Semiclassical analytical solutions of the eigenstate thermalization hypothesis in a quantum billiard

Basic Information

• Paper ID: 2510.12517
• Title: Semiclassical analytical solutions of the eigenstate thermalization hypothesis in a quantum billiard
• Authors: Yaoqi Ye, Chengkai Lin, Xiao Wang (University of Science and Technology of China)
• Classification: quant-ph, cond-mat.stat-mech, nlin.CD
• Publication Date: October 15, 2025 (arXiv preprint)
• Paper Link: https://arxiv.org/abs/2510.12517

Abstract

This paper derives semiclassical analytical solutions for the diagonal and off-diagonal functions in the eigenstate thermalization hypothesis (ETH) within the quarter-stadium quantum billiard model. For representative observables, explicit expressions and asymptotic closed-form solutions are obtained, naturally separating into local contributions and phase-space correlation terms. These analytical results predict the banded structure of observable matrices, including their bandwidth and scaling behavior. The equivalence between the analytical formula and Berry's conjecture is further demonstrated, with numerical evidence showing that Berry's conjecture captures the long-wavelength behavior of energy in eigenstate space, while the analytical solution describes the asymptotic behavior of the f-function in the semiclassical limit. Finally, the connection between bandwidth scaling and classical dynamics is revealed, demonstrating that ETH has important physical significance in single-particle and few-body systems, where "thermalization" manifests as loss of information about initial conditions.

Research Background and Motivation

Problem Definition

The eigenstate thermalization hypothesis (ETH) is an important hypothesis regarding the properties of eigenstates in quantum chaotic systems, formulated as: $\langle E_i|O|E_j\rangle = O(E_i)\delta_{ij} + f(E_i, E_j)r_{ij}$ where $O(E_i)$ and $f(E_i, E_j)$ are smooth functions, and $r_{ij}$ is a Gaussian random variable with zero mean and unit variance.

Research Significance

1. Theoretical Importance: ETH is considered a key framework for understanding the thermalization process in isolated many-body quantum systems
2. Interdisciplinary Impact: Important applications in condensed matter physics, statistical physics, high-energy physics, and quantum information
3. Analytical Gap: Since ETH's proposal, explicit analytical solutions for off-diagonal elements of observables have been lacking

Limitations of Existing Methods

1. Primarily rely on numerical simulations and experimental verification
2. Lack of deep understanding of ETH function structure
3. Insufficient research on ETH in single-particle and few-body systems
4. Lack of bridges connecting quantum thermalization with classical dynamics

Research Motivation

This paper aims to obtain analytical expressions for ETH functions in the quantum billiard model for the first time through semiclassical methods, revealing their physical essence and scaling behavior.

Core Contributions

1. First Analytical Solution: Derives the first explicit analytical expression for off-diagonal elements of the observable $\hat{q}_x$ in ETH
2. Physical Decomposition: Decomposes the analytical solution into local and phase-space correlation terms, revealing contributions from different physical mechanisms
3. Asymptotic Closed-Form Solution: Obtains asymptotic analytical forms of the f-function, explicitly predicting bandwidth scaling behavior
4. Berry Conjecture Equivalence: Proves equivalence between the analytical formula and Berry's conjecture, establishing theoretical connections
5. Classical-Quantum Correspondence: Reveals the connection between bandwidth scaling and classical dynamics, extending ETH applicability to single-particle systems
6. Numerical Verification: Provides detailed numerical evidence supporting theoretical predictions

Methodology Details

Task Definition

In the quarter-stadium quantum billiard, solve for the ETH functions of the observable $\hat{q}_x$ (position in x-direction):

• Input: Energy levels $E_i, E_j$ and geometric parameters
• Output: Analytical expressions for matrix elements $\langle E_i|\hat{q}_x|E_j\rangle$
• Constraints: Semiclassical limit $\hbar \to 0$ and classical chaos conditions

Model Architecture

1. Geometric Model

Quarter-stadium billiard: width $l=2$, height $h=1$, area $S_\Omega = 1+\pi/4$

2. Semiclassical Framework

Based on the Weyl symbol method, the exact expression for off-diagonal matrix elements: $|\langle E_i|O|E_j\rangle|^2 = \int dp dq \int dp' dq' J(p,q,\frac{q'}{\hbar},\frac{p'}{\hbar})W_i(\frac{p-p'}{2},\frac{q-q'}{2})W_j(\frac{p+p'}{2},\frac{q+q'}{2})$

3. Wigner Function Approximation

Employs energy-shell-averaged Wigner functions: $W_i(p,q) = \frac{\delta(H_{cl}(p,q)-E_i)}{S(E_i)}$ where $S(E_i) = 2\pi m S_\Omega$ is the phase-space volume.

Technical Innovations

1. Analytical Integration Techniques

Through coordinate transformations and Bessel function identities, complex multiple integrals are simplified into analytically solvable forms.

2. Physical Decomposition

Results are decomposed into two terms:

• Local Term: $\propto \int dz z_x^2 \int d\tilde{z} J_0(a|\tilde{z}|\sqrt{2mE_i/\hbar})J_0(a|\tilde{z}|\sqrt{2mE_j/\hbar})$
• Correlation Term: $\propto \int dz d\tilde{z} \tilde{z}_x^2 J_0(...)J_0(...)$

3. Asymptotic Expansion

Utilizes asymptotic forms of Bessel functions $J_0(x) \approx \sqrt{\frac{2}{\pi x}}\cos(x-\frac{\pi}{4})$ to obtain closed-form solutions in the high-energy limit.

Experimental Setup

Numerical Methods

• Algorithm: Scaling method for solving the Schrödinger equation
• Parameter Settings: $\hbar = 0.01$, energy range 3.5610～5.7469
• Computational Strategy: Sparsely selected equally-spaced energy levels to reduce computational complexity

Evaluation Metrics

• Consistency between analytical solutions and numerical results
• Accuracy of bandwidth predictions
• Statistical significance of Berry conjecture verification

Comparative Verification

1. Analytical formula vs. numerical computation of matrix elements
2. Theoretically predicted bandwidth vs. actual observations
3. Verification of Berry conjecture's long-wavelength behavior

Experimental Results

Main Results

1. Analytical Solution for Off-Diagonal Functions

$|\langle E_i|\hat{q}_x|E_j\rangle|^2 = \frac{1}{(1+\pi/4)^2}\int dz z_x^2 \int d\tilde{z} J_0(a|\tilde{z}|\sqrt{2mE_i/\hbar})J_0(a|\tilde{z}|\sqrt{2mE_j/\hbar}) - \frac{1}{4(1+\pi/4)^2}\int dz d\tilde{z} \tilde{z}_x^2 J_0(...)J_0(...)$

2. Asymptotic Closed-Form Solution

In the high-energy limit: $|\langle E_i|\hat{q}_x|E_j\rangle|^2 \approx \frac{\hbar^2}{mS_\Omega(E_iE_j)^{1/4}}\left\{[\text{coefficient}]\frac{\sin[\sqrt{\frac{2m}{\hbar}}(\sqrt{E_i}-\sqrt{E_j})Q]}{\sqrt{E_i}-\sqrt{E_j}} + \text{higher-order corrections}\right\}$

3. Diagonal Function

$|\langle E_i|\hat{q}_x|E_i\rangle| = \frac{10+3\pi}{12+3\pi} \approx 0.967$

Bandwidth Scaling Behavior

Theoretical prediction of bandwidth: $w_b \sim \frac{\hbar\sqrt{2E}}{mS_\Omega}$, numerically verified to be approximately 0.07, consistent with theory.

Berry Conjecture Verification

Through calculations with different numbers of averaged energy levels $N_{ave}$, it is confirmed that Berry's conjecture describes the long-wavelength behavior in eigenstate space. As $N_{ave}$ increases, numerical results approach the delta function.

Related Work

ETH Theory Development

• Deutsch (1991) and Srednicki (1994): Original proposal of ETH
• Rigol et al. (2008): Systematic study of ETH and thermalization mechanisms
• D'Alessio et al. (2016): Comprehensive review from quantum chaos to statistical mechanics

Analytical Progress

• Wang & Wang (2024): Semiclassical ETH theoretical framework
• Dymarsky (2022): ETH bounds from transport perspective
• This work: First complete analytical solution for observables

Berry Conjecture

• Berry (1977): Proposal of random wave conjecture
• Berry (1989): Quantum scars theory
• This work: Proof of equivalence between Berry conjecture and ETH

Conclusions and Discussion

Main Conclusions

1. Analytical Breakthrough: First explicit analytical expressions for off-diagonal ETH functions obtained
2. Physical Insights: Reveals different physical mechanisms of local and correlation contributions
3. Scaling Relations: Establishes direct connection between bandwidth and classical dynamics
4. Extended Applicability: Demonstrates that ETH applies not only to many-body systems but also to single-particle chaotic systems

Limitations

1. Model Constraints: Only considers quantum billiards with specific geometry
2. Observable Scope: Only analyzes position operator $\hat{q}_x$
3. Semiclassical Approximation: Depends on validity of $\hbar \to 0$ limit
4. Numerical Precision: Limited by computational resources, finite number of energy levels

Future Directions

1. Extension to other geometries and observables
2. Investigation of finite $\hbar$ effects and quantum corrections
3. Exploration of analytical methods in many-body systems
4. Connection between ETH and quantum information theory

In-Depth Evaluation

Strengths

1. Theoretical Innovation: Provides the first analytical solution in ETH research in 30 years, with milestone significance
2. Methodological Rigor: Complete semiclassical theoretical framework with detailed mathematical derivations
3. Physical Depth: Reveals microscopic mechanisms of thermalization and classical-quantum correspondence
4. Sufficient Verification: High consistency between theoretical predictions and numerical results

Weaknesses

1. Limited Scope: Currently restricted to specific models, universality remains to be verified
2. Technical Complexity: Analytical methods are highly specialized, difficult to generalize
3. Experimental Connection: Lacks direct experimental verification schemes

Impact

1. Academic Value: Provides important analytical tools for ETH theory
2. Interdisciplinary Significance: Connects quantum chaos, statistical physics, and quantum information
3. Methodological Contribution: Semiclassical methods can be extended to other quantum many-body problems

Applicable Scenarios

1. Theoretical analysis of quantum chaotic systems
2. Thermalization research in few-body quantum systems
3. Design of quantum billiards and waveguide devices
4. Decoherence analysis in quantum information processing

References

Key references include:

• Deutsch, J. M. (1991). Quantum statistical mechanics in a closed system
• Srednicki, M. (1994). Chaos and quantum thermalization
• Berry, M. V. (1977). Regular and irregular semiclassical wavefunctions
• Wang, X. & Wang, W. (2024). Semiclassical study of diagonal and off-diagonal functions in ETH

Overall Assessment: This paper achieves important breakthroughs in ETH theory research, providing analytical solutions for the first time and revealing underlying physical mechanisms. It represents a significant contribution to the interdisciplinary field of quantum chaos and statistical physics. Despite model limitations, its methodology and physical insights have broad inspirational value and application prospects.