2025-11-21T16:46:15.723465

Quantum thermodynamics of Gross-Pitaevskii qubits

Deffner
What are the resources that can be leveraged for a thermodynamic device to exhibit genuine quantum advantage? Typically, the answer to this question is sought in quantum correlations. In the present work, we show that quantum Otto engines that operate with nonlinear qubits significantly outperform linear engines. To this end, we develop a comprehensive thermodynamic description of nonlinear qubits starting with identifying the proper thermodynamic equilibrium state. We then show that for ideal cycles as well as at maximum power the efficiency of the nonlinear engine is significantly higher. Interestingly, nonlinear dynamics can be thought of as an effective description of a correlated, complex quantum many body system. Hence, our findings corroborate common wisdom, while at the same time propose a new design of more efficient quantum engines.
academic

Quantum thermodynamics of Gross-Pitaevskii qubits

Basic Information

  • Paper ID: 2510.12599
  • Title: Quantum thermodynamics of Gross-Pitaevskii qubits
  • Author: Sebastian Deffner (University of Maryland, Baltimore County)
  • Classification: cond-mat.stat-mech cond-mat.quant-gas quant-ph
  • Publication Date: October 14, 2025 (arXiv preprint)
  • Paper Link: https://arxiv.org/abs/2510.12599

Abstract

This paper investigates the resources required for quantum thermodynamic devices to achieve genuine quantum advantage. While conventional approaches seek answers in quantum correlations, this work demonstrates that quantum Otto engines employing nonlinear qubits significantly outperform their linear counterparts. The authors develop a comprehensive thermodynamic description of nonlinear qubits, beginning with the identification of appropriate thermodynamic equilibrium states, and prove that nonlinear engines exhibit substantially higher efficiency under both ideal cycles and maximum power conditions. Notably, nonlinear dynamics can be interpreted as an effective description of correlations in complex quantum many-body systems, thereby confirming conventional wisdom while proposing novel designs for more efficient quantum engines.

Research Background and Motivation

Core Problem

The fundamental question addressed in this paper is: What resources can be exploited to enable thermodynamic devices to exhibit genuine quantum advantage?

Research Significance

  1. Theoretical Importance: The dynamics of quantum mechanical systems are inherently linear, yet in complex quantum many-body systems, collective excitations are typically described effectively by nonlinear Schrödinger equations
  2. Practical Applications: Nonlinear quantum computing offers attractive possibilities for quantum information processing, enabling processes impossible in linear systems, such as perfect discrimination of non-orthogonal states or synchronization
  3. Technical Prospects: Provides novel insights for designing more efficient quantum engines

Limitations of Existing Approaches

  1. Conventional wisdom attributes quantum advantage primarily to quantum correlations
  2. Comprehensive thermodynamic descriptions of nonlinear qubits are lacking
  3. Systematic studies of nonlinear quantum engine performance are absent

Research Motivation

The authors begin from the Gross-Pitaevskii equation, which in spatial representation reads: iℏψ˙(x,t)=H(x,t)ψ(x,t)+κ∣ψ(x,t)∣2ψ(x,t)i\hbar \dot{\psi}(x,t) = H(x,t)\psi(x,t) + \kappa |\psi(x,t)|^2 \psi(x,t) where κ measures the "strength" of cooperative quantum effects, providing a physical foundation for the nonlinear term.

Core Contributions

  1. Established a comprehensive thermodynamic description of general nonlinear qubits, including proper identification of thermodynamic equilibrium states
  2. Demonstrated that nonlinear qubit engines outperform linear engines under both ideal cycles and maximum power conditions
  3. Discovered that nonlinear interactions increase internal energy and entropy, while reducing maximum heat capacity
  4. Proposed novel designs for more efficient quantum engines based on nonlinear qubits
  5. Established connections between nonlinear dynamics and correlations in complex quantum many-body systems

Detailed Methodology

Task Definition

Investigation of thermodynamic properties of nonlinear qubits as working media, particularly their performance in Otto cycles.

Theoretical Framework

1. General Nonlinear Qubits

Consider quantum dynamics described by the nonlinear Schrödinger equation: i∂t∣ψt⟩=Ht∣ψt⟩+K∣ψt⟩i \partial_t |\psi_t\rangle = H_t |\psi_t\rangle + K |\psi_t\rangle

where K describes the general form of the nonlinear term: ⟨x∣(K∣ψt⟩)=K(∣⟨x∣ψt⟩∣)⟨x∣ψt⟩\langle x|(K|\psi_t\rangle) = K(|\langle x|\psi_t\rangle|) \langle x|\psi_t\rangle

2. Bloch Representation

In the Bloch representation, the quantum state is: ρt=∣ψt⟩⟨ψt∣=12(I2+r⃗t⋅σ⃗)\rho_t = |\psi_t\rangle\langle\psi_t| = \frac{1}{2}(I_2 + \vec{r}_t \cdot \vec{\sigma})

where r⃗t=(xt,yt,zt)\vec{r}_t = (x_t, y_t, z_t) is the Bloch vector.

3. Equations of Motion

The nonlinear Schrödinger equation in Bloch representation becomes:

\dot{x}_t &= -[2\zeta + \tilde{\kappa}(z_t)]y_t + 2\xi z_t \\ \dot{y}_t &= [2\zeta + \tilde{\kappa}(z_t)]x_t - 2\chi z_t \\ \dot{z}_t &= -2\chi x_t + 2\xi y_t \end{align}$$ where $\tilde{\kappa}(z_t) = \kappa(\sqrt{(1+z_t)/2}) - \kappa(\sqrt{(1-z_t)/2})$. ### Thermodynamic Equilibrium States #### 1. Steady-State Conditions Steady-state solutions must satisfy: $$x = \frac{2\xi z}{2\zeta + \tilde{\kappa}(z)}, \quad y = \frac{2\chi z}{2\zeta + \tilde{\kappa}(z)}$$ #### 2. Bloch Vector Length $$|\vec{r}| = |z|\sqrt{1 + \frac{4(\xi^2 + \chi^2)}{[2\zeta + \tilde{\kappa}(z)]^2}}$$ #### 3. Canonical Equilibrium States Thermodynamic equilibrium is determined via variational methods: $$0 = \delta(S - \beta E) = \delta_z\left(\frac{\partial S}{\partial z} - \beta \frac{\partial E}{\partial z}\right)$$ ### Gross-Pitaevskii Qubits For Gross-Pitaevskii-type nonlinearity $\tilde{\kappa}(z) = gz$, the internal energy is: $$E_{GPE} = \frac{2B^2 + \zeta g z}{2\zeta + g z} z$$ The Bloch vector is: $$r_{GPE} = \frac{|z|}{|2\zeta + gz|}\sqrt{4B^2 + 4\zeta gz + g^2z^2}$$ ## Experimental Setup ### Parameter Configuration - Magnetic field parameters: $\xi = 1, \chi = 0, \zeta = 2$ - Temperature range: $\beta = 0.5$ to $\beta = 1$ - Nonlinearity strength: $g \in [-20, 5]$ - Otto cycle parameters: $\zeta_A = 1, \zeta_B = 1.5$ ### Evaluation Metrics 1. **Internal Energy Change**: $E_{GPE}$ vs $g$ 2. **Entropy Change**: von Neumann entropy $S = -\text{tr}\{\rho \ln \rho\}$ 3. **Heat Capacity**: $C = \partial E/\partial T$ 4. **Otto Cycle Efficiency**: $\eta = 1 - Q_{D\to A}/Q_{B\to C}$ 5. **Maximum Power Efficiency**: Efficiency under internally reversible cycles ## Experimental Results ### Main Findings #### 1. Thermodynamic Properties - **Internal Energy Increase**: Nonlinear interactions significantly increase system internal energy - **Entropy Increase**: Nonlinear effects lead to entropy increase, strengthening with increasing |g| - **Heat Capacity Reduction**: Maximum heat capacity decreases, though qualitative Schottky peak features are preserved #### 2. Ideal Otto Cycle Efficiency - Nonlinear engine efficiency substantially exceeds linear engines (g=0) - Repulsive nonlinearity (g<0) exhibits more pronounced effects - Efficiency saturates at large negative g values #### 3. Internally Reversible Otto Cycles For linear qubits, maximum power efficiency is: $$\eta = 1 - \sqrt{\frac{\beta_h}{\beta_c}}$$ exceeding the Curzon-Ahlborn efficiency. For weakly nonlinear cases (g ≪ 1), efficiency further improves: $$\Delta\eta = \eta_{GPE} - \eta_{linear} > 0$$ ### Numerical Results - Under parameters $\xi=1, \chi=0, \zeta_A=1, \zeta_B=1.5, \beta_A=1, \beta_D=0.5$ - Ideal cycle efficiency increases from approximately 0.25 (linear) to approximately 0.32 (g=-20) - Efficiency enhancement in internally reversible cycles peaks at moderate temperature ratios $\beta_h/\beta_c$ ## Related Work ### Nonlinear Quantum Mechanics 1. **Gross-Pitaevskii Equation**: Describes Bose-Einstein condensates 2. **Kolomeisky Equation**: Includes quintic nonlinear terms 3. **Nonlinear Dirac Equation**: Describes self-interacting fermions ### Nonlinear Quantum Computing 1. Perfect discrimination of non-orthogonal states 2. Quantum synchronization 3. Quantum speed limits 4. Quantum metrology ### Quantum Thermodynamics 1. Quantum Otto engines 2. Internally reversible thermodynamics 3. Curzon-Ahlborn efficiency ## Conclusions and Discussion ### Main Conclusions 1. **Nonlinear qubit engines significantly outperform linear engines**, with higher efficiency under both ideal cycles and maximum power conditions 2. **Nonlinear interactions constitute an effective resource** for enhancing thermodynamic performance 3. **Nonlinear dynamics provide effective descriptions of correlations in quantum many-body systems** ### Physical Mechanisms Nonlinear terms modify the system's energy level structure and thermodynamic properties, increasing available thermodynamic resources and thereby enhancing engine efficiency. ### Limitations 1. **Mathematical Complexity**: Most nonlinear cases require numerical solutions 2. **Parameter Sensitivity**: Effects are sensitive to parameter choices 3. **Experimental Implementation**: Requires specialized physical systems to realize nonlinear dynamics ### Future Directions 1. Explore other types of nonlinearity 2. Investigate nonlinear quantum refrigerators 3. Experimental verification of theoretical predictions 4. Applications to practical quantum device design ## In-Depth Evaluation ### Strengths 1. **Theoretical Completeness**: Provides a comprehensive theoretical framework for nonlinear qubit thermodynamics 2. **Mathematical Rigor**: Derivations proceed from first principles with mathematical precision 3. **Physical Insights**: Reveals the important role of nonlinearity as a resource for quantum advantage 4. **Practical Value**: Offers novel perspectives for quantum engine design ### Limitations 1. **Numerical Dependence**: Many results require numerical computation, lacking analytical expressions 2. **Lack of Experimental Verification**: Theoretical predictions await experimental confirmation 3. **Limited Scope**: Primarily addresses specific types of nonlinearity ### Impact 1. **Academic Contribution**: Provides new perspectives for quantum thermodynamics 2. **Technical Prospects**: May advance development of more efficient quantum devices 3. **Interdisciplinary Value**: Bridges quantum many-body physics and thermodynamics ### Application Scenarios 1. Bose-Einstein condensate systems 2. Nonlinear optical systems 3. Artificial quantum system design 4. Quantum heat engine optimization ## References The paper cites 64 relevant references spanning nonlinear quantum mechanics, quantum thermodynamics, Bose-Einstein condensation, and other important fields, providing a solid theoretical foundation for the research.