First Simultaneous Global QCD Analysis of Kaon and Pion Parton Distributions with Lattice QCD Constraints

Basic Information

• Paper ID: 2510.11979
• Title: First simultaneous global QCD analysis of kaon and pion parton distributions with lattice QCD constraints
• Authors: P. C. Barry, Chueng-Ryong Ji, W. Melnitchouk, N. Sato, Fernanda Steffens (JAM Collaboration)
• Classification: hep-ph hep-ex hep-lat nucl-th
• Publication Date: October 15, 2025
• Paper Link: https://arxiv.org/abs/2510.11979

Abstract

This study presents the first simultaneous global QCD analysis of parton distribution functions (PDFs) for pions and kaons, incorporating pion and kaon-induced Drell-Yan processes, leading neutron electroproduction data, and PDF moment data from lattice QCD. The analysis reveals that the valence ū distribution in K⁻ is softer than in π⁻, while the valence s quark density in K⁻ exhibits a more pronounced peak structure compared to ū. In the range 0.7 ≤ x ≤ 0.95, the effective exponent controlling the high-x behavior of PDFs is βK⁻ū = 1.6(2) for kaons, larger than βπ⁻ū = 1.16(4) for pions. From gluon momentum fraction analysis, the gluon component of pions accounts for approximately one-third of their mass budget at μ = 2 GeV, while for kaons it accounts for only about one-quarter.

Research Background and Motivation

Core Issues

As the lightest composite particles observed in nature, pseudoscalar mesons (pions and kaons) play a special role in understanding the relationship between strong nuclear interactions and fundamental QCD properties (such as SU(2) and SU(3) chiral symmetry breaking and hadron mass generation). However, reconciling this role with the fact that these particles are quark-gluon bound states has remained a central challenge.

Experimental Challenges

• The short lifetimes of pions and kaons and the lack of fixed meson targets make direct determination of their parton structure extremely difficult
• For kaons, available experimental data are even more limited, primarily from CERN's NA3 experiment, which collected only 700 dilepton events
• The NA3 experiment measured the ratio of Drell-Yan cross sections induced by kaons versus pions; the ratio data alone cannot uniquely determine the flavor structure of kaon valence quark PDFs

Theoretical Requirements

Due to the lack of empirical information to separate quark flavor PDFs in kaons, first-principles lattice QCD simulations are needed to supplement experimental measurements. This provides necessary constraints for reliable extraction of kaon PDFs.

Core Contributions

1. First Simultaneous Analysis: Performed the first simultaneous global QCD analysis of pion and kaon PDFs
2. Multi-Source Data Fusion: Combined experimental data (Drell-Yan, leading neutron electroproduction) and lattice QCD theoretical calculations
3. Kaon PDF Characteristics: First systematically determined the distinct characteristics of ū and s valence quark distributions in kaons
4. High-Precision Constraints: Utilized the latest lattice QCD data from the ETM Collaboration with continuum limit extrapolation at physical quark masses
5. Mass Decomposition Insights: Provided quantitative analysis of gluon contributions to the mass budget in pions and kaons

Methodology Details

Task Definition

The objective of this study is to simultaneously determine the parton distribution functions f(x,μ²) for each quark flavor and gluons in π⁻ and K⁻, where x is the parton momentum fraction and μ is the factorization scale.

Theoretical Framework

Drell-Yan Process Description

The factorized cross section for dimuon production h₁h₂ → μ⁺μ⁻X is:

$\frac{d\sigma}{dx_1dx_2} = \frac{4\pi\alpha^2}{9Q^2} \sum_{i,j} [C_{ij} \otimes f_{i/h_1} \otimes f_{j/h_2}](x_1,x_2;\mu^2)$

where Cᵢⱼ are hard coefficients describing the parton subprocess, calculated at next-to-leading order (NLO) and next-to-leading logarithm (NLL) precision.

Lattice QCD Moment Constraints

Utilizing PDF moments calculated from lattice QCD:

$\langle x^n \rangle_q = \int_0^1 dx \, x^n [q(x,\mu) + (-1)^{n+1}\bar{q}(x,\mu)]$

$\langle x^n \rangle_g = \int_0^1 dx \, x^n g(x,\mu), \quad n \text{ odd}$

PDF Parametrization

At the input scale μ₀ = mₒ = 1.28 GeV, a standard parametrization form is employed:

$f(x,\mu_0;a) = N x^\alpha (1-x)^\beta (1 + \gamma\sqrt{x} + \delta x)$

Bayesian Inference Method

A Monte Carlo framework is adopted for Bayesian inference, collecting approximately 1000 posterior distribution Monte Carlo samples to obtain reliable uncertainty quantification.

Technical Innovations

1. Simultaneous Fitting Strategy: Since the NA3 experiment measures ratio data, simultaneous analysis of kaon and pion data is necessary for reliable extraction of kaon PDFs
2. Lattice QCD Constraints: Innovatively combined high-precision lattice QCD moment data from the ETM Collaboration
3. Shape Constraints: For kaon sea quark and gluon distributions with sparse data, adopted a strategy using the same shape as pions but allowing normalization variations
4. Uncertainty Treatment: Applied a factor-of-2 enhancement to uncertainties of higher moments to account for potential systematic effects

Experimental Setup

Datasets

Experimental Data

• Kaon Data: NA3 experiment K⁻/π⁻ Drell-Yan cross section ratio, Q range 4.1-8.5 GeV
• Pion Data:
  • CERN NA10 and Fermilab E615 Drell-Yan data
  • HERA H1 and ZEUS leading neutron electroproduction data

Lattice QCD Data

• ETM Collaboration Data: Momentum fractions ⟨x⟩ of pion and kaon PDFs, calculated at physical pion mass
• Higher Moments: n=2,3 moment data calculated at pion mass 260 MeV

Evaluation Metrics

Fit quality assessed using χ²/N_dat:

• NA3 data: χ²/N_dat = 0.08
• Pion DY data: χ²/N_dat = 0.78
• Leading neutron data: χ²/N_dat = 0.87
• Lattice QCD data: χ²/N_dat = 0.65

Parameter Settings

Total of 25 free parameters:

• Pion PDF parameters: 9
• Kaon PDF parameters: 9
• Data normalization parameters: 6
• Leading neutron cutoff mass: 1

Experimental Results

Main Results

PDF Characteristic Comparison

Figure 2 reveals significantly different characteristics of valence quark distributions in K⁻:

• ūK⁻ᵥ is softer compared to ūπ⁻ᵥ
• sK⁻ᵥ is significantly larger than ūK⁻ᵥ for x ≳ 0.5
• At x = 0.8, sK⁻ᵥ is approximately twice ūK⁻ᵥ

High-x Behavior Analysis

Effective β exponent analysis shows:

• βK⁻ū = 1.6(2) (ū quark in kaons)
• βπ⁻ū = 1.16(4) (ū quark in pions)
• βK⁻ₛ = 1.2(4) (s quark in kaons)

Momentum Fraction Results

Table I presents key momentum fraction comparisons:

Important Findings

1. Strange Quark Dominance: The s quark in kaons carries approximately 30% more momentum than u+ū quarks
2. Gluon Contribution Difference: Gluons account for approximately one-third of pion mass but only one-quarter of kaon mass
3. Lattice QCD Verification: Theoretical calculations show high consistency with lattice QCD data

Future Experimental Predictions

Figure 4 demonstrates the expected impact of the AMBER experiment:

• Luminosity ≥2×10⁻²fb⁻¹ can achieve 3σ discrimination
• This will significantly improve the precision of kaon PDFs

Related Work

Historical Development

• Early Research: Kaon PDF extraction based on constituent quark models
• Statistical Models: Statistical methods combining J/ψ production data
• Lattice QCD: Recent high-precision calculations by ETM Collaboration and others

Advantages of This Work

Compared to previous research, this work is the first to:

1. Simultaneously analyze pion and kaon data
2. Systematically incorporate lattice QCD constraints
3. Provide complete uncertainty quantification

Conclusions and Discussion

Main Conclusions

1. PDF Shape Differences: The ū distribution in K⁻ is softer than in π⁻, with s quark distribution being more peaked
2. Flavor Structure Characteristics: The s quark dominates in the large-x region for kaons
3. Mass Decomposition: Gluon contribution to kaon mass (~1/4) is smaller than for pions (~1/3)
4. Heavy Quark Limit: The hard distribution of s quarks is consistent with theoretical predictions from the heavy quark limit

Limitations

1. Data Scarcity: Kaon experimental data remain limited, primarily dependent on the NA3 experiment
2. Lattice Systematic Errors: Lattice calculations of higher moments contain potential systematic uncertainties
3. Sea Quark Constraints: Constraints on kaon sea quark distributions primarily derive from theoretical assumptions

Future Directions

1. AMBER Experiment: Will provide the first measurement of kaon-induced DY cross sections in nearly 50 years
2. Jefferson Lab: Study kaon PDFs through ep→eΛX processes
3. Electron-Ion Collider (EIC): Can probe sea quark and gluon distributions in the small-x region
4. Other Processes: Charged current charm meson production, tagged semi-inclusive DIS, etc.

In-Depth Evaluation

Strengths

1. Methodological Innovation: First simultaneous global analysis of pion and kaon PDFs, solving the interpretation problem of ratio data
2. Data Fusion: Innovatively combined experimental data and lattice QCD theoretical calculations, improving extraction precision
3. Physical Insights: Revealed significant differences between s and ū quarks in kaons, providing important information for understanding strange quark behavior
4. Technical Rigor: Employed mature Bayesian Monte Carlo methods with complete uncertainty quantification
5. Predictive Value: Provided important theoretical predictions and guidance for future experiments such as AMBER

Limitations

1. Experimental Data Constraints: Kaon data still primarily depend on the decades-old NA3 experiment with limited statistical precision
2. Theoretical Assumptions: Assumptions about the shape of kaon sea quark distributions may affect result reliability
3. Lattice Uncertainties: While systematic errors were considered, uncertainty treatment in lattice QCD calculations could be improved
4. Dynamical Effects: Insufficient consideration of kaon mass effects on PDF evolution

Impact

1. Field Contribution: Provides the first complete kaon PDF analysis for hadron physics, filling an important gap
2. Experimental Guidance: Offers important reference for future experiment design, particularly feasibility analysis for AMBER
3. Theoretical Development: Advances methodology combining lattice QCD with phenomenology
4. Application Prospects: Provides necessary theoretical input for high-energy processes involving kaons

Applicable Scenarios

1. High-Energy Physics Experiments: Provides PDF input for hard scattering processes involving kaons
2. Lattice QCD Research: Provides benchmarks for phenomenological validation of lattice calculation results
3. Hadron Structure Studies: Provides quantitative tools for understanding the role of strange quarks in hadrons
4. Cosmic Ray Physics: Supports theoretical calculations for kaon-related processes in cosmic rays

References

This paper cites 73 important references covering experimental data, lattice QCD calculations, theoretical methods, and other aspects, providing comprehensive literature foundation for field development. Particularly noteworthy is the latest lattice QCD calculation results from the ETM Collaboration 35, which provides critical theoretical constraints for this research.

Overall Assessment: This is a high-quality paper of significant academic and practical value, achieving the first simultaneous global analysis of pion and kaon PDFs and making important contributions to hadron physics development. Despite limitations such as limited experimental data, its methodological innovations and physical insights provide a solid foundation for future development in this field.