Module lattices and their shortest vectors

Basic Information

• Paper ID: 2510.12893
• Title: Module lattices and their shortest vectors
• Authors: Nihar Gargava, Vlad Serban, Maryna Viazovska, Ilaria Viglino
• Classification: math.NT (Number Theory), cs.IT (Information Theory), math.IT (Mathematical Information Theory)
• Publication Date: October 14, 2025 (arXiv preprint)
• Paper Link: https://arxiv.org/abs/2510.12893

Abstract

This paper investigates the length of shortest vectors in module lattices over arbitrary number fields, with particular focus on cyclotomic fields. The authors improve upon techniques from prior work arXiv:2308.15275v2, establishing better results for the variance of the number of lattice vectors with bounded Euclidean norm in random module lattices. Subsequently, they derive tight probabilistic bounds for the length of shortest vectors under several random module lattice models.

Research Background and Motivation

Problem Context

1. Core Problem in Lattice-Based Cryptography: The Shortest Vector Problem (SVP) is fundamental to lattice-based cryptography, and its hardness underpins the security of numerous post-quantum cryptographic systems.
2. Importance of Module Lattices: Since the introduction of the NTRU cryptosystem, module lattices with algebraic structure have attracted significant attention due to their efficiency advantages over unstructured lattices, and now form the basis of multiple NIST post-quantum standards.
3. Theoretical Gap: While Theorem 1 provides precise asymptotic behavior for shortest vectors in general random lattices, analogous results for module lattices with additional algebraic structure have been lacking.

Research Motivation

1. Security Assessment Requirements: Understanding the hardness of computational problems on module lattices in the face of quantum threats.
2. Theoretical Completeness: Filling gaps in module lattice theory regarding probabilistic behavior of shortest vectors.
3. Practical Value: Providing theoretical support and security analysis tools for module lattice-based cryptographic systems.

Core Contributions

1. Improved Moment Estimates: Reduces the minimum rank condition from t ≥ 27 to t ≥ 11 in prior work through more refined treatment of contributions from algebraic numbers with low Weil height.
2. Unified Results for Cyclotomic Fields: Establishes asymptotic behavior of shortest vectors in module lattices over cyclotomic fields (Theorem 3), analogous to classical results for unstructured lattices.
3. Practical Probabilistic Bounds: Provides computable explicit probabilistic bounds applicable to concrete number fields and ranks in current implementations.
4. Improved Technical Methods: Develops refined techniques for handling additional symmetries in module lattices (unit group action), with particular optimization for the cyclotomic case.

Detailed Methodology

Problem Definition

Study the probability distribution of the shortest nonzero vector λ₁(Λ) in random module lattices Λ ∈ Mod_t(K), where K is a number field and t is the O_K-rank. The core random variable is: $\rho_V(\Lambda) := \#(B \cap (\Lambda \setminus \{0\}))$ where B is a ball of volume V centered at the origin.

Model Architecture

1. Extension of Rogers Integral Formula

For module lattices, the integral representation of the second moment is: $E[\rho_V(\Lambda)^2] = \text{vol}(B)^2 + \sum_{\alpha \in K^{\times}} D(\alpha)^{-t} \cdot \text{vol}(B \cap \alpha^{-1}B)$

where D(α) = O_K : α^{-1}O_K ∩ O_K is the lattice index.

2. Treatment of Unit Group

Key observation: Due to the diagonal action of the unit group O_K^×, ρ_V(Λ) is always a multiple of ω_K = #μ(K), making the natural object of study the count of ω_K-tuples.

3. Application of Height Bounds

Using Weil height theory, establish geometric estimates: $\frac{\text{vol}(B \cap \alpha^{-1}B)}{\text{vol}(B)} \leq \left(\frac{e^{2h_{\infty}(\alpha)} + e^{-2h_{\infty}(\alpha)} \cdot N(\alpha)^{2/d}}{2}\right)^{-dt/2}$

Technical Innovations

1. Stratified Height Processing

Stratify algebraic numbers by Weil height, employing different estimation strategies for different height ranges to optimize the minimum rank condition.

2. Special Properties of Cyclotomic Fields

Exploit the CM property of cyclotomic fields and Schinzel-Smyth bounds on heights of totally positive algebraic integers to obtain uniform constants:

• c(K) = 0.155 (general case)
• c_o(K) = 0.2406 (infinite order case)
• c_S(K) = 0.271763 (case outside unit group)

3. Refined Unit Counting Estimates

Lemma 10 provides bounds on the count of units with bounded height: $\#\{\beta \in O_K^{\times} | h(\eta + L(\beta)) \leq X\} \leq \#S_K \cdot \left(\frac{X + c_S(K)/2}{c_S(K)/2}\right)^{r_1+r_2-1}$

Experimental Setup

Theoretical Verification

The paper is primarily theoretical work, with numerical computations verifying theoretical predictions:

Datasets

• Cyclotomic fields K = Q(ζ_m), m = 8,10,12,13,15,16
• O_K-rank ranges: 15 ≤ t ≤ 32
• Specific case: K = Q(ζ₁₆), t = 32 (dimension 256)

Computational Methods

Implementation using SageMath:

1. Enumeration algorithms for bounded height points
2. Numerical computation of Dedekind ζ functions
3. Explicit bounds on error terms

Implementation Details

• Height threshold: h₀ = 0.6
• Exceptional unit count: #S_K ≤ 17·#μ(K)
• Computational precision: error terms reaching 10^{-11} magnitude

Experimental Results

Main Results

Theorem 3 (Main Result for Cyclotomic Fields)

For fixed t ≥ 11 and cyclotomic field K = Q(ζ_k), as k → ∞, random unit volume module lattices Λ satisfy with probability 1-o(1): $1 - \frac{\log\log\omega_K}{n} \leq \omega_K^{-1/n} \cdot \frac{\lambda_1(\Lambda)}{\gamma(n)} \leq 1 + \frac{\log\log\omega_K}{n}$

Example 30 (Concrete Numerical Results)

For K = Q(ζ₁₆), t = 32:

• Error term η ≤ 1.2 × 10^{-11}
• Probabilistic bound: ≥ 0.639
• Shortest vector approximately 0.8156% longer than unstructured lattices

Technical Improvements

1. Minimum Rank Reduction: Improved from t ≥ 27 to t ≥ 11
2. Constant Optimization: Obtaining explicit, computable constants
3. Extended Applicability: Covering more practical scenarios

Experimental Findings

1. Conductor Effects: Conductors containing small odd primes produce more noise
2. Dimension Effects: Error terms decay rapidly in high dimensions
3. Practical Relevance: Providing meaningful bounds for parameter ranges in current cryptographic schemes

Related Work

Classical Lattice Theory

• Siegel Mean Value Theorem: Establishes expectation theory for lattice point counting
• Rogers Integral Formula: Provides integral representations for higher moments
• Ajtai-Nguyen Results: Asymptotic behavior of shortest vectors in unstructured lattices

Module Lattice Theory

• NTRU and Developments: Initiating research on structured lattices
• Ring LWE/SIS Problems: Establishing theoretical foundations
• Algebraic Code Lifting: Study of discrete module lattice sets

Height Theory

• Lehmer Problem: Classical problem on height bounds for algebraic numbers
• Schinzel-Smyth Work: Height bounds for totally real/totally positive integers
• Amoroso-Dvornicich: Height bounds in abelian extensions

Conclusions and Discussion

Main Conclusions

1. The behavior of shortest vectors in module lattices can be precisely characterized, similar to unstructured lattices but with an additional ω_K factor
2. Cyclotomic fields provide ideal objects of study with favorable height properties
3. Theoretical results yield meaningful numerical bounds for practical parameters

Limitations

1. Minimum Rank Constraint: The condition t ≥ 11 may not be optimal
2. Cyclotomic Field Restriction: General number field cases require further work
3. Computational Complexity: Explicit computation remains difficult for high-degree fields

Future Directions

1. Minimum Rank Optimization: Further reduction to t = 3,4,5
2. General Number Fields: Extension to broader classes of number fields
3. Algorithmic Applications: Applying theoretical results to lattice reduction algorithm analysis

In-Depth Evaluation

Strengths

1. Theoretical Depth: Skillfully combines profound results from number theory, geometry, and probability
2. Technical Innovation: Significant improvements in handling infinite unit groups
3. Practical Value: Provides important theoretical support for post-quantum cryptography
4. Computational Verification: Theoretical results supported by numerical experiments

Weaknesses

1. Technical Threshold: Requires deep background in algebraic number theory
2. Limited Scope: Primarily focused on cyclotomic fields; general cases still need development
3. Computational Complexity: Explicit computation for high-degree cases remains challenging

Impact

1. Theoretical Contribution: Fills important gaps in module lattice theory
2. Cryptographic Applications: Provides security analysis tools for lattice-based post-quantum cryptography
3. Methodological Value: Developed techniques applicable to related problems

Applicable Scenarios

1. Post-Quantum Cryptography Analysis: Assessing security of module lattice-based cryptographic systems
2. Lattice Reduction Algorithms: Understanding algorithm performance on structured lattices
3. Theoretical Research: Foundation for further investigation of module lattice properties

References

The paper cites 31 important references spanning multiple domains including lattice theory, algebraic number theory, and cryptography, reflecting the comprehensiveness and depth of the research.