Search for the $D^{*}\bar{D}^{*}$ Molecular State $X_{2}(4013)$ in $K^{-}p$ and $pp$ Collisions

Basic Information

• Paper ID: 2510.12292
• Title: Search for the $D^{*}\bar{D}^{*}$ Molecular State $X_{2}(4013)$ in $K^{-}p$ and $pp$ Collisions
• Authors: Min Yuan, Yin Huang (Southwest Jiaotong University)
• Classification: hep-ph (High Energy Physics - Phenomenology)
• Submission Date: October 15, 2025
• Paper Link: https://arxiv.org/abs/2510.12292

Abstract

Based on the interpretation of $X(3872)$ as a $D\bar{D}^{*}$ molecular state, this paper predicts its spin-2 partner state $X_{2}(4013)$ through heavy quark spin symmetry, which can be viewed as a $D^{*}\bar{D}^{*}$ molecule with quantum numbers $J^{PC} = 2^{++}$. Within the effective Lagrangian framework, the authors investigate the production mechanisms of $X_{2}(4013)$ in the reactions $K^{-}p \to \Lambda_{c}^{+} D_{s}^{-} X_{2}(4013)$ and $pp \to \Lambda_{c}^{+}\Lambda_{c}^{+} X_{2}(4013)$. The calculations show that the total cross sections can reach the picobarn level, and the inclusion of initial state interactions (ISI) enhances the cross sections by nearly an order of magnitude, providing theoretical benchmarks for searching for this particle at experiments such as AMBER@CERN and LHCb.

Research Background and Motivation

Scientific Questions

1. Core Problem: Searching for experimental evidence of the theoretically predicted $D^{*}\bar{D}^{*}$ molecular state $X_{2}(4013)$
2. Physical Significance: Verifying the molecular state interpretation of $X(3872)$ and predictions from heavy quark spin symmetry
3. Experimental Challenge: Direct analysis of $\bar{D}^{*}D^{*}$ invariant mass spectra has failed to find clear resonance signals near 4013 MeV

Research Motivation

• Since its discovery by the Belle collaboration in 2003, the molecular state interpretation of $X(3872)$ has gained widespread support
• Heavy quark symmetry predicts the existence of a $J^{PC} = 2^{++}$ $D^{*}\bar{D}^{*}$ molecular state partner
• Multiple theoretical frameworks (contact interaction effective field theory, single boson exchange models, lattice QCD) consistently predict its mass to be approximately 4013 MeV
• Limitations of existing experimental methods necessitate exploring new production and detection mechanisms

Core Contributions

1. Proposing New Production Mechanisms: First systematic study of $X_{2}(4013)$ production in $K^{-}p$ and $pp$ collisions
2. Establishing Theoretical Framework: Constructing an effective Lagrangian model incorporating initial state interactions
3. Quantifying Production Cross Sections: Calculating total cross sections at the picobarn level, providing quantitative predictions for experimental searches
4. Revealing ISI Importance: Demonstrating that initial state interactions enhance cross sections by approximately 10 times
5. Predicting Angular Distribution Features: Discovering different angular behaviors in differential cross sections for the two reactions

Methodology Details

Task Definition

Investigation of $X_{2}(4013)$ production in the following reactions:

• Reaction 1: $K^{-}p \to \Lambda_{c}^{+} D_{s}^{-} X_{2}(4013)$
• Reaction 2: $pp \to \Lambda_{c}^{+}\Lambda_{c}^{+} X_{2}(4013)$

Theoretical Framework

Effective Lagrangian Density

Lagrangian densities for key interaction vertices:

1. $X_2D^*\bar{D}^*$ Coupling: $\mathcal{L}_{X_2D^*\bar{D}^*} = g_{X_2} X_2^{\mu\nu} D^*_\mu \bar{D}^*_\nu$
2. $\Lambda_c p D^*$ Coupling: $\mathcal{L}_{\Lambda_c p D^*} = g_{\Lambda_c p D^*} \bar{\Lambda}_c \gamma^\mu p D^{*0}_\mu + \text{H.c.}$
3. $K\bar{D}^* D_s$ Coupling: $\mathcal{L}_{K\bar{D}^* D_s} = ig_{K\bar{D}^* D_s} \bar{D}^{*\mu} [\bar{D}_s \partial_\mu K - (\partial_\mu \bar{D}_s)K] + \text{H.c.}$

Form Factors

Employing monopole form factors to describe finite size effects of hadrons: $F_i = \frac{\Lambda_i^2 - m_i^2}{\Lambda_i^2 - q_i^2}, \quad i = \bar{D}^*, D^*$

where $\Lambda_i = m_i + \alpha \Lambda_{QCD}$, $\Lambda_{QCD} = 220$ MeV, $\alpha = 1.5, 1.7$.

Initial State Interactions (ISI)

Describing $K^-p \to K^-p$ and $pp \to pp$ elastic scattering through Pomeron and Reggeon exchange:

$T(s,t) = A_{IP}(s,t) + A_{f_2}(s,t) \pm A_{a_2}(s,t) + A_\omega(s,t) \pm A_\rho(s,t)$

Each amplitude employs the standard Regge pole form: $A_i(s,t) = \eta_i s C_i^{K\bar{N}/NN} \left(\frac{s}{s_0}\right)^{\alpha_i(t)-1} \exp\left[\frac{B_i^{K\bar{N}/NN}}{2}t\right]$

Scattering Amplitude Calculation

The complete amplitude including ISI is: $\mathcal{M}_{full} = \mathcal{M}_{Born} + \frac{i}{16\pi^2 s} \int d^2\vec{k}_t T(s, k_t^2) \mathcal{M}_{Born}(s, k_t^2)$

Experimental Setup

Parameter Settings

• Coupling Constants: $g_{X_2} = 9$ GeV, $g_{\Lambda_c p D^*} = -5.20$ GeV, $g_{K\bar{D}^* D_s} = 5.0$ GeV
• Particle Masses: $m_{K^-} = 493.68$ MeV, $m_{\Lambda_c} = 2286.46$ MeV, $m_p = 938.27$ MeV
• Form Factor Parameters: $\alpha = 1.5, 1.7$

Energy Range

• $K^-p$ reaction: Threshold $\sqrt{s} = 8267.81$ MeV, calculations up to 58 GeV
• $pp$ reaction: Threshold $\sqrt{s} = 8585.92$ MeV, calculations up to 58 GeV

Evaluation Metrics

• Total cross section $\sigma_{total}$
• Differential cross section $d\sigma/d\cos\theta$
• ISI enhancement factor $R = \sigma(\text{with ISI})/\sigma(\text{without ISI})$

Experimental Results

Main Results

Total Cross Sections

Near $\sqrt{s} = 50$ GeV:

ISI Effects

• $K^-p$ reaction: ISI enhances cross section by approximately 9.9 times
• $pp$ reaction: ISI enhances cross section by approximately 9.9 times
• Enhancement factors are essentially identical for both reactions, with $pp$ reaction slightly larger

Parameter Sensitivity

Impact of form factor parameter $\alpha$:

• At $\sqrt{s} = 30$ GeV: $R_\alpha = \sigma(\alpha=1.7)/\sigma(\alpha=1.5) \approx 1.56-1.60$
• Larger enhancement factors at high energy: $R_\alpha \approx 1.58-1.62$ at $\sqrt{s} = 50$ GeV

Differential Cross Section Analysis

Angular Distribution Features

1. $K^-p$ reaction:
   • Exhibits typical $t$-channel contribution characteristics
   • Forward-peaked distribution (maximum at $\cos\theta \to 1$)
   • Monotonic decrease at backward angles
2. $pp$ reaction:
   • Non-monotonic distribution
   • Pronounced dip near central angles ($\cos\theta \approx 0$)
   • Enhancement at forward and backward angles
   • Dip structure deepens with increasing incident energy

Physical Mechanisms

The central dip in the $pp$ reaction may originate from:

• "Dynamical zeros" under helicity conservation constraints
• Complex helicity structure of baryon current couplings
• Constraint effects from coupling to high-spin final state particles

Experimental Feasibility

• Cross sections reach the picobarn level, observable at experiments such as AMBER@CERN and LHCb
• The importance of ISI effects indicates that initial state interactions cannot be neglected
• Complementarity of different reaction channels aids in signal confirmation

Related Work

Theoretical Studies

• Molecular State Models: Contact interaction EFT, single boson exchange models
• Lattice QCD: Non-perturbative first-principles calculations
• Heavy Quark Symmetry: Predictions of $X(3872)$ partner states

Current Experimental Status

• Direct Searches: Analysis of $\bar{D}^*D^*$ invariant mass spectra has not found clear signals
• Indirect Evidence: BESIII reports possible signals in $e^+e^- \to \pi^+\pi^-J/\psi$
• Other Attempts: $B^+ \to K^+ X_2(4013)$ reconstruction, radiative transitions, etc.

Conclusions and Discussion

Main Conclusions

1. Production Cross Sections: The production cross sections of $X_2(4013)$ in $K^-p$ and $pp$ collisions can reach the picobarn level
2. ISI Importance: Initial state interactions enhance cross sections by nearly an order of magnitude and cannot be neglected
3. Angular Distribution Differences: The two reactions exhibit distinctly different angular behaviors, providing complementary information
4. Experimental Feasibility: Observation of this particle at current and future experimental facilities is feasible

Limitations

1. Parameter Uncertainties: Theoretical uncertainties exist in the form factor parameter $\alpha$
2. Model Dependence: Based on effective Lagrangian methods, model dependencies exist
3. Coupling Constants: Some coupling constants derive from SU(4) symmetry estimates with limited precision
4. Background Processes: Possible background reactions and interference effects are not considered

Future Directions

1. Experimental Verification: Search for predicted signals at AMBER@CERN, LHCb, and other experiments
2. Theoretical Improvements: Inclusion of more reaction channels and more precise coupling constants
3. Background Studies: Detailed analysis of possible background processes
4. Alternative Production Mechanisms: Exploration of additional reaction channels for $X_2(4013)$ production

In-Depth Evaluation

Strengths

1. Novelty: First systematic study of this molecular state production in hadronic collisions
2. Theoretical Rigor: Employs mature effective Lagrangian methods and Regge theory
3. Practical Value: Provides quantitative predictions and theoretical benchmarks for experimental searches
4. Physical Insights: Reveals the importance of ISI effects and complementarity of different reactions

Weaknesses

1. Theoretical Uncertainties: Significant uncertainties in the choice of form factor parameter $\alpha$
2. Model Simplification: The ISI model is relatively simple and may underestimate complexity
3. Experimental Challenges: Picobarn-level cross sections remain small, requiring high-luminosity experiments
4. Competing Processes: Insufficient discussion of mixing effects with other particles (e.g., $Z_c(4020)$)

Impact

1. Theoretical Contribution: Provides new theoretical methods for searching for molecular states
2. Experimental Guidance: Offers important references for future experimental design
3. Field Advancement: Promotes development of exotic hadron state research
4. Methodological Value: ISI effect studies provide insights applicable to other processes

Applicable Scenarios

• High-energy hadronic collider experiments (LHC, RHIC, etc.)
• Fixed-target experiments (AMBER@CERN, etc.)
• Theoretical and experimental studies of exotic hadron states
• Molecular state physics in heavy quark systems

References

The paper cites 46 important references covering experimental discoveries of exotic hadron states, theoretical models, and related phenomenological studies, providing a comprehensive literature foundation for this field.