Tunable quantum Mpemba effect in long-range interacting systems

Basic Information

• Paper ID: 2510.12875
• Title: Tunable quantum Mpemba effect in long-range interacting systems
• Authors: Andrew Hallam, Matthew Yusuf, Aashish A. Clerk, Ivar Martin, Zlatko Papić
• Classification: quant-ph cond-mat.stat-mech cond-mat.str-el
• Publication Date: October 16, 2025
• Paper Link: https://arxiv.org/abs/2510.12875

Abstract

This paper investigates the tunability of the quantum Mpemba effect (QME) in a one-dimensional spin-1/2 XYZ model with power-law decaying long-range interactions in a magnetic field. Within the prethermalization regime generated by strong magnetic field strengths, the system develops an emergent continuous U(1) symmetry, enabling the appearance of QME. However, due to the Hohenberg-Mermin-Wagner theorem, QME can only occur when interactions are sufficiently short-ranged. This leads to intricate interplay between the external magnetic field, interaction range, and dynamical symmetry restoration. The study systematically explores this interplay and analyzes the dependence of QME on the effective temperature of the initial state.

Research Background and Motivation

Core Issues

1. Tunability of quantum Mpemba effect: While traditional research focuses on the existence of QME, this work explores how to control the emergence and disappearance of QME through parameter tuning.
2. Effects of long-range interactions: Long-range interactions play important roles in quantum many-body systems, yet their mechanisms of influence on QME remain unclear.
3. Dynamics of symmetry breaking and restoration: QME is fundamentally related to dynamical symmetry restoration, requiring understanding of how symmetry breaking affects this process.

Research Significance

• Theoretical importance: Connects fundamental theories including non-equilibrium quantum dynamics, symmetry breaking, and the Hohenberg-Mermin-Wagner theorem
• Experimental relevance: Can be implemented on experimental platforms such as trapped ions, polar molecules, and NV centers
• Application prospects: Provides new insights for thermalization control in quantum simulation and quantum computing

Limitations of Existing Approaches

• Most research focuses on short-range interaction systems
• Lack of systematic investigation of QME tunability
• Insufficient understanding of how long-range interactions affect symmetry restoration

Core Contributions

1. Established a dynamic phase diagram for QME: By tuning magnetic field strength and interaction range, the paper maps out a complete phase diagram showing where QME appears and disappears.
2. Revealed the suppression mechanism of long-range interactions on QME: Demonstrated that long-range interactions prevent QME by promoting spontaneous symmetry breaking.
3. Discovered the critical role of initial state energy density: Showed that the critical interaction range for QME strongly depends on the effective temperature of the initial state.
4. Provided experimentally feasible control schemes: Achieved dynamic control of U(1) symmetry through prethermalization mechanisms.

Methodology Details

Task Definition

Study the emergence conditions of QME in one-dimensional long-range XYZ spin chains, with inputs being Hamiltonian parameters (magnetic field strength $h_z$, interaction range $\alpha$, coupling constants $J_{\nu}$) and initial states, and outputs being the time evolution of entanglement asymmetry and Mpemba time $\tau_M$.

Model Architecture

Hamiltonian Design

The system Hamiltonian is: $\hat{H} = \frac{1}{N}\sum_{i<j}\sum_{\nu\in\{x,y,z\}} \frac{J_\nu}{|i-j|^\alpha}\hat{\sigma}^\nu_i\hat{\sigma}^\nu_j + h_z\sum_i\hat{\sigma}^z_i$

where $\alpha$ controls the interaction range, with Kac normalization ensuring extensivity of energy density.

Prethermalization Effective Theory

In the large magnetic field limit ($h_z \gg J$), the system can be described by an effective XXZ Hamiltonian: $\hat{H}_{\text{eff}} = \frac{1}{N}\sum_{i<j}\left[\frac{J_x+J_y}{2}\left(\frac{\hat{\sigma}^x_i\hat{\sigma}^x_j + \hat{\sigma}^y_i\hat{\sigma}^y_j}{|i-j|^\alpha}\right) + J_z\frac{\hat{\sigma}^z_i\hat{\sigma}^z_j}{|i-j|^\alpha}\right] + h_z\hat{Z}$

This effective theory possesses U(1) symmetry, providing the foundation for QME emergence.

Technical Innovations

Entanglement Asymmetry Diagnostics

Uses entanglement asymmetry $\Delta S_A$ as a diagnostic tool for QME: $\Delta S_A = S(\hat{\rho}_{A,Q}) - S(\hat{\rho}_A)$

where $\hat{\rho}_{A,Q} = \sum_q \hat{\Pi}_q\hat{\rho}_A\hat{\Pi}_q$ is the symmetrized reduced density matrix.

Infinite System Time Evolution

Employs translation-invariant infinite matrix product states (iMPS) and time-dependent variational principle (TDVP) to directly perform time evolution in the thermodynamic limit, avoiding finite-size effects.

Efficient Treatment of Long-Range Interactions

Fits power-law interactions as a sum of exponentials: $f(n) = \sum_{k=1}^K a_k e^{b_k n}$, reducing the MPO bond dimension from infinity to $2+3K$.

Experimental Setup

Initial State Design

Considers two types of experimentally preparable initial states:

1. Tilted product states: $|\psi(t=0,\theta)\rangle = \bigotimes_j \exp(i\theta\hat{\sigma}^y_j)|↑\rangle_j$
2. Tilted Néel states: $|\phi(t=0,\phi)\rangle = \bigotimes_i (|↑\rangle_{2i-1} \otimes [\cos\phi|↑\rangle_{2i} - \sin\phi|↓\rangle_{2i}])$

Evaluation Metrics

• Entanglement asymmetry ratio: Time evolution of $\Delta S_A^{\theta_1}/\Delta S_A^{\theta_2}$
• Mpemba time: Time $\tau_M$ when the ratio first drops below 1
• Spontaneous symmetry breaking boundary: Determined through effective central charge $c_{\text{eff}}$ and entanglement spectrum

Comparison Methods

• Comparison across different $\alpha$ values for interaction range
• Prethermalization analysis at different magnetic field strengths $h_z$
• Finite-size scaling analysis comparing finite and infinite systems

Implementation Details

• iMPS bond dimension: $\chi = 128$
• Time step: $\delta t = 0.025$
• Number of exponential fitting terms: $K = 8$
• DMRG maximum bond dimension: $\chi = 250$

Experimental Results

Main Findings

Magnetic Field Control of QME

For $\alpha = 4$ (short-range), as $h_z$ increases, the system transitions from a non-QME state to one with pronounced QME. The entanglement asymmetry ratio becomes significantly below 1 at large magnetic fields, indicating QME emergence.

For $\alpha = 1.5$ (long-range), no QME is observed even at large magnetic fields, with the ratio remaining above 1.

Critical Effects of Interaction Range

For fixed $J_z = -0.75$, a critical value $\alpha_M \approx 2.5$ is found, below which QME is completely suppressed.

Simultaneously, the critical value for spontaneous symmetry breaking is determined as $\alpha_c \approx 3.2$, satisfying $\alpha_M < \alpha_c$, indicating that SSB sets an upper bound for QME.

Effects of Energy Density

Comparing tilted product states ($\epsilon \sim 0.03$) and tilted Néel states ($\epsilon \sim 0.3$) reveals that higher energy density states have smaller $\alpha_M$ values, i.e., are more easily suppressed by long-range interactions.

Ablation Studies

SU(2) Symmetry Point Analysis

At the Heisenberg point $J_x = J_y = J_z = -1$, QME persists for all $\alpha$ values because this point lacks SU(2) spontaneous symmetry breaking.

Trace Distance Verification

Uses trace distance as an alternative diagnostic tool, verifying results consistent with entanglement asymmetry in finite systems.

Experimental Observations

1. Robustness of prethermalization: When $h_z \gtrsim 2J$, prethermalization description remains valid for both short-range and long-range interactions
2. Continuous time crystal features: Persistent oscillations of order parameters are observed in the prethermalization regime, characteristic of continuous time crystals
3. Universality of phase diagram: The dynamic phase diagram maintains consistent structure across different types of initial state combinations

Related Work

Current State of QME Research

• Integrable systems: Rylands et al. explain QME mechanisms through quasiparticle pictures
• Random circuits: QME observed in Floquet systems and random quantum circuits
• Open systems: Carollo et al. discover exponentially accelerated QME in Markovian open systems

Long-Range Interaction Systems

• Phase transition theory: Maghrebi et al. establish theory of continuous symmetry breaking in 1D long-range systems
• Experimental realization: Chen et al. and Feng et al. observe continuous symmetry breaking in Rydberg atom arrays and trapped ions

Novelty of This Work

Compared to existing work, this paper is the first to systematically investigate the control of QME by long-range interactions and establish a complete dynamic phase diagram.

Conclusions and Discussion

Main Conclusions

1. Tunability of QME: By adjusting magnetic field strength and interaction range, one can precisely control the emergence and disappearance of QME.
2. Critical role of HMW theorem: The Hohenberg-Mermin-Wagner theorem, by forbidding continuous symmetry breaking in long-range systems, provides necessary conditions for QME existence.
3. Initial state dependence: The critical parameters for QME strongly depend on the energy density of the initial state, with high-temperature states more easily suppressed by long-range interactions.
4. Experimental feasibility: The proposed control schemes can be implemented on existing quantum simulation platforms.

Limitations

1. Prethermalization time constraints: The effective theory is valid only within exponentially long prethermalization times, limiting the observation window.
2. Specific initial states: Research primarily focuses on product and Néel states; universality for other initial state types requires further verification.
3. One-dimensional restriction: Results primarily apply to one-dimensional systems; higher-dimensional generalizations require additional considerations.

Future Directions

1. Higher-dimensional extensions: Study similar phenomena in two-dimensional long-range Heisenberg models
2. Floquet driving: Explore QME control mechanisms under periodic driving
3. Experimental verification: Implement and verify theoretical predictions on trapped ion and polar molecule platforms
4. Non-abelian symmetries: Extend to non-abelian symmetries such as SU(N)

In-Depth Evaluation

Strengths

1. Theoretical depth: Cleverly connects QME, symmetry breaking, and the HMW theorem, providing profound physical insights.
2. Methodological innovation: Uses iMPS to directly study dynamics in the thermodynamic limit, avoiding finite-size effects.
3. Systematic investigation: Establishes a complete dynamic phase diagram, systematically exploring parameter space.
4. Experimental relevance: The considered initial states and parameter ranges have strong experimental feasibility.

Weaknesses

1. Numerical precision: Exponential fitting of long-range interactions may introduce systematic errors.
2. Phase boundary determination: SSB phase boundary determination depends on threshold choices for central charge deviation, introducing some subjectivity.
3. Mechanism explanation: Microscopic mechanisms explaining QME persistence in the $\alpha_M < \alpha_c$ region are insufficiently explained.

Impact

1. Theoretical contribution: Provides a new framework for understanding symmetry dynamics in non-equilibrium quantum many-body systems.
2. Experimental guidance: Provides theoretical guidance for designing QME control schemes in quantum simulation experiments.
3. Cross-disciplinary impact: Connects condensed matter physics, quantum information, and statistical physics.

Applicable Scenarios

1. Quantum simulation: QME experiments on trapped ions, polar molecules, Rydberg atoms, and other platforms
2. Quantum computing: Thermalization control in quantum annealing and adiabatic quantum computing
3. Fundamental research: Study of symmetry dynamics in non-equilibrium quantum many-body systems

References

This paper cites 117 important references covering recent advances in key areas including QME, long-range interactions, and symmetry breaking, providing a solid theoretical foundation for the research.

Overall Assessment: This is an excellent paper with significant theoretical value and experimental guidance. Through systematic theoretical analysis and numerical simulation, it deeply reveals the control mechanisms of long-range interactions on the quantum Mpemba effect, making important contributions to the development of this field.