Dominating Hadwiger's Conjecture holds for all $2K_2$-free graphs

Basic Information

• Paper ID: 2510.12567
• Title: Dominating Hadwiger's Conjecture holds for all $2K_2$-free graphs
• Authors: Zi-Xia Song (University of Central Florida), Thomas Tibbetts (University of Central Florida)
• Classification: math.CO (Combinatorics)
• Publication Date: October 14, 2024 (arXiv preprint)
• Paper Link: https://arxiv.org/abs/2510.12567

Abstract

This paper investigates an important conjecture in graph theory—the dominating Hadwiger's conjecture. A dominating $K_t$-minor is defined as a sequence $(T_1,\dots,T_t)$ in a graph $G$, where $T_i$ are pairwise disjoint non-empty connected subgraphs, and for $1 \leq i<j\leq t$, every vertex in $T_j$ has a neighbor in $T_i$. This is a stronger condition than the standard $K_t$-minor definition (which requires only "some vertex" rather than "every vertex"). The dominating Hadwiger's conjecture asserts that every graph with chromatic number $t$ contains a dominating $K_t$-minor. This paper proves that the dominating Hadwiger's conjecture holds for all $2K_2$-free graphs, where $2K_2$ denotes the complement of a 4-cycle.

Research Background and Motivation

1. Problem to be Addressed: Verification of the dominating Hadwiger's conjecture on specific graph classes ($2K_2$-free graphs).
2. Problem Significance:
   • Hadwiger's conjecture is one of the most important unsolved problems in graph theory, equivalent to the Four Color Theorem for $t \geq 5$
   • The dominating Hadwiger's conjecture is a substantial strengthening of the classical Hadwiger's conjecture
   • This research contributes to understanding the deep relationship between chromatic number and structural properties of graphs
3. Limitations of Existing Methods:
   • The classical Hadwiger's conjecture itself is extremely difficult, remaining open for $t \geq 7$
   • The dominating version is even more challenging; Norin conjectures that this version may be false
   • Existing results have only verified the case $t \leq 5$
4. Research Motivation: By verifying the dominating Hadwiger's conjecture on specific graph classes, to provide more evidence for the truth or falsity of the conjecture and to develop new proof techniques.

Core Contributions

1. Main Theorem: Proves that the dominating Hadwiger's conjecture holds for all $2K_2$-free graphs, i.e., every $2K_2$-free graph $G$ satisfies $h_d(G) \geq \chi(G)$.
2. Novel Proof Techniques: Cleverly exploits the existence of induced banners (graph structures obtained by adding a vertex to a 4-cycle).
3. Structural Insights: Provides deep understanding of the structural properties of $2K_2$-free graphs.
4. Theoretical Contribution: Provides new technical tools and analytical methods for research on the dominating Hadwiger's conjecture.

Detailed Methodology

Problem Definition

Input: A $2K_2$-free graph $G$ (i.e., a graph that does not contain $2K_2$ as an induced subgraph) Output: Proof that $h_d(G) \geq \chi(G)$, where $h_d(G)$ is the dominating Hadwiger number of graph $G$Constraints: Graph $G$ must be $2K_2$-free

Key Concepts

1. Dominating $K_t$-minor: A sequence $(T_1, \ldots, T_t)$ where $T_i$ are pairwise disjoint connected subgraphs, and for $1 \leq i < j \leq t$, every vertex in $T_j$ has a neighbor in $T_i$.
2. Banner: A graph obtained by adding a vertex to a 4-cycle $C_4$, where this vertex is adjacent to exactly one vertex on $C_4$.
3. $2K_2$-free graph: A graph that does not contain two disjoint edges as an induced subgraph.

Proof Architecture

The proof employs proof by contradiction, assuming there exists a counterexample $G$ such that $h_d(G) < \chi(G)$, and selecting such a graph with the minimum number of vertices.

Key Lemma System:

1. Claim 1: If $G$ contains an induced banner $B = (b_1, b_2, b_3, b; b')$, then there exist adjacent vertices $b_4, b_5$ satisfying specific adjacency relations.
2. Claim 2: $G$ contains $C_5$ as an induced subgraph.
3. Claim 3: Every vertex in $H$ is adjacent to at least 4 vertices on $C_5$.
4. Claims 4-9: Detailed analysis of the distribution and adjacency patterns of vertices surrounding $C_5$.

Technical Innovations

1. Clever Use of Banner Structures: Controls local structure of the graph by analyzing the existence of banners.
2. Modular Arithmetic Techniques: Uses modulo 5 arithmetic when handling vertices on $C_5$, simplifying index management.
3. Systematic Case Analysis: Precisely classifies vertices outside $C_5$ according to their adjacency patterns with $C_5$.
4. Regularity Analysis: Proves regularity properties of certain bipartite graphs, which is key to constructing dominating minors.

Experimental Setup

This paper is purely theoretical research and does not involve experimental verification. All results are obtained through rigorous mathematical proofs.

Experimental Results

Main Results

Theorem 1.3: Every $2K_2$-free graph $G$ satisfies $h_d(G) \geq \chi(G)$.

This is the core result of the paper, completely resolving the dominating Hadwiger's conjecture on $2K_2$-free graphs.

Auxiliary Results

Theorem 1.4: Every $\{C_4, C_5, C_6, \ldots, C_{2\alpha(G)}\}$-free graph $G$ satisfies $h_d(G) \geq \chi(G)$.

Theorem 1.5: For graphs with independence number at most 2, the dominating Hadwiger's conjecture holds when certain small graphs are excluded.

Comparison with Classical Results

Theorem 1.6 (Micu, 2005): Every $2K_2$-free graph $G$ contains a $K_{\chi(G)}$-minor.

The result in this paper is a substantial strengthening of Micu's result, since a dominating $K_t$-minor imposes stricter requirements than an ordinary $K_t$-minor.

Related Work

Classical Hadwiger's Conjecture Research

1. Historical Development: Hadwiger (1943) and Dirac (1952) proved the case $t \leq 4$
2. Relationship to Four Color Theorem: Wagner (1937) proved that the case $t=5$ is equivalent to the Four Color Theorem
3. Approximation Results: The Kostochka-Thomason theorem provides a lower bound of $\Omega(t/\sqrt{\log t})$

Research on the Dominating Version

1. Concept Introduction: Illingworth and Wood (2024) first introduced the concept of dominating $K_t$-minors
2. Known Results: The case $t \leq 4$ has been verified; Norin announced results for $t=5$
3. General Upper Bound: Every graph without a dominating $K_t$-minor is $2^{t-2}$-colorable

Conclusions and Discussion

Main Conclusions

This paper successfully proves that the dominating Hadwiger's conjecture holds for all $2K_2$-free graphs, providing important positive evidence for research on this conjecture.

Limitations

1. Limited Scope: Results apply only to $2K_2$-free graphs and cannot be generalized to arbitrary graphs
2. Non-constructive: The proof is existential and does not provide an effective algorithm for constructing dominating minors
3. Technical Dependence: The proof heavily relies on the $2K_2$-free assumption, making the techniques difficult to generalize

Future Directions

1. Extension to Larger Graph Classes: Study the dominating Hadwiger's conjecture on other forbidden subgraph classes
2. Algorithmic Problems: Develop effective algorithms for finding dominating minors
3. Counterexample Construction: Search for counterexamples to the dominating Hadwiger's conjecture

In-Depth Evaluation

Strengths

1. Technical Innovation: The use of banner structures is highly clever, providing new insights for handling such problems
2. Proof Rigor: Nine key lemmas form a complete logical chain
3. Theoretical Significance: Provides important positive evidence for a significant conjecture
4. Clear Presentation: The structured proof is easy to understand and verify

Weaknesses

1. Limited Applicability: Applies only to specific graph classes, far from resolving the general case
2. Technical Specificity: Proof techniques are highly dependent on the structural properties of $2K_2$-free graphs
3. Lack of Algorithms: No constructive algorithms are provided

Impact

1. Theoretical Contribution: Provides important progress in research on the dominating Hadwiger's conjecture
2. Technical Value: Banner techniques may have applications in other structural graph theory problems
3. Inspirational Significance: Provides a model for studying difficult conjectures on specific graph classes

Applicable Scenarios

This result is primarily applicable to:

1. Theoretical research in structural graph theory
2. Analysis of graph coloring problems
3. Development of forbidden subgraph theory

References

Main references include:

1. Hadwiger (1943): Original Hadwiger's conjecture
2. Illingworth & Wood (2024): Introduction of the concept of dominating minors
3. Micu (2005): Proof of classical Hadwiger's conjecture on $2K_2$-free graphs
4. Strong Perfect Graph Theorem: Important result in perfect graph theory

Overall Assessment: This is a high-quality theoretical graph theory paper that completely resolves an important conjecture in a specific case. Although the scope of application is limited, the technical innovation is strong and lays the foundation for further research in this field.