Experimental verification of multi-copy activation of genuine multipartite entanglement

Basic Information

• Paper ID: 2510.12457
• Title: Experimental verification of multi-copy activation of genuine multipartite entanglement
• Authors: Robert Stárek, Tim Gollerthan, Olga Leskovjanová, Michael Meth, Peter Tirler, Nicolai Friis, Martin Ringbauer, Ladislav Mišta Jr.
• Classification: quant-ph (Quantum Physics)
• Publication Date: October 15, 2025
• Paper Link: https://arxiv.org/abs/2510.12457

Abstract

A fundamental concept in quantum information processing is genuine multipartite entanglement (GME), a form of correlation that transcends bipartite separability—correlations that cannot be explained by statistical mixtures of partially separable states. GME is crucial for characterizing and benchmarking complex quantum systems and serves as an important resource for applications such as quantum communication. Notably, it has been discovered that GME can be activated from multiple copies of bipartite separable quantum states, which individually do not possess GME. This paper provides experimental evidence of GME activation from two copies of a biseparable three-qubit state in a trapped-ion quantum processor. These results not only challenge conventional concepts of quantum resources but also highlight the potential of utilizing multiple copies of quantum states to accomplish tasks beyond the capabilities of single copies.

Research Background and Motivation

Problem Definition

The core problem addressed by this research is the experimental verification of the counterintuitive quantum phenomenon of "multi-copy activation of genuine multipartite entanglement." Specifically, the researchers aim to demonstrate that although a single quantum state may be merely biseparable, multiple copies of that state combined together can exhibit genuine multipartite entanglement (GME).

Significance

1. Theoretical Significance: This phenomenon challenges conventional understanding of quantum resources, demonstrating that "creation from nothing" style entanglement activation is possible
2. Practical Value: Holds important implications for quantum networks and distributed quantum computing, particularly in quantum communication protocols
3. Fundamental Research: Provides new perspectives for understanding the complex behavior of multipartite quantum systems

Existing Limitations

1. Theory-Experiment Gap: Although theoretically proven possible, GME activation lacks convincing experimental verification
2. Technical Challenges: Requires precise preparation and measurement of multi-qubit states, imposing extremely high demands on experimental techniques
3. Verification Difficulty: Must simultaneously demonstrate biseparability of single copies and GME properties of multiple copies

Research Motivation

The authors' motivation is to provide definitive experimental proof of the GME activation principle, laying the foundation for future development of practical quantum technologies exploiting this phenomenon.

Core Contributions

1. First Experimental Verification: First experimental demonstration of two-copy GME activation on a trapped-ion platform
2. Rigorous Theoretical Construction: Design of a biseparable three-qubit state with ideal properties that exhibits GME in the two-copy case
3. Complete Verification Protocol: Establishment of a comprehensive experimental verification protocol including biseparability proof and GME witness
4. Technical Innovation: Development of a modified subtraction algorithm to prove biseparability of experimental states
5. Practical Analysis: Assessment of feasibility and technical challenges for extension to multiple copies

Methodology Details

Task Definition

Input: Biseparable three-qubit state ρ_ABC Output: Verification that two copies ρ_A1B1C1 ⊗ ρ_A2B2C2 possess GME with respect to partition A1A2|B1B2|C1C2 Constraints: Single copy must be biseparable but completely inseparable

Theoretical Construction

Target State Design

The researchers constructed a balanced mixture composed of eight three-qubit states:

ρ̃_ABC = (1/8) Σ_{i=0}^7 |a_i⟩⟨a_i|

where the first four states have the form:

• |a_{0,1}⟩ = |±⟩A ⊗ |Φ^±⟩
• |a_{2,3}⟩ = (Z ⊗ √Z ⊗ √Z)|±⟩A ⊗ |Φ^±⟩

The latter four states are obtained by exchanging qubits A and B.

Robustness Enhancement

To improve experimental robustness, a small amount of colored noise was added:

ρ_ABC = ((1-q)/8) Σ_{i=0}^7 |a_i⟩⟨a_i| + (q/2)(|ã_8⟩⟨ã_8| + |ã_9⟩⟨ã_9|)

where q = 6×10^{-2}, |ã_8⟩ = |001⟩, |ã_9⟩ = |110⟩.

GME Witness Design

Completely Decomposable Witness

A completely decomposable witness is employed to detect GME:

W = P_M + Q_M^{T_M}

The witness operator W is obtained through semidefinite programming (SDP) optimization, with expected value ⟨W⟩ = -1.042×10^{-2}.

Pauli Decomposition

The witness operator decomposes into 32 six-qubit Pauli strings:

W = Σ_{k=0}^{31} m_k M_k

This allows experimental verification using only 17 distinct measurement settings.

Biseparability Verification Algorithm

Modified Subtraction Algorithm

Due to the special structure of the target state, the researchers modified the original subtraction algorithm:

1. Rather than subtracting pure separable states, biseparable mixtures are subtracted
2. Maximum overlap with separable states is sought through biased residuals
3. Mixing weights are optimized to achieve maximum overlap

Experimental Setup

Experimental Platform

• System: Six ^{40}Ca^+ ions in a linear Paul trap
• Qubit Encoding:
  • |0⟩ = ^4S_{1/2}(m_j = -1/2)
  • |1⟩ = ^3D_{5/2}(m_j = -1/2)
• Control Laser: 729 nm narrowband laser driving electric quadrupole transitions

State Preparation

• Single-Qubit Gates: Arbitrary-axis rotations and virtual Z gates
• Two-Qubit Gates: Mølmer-Sørensen (MS) gates
• Ion Arrangement: First copy uses ions 0, 2, 4; second copy uses ions 5, 3, 1

Measurement Protocol

• Tomography: Pauli tomography on each constituent state with 200 measurements per configuration
• Witness Measurement: Pauli measurements on 10×10 constituent states with 50 measurements per setting
• Readout Fidelity: Readout error below 2×10^{-3}

Experimental Results

Main Results

State Fidelity

The infidelities of the two single-copy states relative to the target state are:

• First copy: (2.54±0.05)×10^{-2}
• Second copy: (1.30±0.06)×10^{-2}

Biseparability Verification

The modified subtraction algorithm successfully proved biseparability of both single-copy states:

• First copy: 95% of Monte Carlo samples converged
• Second copy: 99% of Monte Carlo samples converged

GME Activation Verification

The experimental measurement value of the witness operator is:

⟨W⟩ = (-5.7 ± 0.5) × 10^{-3}

This is more than 11 standard deviations below zero, definitively confirming the presence of GME in the two-copy state.

Statistical Analysis

Error propagation was performed using vector formalism and verified through Monte Carlo resampling. The experimental results are consistent with the theoretical prediction of -8.87×10^{-3} within error margins.

Related Work

Theoretical Foundation

1. GME Activation Theory: Huber and Plesch (2011) first proposed the concept of multi-copy GME activation
2. Completeness Results: Yamasaki et al. (2022) proved that every completely inseparable biseparable state can be activated
3. Continuous Variable Extension: Baksová et al. (2025) extended results to infinite-dimensional systems

Experimental Progress

1. Photonic Systems: Chen et al. (2024) reported entanglement activation in multi-photon distillation networks
2. Advantages of This Work: Provides more rigorous verification, including explicit biseparable decomposition and sufficient GME witness
3. Application Prospects: New resource management strategies for distributed quantum computing in quantum networks; potential applications in quantum key distribution and conference key agreement

Conclusions and Discussion

Main Conclusions

1. Successful Verification: First experimental definitive proof of two-copy GME activation phenomenon
2. Technical Feasibility: Demonstrates the feasibility of achieving GME activation with current technology levels
3. Theoretical Validation: Experimental results are highly consistent with theoretical predictions

Limitations

1. Scalability Challenges: Extension to three copies requires 1000 combinations, with experimental complexity increasing dramatically
2. Noise Sensitivity: GME activation is highly sensitive to experimental imperfections
3. Measurement Overhead: Requires extensive measurement settings to verify higher-order activation

Future Directions

1. Three-Copy Activation: Theoretically feasible but technically more challenging
2. Distributed Implementation: Observation and utilization of GME activation in spatially separated systems
3. Practical Applications: Development of quantum communication protocols based on GME activation

In-Depth Evaluation

Strengths

1. Experimental Rigor: Provides a complete verification process including biseparability proof and GME witness
2. Technical Innovation: Development of modified algorithms suited to experimental state structure
3. Theoretical Contribution: Construction of activatable states with ideal properties
4. Statistical Reliability: Employs rigorous error analysis and statistical verification

Limitations

1. System Scale Constraints: Demonstrated only in a six-qubit system; scalability remains to be verified
2. Noise Requirements: Requires artificial noise addition to ensure experimental robustness
3. Measurement Complexity: Although measurement settings are optimized, 17 distinct configurations are still required

Impact

1. Fundamental Science: Provides important experimental verification for quantum resource theory
2. Technological Advancement: Opens new directions for quantum networks and distributed quantum computing
3. Methodological Contribution: Established verification protocols applicable to other multipartite entanglement research

Application Scenarios

1. Quantum Network Nodes: Application in quantum networks with biseparable entanglement sources
2. Distributed Quantum Computing: Utilization of multi-copy activation to enhance computational resources
3. Quantum Communication Protocols: Development of new secure communication schemes based on GME activation

References

1. Huber, M. & Plesch, M. Purification of genuine multipartite entanglement. Phys. Rev. A 83, 062321 (2011)
2. Yamasaki, H. et al. Activation of genuine multipartite entanglement: beyond the single-copy paradigm. Quantum 6, 695 (2022)
3. Jungnitsch, B. et al. Taming Multiparticle Entanglement. Phys. Rev. Lett. 106, 190502 (2011)
4. Ringbauer, M. et al. A universal qudit quantum processor with trapped ions. Nat. Phys. 18, 1053–1057 (2022)

Technical Summary:

• Successfully verified two-copy GME activation on a trapped-ion platform
• Employed completely decomposable witness to detect GME, requiring only 17 measurement settings
• Developed modified subtraction algorithm to prove single-copy biseparability
• Results provide important support for quantum resource theory and quantum network applications