Dark Matter-Electron Interactions Alter the Luminosity and Spectral Index of M87

Basic Information

• Paper ID: 2510.12877
• Title: Dark Matter-Electron Interactions Alter the Luminosity and Spectral Index of M87
• Authors: Abdelaziz Hussein (MIT), Gonzalo Herrera (MIT, Harvard, Virginia Tech)
• Classification: hep-ph astro-ph.CO astro-ph.HE
• Publishing Institution: FERMILAB-PUB-25-0729-T
• Paper Link: https://arxiv.org/abs/2510.12877v1

Abstract

This paper investigates whether cosmic ray electron cooling induced by dark matter-electron scattering can explain the low radiative efficiency phenomenon observed in radio-active galaxies (such as M87). Light dark matter can effectively scatter with electrons in M87, reducing the observed thermal luminosity relative to astrophysical predictions. This consideration enables exploration of previously unexplored regions in the dark matter-electron interaction parameter space. The study further models the cosmic ray electron distribution by numerically solving the diffusion equation along the jet, finding that effective dark matter-electron interactions can cause spectral index flattening at different distances from the central supermassive black hole, achieving better consistency with M87's radio observations.

Research Background and Motivation

Core Problems

1. Silent Black Hole Problem: The observed thermal luminosity is many orders of magnitude lower than the Eddington luminosity, an open question in galactic astrophysics
2. Limitations of Traditional Models: Existing accretion models (such as ADAF) and GRMHD simulations face difficulties in explaining observed fluxes and spectral index distributions
3. Model Simplification Assumptions: GRMHD simulations typically assume thermal Maxwell-Juttner distributions, neglecting non-thermal effects such as magnetic reconnection and turbulent dissipation

Research Motivation

• Explore the potential impact of dark matter particles on black hole observations
• Utilize the dark matter spike structure near supermassive black holes
• Develop new dark matter detection methods, particularly for sub-GeV mass regions
• Address velocity suppression issues in direct detection experiments (relativistic electrons vs. non-relativistic dark matter)

Core Contributions

1. Propose a New Dark Matter Detection Mechanism: Utilize cosmic ray electron cooling induced by dark matter-electron scattering in M87 to constrain dark matter parameters
2. Establish Luminosity-Cooling Timescale Relationship: Establish quantitative constraint relationships by correlating observed low thermal luminosity with dark matter cooling effects
3. Develop Spectral Index Modeling Method: Numerically solve the diffusion equation to predict the impact of dark matter interactions on jet spectral indices
4. Obtain Competitive Constraints: Surpass existing direct detection experimental constraints in certain parameter regions
5. Explore Unconstrained Parameter Space: Particularly for velocity-suppressed regions of Majorana dark matter

Methodology Details

Dark Matter Model

Employ an extended Standard Model containing an additional U(1)' gauge symmetry:

$L = -\frac{1}{4}F_{\mu\nu}F^{\mu\nu} - \frac{1}{4}F'_{\mu\nu}F'^{\mu\nu} - \frac{\epsilon}{2}F_{\mu\nu}F'^{\mu\nu} + \frac{m_{A'}^2}{2}A'_\mu A'^{\mu} + A'_\mu g_\chi \bar{\chi}\gamma^\mu\chi$

where $A'$ is the dark photon, $\epsilon$ is the kinetic mixing parameter, and $g_\chi$ is the dark matter coupling strength.

Scattering Cross Section Calculation

The differential cross section for dark matter-electron scattering is:

$\frac{d\sigma}{dT_\chi} = \frac{\epsilon^2 e^2 g_\chi^2}{4\pi (E_e^2 - m_e^2)(m_{A'}^2 + 2m_\chi T_\chi)^2} \times [2E_e^2 m_\chi - (m_e^2 + m_\chi(2E_e + m_\chi))T_\chi + m_\chi T_\chi^2]$

Cooling Timescale Analysis

Synchrotron Cooling Timescale: $\tau_{syn} = \left[\frac{4c\sigma_T}{3E_e}\frac{B^2}{8\pi}\gamma_e\beta_e^2\right]^{-1}$

Dark Matter-Electron Scattering Cooling Timescale: $\tau_{\chi e} = \left[-\frac{1}{E_e}\left(\frac{dE_e}{dt}\right)_{\chi e}\right]^{-1}$

where: $\left(\frac{dE_e}{dt}\right)_{\chi e} = -\frac{\rho_{DM}}{m_\chi}\int_0^{T_{\chi}^{max}} dT_\chi T_\chi \frac{d\sigma_{\chi e}}{dT_\chi}$

Luminosity Constraint Relationship

Based on the principle that dark matter cooling cannot reduce luminosity below observed values: $\log\left(\frac{L_{bol}}{L_{edd}}\right) = -\frac{\tau_{sync}}{\tau_{\chi e}} \approx -9$

Parameters are considered excluded when $\tau_{sync}/\tau_{\chi e} \geq 10$.

Spectral Index Modeling

Solve the diffusion equation: $\frac{dN(\gamma,\tau)}{d\tau} = Q(\gamma,\tau) - 3b_{adi}N(\gamma,\tau) - \frac{\partial b(\gamma,\tau)}{\partial\gamma}N(\gamma,\tau)$

where the total energy loss rate is: $b = b_{SM} + b_{DM} = -b_{adi}\gamma - b_{sync}\gamma^2 + \frac{1}{m_e}\left(\frac{dE}{dt}\right)_{\chi e}$

Experimental Setup

Dark Matter Density Distribution

Employ a dark matter spike formed by adiabatic growth of the supermassive black hole: $\rho_{DM}(r) = \rho_R g_\gamma(r)\left(\frac{R_{sp}}{r}\right)^{\gamma_{sp}}$

For M87: $R_{sp} \approx 4 \times 10^5 R_s$, $\gamma_{sp} = 7/3$

Magnetic Field Parameters

Consider two representative values:

• Conservative Estimate: $\langle B_{VLBI}\rangle = 7G$ (based on average VLBI measurements)
• Aggressive Estimate: $B_{MAGIC} = 0.003G$ (based on MAGIC telescope SED fitting)

Observational Data

• Thermal Luminosity: $L_{bol} \sim 10^{42}$ erg/s
• Eddington Luminosity: $L_{edd} \approx 8.45 \times 10^{47}$ erg/s
• Spectral Index Observations: From KaVA and VLBA observations at 22 GHz and 43 GHz

Experimental Results

Main Constraint Results

Dark Photon Parameter Space Constraints:

• For $m_\chi = 15$ eV: Constrain $\epsilon \gtrsim 10^{-12}$ in the $m_{A'} \sim 10^{-6}$ eV region
• For $m_\chi = 15$ keV: Stricter constraints covering larger parameter space

DM-Electron Scattering Cross Section Constraints:

• Dirac Dark Matter: Surpass direct detection constraints when $m_\chi \leq 6$ MeV
• Majorana Dark Matter: More significant constraints due to velocity suppression
• Using $B_{MAGIC}$, constraints are 2-4 orders of magnitude stronger than future direct detection experiments

Spectral Index Predictions

Dark matter interactions lead to spectral index flattening:

• $m_\chi = 100$ MeV, $m_{A'} = 150$ GeV: No significant effect
• $m_\chi = 10$ MeV, $m_{A'} = 30$ GeV: Predictions consistent with observations within 1σ range
• Lighter dark matter masses lead to over-flattening, inconsistent with observations

Comparison with Other Constraints

• BBN Constraints: $m_\chi \gtrsim 10$ MeV (from effective relativistic degrees of freedom measurements)
• Direct Detection: DAMIC-M ($m_\chi \lesssim 20$ MeV), PandaX-4T (20-200 MeV), CRESST-III ($>200$ MeV)
• Thermal Relic Abundance: Covers portions of thermally-produced dark matter parameter space

Related Work

Dark Matter Spike Research

• Gondolo & Silk (1999): First proposed the concept of dark matter spikes near supermassive black holes
• Subsequent studies considered effects of self-annihilation, stellar heating, and mergers on spike structure

Dark Matter-Electron Interactions

• Recent studies (Herrera & Murase 2024, etc.): Utilize cosmic ray cooling in AGN to constrain dark matter
• This work extends to luminosity constraints and spectral index modeling

Direct Detection Development

• Recent breakthroughs by DAMIC-M and PandaX-4T in sub-GeV dark matter detection
• This method circumvents velocity suppression issues in laboratory experiments

Conclusions and Discussion

Main Conclusions

1. New Constraint Method: M87's low luminosity can serve as a new tool for constraining dark matter-electron interactions
2. Parameter Space Exploration: Provides stronger constraints than direct detection in certain regions
3. Spectral Index Diagnostics: First proposal to utilize spectral index observations at different distances to constrain dark matter interactions
4. Model Verification: Certain dark matter parameter configurations better explain M87's radio observations

Limitations

1. Magnetic Field Uncertainty: Constraint strength highly depends on magnetic field strength assumptions (varying by 3-4 orders of magnitude)
2. Dark Matter Density Distribution: Spike structure may be disrupted by astrophysical processes
3. Standard Model Process Understanding: Spectral index constraints depend on accurate modeling of electron acceleration mechanisms
4. Single Source Limitation: Based solely on M87; extension to larger AGN samples needed

Future Directions

1. AGN Sample Extension: Apply framework to more radio-active galaxies
2. Multi-Wavelength Observations: Combine simultaneous observations at different wavelengths to distinguish dark matter effects from conventional astrophysical processes
3. Density Distribution Determination: Develop particle-independent methods to determine dark matter density distribution
4. Theoretical Improvements: Improve understanding of standard model processes through particle-in-cell simulations

In-Depth Evaluation

Strengths

1. High Originality: First to connect AGN luminosity suppression with dark matter interactions, opening new detection pathways
2. Complete Methodology: Forms comprehensive analytical framework from theoretical modeling to numerical computation
3. Practical Value: Provides currently strongest constraints in certain parameter regions, particularly for Majorana dark matter
4. Observation-Oriented: Closely integrates multi-frequency observational data from M87
5. Technical Rigor: Considers relativistic effects, magnetic field distribution, dark matter density distribution and other critical factors

Shortcomings

1. Large Systematic Uncertainties: Uncertainties in magnetic field and dark matter density lead to wide constraint ranges
2. Model Dependence: Results strongly depend on specific dark matter models and astrophysical assumptions
3. Verification Difficulty: Hard to independently verify dark matter cooling hypothesis; model degeneracies exist
4. Limited Applicability: Method primarily applicable to AGN with strong jets, limiting universality

Impact

1. Interdisciplinary Bridging: Connects particle physics and astrophysics, promoting cross-disciplinary research
2. Methodological Contribution: Provides new perspectives for dark matter indirect detection
3. Observational Incentive: May stimulate more precise observations of AGN jets
4. Theoretical Development: Advances theoretical understanding of AGN physics and dark matter interactions

Application Scenarios

1. Sub-GeV Dark Matter Research: Particularly suitable for exploring light dark matter where direct detection is challenging
2. Majorana Dark Matter: Circumvents velocity suppression, providing effective constraint means
3. Radio Astronomy: Provides new physical interpretation framework for radio observations
4. Multi-Messenger Astrophysics: Studies dark matter properties combining different observational methods

References

This paper cites 79 relevant references spanning multiple fields including dark matter theory, AGN physics, and direct detection experiments. Key references include Gondolo & Silk (1999) on pioneering dark matter spike work and recent results from DAMIC-M and PandaX-4T experiments.