4. Mathematical Rigor: Detailed calculations and comprehensive appendix materials
5. Problem Awareness: Correctly identifies limitations of equilibrium assumptions

Weaknesses

1. Approximation Limitations: Kerr black hole analysis restricted to small angular momentum case, limiting result generality
2. Insufficient Theoretical Explanation: Lacks deep physical explanation for why CA duality is more universal than CV duality
3. Difficult Experimental Verification: As pure theoretical research, lacks observable experimental predictions
4. Incomplete Calculations: Analysis of Hawking radiation case acknowledged as incomplete

Impact

1. Theoretical Contribution: Provides important systematic verification for holographic complexity theory
2. Methodological Value: Establishes standard methods for studying black hole complexity dynamics
3. Inspirational Significance: Provides new perspectives for understanding black hole interior structure and information storage mechanisms
4. Foundation for Future Research: Lays groundwork for further study of non-equilibrium complexity evolution

Applicable Scenarios

1. Theoretical Physics Research: Holographic duality, black hole physics, quantum gravity theory
2. Numerical Simulations: Provides theoretical expectations for complexity evolution in black hole numerical relativity
3. Educational Applications: Serves as standard textbook case for holographic complexity theory
4. Interdisciplinary Research: Bridge connecting quantum information theory with gravitational theory

References

This paper cites important literature in the field, including:

• Foundational work on complexity-geometry duality by Susskind et al.
• Research on black hole interior volume by Christodoulou-Rovelli
• AdS/CFT correspondence theory by Maldacena
• Complexity-action duality proposal by Brown et al.
• Authors' prior research on maximal hypersurfaces in Kerr black holes

Overall Assessment: This is a high-quality theoretical physics paper that systematically verifies important predictions of holographic complexity theory, reveals the advantages of CA duality over CV duality, and discovers rich behavior of complexity growth rates in dynamical processes. Despite some technical limitations, it provides important theoretical contributions and research directions for the field.