Possible Bose-Einstein condensation of magnons in a S = 5/2 honeycomb lattice

Basic Information

• Paper ID: 2510.12682
• Title: Possible Bose-Einstein condensation of magnons in a S = 5/2 honeycomb lattice
• Authors: J. Khatua, S. M. Kumawat, G. Senthil Murugan, C.-L. Huang, Heung-Sik Kim, K. Sritharan, R. Sankar, Kwang-Yong Choi
• Classification: cond-mat.str-el (Strongly Correlated Electron Systems)
• Publication Date: October 15, 2025
• Paper Link: https://arxiv.org/abs/2510.12682

Abstract

Quantum magnets provide a unique platform for exploring exotic quantum phases and quantum phase transitions through external magnetic fields. A prominent example is field-induced Bose-Einstein condensation (BEC) of magnons near saturation field. While this behavior has been observed in low-spin systems, its realization in high-spin, quasi-two-dimensional magnets—where multiple site excitations may exist—remains extremely rare. This paper reports thermodynamic and density functional theory results for single crystals of the honeycomb lattice antiferromagnet K₄MnMo₄O₁₅ (S = 5/2). The system undergoes a field-induced transition to a fully polarized state at critical field μ₀Hs = 6.4 T. The results reveal possible thermodynamic signatures of magnon BEC with TN ∼ (Hs - H)^(2/d) (d = 3), extending BEC-driven quantum criticality to high-spin quasi-two-dimensional antiferromagnets with negligible anisotropy.

Research Background and Motivation

Research Questions

This study aims to explore the Bose-Einstein condensation phenomenon of magnons in high-spin quasi-two-dimensional magnetic systems, particularly in the S = 5/2 honeycomb lattice antiferromagnet K₄MnMo₄O₁₅ (KMMO).

Significance of the Problem

1. Theoretical Significance: Magnon BEC represents an important phenomenon in quantum many-body physics, providing an ideal platform for understanding quantum criticality
2. Dimensional Effects: In two-dimensional systems, the finite density of states at zero energy traditionally precludes BEC realization, with Berezinskii-Kosterlitz-Thouless transitions expected instead
3. Spin Quantum Number Effects: High-spin systems (S > 1) possess multiple internal spin energy levels, allowing richer excitation pathways and potentially more complex BEC forms

Limitations of Existing Approaches

1. Low-Spin Systems: Previous BEC studies have primarily focused on low-spin systems, such as S = 1/2 or S = 1
2. Three-Dimensional Systems: Most research has concentrated on triplon BEC in three-dimensional dimerized antiferromagnets
3. Strong Anisotropy Requirements: BEC in quasi-two-dimensional systems typically requires strong magnetic anisotropy

Research Motivation

To explore the possibility of realizing magnon BEC in high-spin quasi-two-dimensional honeycomb lattice systems with negligible anisotropy, thereby extending the scope of BEC-driven quantum criticality research.

Core Contributions

1. First Report: Observation of thermodynamic signatures of magnon BEC in S = 5/2 honeycomb lattice antiferromagnet
2. Critical Scaling Behavior: Confirmation of scaling relation TN ∝ (Hs - H)^0.60±0.01, consistent with three-dimensional BEC universality class
3. Phase Diagram Construction: Establishment of complete temperature-magnetic field phase diagram, revealing crossover from Heisenberg to XY-type ordering
4. Theoretical Calculation Support: DFT calculations determining exchange interaction parameters, supporting experimental observations
5. Extension of BEC Field: Extension of BEC phenomena to high-spin quasi-two-dimensional systems, enriching the research scope of quantum magnets

Detailed Methodology

Experimental Methods

Sample Preparation

1. Polycrystalline Samples: Prepared using standard solid-state reaction method with high-purity K₂CO₃, MnO, and MoO₃ precursors
2. Single Crystal Growth: Deep blue single crystals of approximately 5×2×2 mm³ grown via slow cooling method
3. Structural Characterization: Crystal structure confirmed using powder X-ray diffraction

Measurement Techniques

1. Magnetic Measurements: SQUID-VSM magnetometer, temperature range 2-300 K, magnetic field up to 7 T
2. Heat Capacity Measurements: PPMS physical property measurement system, temperature range 0.13-300 K, magnetic field up to 9 T
3. Ultra-Low Temperature Measurements: ³He option for extremely low-temperature magnetization measurements

Theoretical Calculations

DFT Calculations

1. Computational Method: OpenMX code with PBE functional
2. Parameter Settings: Plane-wave cutoff energy 300 Ry, k-point mesh 4×4×6
3. Correlation Effects: Hubbard U parameter applied to account for strong electron correlations on Mn atoms

Exchange Interactions

Exchange coupling parameters calculated using JX code based on Liechtenstein method's Green's function formula.

Experimental Setup

Crystal Structure

• Space Group: Trigonal P-3
• Lattice Parameters: a = b = 10.37 Å, c = 8.16 Å
• Magnetic Structure: Mn²⁺ ions form honeycomb lattice perpendicular to c-axis
• Coordination Environment: Mn²⁺ ions octahedrally coordinated by six O²⁻ ions

Measurement Conditions

• Magnetic Field Direction: Perpendicular to ab-plane (honeycomb plane)
• Temperature Range: 0.13 K - 300 K
• Magnetic Field Range: 0 - 9 T

Analysis Methods

1. Curie-Weiss Fitting: Determination of effective magnetic moment and Weiss temperature
2. Debye-Einstein Model: Separation of lattice contribution to heat capacity
3. Critical Scaling Analysis: Investigation of power-law behavior near phase transition

Experimental Results

Basic Magnetic Properties

1. Magnetic Susceptibility:
   • Effective magnetic moment μeff = 6.13 μB (theoretical value 5.91 μB)
   • Weiss temperature θCW = -9 K, indicating antiferromagnetic interactions
   • Broad peak at 4.2 K indicating short-range correlations
2. Long-Range Magnetic Ordering:
   • Néel temperature TN = 2.21 K
   • λ-type anomaly observed in heat capacity
   • Magnetic entropy release approximately 91% of theoretical value

Exchange Interaction Parameters

From DFT calculations (U = 7 eV):

• J₁ = 1.038 K (in-plane nearest-neighbor antiferromagnetic)
• J₂ = -0.073 K (inter-layer ferromagnetic)
• J₃ = 0.0165 K (in-plane next-nearest-neighbor antiferromagnetic)

Field-Induced Phase Transition

1. Critical Magnetic Field: μ₀Hs = 6.4 T
2. Saturation Magnetization: Approaches 5 μB/f.u.
3. Gap Behavior: Linear gap Δ ∝ (H - Hs) observed in fully polarized phase

Phase Diagram Features

1. Heisenberg-XY Crossover: TN initially increases then decreases with decreasing field
2. Short-Range Correlation Region: Extensive short-range correlations exist above TN
3. Fully Polarized Phase: Gapped polarized phase forms above Hs

Critical Scaling Behavior

1. Temperature Scaling: TN ∝ (Hs - H)^0.60±0.01, consistent with expected 2/3 exponent for three-dimensional BEC
2. Heat Capacity Scaling: Cmag ∝ T^1.45±0.02, approaching T^3/2 behavior of three-dimensional systems
3. BEC Signatures: These scaling relations strongly support realization of magnon BEC

Related Work

Historical Development

1. Three-Dimensional Systems: Triplon BEC in three-dimensional dimerized antiferromagnets such as TlCuCl₃ and BaCuSi₂O₆
2. Quasi-Two-Dimensional Systems:
   • Bound state of two magnons BEC in Na₂BaNi(PO₄)₂
   • Magnon BEC in YbCl₃ (Jeff = 1/2)
3. High-Spin Systems: Double BEC dome in Ba₂Co₁₋ₓZnₓGe₂O₇

Theoretical Framework

1. Universality: TN ∝ (Hs - H)^α, with universal exponent α = 2/3
2. Dimensional Effects: BKT transition vs. three-dimensional BEC in two-dimensional systems
3. Anisotropy Effects: Impact of easy-axis anisotropy on BEC

Uniqueness of This Work

Compared to existing work, this study is the first to observe three-dimensional BEC behavior in a high-spin (S = 5/2) quasi-two-dimensional honeycomb lattice system with negligible magnetic anisotropy.

Conclusions and Discussion

Main Conclusions

1. BEC Realization: K₄MnMo₄O₁₅ possibly realizes magnon BEC at critical field 6.4 T
2. Three-Dimensional Behavior: Despite being quasi-two-dimensional, exhibits critical exponents of three-dimensional BEC
3. High-Spin Effects: Demonstrates feasibility of BEC in high-spin systems
4. Anisotropy: Weak anisotropy of the system does not impede BEC formation

Physical Mechanism

1. Dimensional Crossover: Weak inter-layer coupling causes system to behave three-dimensionally at low temperatures
2. Spin Reduction: External magnetic field suppresses out-of-plane spin fluctuations, leading to XY behavior
3. Quantum Fluctuations: Rich quantum states in high-spin systems enhance magnon interactions

Limitations

1. Confirmation Needed: More low-temperature experiments required to definitively confirm BEC behavior
2. Magnetic Field Range: Limited magnetic field range restricts precise determination of saturation magnetization
3. Microscopic Evidence: Lack of direct evidence from microscopic probes such as neutron scattering

Future Directions

1. High-Frequency ESR: Detection of magnon bound states near saturation field
2. Neutron Scattering: Direct observation of magnon dispersion and condensation
3. Theoretical Models: Development of BEC theory for high-spin quasi-two-dimensional systems
4. Material Exploration: Search for additional high-spin BEC candidate materials

In-Depth Evaluation

Strengths

1. Strong Innovation: First report of BEC phenomena in high-spin honeycomb lattice system
2. Comprehensive Experiments: Combination of multiple thermodynamic measurements including magnetization and heat capacity
3. Theoretical Support: DFT calculations well support experimental observations
4. Detailed Analysis: Thorough critical scaling analysis provides compelling evidence
5. Clear Presentation: Well-structured paper with clear exposition

Weaknesses

1. Indirect Evidence: Primarily based on thermodynamic measurements, lacking direct microscopic evidence
2. Temperature Limitation: Minimum measurement temperature (0.13 K) may be insufficient
3. Theoretical Analysis: Relatively simple theoretical analysis of BEC mechanism
4. Limited Comparison: Limited comparison with other high-spin systems

Impact

1. Academic Value: Extends material scope and theoretical framework of BEC research
2. Application Prospects: Provides guidance for designing novel quantum magnetic materials
3. Methodological Contribution: Provides exemplar for studying quasi-two-dimensional magnetic systems
4. Interdisciplinary: Connects condensed matter physics and quantum many-body theory

Applicable Scenarios

1. Basic Research: Investigation of quantum magnets and quantum phase transitions
2. Material Design: Discovery and design of new BEC materials
3. Theory Development: Development of quantum many-body theory for high-spin systems
4. Technical Applications: Potential applications in quantum information and quantum computing

References

The paper cites 45 important references covering BEC theory, experimental methods, and related materials, providing solid theoretical foundation and experimental comparison for the research.

Overall Assessment: This is a high-quality condensed matter physics research paper. The discovery of BEC phenomena in high-spin quasi-two-dimensional magnetic systems has important scientific significance. The experimental design is sound, data analysis is comprehensive, and conclusions are credible. While further experimental verification is needed, this work makes important contributions to the field's development.