New Tests of Low-Scale Quantum Gravity with Cosmic-Ray Collisions

Basic Information

• Paper ID: 2510.11879
• Title: New Tests of Low-Scale Quantum Gravity with Cosmic-Ray Collisions
• Authors: Manuel Ettengruber (Université Paris–Saclay), Gonzalo Herrera (MIT, Harvard, Virginia Tech)
• Classification: hep-ph astro-ph.HE gr-qc hep-th
• Publication Date: October 13, 2025
• Paper Link: https://arxiv.org/abs/2510.11879

Abstract

This paper proposes three novel methods for testing low-scale quantum gravity theories using cosmic-ray collisions. The study finds that high-energy neutrino data from the blazar TXS 0506+056 imposes constraints on the gravitational fundamental scale of approximately $M_f \gtrsim 0.3$ TeV, while future high-energy neutrino data could potentially raise this limit to $M_f \gtrsim 200$ TeV. The authors further note that in certain active galactic nuclei (AGN) environments, cosmic-ray collisions may occur at significant rates, allowing tests of unprecedented fundamental scales of $M_f \gtrsim 2$ PeV.

Research Background and Motivation

Core Issues

1. Determination of the Gravitational Fundamental Scale: The conventional view holds that the gravitational fundamental scale $M_f$ equals the Planck scale $M_P$, but new theories suggest that the actual fundamental scale may be given by $M_f = M_P/\sqrt{N}$, where $N$ is the number of particle species.
2. Limitations of Existing Detection Methods: Particle colliders such as the LHC have reached their maximum center-of-mass energy and cannot probe higher fundamental scales further, necessitating new testing pathways.
3. Advantages of Cosmic Rays: Cosmic rays can be accelerated in active galactic nuclei (AGN) to energies far exceeding those of the LHC, providing a unique opportunity to test low-scale gravity theories.

Theoretical Foundation

• Extra-Dimensional Theories (ADD Model): Reduces the gravitational fundamental scale to the TeV scale, addressing the hierarchy problem
• Multi-Species Theories: Lowers the gravitational scale through collective effects of numerous particle species
• Certain String Theory Versions: Predict the production of gravitons and black holes in high-energy collisions

Core Contributions

1. Proposed three novel methods for testing low-scale gravity:
   • Cosmic-ray collisions with environmental protons in AGN
   • Cosmic-ray-cosmic-ray collisions
   • Thermal neutrino spectra from Hawking radiation of microscopic black holes
2. Established constraints based on TXS 0506+056 observational data: Provides quantitative limits on the gravitational fundamental scale $M_f$
3. Predicted unique observable signals: Including thermal spectrum neutrino emission and high-energy particle emission from other branes
4. Extended the testing range: From TeV scales to PeV scales, far exceeding existing collider capabilities

Methodology Details

Task Definition

This research aims to constrain fundamental parameters in low-scale quantum gravity theories, particularly the gravitational fundamental scale $M_f$ and the number of extra dimensions $n$, using cosmic-ray collision processes in AGN.

Theoretical Framework

1. Graviton Production Process

For cosmic-ray electrons, gravitons are primarily produced via gravitational Compton scattering: $\sigma \sim \frac{e^2}{16\pi} \frac{E^n}{M_f^{2+n}}$

For cosmic-ray protons, via gravitational Primakoff scattering: $\sigma \sim \frac{Z^2}{16\pi} \frac{E^n}{M_f^{n+2}}$

2. Black Hole Production Mechanism

When the center-of-mass energy $\sqrt{s} > M_f$, collisions may produce black holes. The Schwarzschild radius of the black hole is: $r_s = \frac{a_n}{M_f}\left(\frac{M_{BH}}{M_f}\right)^{\frac{1}{1+n}}$

The geometric cross-section is: $\sigma_0 = \pi r_s^2$

3. Cooling Timescale Analysis

A key physical quantity is the cooling timescale for various processes: $\tau_{pp} = \frac{1}{n_p \sigma_{pp} c}$

where $n_p$ is the proton number density and $\sigma_{pp}$ is the corresponding cross-section.

Technical Innovations

1. Comprehensive Multi-Process Analysis: Simultaneously considers graviton production and black hole production processes, providing a more complete physical picture
2. Realistic Astrophysical Environments: Constrains based on observational data from real AGN such as TXS 0506+056
3. Cosmic-Ray Collision Mechanism: First systematic consideration of cosmic-ray-cosmic-ray collision constraints on low-scale gravity
4. Thermal Spectrum Predictions: Calculates characteristic thermal neutrino spectra produced by Hawking radiation from microscopic black holes

Experimental Setup

Observational Data

• TXS 0506+056: The first extragalactic high-energy neutrino source detected by IceCube
• NGC 1068: Another confirmed neutrino-emitting AGN
• KM3NeT Event: Ultra-high-energy cosmic neutrino event KM3-230213A

Astrophysical Parameters

• Proton Number Density: $n_p = 10^{12} \text{ cm}^{-3}$ (TXS 0506+056)
• Magnetic Field Strength: $B = 100$ kG (typical AGN corona)
• Acceleration Efficiency: $\eta = 1$ (optimistic estimate)
• Dynamical Timescale: $\tau_{dyn} \sim 10^5$ s (TXS 0506+056)

Model Parameters

• Number of Extra Dimensions: $n = 2$ (primary case considered)
• Gravitational Fundamental Scale: $M_f = 0.2-2000$ TeV (scanning range)
• Cosmic-Ray Energy: $E_{CR} = 10^2 - 10^{12}$ GeV

Experimental Results

Main Constraint Results

1. TXS 0506+056 Constraints

For the case $n = 2$:

• Current Constraints: $M_f \gtrsim 0.3$ TeV
• Physical Principle: Requires that the cooling timescale of gravitational processes cannot be significantly shorter than the dynamical timescale inferred from observations

2. Future Detection Potential

• GZK Neutrinos: $M_f \gtrsim 200$ TeV
• KM3-230213A-type Events: Can provide moderate improvements
• Cosmic-Ray Collisions: Theoretical limit $M_f \gtrsim 2$ PeV

3. Parameter Dependence

Constraint strength varies with the number of extra dimensions $n$:

• Larger $n$ yields weaker constraints in the high-energy region
• However, constraints are stronger near the low-energy threshold

Thermal Neutrino Spectrum Predictions

The neutrino spectrum produced by Hawking radiation from microscopic black holes exhibits the following characteristics:

• Thermal Spectrum Shape: Distinctly different from the power-law spectrum of meson decay
• Peak Position: $E_{peak} \sim T_H \approx M_f$
• Normalization: Proportional to the geometric production rate $\sigma_0 \propto M_f^{-2}$

Multi-Brane World Signals

Proposes a unique observational feature:

• High-energy particle emission from regions of the sky with no multi-wavelength counterparts
• Produced through graviton propagation from other branes and decay in our universe
• Energy Scale: $E_{messenger} \lesssim M_f$

Related Work

Traditional Constraint Methods

1. Collider Experiments: ATLAS and CMS searches at $\sqrt{s} = 13$ TeV
2. Astrophysical Constraints:
   • SN1987A limitations on graviton production
   • Neutron star cooling constraints
   • Cosmological relic graviton constraints

Neutrino Astrophysics Applications

• Dark matter-neutrino scattering constraints
• Supersymmetric particle searches
• Non-standard neutrino interaction searches

Advantages of This Work

1. Energy Scale: Far exceeds collider experiments
2. Real Data: Based on actual observations rather than theoretical expectations
3. Systematicity: Considers multiple production mechanisms and observational features

Conclusions and Discussion

Main Conclusions

1. Current Constraints: TXS 0506+056 data already imposes meaningful constraints on low-scale gravity theories of $M_f \gtrsim 0.3$ TeV
2. Future Potential: High-energy neutrino observations have the potential to raise constraints to the 200 TeV level
3. Theoretical Limit: The ultimate limit of the cosmic-ray method is approximately 2 PeV, constrained by the age of the universe
4. Observational Predictions: Microscopic black hole production will result in distinguishable thermal neutrino spectra

Limitations

1. Astrophysical Uncertainties: AGN environmental parameters (density, magnetic field, etc.) have substantial uncertainties
2. Theoretical Assumptions:
   • The assumption of complete black hole evaporation may not hold
   • Validity of EFT description near $\sqrt{s} \sim M_f$
   • Applicability range of semi-classical Hawking radiation theory
3. Observational Challenges:
   • Cosmic-ray collisions require special astrophysical environments
   • Detection of thermal neutrino spectra requires high statistics and good energy resolution
4. Model Dependence: Constraint strength depends on specific low-scale gravity model parameters

Future Directions

1. Observational Improvements:
   • Discovery of more AGN neutrino sources
   • Accumulation of ultra-high-energy neutrino events
   • Combination of multi-messenger observations
2. Theoretical Development:
   • More precise AGN environment modeling
   • Non-perturbative treatment of quantum gravity effects
   • New physics related to black hole information paradox
3. Method Extensions:
   • Utilization of other high-energy astrophysical environments
   • Potential contributions from gravitational wave detectors
   • Integration with direct cosmic-ray observations

In-Depth Evaluation

Strengths

1. Strong Innovation: First systematic combination of high-energy neutrino astrophysics with low-scale gravity theory
2. Complete Methodology: Forms a complete research chain from theoretical calculations to observational constraints to future predictions
3. Practical Feasibility: Based on existing observational data, with proposed future tests being operationally viable
4. Deep Physical Insights:
   • Identifies the importance of cosmic-ray collisions
   • Predicts unique thermal spectrum features
   • Proposes observable characteristics of multi-brane worlds

Shortcomings

1. Substantial Uncertainties: Uncertainties in astrophysical environment parameters may affect the reliability of constraints
2. Theoretical Assumptions: Some key assumptions (such as complete black hole evaporation) remain theoretically controversial
3. Observational Verification Challenges: Some predictions (such as multi-brane world signals) may be difficult to verify in actual observations
4. Lack of Comparative Analysis: Insufficient discussion of comparisons with other high-energy constraint methods

Impact

1. Interdisciplinary Crossing: Promotes cross-disciplinary research among particle physics, gravity theory, and astrophysics
2. Methodological Contribution: Provides a new paradigm for using astrophysical observations to constrain fundamental physics
3. Practical Value: Provides new scientific objectives for future neutrino telescopes and multi-messenger observations
4. Theoretical Inspiration: May advance further development of low-scale gravity theories and quantum black hole physics

Applicable Scenarios

1. High-Energy Neutrino Astrophysics: Provides new analytical frameworks for experiments such as IceCube and KM3NeT
2. Multi-Messenger Astrophysics: Combines neutrino, gamma-ray, and gravitational wave observations
3. Fundamental Physics Testing: Important pathway for seeking new physics beyond the LHC
4. Theoretical Physics Research: Provides observational tests for extra-dimensional and string theory models

References

The paper cites 83 important references covering the following major directions:

• Foundational work on low-scale gravity theories (ADD model, multi-species theories)
• High-energy neutrino astrophysics observations (IceCube, KM3NeT)
• Black hole physics and Hawking radiation theory
• AGN physics and cosmic-ray acceleration mechanisms
• New physics searches beyond the Standard Model

Overall Assessment: This is a high-quality theoretical physics paper that innovatively combines high-energy astrophysical observations with fundamental physics theory testing, opening new pathways for experimental verification of low-scale quantum gravity theories. Despite certain theoretical and observational uncertainties, its methodological contributions and physical insights possess significant academic value and practical significance.