Euclidean Correlation Functions in Quantum Gravity

Basic Information

• Paper ID: 2510.11888
• Title: Euclidean Correlation Functions in Quantum Gravity
• Authors: Jack Laiho (Syracuse University), Kenny Ratliff (Syracuse University & Kenyon College)
• Classification: hep-th (High Energy Physics - Theory)
• Publication Date: October 15, 2025
• Paper Link: https://arxiv.org/abs/2510.11888

Abstract

This paper calculates subleading-order Euclidean correlation functions in the low-energy effective theory of gravity. The research focuses on correlation functions of curvature and volume operators, computed to one-loop order. The authors demonstrate that quantum fluctuations of the background spacetime must be considered to obtain gauge-invariant expressions, and highlight subtleties related to conformal mode analytic continuation. The resulting correlation function expressions depend only on Newton's constant and the source-sink separation distance, representing universal predictions of the low-energy effective theory that serve as useful comparison points for non-perturbative lattice formulations of gravity.

Research Background and Motivation

1. Core Problem: The formulation of quantum gravity remains an important unsolved problem in theoretical physics. While a quantum gravity theory applicable at all scales has not yet been established, the low-energy effective theory expressed in terms of propagating gravitons over long distances is known.
2. Problem Significance:
   • The effective theory is non-renormalizable, requiring introduction of new low-energy constants at each order of perturbative expansion
   • Lattice quantum gravity methods attempt to go beyond the effective theory and capture non-perturbative effects
   • There is a need to establish connections between the effective theory and lattice approaches
3. Existing Limitations:
   • Leading-order calculations of curvature correlation functions yield contact terms, which are invisible in numerical lattice calculations
   • Lack of effective theory calculations for volume correlation functions
   • Coordinate corrections must be considered to obtain gauge-invariant results
4. Research Motivation: To provide theoretical predictions comparable with numerical lattice gravity calculations, verifying whether lattice methods recover the effective theory in the low-energy limit.

Core Contributions

1. First Systematic Calculation: Completion of systematic calculations of curvature-curvature and volume-volume correlation functions to subleading order (one-loop)
2. Coordinate Corrections: Demonstration of the necessity of coordinate corrections for obtaining gauge-invariant expressions
3. Gauge Invariance: Demonstration that results are completely independent of gauge parameters α and β upon inclusion of coordinate corrections
4. Conformal Mode Treatment: Identification and proper handling of subtleties in conformal mode analytic continuation
5. Universal Predictions: Final expressions depend only on Newton's constant, providing explicit comparison benchmarks for lattice gravity

Methodology Details

Task Definition

Calculate Euclidean two-point correlation functions of scalar curvature R and volume factor √(-g) in the gravitational effective theory:

• Input: spacetime point separation x-y
• Output: ⟨R(x)R(y)⟩ and ⟨√(-G)(x)√(-G)(y)⟩
• Constraints: gauge invariance, positive definiteness (reflection positivity)

Relational Observable Construction

Coordinate Scalar Definition

Construction of "principal coordinate system" X satisfying harmonic conditions:

∇²X^μ = 0

Perturbative expansion as:

X(x) = x + κX₁(x) + κ²X₂(x) + O(κ³)

Invariant Construction

For arbitrary tensor field C, its relational observable is defined as the component in the coordinate scalar system:

C̄ = C^μ_ν D_μ ⊗ dX^ν

Feynman Rules

Propagators

• Graviton Propagator: In generalized de Donder gauge

Δ^μνρσ(p) = (i/p²)[G^μνρσ - (1/2)tr^μνρσ + gauge-related terms]

• Ghost Propagator:

S^μν(p) = (i/p²)[(1 - d/(2(d-1-β)))p^μp^ν - g^μν]

External Vertices

• Standard R Vertex: E^μν_h(p) = κ(p²η^μν - p^μp^ν)
• Coordinate Correction Vertex: Non-local terms including scalar propagator factor 1/p²

One-Loop Calculations

Curvature Correlation Function

Contains 8 Feynman diagrams:

1. Standard field theory diagrams (4): bubble, triangle, ghost loop diagrams
2. Coordinate correction diagrams (4): corresponding coordinate-corrected versions

Final result:

iA^R_one-loop = -(κ⁴/16)q⁴B₀(q²,0,0)

Volume Correlation Function

Tree-level contains 3 contributions:

• Standard-standard vertex
• Standard-coordinate correction vertex
• Coordinate correction-coordinate correction vertex

Experimental Setup

Computational Tools

• Algebraic Computation: MATHEMATICA with XACT package for tensor calculations
• One-Loop Integrals: FEYNCALC package for Passarino-Veltman integrals
• Dimensional Regularization: d = 4-2ε, MS scheme

Gauge Parameters

• α: Arbitrary gauge parameter
• β: Arbitrary gauge parameter
• Special Cases: Harmonic gauge α=1/2, β=d/2-1

Regularization Scheme

Dimensional regularization employed to handle ultraviolet divergences, with higher-order curvature operators providing necessary counterterms.

Experimental Results

Main Results

Curvature Correlation Function

• Tree-level: Contact term, vanishing outside the origin
• One-loop:

Position space: 3κ⁴/(4π⁴x⁸) = 768G²/(π²x⁸_E)

Volume Correlation Function

• Tree-level:

Position space: 3κ²/(8π²x²) = 12G/(πx²_E)

• One-loop:

Position space: κ⁴/(256π⁴x⁴) = 4G²/(π²x⁴_E)

Gauge Invariance Verification

All results are completely independent of gauge parameters α and β upon inclusion of coordinate corrections, constituting a highly non-trivial consistency check.

Positive Definiteness Verification

All Euclidean correlation functions are positive, consistent with reflection positivity requirements.

Related Work

Historical Development

1. Modanese (1992): First calculation of tree-level curvature correlation functions
2. Fröb (2018): Development of relational observable formalism
3. Lattice Gravity: Numerical studies by Hamber, Ambjørn, and others

Innovations in This Work

• First systematic one-loop calculations including coordinate corrections
• First theoretical calculation of volume correlation functions
• Proper treatment of conformal mode analytic continuation

Conclusions and Discussion

Main Conclusions

1. Coordinate corrections are essential for gauge invariance
2. One-loop results depend only on Newton's constant, representing universal predictions
3. Conformal modes require special analytic continuation treatment
4. Explicit theoretical benchmarks provided for lattice gravity

Limitations

1. Calculations only to one-loop order
2. Based on perturbative expansion, applicable to weak-field regime
3. Treatment of contact terms requires more refined analysis

Future Directions

1. Higher-order loop calculations
2. Correlation functions of other geometric operators
3. Numerical comparison with lattice calculations
4. Investigation of non-perturbative effects

In-Depth Evaluation

Strengths

1. Technical Rigor: Complete treatment of coordinate corrections, a critical but often-overlooked effect
2. Computational Completeness: Systematic verification of gauge invariance, providing strong consistency checks
3. Physical Insight: Identification and proper handling of conformal mode subtleties
4. Practical Value: Provides concrete theoretical predictions for lattice gravity research

Weaknesses

1. Computational Complexity: Enormous complexity of three-graviton vertices limits higher-order calculations
2. Missing Numerical Verification: Comparison with actual lattice calculations not yet performed
3. Contact Term Treatment: Physical interpretation of delta function terms requires further clarification

Impact

1. Theoretical Contribution: Provides new computational tools and results for quantum gravity effective theory
2. Bridge Role: Connects perturbative and non-perturbative methods
3. Methodological Value: Successful application of relational observable methods

Applicable Scenarios

1. Theoretical benchmarks for lattice quantum gravity
2. Precision tests of gravitational effective theory
3. Quantum gravity phenomenology research
4. Quantum gravity effects in cosmology

References

This paper cites 68 relevant references spanning multiple fields including quantum gravity, effective field theory, and lattice methods, particularly:

• Pioneering work on gravitational effective theory by Donoghue et al.
• Lattice gravity research by Ambjørn, Loll, and others
• Development of relational observable theory by Fröb et al.

Technical Note: This is a technically demanding theoretical physics paper making important contributions to perturbative calculations in quantum gravity. The systematic treatment of coordinate corrections and verification of gauge invariance represent its most outstanding technical achievements, laying a solid foundation for further development in this field.