On $\alpha$-monotone operators and their resolvent in Banach spaces

Basic Information

• Paper ID: 2510.12538
• Title: On $\alpha$-monotone operators and their resolvent in Banach spaces
• Authors: Changchi Huang, Jigen Peng, Yuchao Tang
• Classification: math.FA (Functional Analysis)
• Publication Date: October 14, 2025 (ArXiv Preprint)
• Paper Link: https://arxiv.org/abs/2510.12538

Abstract

This paper introduces a novel definition of $\alpha$-monotone operators in real 2-uniformly convex smooth Banach spaces. Based on this new definition, several novel structural and analytical properties of such operators are established, which not only extend classical results from Hilbert spaces but also reveal new insights into Banach space geometry. In particular, the resolvent of $\alpha$-maximal monotone operators is investigated, and its behavior is proven to be consistent with and generalize the firmly nonexpansive property in Hilbert space settings. Building on this theoretical framework, algorithmic applications are further studied. The forward-reflected-backward splitting algorithm under the new $\alpha$-monotonicity assumption is analyzed, and strong convergence and R-linear convergence rates are established in real 2-uniformly convex smooth Banach spaces.

Research Background and Motivation

Problem Background

1. Core Problem: Many problems in economics, mechanics, signal and image processing, and machine learning can be formulated as finding a point $x$ satisfying the inclusion $0 \in Ax$, where $A: X \to 2^{X^*}$ is a maximal monotone operator.
2. Limitations of Hilbert Spaces: In Hilbert spaces, the resolvent $J_\lambda^A = (I + \lambda A)^{-1}$ of a maximal monotone operator possesses the firmly nonexpansive property, which directly guarantees the convergence of the proximal point algorithm (PPA). However, this property no longer holds in general Banach spaces.
3. Insufficiency of Existing Methods:
   • Dao and Phan introduced the concept of $\alpha$-monotone operators in Hilbert spaces, but their classical definition has fundamental defects in Banach spaces
   • The classical definition is tied to the Hilbert space inner product and fails to reflect Banach space geometric properties such as convexity and smoothness
   • For the case $\alpha \neq 0$, existing methods cannot establish analogous resolvent operator properties in Banach spaces

Research Motivation

The authors propose a key insight: naive generalization of the classical $\alpha$-monotonicity definition is insufficient in Banach spaces because it fails to explicitly integrate the normalized duality mapping $J: X \to X^*$, a core geometric object.

Core Contributions

1. New Definition: A novel definition of $\alpha$-monotone operators is proposed in smooth Banach spaces (Definition 3.2), which explicitly incorporates the normalized duality mapping, aligning operator monotonicity with Banach space geometry.
2. Theoretical Properties: The fundamental properties of $\alpha$-monotone operators under the new definition are systematically characterized, establishing connections with existing operator classes such as maximal monotone and strongly monotone operators, and determining sufficient conditions for $\alpha$-monotone operators to be maximal.
3. Resolvent Analysis: The resolvent of $\alpha$-monotone operators in real 2-uniformly convex uniformly smooth Banach spaces is proven to preserve key contraction-type properties, which are natural analogues of the contractive behavior of resolvents in Hilbert spaces.
4. Algorithm Convergence: The concept of $\alpha$-monotonicity is applied to the analysis of the forward-reflected-backward splitting algorithm in Banach spaces. Under the condition that "strong convexity dominates weak convexity," strong convergence and R-linear convergence rates are established.

Detailed Methodology

Core Ideas of the New Definition

Classical Definition 3.1 ($\alpha$-monotone operators in Banach spaces): An operator $A: X \Rightarrow X^*$ is called $\alpha$-monotone ($\alpha \in \mathbb{R}$) if $\forall (x,u), (y,v) \in \text{gra } A, \quad \langle x-y, u-v \rangle \geq \alpha \|x-y\|^2$

New Definition 3.2 ($\alpha$-monotone operators in smooth Banach spaces): Let $X$ be a smooth Banach space. An operator $A: X \Rightarrow X^*$ is called $\alpha$-monotone ($\alpha \in \mathbb{R}$) if $\forall (x,u), (y,v) \in \text{gra } A, \quad \langle x-y, u-v \rangle \geq \alpha \langle x-y, Jx-Jy \rangle$

where $J: X \to X^*$ is the normalized duality mapping.

Technical Innovations

1. Geometric Compatibility: The new definition replaces the Hilbert space norm squared $\|x-y\|^2$ with the dual pairing $\langle x-y, Jx-Jy \rangle$. This term serves as a "Banach space-adapted inner product proxy" that can meaningfully quantify monotonicity aligned with space geometry.
2. Backward Compatibility: In Hilbert spaces, $J$ degenerates to the identity mapping, so Definition 3.2 recovers standard $\alpha$-monotonicity, ensuring backward compatibility.
3. Resolvent Properties: Key Lemma 3.15 is established, proving that the resolvent $J_\gamma^A$ of an $\alpha$-monotone operator is $(1+\gamma\alpha)$-firmly nonexpansive type: $\langle Jx - Jy, J_\gamma^A x - J_\gamma^A y \rangle \geq (1+\gamma\alpha) \langle J_\gamma^A x - J_\gamma^A y, JJ_\gamma^A x - JJ_\gamma^A y \rangle$

Key Theoretical Results

Theorem 3.4: Let $X$ be a real smooth 2-uniformly convex Banach space. Then there exists $\mu \geq 1$ such that $\frac{1}{2\mu}\|x-y\|^2 \leq \langle x-y, Jx-Jy \rangle, \quad \forall x,y \in X$

Theorem 3.5: If in a 2-uniformly convex smooth Banach space $X$ there exists $L > 0$ such that $\langle x-y, Jx-Jy \rangle \leq L\|x-y\|^2$ for all $x,y \in X$, then $X$ is isomorphic to a Hilbert space.

These results reveal the precise relationship between the two definitions and demonstrate the necessity of the new definition in non-Hilbert Banach spaces.

Experimental Setup

This is a pure theoretical research paper with no numerical experiments. All results are established through rigorous mathematical proofs.

Experimental Results

Main Theoretical Results

1. Equivalence Analysis (Remark 3.2):
   • Strong monotonicity under the new definition $\Rightarrow$ strong monotonicity under the classical definition (converse does not hold)
   • Weak monotonicity under the classical definition $\Rightarrow$ weak monotonicity under the new definition (converse does not hold)
   • The two definitions are completely equivalent if and only if the space is isomorphic to a Hilbert space
2. Density Result (Theorem 3.20): Maximal strongly monotone operators under the new definition are dense in maximal strongly monotone operators under the classical definition, providing an approximation method.
3. Algorithm Convergence (Theorem 4.1): In 2-uniformly convex uniformly smooth Banach spaces, the forward-reflected-backward splitting algorithm achieves strong convergence and R-linear convergence rate under the condition $\alpha + \beta > 0$.

Convergence Analysis

For the algorithm: $x_{n+1} = J_{\lambda_n}^A \circ J^{-1}(Jx_n - \lambda_n Bx_n - \lambda_{n-1}(Bx_n - Bx_{n-1}))$

where $\lambda_n \subseteq [\epsilon, \frac{1-2\epsilon}{2\mu L}]$, it is proven that there exists $\theta > 1$ such that $\|x_{n+1} - x^*\|^2 \leq \frac{M}{\theta^n}$

This extends the results of Malitsky and Tam in Hilbert spaces to Banach spaces.

Related Work

1. Monotone Operator Theory: Built on classical work by Browder, Rockafellar, and others, particularly the characterization of maximality of monotone operators in Banach spaces.
2. Banach Space Geometry: Utilizes work by Alber and Kamimura-Takahashi on Bregman distances and $\phi$-functions.
3. Operator Splitting Methods: Extends the theoretical framework of Kohsaka-Takahashi on firmly nonexpansive-type mappings.
4. $\alpha$-Monotonicity: Directly generalizes the pioneering work of Dao-Phan in Hilbert spaces.

Conclusions and Discussion

Main Conclusions

1. Studying $\alpha$-monotone operators in Banach spaces requires a new definitional framework; direct generalization of the classical definition is insufficient.
2. The new definition not only maintains consistency with Hilbert space results but also reveals deeper structures of Banach space geometry.
3. The contractive properties of resolvents can be preserved and generalized in appropriate classes of Banach spaces.
4. Strong convergence and linear convergence rates of operator splitting algorithms can be established in Banach spaces under the new framework.

Limitations

1. Space Restrictions: Main results require 2-uniform convexity and smoothness assumptions, which limit the applicable classes of Banach spaces.
2. Parameter Conditions: Algorithm convergence requires the condition "strong convexity dominates weak convexity" ($\alpha + \beta > 0$), which may be restrictive in practical applications.
3. Numerical Verification: As a pure theoretical work, it lacks numerical experiments to verify theoretical predictions.

Future Directions

The paper explicitly proposes several research directions:

1. Apply the new $\alpha$-monotonicity definition to other operator splitting algorithms
2. Study convergence of forward-backward-half-forward splitting algorithms
3. Analyze semi-reflected-forward-backward splitting algorithms
4. Theoretical analysis of outer-reflected forward-backward splitting algorithms

In-Depth Evaluation

Strengths

1. Theoretical Innovation: Proposes a geometrically natural and mathematically rigorous new definition that resolves fundamental defects of the classical definition in Banach spaces.
2. Systematicity: Comprehensively analyzes the relationship between the new and classical definitions, providing a complete theoretical framework.
3. Technical Depth: Proof techniques are sophisticated, particularly in the analysis utilizing Bregman distances and duality mapping properties.
4. Practical Significance: Provides new theoretical foundations for optimization algorithms in Banach spaces.

Shortcomings

1. Abstraction: Theoretical results are highly abstract with insufficient direct connection to concrete applications.
2. Strength of Assumptions: The 2-uniform convexity and smoothness assumptions are strong and may limit practical applicability.
3. Computational Complexity: The new definition involves computation of duality mappings, which may increase implementation complexity of algorithms.

Impact

1. Academic Contribution: Provides important theoretical tools for the development of monotone operator theory in Banach spaces.
2. Methodological Value: Demonstrates how to appropriately generalize Hilbert space concepts to Banach spaces.
3. Subsequent Research: Establishes theoretical foundations for Banach space generalizations of related algorithms.

Applicable Scenarios

This theoretical framework is particularly suitable for:

1. Optimization problems in Banach spaces with special geometric structures
2. Algorithm design requiring strong convergence guarantees
3. Theoretical analysis of monotone inclusion problems
4. Solution of variational inequalities and equilibrium problems

References

The paper cites 38 important references covering multiple fields including monotone operator theory, Banach space geometry, and operator splitting methods, encompassing both classical and cutting-edge work. Particularly noteworthy are citations and extensions of key works by Dao-Phan (2019), Kohsaka-Takahashi (2008), and Malitsky-Tam (2020).

This paper makes important theoretical contributions at the intersection of functional analysis and optimization theory, opening new directions for the development of monotone operator theory in Banach spaces. Although it is a pure theoretical work, the framework it establishes provides a solid mathematical foundation for subsequent algorithm design and analysis.