Visualizing the Impact of Quenched Disorder on 2D Electron Wigner Solids

Basic Information

• Paper ID: 2510.12009
• Title: Visualizing the Impact of Quenched Disorder on 2D Electron Wigner Solids
• Authors: Zhehao Ge, Conor Smith, Zehao He, Yubo Yang, et al. (from UC Berkeley, Flatiron Institute, and other institutions)
• Classification: cond-mat.str-el (strongly correlated electron systems), cond-mat.mes-hall (mesoscopic Hall effect)
• Publication Date: 2024
• Paper Link: https://arxiv.org/abs/2510.12009

Abstract

This study achieves the first direct visualization and precise theoretical description of disordered 2D electron Wigner solids by combining atomic-resolution scanning tunneling microscopy (STM) and quantum Monte Carlo (QMC) simulations. The research identifies two distinct physical regimes: low defect density (LDD) and high defect density (HDD) regimes, revealing different mechanisms by which long-range and short-range disorder affect electron Wigner solids.

Research Background and Motivation

Core Problem

The competing effects between electron-electron interactions and electron-disorder interactions represent a central unresolved problem in condensed matter physics. When electron-electron interactions dominate, 2D electron systems undergo a transition from Fermi liquid to Wigner crystals; however, inevitable disorder in real materials significantly modifies this correlated electron behavior.

Significance of the Problem

1. Fundamental Physics: Understanding phase transition mechanisms in strongly correlated electron systems
2. Technical Applications: Providing theoretical foundations for quantum device design
3. Methodological Breakthrough: Establishing a new paradigm combining experiment and theory

Limitations of Existing Methods

1. Experimental Constraints: Lack of single-defect-resolved experimental measurement techniques
2. Theoretical Difficulties: Absence of accurate theoretical tools for treating disorder effects
3. Comparison Challenges: Inability to achieve quantitative experiment-theory comparisons

Research Motivation

By leveraging STM's atomic-scale imaging capability and advanced QMC methods, this work overcomes these limitations and establishes a new framework for quantitatively understanding disorder's impact on strongly correlated electron systems.

Core Contributions

1. First realization of atomic-resolution direct imaging of disordered 2D electron Wigner solids
2. Discovery of two new physical regimes: LDD and HDD regimes with distinctly different electronic behaviors
3. Observation of novel phenomena: Reentrant melting/crystallization behavior and modulation of Friedel oscillations
4. Establishment of new methodology: Integrated STM-QMC experimental-theoretical framework
5. Development of new QMC method: (MP)²-NQSs approach capable of unified description of solid and liquid phases

Detailed Methodology

Experimental Setup

Sample Preparation

• Material System: Gate-tunable bilayer MoSe₂ devices
• Structure: Graphene nanoribbon contact/bilayer MoSe₂/hexagonal boron nitride heterostructure
• Substrate: SiO₂/Si wafer
• Fabrication Process: Polymer transfer method and electron beam evaporation

STM Measurement Technique

• "In-gap" Tunneling Technique: Minimizes STM tip-induced perturbations
• Bias Adjustment: V_bias tuned to tip-sample work function difference, maintaining tip Fermi level within band gap
• Measurement Conditions: Ultra-high vacuum, 4.8 K cryogenic temperature

Theoretical Methods

QMC Simulations

• Novel Method: (MP)²-NQSs (multiple-plane-waves-message-passing neural quantum states)
• Advantages: Unified framework describing both solid and liquid phases, avoiding biases of conventional methods
• Innovation: Direct use of experimentally extracted disorder distributions in simulations

Disorder Treatment

• Long-range Disorder: Charged defects with 1/r Coulomb potential
• Short-range Disorder: Equivalent defects with short-range potential
• Realistic Modeling: Defect positions directly extracted from STM images

Experimental Parameters

Material System Parameters

• Effective Mass: m* ≈ 0.54m₀
• Dielectric Constant: ε ≈ 2.58ε₀ (hBN/vacuum interface)
• Critical Wigner-Seitz Radius: rs ≈ 37 (theoretical prediction)

Defect Density Ranges

• LDD Devices: n_LR ≈ 1.6×10¹⁰ cm⁻², n_SR ≈ 3.5×10¹⁰ cm⁻²
• HDD Devices: n_SR approximately 28 times higher than LDD, n_LR comparable

Measurement Parameters

• Electron Density Range: 2.9×10¹⁰ - 2.5×10¹¹ cm⁻²
• Wigner-Seitz Radius: rs ≈ 14-41
• Temperature: 4.8 K

Experimental Results

Major Findings

LDD Regime Characteristics (n_SR ≲ n_e)

1. Reentrant Melting/Crystallization: Non-monotonic solid-liquid transitions with increasing electron density
2. Mixed Phase Coexistence: Spatial coexistence of solid and liquid phases
3. Pronounced Friedel Oscillations: Evident charge density oscillations at high density
4. Long-range Order: Local triangular lattice structure

HDD Regime Characteristics (n_SR ≫ n_e)

1. Robust Amorphous Wigner Solid: Persistence to higher electron densities
2. Suppressed Reentrant Behavior: Absence of reentrant melting/crystallization phenomena
3. Quenched Friedel Oscillations: No pronounced oscillations at high density
4. Uniform Electron Localization: Strong electron localization with disordered spatial arrangement

Quantitative Results

Phase Transition Critical Values

• Theoretical Prediction: rs ≈ 37 (pure system)
• LDD Experiment: Wigner solid remains stable at rs < 37
• HDD Experiment: Further enhanced solid phase stability

Structure Factor Analysis

• LDD: Pronounced structure factor peaks indicating intermediate-range order
• HDD: Vanishing structure factor peaks confirming amorphous character

Theory-Experiment Comparison

Excellent Agreement

1. Electron Distribution: QMC simulations highly consistent with STM images
2. Phase Transition Behavior: Theory perfectly reproduces reentrant phenomena
3. Friedel Oscillations: QMC results quantitatively match experiments
4. Defect Effects: Theory accurately predicts impacts of different disorder types

Related Work

Historical Development

1. Wigner Crystal Theory: Wigner's 1934 proposal of electron crystal concept
2. QMC Development: Phase diagrams established by Tanatar, Ceperley, and others for 2D electron gas
3. Experimental Progress: Recent observations of Wigner solids in TMD materials

Innovations of This Work

1. First Direct Imaging: Atomic-resolution observation of disordered Wigner solids
2. Quantitative Theory Comparison: Precise QMC simulations with realistic disorder configurations
3. New Physics Discovery: Two distinct disorder regimes and reentrant phenomena

Conclusions and Discussion

Main Conclusions

1. Established New Framework: Experimental-theoretical combined approach for studying disordered quantum solids
2. Discovered New Regimes: LDD and HDD regimes with distinct physical properties
3. Revealed New Mechanisms: Decisive role of short-range disorder on electron correlations
4. Observed Novel Phenomena: Reentrant melting/crystallization and Friedel oscillation modulation

Physical Mechanism Understanding

LDD Regime Mechanism

• Dominant Factor: Long-range Coulomb potential of charged defects
• Electronic Behavior: Localization between defects while maintaining certain mobility
• Phase Transition Characteristics: Density-dependent commensurate/incommensurate transitions causing reentrant behavior

HDD Regime Mechanism

• Dominant Factor: Short-range potential of high-density equivalent defects
• Electronic Behavior: Strong localization with disordered spatial arrangement
• Stabilization Mechanism: Short-range disorder enhances electron localization, stabilizing solid phase

Limitations

1. Temperature Constraints: Study conducted only at 4.8 K; thermal effects insufficiently explored
2. Size Limitations: STM field-of-view restricts large-scale behavior investigation
3. Material Specificity: Results primarily based on MoSe₂ system

Future Directions

1. Extended Studies: Larger areas and different material systems
2. Temperature Dependence: Investigation of thermal melting behavior
3. Dynamics Research: Time-resolved phase transition dynamics
4. Application Exploration: Quantum device design based on disorder engineering

In-Depth Evaluation

Strengths

Technical Innovation

1. Methodological Breakthrough: STM-QMC combination represents pioneering new paradigm
2. Theoretical Progress: (MP)²-NQSs method resolves long-standing technical challenges
3. Experimental Precision: Atomic-level resolution and quantitative disorder characterization

Scientific Contributions

1. Novel Physics Discovery: Two disorder regimes and reentrant phenomena possess significant importance
2. Mechanism Understanding: Deepens comprehension of electron correlation-disorder competition
3. Quantitative Verification: Precise theory-experiment comparison establishes new standards

Shortcomings

1. Universality Questions: Results require verification in other material systems
2. Scale Limitations: STM field-of-view restricts macroscopic property investigation
3. Computational Cost: QMC simulation computational demands limit parameter space exploration

Impact Assessment

Academic Impact

1. Field Advancement: Provides new tools for strongly correlated electron system research
2. Methodological Exemplar: Establishes paradigm for deep experimental-theoretical integration
3. Theory Development: Promotes quantum many-body theory advancement

Application Prospects

1. Quantum Devices: Guidance for correlation-based device design
2. Material Engineering: Electronic property control through disorder engineering
3. Computational Methods: Broad applicability of improved QMC methods

Applicable Scenarios

1. Basic Research: Phase transition studies in strongly correlated electron systems
2. Materials Science: Electronic property modulation in 2D materials
3. Quantum Technology: Quantum phase transitions and quantum critical phenomena research
4. Computational Physics: Numerical method development for quantum many-body systems

Technical Details Supplement

STM Technical Points

• Tip Preparation: Electrochemically etched tungsten tips, calibrated on Au(111)
• Measurement Conditions: UHV < 1×10⁻¹⁰ mbar
• Data Processing: Radial averaging, structure factor analysis

QMC Computational Details

• Wave Function Form: Neural network Jastrow factor + backflow transformation
• Optimization Algorithm: Variational Monte Carlo optimization
• Parallel Computing: Large-scale parallel implementation

This research represents an important milestone in condensed matter physics combining experiment and theory, opening new pathways for understanding disordered quantum many-body systems.