Dual Truncated Hankel Operators: Characterization and Properties

Basic Information

• Paper ID: 2510.12223
• Title: Dual Truncated Hankel Operators: Characterization and Properties
• Authors: Arup Chattopadhyay, Supratim Jana
• Classification: math.FA (Functional Analysis)
• Submission Date: October 14, 2025 to arXiv
• Paper Link: https://arxiv.org/abs/2510.12223

Abstract

This paper introduces the concept of dual truncated Hankel operators (DTHO) and provides several operator equation characterizations utilizing dual compressions of the shift operator. These characterizations are analogous to results for classical Hankel operators and are consistent with recent developments in truncated Hankel operators (THO). Furthermore, this work resolves comprehensive solutions to various operator equations encountered in the study of THO and classical Hankel operators. We also establish fundamental operator-theoretic properties of DTHO applicable to general symbols and symbols under specific conditions.

Research Background and Motivation

Problem Background

1. Operator Theory on Hardy-Hilbert Spaces: Over the past century, the study of Toeplitz operators, Hankel operators, and composition operators on the Hardy-Hilbert space H² and its subspaces has received extensive attention.
2. Development of Model Space Operators: In 2007, Sarason pioneered the study of truncated Toeplitz operators (TTO), followed by Ding-Sang's introduction of dual truncated Toeplitz operators (DTTO).
3. Research on Truncated Hankel Operators: C. Gu and P. Ma recently investigated algebraic properties of truncated Hankel operators (THO).

Research Motivation

The core motivation of this paper is to fill the theoretical gap in dual truncated Hankel operators, specifically:

• Establishing operator equation characterizations for DTHO
• Investigating structural similarities between DTHO and classical Hankel operators
• Exploring fundamental operator-theoretic properties of DTHO
• Resolving operator equations encountered in THO and classical Hankel operator research

Core Contributions

1. Introduction of Dual Truncated Hankel Operators (DTHO): Defining a new operator class on the orthogonal complement K⊥θ of model spaces
2. Establishment of Operator Equation Characterizations: Providing four main operator equation characterization theorems
3. Complete Parametric Representation of Operator Equation Solutions: Giving comprehensive parametrizations of solutions to relevant operator equations
4. Revelation of Structural Similarities: Proving similarities between DTHO and classical Toeplitz and Hankel operators
5. Discovery of O'Toeplitz Operators: Introducing and studying a new class of operators exhibiting similarities to classical Toeplitz operators
6. Establishment of Fundamental Properties: Investigating boundedness, compactness, and subnormality of DTHO

Methodology Details

Task Definition

Let θ be an inner function, Kθ be the model space, and K⊥θ be its orthogonal complement. The dual truncated Hankel operator is defined as: $H^θ_φ : K^⊥_θ → K^⊥_θ, \quad H^θ_φ(h) = Q_θJ(φh)$ where φ ∈ L∞, J is the flip operator, and Qθ is the orthogonal projection from L² to K⊥θ.

Core Theoretical Framework

1. Operator Equation Characterizations

The paper establishes four main operator equations:

Theorem 2.2: $H^θ_φU_θ - U^*_θH^θ_φ = \bar{z} ⊗ Q_θJ(α_{φ^*}) - Q_θJ(α_φ) ⊗ \bar{z}$ where $α_φ = φ(1 - \bar{θ_0}θ)$

Theorem 2.4: $H^θ_φ - U^*_θH^θ_φU^*_θ = \bar{z} ⊗ (β_φ - ⟨β_φ, θ⟩θ) + (Q_θJη_φ + δ\bar{z}) ⊗ θ$

Theorems 2.6 and 2.7: Similar operator equation forms

2. Solutions to Operator Equations

For operator equations of the form $A = U^*_θAU^*_θ$, the paper provides complete parametric representations of solutions:

• When θ₀ = 0: There exists an L∞ function ψ such that $A(h) = P H^θ_{ψθ̆}(Qh)$
• When θ₀ ≠ 0: There exist ψ, η ∈ H∞ such that A = F_η + G_ψ

Technical Innovations

1. Dual Structure Properties: DTHO exhibits both properties similar to Toeplitz operators (symbol uniqueness, boundedness conditions) and properties similar to Hankel operators (commutation relations, subnormality)
2. Systematic Study of Operator Equations: Providing unified solutions to various operator equations encountered in THO and classical Hankel operator research
3. Discovery of O'Toeplitz Operators: Discovering a new class of operators during the investigation, possessing independent theoretical value

Experimental Setup

As a pure mathematical theory paper, this work does not involve numerical experiments but rather verifies theoretical results through rigorous mathematical proofs.

Theoretical Verification Methods

1. Constructive Proofs: Proving existence through explicit construction of operator actions
2. Proof by Contradiction: Establishing uniqueness and necessary conditions
3. Mathematical Induction: Utilizing iterative properties of operators to establish general results
4. Duality Arguments: Employing operator duality relations to establish mutual characterizations

Experimental Results

Main Theoretical Results

1. Symbol Uniqueness (Theorem 4.1)

Result: The symbol of DTHO is unique, i.e., $H^θ_φ = 0$ if and only if φ = 0

2. Boundedness and Compactness (Theorem 4.2)

Result:

• $H^θ_φ$ is bounded if and only if φ ∈ L∞, with $\|H^θ_φ\| = \|φ\|_∞$
• The only compact DTHO is the zero operator

3. Product Properties (Theorems 4.3-4.5)

Result:

• Establishing lower bound estimates for products of DTHO
• Proving that the product of two DTHO is zero if and only if one of them is zero

4. Similarities with Classical Operators

Brown-Halmos Type Characterization (Theorem 4.7): Under specific conditions, the product of DTHO satisfies the Brown-Halmos Toeplitz identity if and only if one of them is zero

Commutativity (Theorem 4.8): Under restrictive conditions, two DTHO commute if and only if one is a scalar multiple of the other

5. Subnormality (Theorem 4.10)

Result: Every subnormal DTHO is normal

Complete Characterization of Operator Equation Solutions

The paper provides complete parametric representations of solutions to multiple operator equations, such as:

• Solutions to $A = U^*_θAU^*_θ$ (Theorem 3.2)
• Solutions to $A = U_θAU_θ$ (Theorem 3.5)
• Solutions to $U^*_θA = AU_θ$ (Theorem 3.8)

Related Work

Historical Development

1. Classical Theory: Brown-Halmos's Toeplitz operator theory laying the foundation
2. Model Space Theory: Sarason's truncated Toeplitz operators opening new directions
3. Recent Developments: Ding-Sang's dual truncated Toeplitz operators, Gu-Ma's truncated Hankel operators

Positioning of This Work

This paper extends truncated operator theory to the dual truncated case of Hankel operators, filling theoretical gaps and discovering new operator classes (O'Toeplitz operators).

Conclusions and Discussion

Main Conclusions

1. Theoretical Completeness: Establishing a complete theoretical framework for DTHO, including operator equation characterizations, parametric representations of solutions, and fundamental properties
2. Structural Similarities: Proving deep connections between DTHO and classical Toeplitz and Hankel operators
3. New Operator Discovery: The introduction of O'Toeplitz operators enriches operator theory

Limitations

1. Condition Restrictions: Some results require specific conditions (such as θ₀ = 0 or θ* = θ)
2. Application Scope: Primarily concentrated at the theoretical level, with practical applications requiring further exploration

Future Directions

The paper raises several open questions:

1. Determining general conditions for DTHO normality
2. Investigating when the product of two DTHO remains a DTHO or DTTO
3. Further investigation of O'Toeplitz operator properties

In-Depth Evaluation

Strengths

1. Theoretical Rigor: All results have complete mathematical proofs with clear logic
2. Systematicity: Establishing a complete theoretical system for DTHO
3. Novelty: Introducing new concepts and discovering unexpected operator classes
4. Unification: Providing a unified framework for solving multiple related operator equations

Weaknesses

1. Technical Complexity: Proofs are relatively complex, potentially affecting theoretical generalization and application
2. Condition Dependency: Many results require specific technical conditions
3. Practical Applications: Lacking connections to concrete application problems

Impact

1. Theoretical Contribution: Making important contributions to operator theory, particularly model space operator theory
2. Methodological Value: Providing technical methods applicable to studying other related operators
3. Inspirational Value: The discovery of O'Toeplitz operators may open new research directions

Applicable Scenarios

This research is primarily applicable to:

1. Theoretical research in functional analysis and operator theory
2. Development of Hardy space and model space theory
3. Applications of operator methods in complex analysis

References

The paper cites 35 relevant references, covering classical and recent developments in operator theory, particularly:

• Brown-Halmos's classical theory of Toeplitz operators
• Sarason's theory of truncated Toeplitz operators
• Gu-Ma's recent research on truncated Hankel operators
• Related literature on model space operator theory

Overall Assessment: This is a high-quality pure mathematics theory paper making important contributions to the field of operator theory. The paper not only establishes a complete theory of dual truncated Hankel operators but also unexpectedly discovers new operator classes, demonstrating profound mathematical insight. Although technically demanding, it provides a solid foundation for further research in related fields.