Quantifying the form-flow-saltation dynamics of aeolian sand ripples

Basic Information

• Paper ID: 2510.11876
• Title: Quantifying the form-flow-saltation dynamics of aeolian sand ripples
• Authors: Joanna M. Nield, Matthew C. Baddock, Giles F.S. Wiggs, Jim Best, Kenneth T. Christensen, Pauline Delorme, Andrew Valdez, Nathaniel R. Bristow, Martin H.T. Hipondoka, Daniel P. Goss, Natasha S. Wallum, Philippe Claudin
• Classification: physics.geo-ph (Geophysics)
• Published Journal: Journal of Geophysical Research: Earth Surface, 130, e2025JF008616 (2025)
• Paper Link: http://dx.doi.org/10.1029/2025JF008616

Abstract

Sand ripples represent the most fundamental and ubiquitous aeolian landforms on sandy surfaces; however, their small scale and rapid response times make them difficult to measure. Nevertheless, these characteristics also render ripples excellent flow indicators, widely utilized for this purpose in planetary environments. This study employs terrestrial laser scanning (TLS) to simultaneously measure ripple morphometry and migration velocity, as well as saltation heights above the ripple surface. The findings reveal that while ripple height and wavelength exhibit linear responses to increasing shear velocity, ripple migration velocity demonstrates nonlinear growth under strong wind conditions. This relationship at high wind speeds is also reflected in the response of aerodynamic roughness and saltation mechanics, with greater maximum saltation heights observed on the ripple lee slope. Importantly, when using ripple patterns as flow condition indicators, migration velocity or height should be prioritized over wavelength, as they respond more rapidly to wind speed variations.

Research Background and Motivation

1. Research Questions

This study addresses the quantification of form-flow-saltation dynamics of aeolian sand ripples, particularly the response patterns of ripple characteristic parameters (height, wavelength, migration velocity) under varying wind conditions.

2. Significance of the Problem

• Geomorphological significance: Ripples represent the most fundamental aeolian landforms; understanding their dynamics is crucial for predicting dune evolution and desert environmental changes
• Planetary science applications: Ripples are widespread on planetary surfaces such as Mars and serve as important indicators of paleoenvironmental conditions
• Engineering applications: Practical implications for desertification prevention and coastal protection engineering

3. Limitations of Existing Methods

• Traditional measurement approaches (e.g., shadow methods, time-lapse photography) are primarily limited to 1D or 2D analysis
• Lack of synchronized measurement of three-dimensional ripple morphology and saltation mechanics
• Discrepancies between wind tunnel experiments and field measurements
• Insufficient understanding of ripple dynamics under strong wind conditions

4. Research Motivation

Through high-precision terrestrial laser scanning technology, this study achieves the first synchronized three-dimensional measurement of ripple morphology and saltation mechanics, revealing the coupling mechanisms between form, flow, and sediment transport.

Core Contributions

1. First synchronized measurement: Quantifies ripple morphology, migration velocity, and saltation mechanics simultaneously using TLS technology
2. Discovery of nonlinear relationships: Reveals a cubic relationship between ripple migration velocity and shear velocity under strong wind conditions
3. Response time differentiation: Elucidates the differential response times of different ripple parameters to wind speed changes (migration velocity fastest, wavelength slowest)
4. Saltation spatial distribution: Identifies significant spatial differences in saltation heights between ripple stoss and lee slopes
5. Practical guidance: Provides quantitative evidence for the application of ripples as paleoenvironmental indicators in planetary science and stratigraphy

Methodology

Task Definition

Quantify the dynamic relationships between three-dimensional morphological characteristics of aeolian sand ripples and wind fields, saltation transport processes through field measurements, establishing quantitative relationships between ripple parameters and flow conditions.

Experimental Setup

Study Sites

• Primary site: Medano Creek dry riverbed, Great Sand Dunes National Park, Colorado, USA
• Supplementary site: Huab Valley dune field, Namibia
• Comparative dataset: Oceano Dunes dataset

Measurement Systems

1. Terrestrial Laser Scanner: Leica TLS (P20/P50)
   • Scanning range: approximately 1×1 m²
   • Horizontal resolution: 0.8-1.6 mm (at 10 m distance)
   • Vertical resolution: 5.5×10⁻⁴ m
   • Scanning frequency: adjusted according to wind speed (1.5-3 minutes)
2. Wind speed measurement: Campbell Scientific CSAT3 three-dimensional sonic anemometer
   • Height: 0.24 m
   • Sampling frequency: 10 Hz
   • Measured parameters: wind speed, wind direction, Reynolds stress
3. Sediment transport measurement:
   • Sensit piezoelectric sensor (height 0.014 m)
   • Wenglor optical sensor (0.02 m and 0.05 m)

Data Processing Methods

Ripple Parameter Extraction

1. Surface reconstruction: 0.002 m gridding with 0.05×0.05 m moving window filtering
2. Ripple height: calculated using zero-upcrossing method for each cross-section
3. Wavelength and migration velocity: computed using MATLAB cross-correlation function
4. Ripple crest identification: Canny edge detection algorithm combined with deblurring processing

Saltation Height Calculation

Radial filtering (0.1 m radius, 35° angle) is used to separate bed surface points from saltating particles, calculating maximum saltation height.

Aerodynamic Roughness

Calculated based on wall law and Reynolds stress measurements:

• Bagnold roughness law: $z_o = z_f \exp(-\kappa u_f / u_*)$
• Charnock model: $z_o = Cu_*^2/g$

Experimental Results

Major Findings

1. Relationships between Ripple Parameters and Shear Velocity

• Ripple height and wavelength: exhibit linear relationships with shear velocity (R² = 0.96 and 0.82)
• Ripple migration velocity: demonstrates nonlinear (cubic) relationship under strong wind conditions (R² = 0.95)
• Ripple index: remains relatively constant (lr/hr = 41 ± 2.4)

2. Response Time Differentiation

3. Sediment Flux Relationships

• Flux model based on ripple height: R² = 0.98
• Flux model based on wavelength: R² = 0.93

4. Saltation Spatial Distribution

• Peak saltation height occurs approximately 0.43lr downwind from the ripple crest
• Lee slope exhibits greater saltation height variability (5.1×10⁻⁴ m vs 4.5×10⁻⁴ m)
• Spatial differences are more pronounced under strong wind conditions

Aerodynamic Roughness Analysis

• Roughness increases with increasing shear velocity
• Optimal fit value for Charnock constant: 0.0155
• Roughness threshold corresponding to collision mechanism transition: ~0.365 mm

Related Work

Theoretical Foundations

• Anderson (1987, 1990): Particle-bed collision theory of ripple formation
• Duran et al. (2014): Direct numerical simulation of aeolian sand ripples
• Pähtz and Durán (2020): Theory of saltation-to-collision mechanism transition

Development of Measurement Techniques

• Traditional methods: shadow methods, time-lapse photography, laser sheet techniques
• Application progress of TLS technology in aeolian research
• Comparative studies between wind tunnel and field measurements

Planetary Science Applications

Martian ripple observations and Earth-based analogue studies providing evidence for Martian paleoclimate reconstruction.

Conclusions and Discussion

Main Conclusions

1. Nonlinear dynamics: Ripple migration velocity exhibits a cubic relationship with shear velocity under strong wind conditions, possibly related to the transition from saltation to collision mechanisms
2. Hierarchical response times: Migration velocity responds fastest, height intermediately, and wavelength slowest, with important implications for paleoenvironmental reconstruction
3. Optimal indicator parameters: Migration velocity and height are more suitable than wavelength as instantaneous wind condition indicators
4. Spatial heterogeneity: Ripple topography significantly influences saltation distribution, with greater saltation heights and variability on lee slopes

Limitations

1. Measurement range: Primarily concentrated on moderate to strong wind conditions, lacking extreme wind data
2. Particle size: Research primarily focuses on quartz sand within specific grain size ranges
3. Geographic limitations: Observations mainly based on two locations, requiring broader geographic validation
4. Mechanism interpretation: Physical mechanisms underlying nonlinear relationships require further theoretical and experimental verification

Future Directions

1. Multi-scale studies: Extension to different grain sizes and wind conditions
2. Mechanism verification: In-depth investigation of the physical processes of collision mechanism transition
3. Model improvement: Integration of observational results into numerical models
4. Planetary applications: Extension to ripple studies in other planetary environments such as Mars

In-Depth Evaluation

Strengths

1. Technical innovation: First synchronized three-dimensional measurement of ripple morphology and saltation, employing advanced technical approaches
2. Data quality: High-precision TLS data provides unprecedented spatiotemporal resolution
3. Scientific discovery: Discovery of nonlinear relationships under strong wind conditions possesses significant scientific value
4. Practical value: Provides quantitative tools for planetary science and paleoenvironmental reconstruction
5. Experimental design: Multi-site validation enhances result reliability

Limitations

1. Theoretical interpretation: Physical mechanism explanation for nonlinear relationships remains incomplete
2. Parameter range: Relatively limited parameter ranges studied; universal applicability requires verification
3. Long-term observations: Lacks long-term continuous observational data
4. Cost considerations: High cost of TLS technology limits large-scale application

Impact

1. Disciplinary contribution: Provides new research paradigm for aeolian geomorphology
2. Methodological value: Demonstrates application of TLS technology in surface process research
3. Interdisciplinary impact: Significant reference value for planetary science, sedimentology, and related fields
4. Engineering applications: Provides scientific basis for desertification control and coastal protection

Applicable Scenarios

1. Planetary exploration: Paleoenvironmental reconstruction of planetary surfaces such as Mars
2. Paleoenvironmental research: Paleoclimate interpretation of ripple structures in geological records
3. Environmental monitoring: Monitoring desertification processes and aeolian activity
4. Engineering design: Determination of design parameters for aeolian protection engineering

References

This study cites 127 relevant references, primarily including:

• Classical theory: Bagnold (1941), Anderson (1987, 1990)
• Numerical simulation: Duran et al. (2014), Andreotti et al. (2006)
• Experimental research: Sherman et al. (2019a), Gordon and McKenna Neuman (2011)
• Planetary applications: Ewing et al. (2017), Lapôtre et al. (2021)
• Technical methods: Nield and Wiggs (2011), Field and Pelletier (2018)

Through innovative measurement technology and rigorous experimental design, this research provides significant advances in the study of aeolian sand ripple dynamics, particularly the discovery of nonlinear behavior under strong wind conditions, which possesses important scientific value for understanding aeolian processes on Earth and planetary surfaces.