Topological Robustness of Anyon Tunneling at ν = 1/3

Basic Information

• Paper ID: 2510.11860
• Title: Topological Robustness of Anyon Tunneling at ν = 1/3
• Authors: Adithya Suresh, Ramon Guerrero-Suarez, Tanmay Maiti, Shuang Liang, Geoffrey Gardner, Claudio Chamon, Michael Manfra
• Classification: cond-mat.mes-hall, cond-mat.str-el
• Publication Date: October 15, 2025
• Paper Link: https://arxiv.org/abs/2510.11860

Abstract

This study probes the topological robustness of chiral Luttinger liquid at the boundary of the ν = 1/3 state by measuring tunneling conductance between counter-propagating edge modes as a function of quantum point contact transmission. The research demonstrates that when transmission t ≥ 0.7, the tunneling conductance can be well described by the first two terms of the perturbative series expansion corresponding to g = 1/3. Furthermore, the measured scaling exponent is robustly fixed at g = 1/3 across the entire plateau, with deviations occurring only when the bulk becomes compressible. Finally, the influence of weak disorder on the scaling exponent is examined, revealing insensitivity to such perturbations. These measurements definitively establish the topological robustness of anyon tunneling at ν = 1/3 and confirm the chiral Luttinger liquid description of edge modes.

Research Background and Motivation

1. Core Problem: Whether the quasi-particle propagation scaling exponent g of incompressible states in the Laughlin sequence of the fractional quantum Hall effect (FQHE) exhibits topological robustness against perturbations that do not close the energy gap.
2. Significance:
   • The chiral Luttinger liquid theory of edge modes encodes the correspondence with bulk topological order
   • The scaling exponent g, together with the effective anyon charge e* and statistical angle θa, completely determines the topological order of the ground state
   • Connects edge physics with properties of bulk quantum Hall states
3. Limitations of Existing Methods:
   • Early experimental results showed significant discrepancies with chiral Luttinger liquid predictions
   • Likely caused by soft confinement potentials and disorder-induced edge reconstruction
   • Split-gate overgrowth heterostructure experiments found g varying continuously across the ν = 1/3 plateau, contradicting theoretical expectations of quantization
4. Research Motivation:
   • Establish universal chiral Luttinger liquid behavior observed in devices with sharp confinement potentials
   • Systematically investigate the transmission range and conditions for topological robustness
   • Verify theoretically predicted quantized behavior

Core Contributions

1. Established transmission range: Demonstrated that tunneling conductance can be well described by the perturbative series expansion for g = 1/3 when t ≥ 0.7
2. Verified topological robustness: Proved that the scaling exponent remains robustly fixed at g = 1/3 within the incompressible region
3. Extended perturbative theory: Incorporated higher-order correction terms, accurately describing tunneling conductance at lower transmission rates
4. Examined disorder effects: Demonstrated that weak disorder does not affect the universality of the scaling exponent
5. Established theoretical validity: Provided strong evidence for the validity of the chiral Luttinger liquid model in fractional quantum Hall systems

Detailed Methodology

Task Definition

Investigate the topological robustness of anyon tunneling between edge modes in the ν = 1/3 fractional quantum Hall state by measuring how tunneling conductance of a quantum point contact (QPC) varies with transmission rate to extract the scaling exponent g.

Experimental Architecture

Device Design:

• Utilized QPC element in a Fabry-Pérot interferometer
• Electronic density: n = 0.95×10¹¹ cm⁻²
• Mobility: μ = 7.5×10⁶ cm²/Vs
• Screened well heterostructure providing sharp confinement potential
• QPC opening 300 nm, gate spacing 800 nm

Measurement Circuit:

• Voltage excitation VS applied to source
• Two drains D1 and D2 measuring transmitted current I and tunneling current Itun respectively
• Standard lock-in technique with AC excitation of 5 μV at 7 Hz frequency
• Cold RC filter (1.2 kΩ, 10 nF)

Theoretical Framework

Perturbative Expansion:

First-order tunneling conductance: $G^{(1)} = \frac{e^2}{h}\left(\frac{2\pi T}{T_0}\right)^{2g-2}F_g\left(\frac{e^*V_{SD}}{k_BT}\right)$

Second-order correction: $G^{(2)} = \frac{e^2}{h}\left[\left(\frac{2\pi T}{T_0}\right)^{2g-2}F_g\left(\frac{e^*V_{SD}}{k_BT}\right) + \alpha_g\left(\frac{2\pi T}{T_0}\right)^{4g-4}K_g\left(\frac{e^*V_{SD}}{k_BT}\right)\right]$

where Fg(x) and Kg(x) are universal scaling functions.

Technical Innovations

1. Higher-order Perturbative Analysis:
   • Incorporated correction terms of order (T/T₀)^(4g-4)
   • Computed higher-order contributions using Jack polynomial methods
2. Data Collapse Analysis:
   • Rescaled deviations ΔGt by expected scaling factors
   • Verified universal scaling behavior
3. Temperature Measurement:
   • Measured electron temperature under operating conditions using Coulomb blockade thermometry
   • Ensured accurate scaling analysis

Experimental Setup

Sample Preparation

• AlGaAs/GaAs heterostructure with screened well design
• Top and bottom gates locally deplete the screened well
• Main quantum well maintains electrical connection to ohmic contacts

Measurement Conditions

• Mixing chamber temperature TMC = 10 mK
• Electron temperature Te = 39 mK (measured via Coulomb blockade thermometry)
• Magnetic field B = 10.82 T (center of ν = 1/3 plateau)

Evaluation Metrics

• Tunneling conductance Gt = ∂Itun/∂V|VSD
• Transmission rate t (extracted from linear conductance)
• Scaling exponent g (extracted from fitting)
• Residual sum of squares (RSS) for assessing fit quality

Experimental Results

Main Results

Transmission Dependence:

• Measured tunneling conductance in the range t = 0.99 to t = 0.65
• At t > 0.8, G^(1) accurately describes data (ΔGt ≈ 0)
• At t < 0.8, higher-order corrections from G^(2) are required

Scaling Collapse:

• Rescaled deviations ΔG̃t collapse to a single curve as a function of e*VSD/kBT
• Confirms the universal nature of higher-order corrections

Fit Quality Comparison:

• At high transmission, RSS for G^(1) and G^(2) are equal
• At low transmission, G^(2) significantly outperforms G^(1)

Magnetic Field Dependence

• g remains constant across a 1 T magnetic field range
• Average value g = 0.333 ± 0.001, in perfect agreement with theoretical expectation g = 1/3
• g deviates only when the bulk becomes compressible

Disorder Effects

• Non-monotonic features introduced in QPC linear conductance
• Measured at four different bias points, all maintaining t = 0.91
• Scaling exponent remains close to g = 1/3 at all points
• Weak disorder does not alter the scaling exponent of anyon tunneling

Related Work

Theoretical Development

• Wen's initial description of ν = 1/3 edge modes as chiral Luttinger liquid
• Fendley et al.'s derivation of tunneling conductance under weak backscattering using perturbation theory
• Kane-Fisher theory establishing transport theory for one-dimensional interacting electron gas

Experimental Progress

• Early experiments (Roddaro et al.) showed qualitative and quantitative discrepancies with theory
• Split-gate overgrowth experiments (Chang et al.) found continuous variation of g
• Recent AlGaAs/GaAs and graphene experiments successfully observed consistent chiral Luttinger liquid behavior

Advantages of This Work

• Systematic investigation of transmission dependence
• Incorporation of higher-order perturbative corrections
• Verification of robustness under magnetic field and disorder
• Provides quantitative evidence of topological robustness

Conclusions and Discussion

Main Conclusions

1. Established effective range: Chiral Luttinger liquid theory is valid when t ≥ 0.7
2. Verified topological protection: g is robustly quantized to 1/3 within the incompressible region
3. Extended theory: Higher-order corrections accurately describe the strong-coupling regime
4. Confirmed robustness: Weak disorder does not affect topological properties

Limitations

1. Single-mode edge: Only studied single chiral edge mode at ν = 1/3
2. Device dependence: Requires specialized screened well heterostructure design
3. Temperature constraints: Experiments conducted at millikelvin temperatures
4. Magnetic field range: Study limited to specific magnetic field region

Future Directions

1. Multi-mode edge states: Extension to complex states such as ν = 2/3 and ν = 2/5
2. Stronger disorder: Investigation of disorder effects on edge modes
3. Other fractional states: Verification of robustness in other Laughlin sequence states
4. Quantum interference: Combined Fabry-Pérot interference measurements for further characterization of topological order

In-Depth Evaluation

Strengths

1. Methodological Innovation:
   • First systematic study of transmission-dependent topological robustness
   • Theoretical analysis incorporating higher-order perturbative corrections
   • Data collapse method verifying universality
2. Experimental Rigor:
   • Accurate electron temperature measurement under operating conditions
   • Systematic investigation of magnetic field and disorder dependence
   • Quantitative assessment of fit quality
3. Convincing Results:
   • Precise agreement with theoretical predictions (g = 0.333 ± 0.001 vs 1/3)
   • Clear scaling behavior and universal collapse
   • Consistency across multiple independent measurements

Shortcomings

1. Theoretical Limitations: Perturbative expansion may fail at lower transmission rates
2. Device Specificity: Results depend on particular heterostructure design
3. Finite Temperature Effects: Insufficient exploration of finite temperature effects on topological protection

Impact

1. Fundamental Physics: Provides critical experimental verification for theoretical understanding of topological quantum matter
2. Quantum Computing: Offers important foundation for implementation of topological qubits
3. Device Applications: Provides guidance for design of quantum devices based on anyons

Applicable Scenarios

• Topological characterization of fractional quantum Hall states
• Experimental investigation of anyon physics
• Fundamental research in topological quantum computing
• Edge state physics in strongly correlated electron systems

References

This paper cites 38 important references covering classical works in chiral Luttinger liquid theory, fractional quantum Hall effect experiments, and topological quantum matter, providing a solid theoretical and experimental foundation for the research.