Lorentz Covariant Supertranslation Frames for the Angular Momentum Aspect

Basic Information

• Paper ID: 2510.11849
• Title: Lorentz Covariant Supertranslation Frames for the Angular Momentum Aspect
• Authors: Reza Javadinezhad (Institute for Research in Fundamental Sciences, Iran), Massimo Porrati (New York University)
• Classification: gr-qc (General Relativity and Quantum Cosmology), hep-th (High Energy Physics - Theory)
• Publication Date: October 13, 2025
• Paper Link: https://arxiv.org/abs/2510.11849v1

Abstract

This paper addresses the well-known ambiguity in defining angular momentum (and mass dipole) fluxes in general relativity and reinterprets recent work that resolves this ambiguity through the definition of invariant charges. The authors resolve this ambiguity by finding conditions that fix supertranslation and spacetime translation reference frames. They propose a fundamental method for measuring the angular momentum aspect and explicitly calculate the supertranslation frame-fixing conditions for the metric generated by point particles at first order in Newton's constant.

Research Background and Motivation

Core Problems

1. Ambiguity in Angular Momentum Definition: In general relativity, the symmetries of asymptotically flat spacetime include the BMS (Bondi-van der Burg-Sachs-Metzner) algebra, which contains an infinite-dimensional abelian subalgebra (supertranslations) that extends the Poincaré algebra. The Lorentz transformation generators $J^{\mu\nu}$ do not commute with supertranslations, leading to infinitely many equivalent forms for angular momentum and boost (mass dipole).
2. Confusion About Physical Meaning: If the angular momentum flux is interpreted as the output flux of massless particles, this ambiguity appears strange, since all different fluxes correspond to the same energy flux, implying that angular momentum can be carried by zero-energy particles.
3. Preservation of Lorentz Covariance: A prescription is needed that eliminates the ambiguity while maintaining Lorentz covariance.

Research Significance

• Precise definitions of angular momentum and mass dipole are crucial for gravitational wave physics
• Fundamental importance in calculations of gravitational scattering and gravitational radiation
• Closely related to soft graviton physics and memory effects

Core Contributions

1. Proposed a new frame-fixing prescription: Through the condition $\delta^{3/2}_{Y(J)}M|_{l=0,1} = 0$ to fix the supertranslation frame while maintaining Lorentz covariance
2. Established a physical measurement method for the angular momentum aspect: Through light time delay and Lense-Thirring effect to measure $N_A$
3. Complete flux definition: Extended the frame-fixing prescription to angular momentum and mass dipole fluxes
4. Concrete computational examples: Explicitly calculated the metric and corresponding frame-fixing conditions for a system of n point particles at $O(G)$ order
5. Covariant transformation properties: Detailed analysis of how supertranslation frames transform under Lorentz transformations

Methodology Details

BMS Algebra and Supertranslations

In Bondi-Sachs coordinates, the metric near future null infinity $I^+$ is: $ds^2 = -du^2 - 2du dr + r^2\left(h_{AB} + \frac{C_{AB}}{r}\right)d\Theta^A d\Theta^B + \ldots$

where the mass aspect $M(\Theta,u)$, angular momentum aspect $N_A(\Theta,u)$, and shear $C_{AB}(\Theta,u)$ are functions on the celestial sphere.

The supertranslation transformation $u \to u' = u + f(\Theta)$ acts on these quantities as: $N_A(\Theta,u) \to N'_A(\Theta,u') = N_A(\Theta,u) - 3M(\Theta,u)D_A f(\Theta) - D_A M(\Theta,u)f(\Theta)$

Frame-Fixing Conditions

1. Higher Mode Fixing

For spherical harmonic modes with $l > 1$, fixing is achieved through the condition $D_A D_B C_{AB} = 0$: $f_{lm} = C_{lm}, \quad l > 1$

2. Covariant Fixing of Low-Order Modes

The key innovation is using a covariant condition for $l = 0,1$ modes: $\delta^{3/2}_{Y(J)}M|_{l=0,1} = 0$

where $Y^A(J)$ is a conformal Killing vector constructed from Lorentz charges: $Y^A(J) = \sum_\alpha Y^A_\alpha J_{Y_\alpha}(-\infty)$

In the center-of-mass frame, this simplifies to: $\int d^2\Theta \sqrt{h} Y^A N_A = 0, \quad Y^A = D^A\psi, \quad D^2\psi = -2\psi$

Through integration by parts, the frame-fixing condition for $l=1$ modes is obtained: $f_{1,-m} = -\frac{1}{6M_{00}} \int d^2\Theta \sqrt{h} Y_{1m} D^A N_A$

Covariant Definition of Fluxes

For flux definitions, the authors propose two choices:

1. Choice 1: Always use the initial frame condition $D_A D_B C_{AB}(-\infty) = 0$
2. Choice 2: Use respective frame conditions at initial and final times separately

Additional covariant conditions are introduced to fix remaining degrees of freedom: $P^i_\mu P^f_\nu J^f_{\mu\nu} = 0$

Experimental Setup and Calculations

Point Particle System

The authors consider a system of n point particles with the linearized metric at $O(G)$ order: $g_{\mu\nu} = \eta_{\mu\nu} - 4G\sum \frac{m}{\Gamma(x)}\left(v_\mu v_\nu + \frac{1}{2}\eta_{\mu\nu}\right)$

where $\Gamma(x) = \sqrt{(x_\mu - c_\mu)(x_\nu - c_\nu)\Pi^{\mu\nu}}$.

Specific Results

For a single particle moving along the z-axis:

• Shear tensor: $C_{\theta\theta} = \frac{2Gmv^2\sin^2\theta}{\sqrt{1-v^2}(1-v\cos\theta)}$
• Mass aspect: $M = \frac{Gm}{(1-v^2)^{3/2}(1-v\cos\theta)^3}$
• Angular momentum aspect: Contains complex angular and time-dependent terms

Covariance Verification

The transformation law of the mass aspect under Lorentz transformations: $M_1(\theta_1,\phi_1) = -M_2(\theta_2,\phi_2)(n_1 \cdot v)^3$

This verifies the property of the mass aspect as a scalar of weight $3/2$.

Main Results

Theoretical Results

1. Application of Jacobi Identity: Proved that tensors invariant under supertranslations and Lorentz covariant must also be translation invariant
2. Uniqueness of Frame Fixing: The condition $\delta^{3/2}_{Y(J)}M|_{l=0,1} = 0$ uniquely determines the covariant supertranslation frame
3. Transformation of Boundary Gravitons: $C_1(\theta_1,\phi_1) = -(n_1 \cdot v)C_2(\theta_2,\phi_2)$

Numerical Results

For the slow-motion limit ($v \ll 1$), exact expansion formulas are obtained: $C_{2|00} = C_{1|00} + vC_{1|10} + O(v^2)$$C_{2|10} = C_{1|10} + 2vC_{1|20} + O(v^2)$

Related Work

Historical Development

• BMS Algebra: Pioneering work by Bondi, van der Burg, Metzner, Sachs (1960s)
• Supertranslation-Invariant Definitions: Contributions by Compère et al. 8, Chen et al. 9,10
• Soft Graviton Approach: Volume integral method by Javadinezhad et al. 11

Innovations in This Paper

Compared to existing work, this paper provides:

1. More concise yet rigorous definitions
2. Fully covariant prescription
3. Concrete computational examples and verification

Conclusions and Discussion

Main Conclusions

1. Physical Origin of Ambiguity: The ambiguity in angular momentum definition caused by supertranslation symmetry has deep physical roots
2. Covariant Solution: The ambiguity can be resolved covariantly through the condition $\delta^{3/2}_{Y(J)}M|_{l=0,1} = 0$
3. Measurability: The angular momentum aspect is a measurable physical quantity through time delay and frame-dragging effects

Limitations

1. Linearized Approximation: Calculations are limited to $O(G)$ order
2. Non-Radiative Regions: Analysis primarily focuses on regions where the Bondi news tensor vanishes
3. Infrared Divergences: Infrared divergence problems exist at $O(G^4)$ order

Future Directions

1. Extension to higher-order gravitational effects
2. Complete analysis in radiative regions
3. Integration with practical applications to gravitational wave detection

In-Depth Evaluation

Strengths

1. Theoretical Rigor: Provides mathematically strict covariant prescription
2. Physical Intuition: Connects abstract mathematical conditions with measurable physical effects
3. Computational Completeness: Includes detailed computational examples and verification
4. Clear Writing: Logical structure and detailed mathematical derivations

Weaknesses

1. Scope of Applicability: Limited to asymptotically flat spacetime and weak-field approximation
2. Practical Relevance: Direct connection to current gravitational wave detection technology is not sufficiently clear
3. Numerical Verification: Lacks comparative verification with numerical relativity

Impact

1. Theoretical Contribution: Provides new theoretical tools for BMS symmetry and soft graviton physics
2. Practical Value: Provides theoretical foundation for precise gravitational wave data analysis
3. Reproducibility: Detailed computational procedures facilitate verification and extension

Applicable Scenarios

• Gravitational wave theory research
• Soft graviton physics
• Asymptotic symmetry analysis
• Theoretical predictions for precision gravitational experiments

References

The paper cites 35 important references covering key works in BMS algebra, supertranslation symmetry, soft graviton physics, and related fields, providing readers with comprehensive background knowledge and starting points for further research.

This paper provides an elegant and practical solution to the long-standing ambiguity problem in defining angular momentum in general relativity, with significant value in theoretical physics, particularly in gravitational physics.