Random packing fraction of binary convex and similar hyperparticles with small size difference: Statistical geometry approaches to excluded volume

Basic Information

• Paper ID: 2510.12898
• Title: Random packing fraction of binary convex and similar hyperparticles with small size difference: Statistical geometry approaches to excluded volume
• Author: H.J.H. Brouwers (Eindhoven University of Technology)
• Classification: cond-mat.soft (Soft Condensed Matter Physics)
• Publication Date: October 14, 2026
• Paper Link: https://arxiv.org/abs/2510.12898

Abstract

This paper employs two statistical geometry approaches to investigate the random packing fraction of binary similar hyperparticles with small size differences in D-dimensional Euclidean space. These geometric methods involve stochastic geometry and integral geometry for calculating the excluded volume of particle pairs. The rectangular excluded area derived from stochastic geometry in two-dimensional Euclidean space is used to derive an explicit equation for the bidisperse packing fraction, which is compatible with previously published expressions. Subsequently, the excluded volumes of convex particle pairs in D = 2, 3, 4 dimensions derived from integral geometry are presented. These excluded volumes are in complete agreement with those of specific-shaped particles (three-dimensional spherocylinders and two-dimensional rectangles) derived through stochastic geometry. Furthermore, these excluded volumes contain geometric measures: particle volume, surface area, mean curvature, and second quermassintegral, thereby allowing the derivation of closed-form universal expressions for the random packing fraction of binary convex hyperparticles in Euclidean spaces R², R³, and R⁴.

Research Background and Motivation

Research Questions

1. Core Problem: Investigating the random packing fraction of binary similar hyperparticles with small size differences in multidimensional Euclidean space
2. Theoretical Challenge: Generalizing Onsager's excluded volume theory from specific particle shapes (spherocylinders) to arbitrary convex particle shapes
3. Dimensional Extension: Extending from three-dimensional space to two-dimensional, four-dimensional, and higher-dimensional spaces

Significance

1. Fundamental Scientific Value: Particle packing is an ancient problem in physics and mathematics, involving fundamental material properties
2. Practical Applications: Hard particle systems serve as powerful models for studying liquid-glass-crystal transitions, with widespread applications in colloidal physics, biology, and engineering
3. Theoretical Significance: An important bridge connecting microscopic geometry with macroscopic thermodynamic behavior

Limitations of Existing Methods

1. Onsager Method: Applicable only to spherocylinders and cylinders in three-dimensional space
2. Monodisperse Limitation: The excluded volume method is only qualitatively correct for monodisperse cases
3. Shape Specificity: Lack of universal theory applicable to arbitrary convex particle shapes

Core Contributions

1. Theoretical Verification: Verification through stochastic geometry that the packing fraction expression for two-dimensional rectangles is consistent with previous three-dimensional theory
2. Method Unification: Demonstration of the equivalence of stochastic geometry and integral geometry methods in calculating excluded volumes
3. Dimensional Generalization: Establishment of universal packing fraction expressions applicable to arbitrary convex particles in 2, 3, and 4-dimensional Euclidean spaces
4. Mathematical Rigor: Rigorous mathematical derivation based on Minkowski integrals without adjustable parameters

Methodology Details

Task Definition

Investigation of the random packing fraction η(u, X₁, D) of binary particle systems, where:

• u = d₁/d₂: Size ratio of two particle types
• X₁, X₂: Number fractions of two particle types (X₁ + X₂ = 1)
• D: Space dimensionality
• Constraint: Particle shapes are similar with small size differences

Core Theoretical Framework

1. Stochastic Geometry Method (Onsager Method)

Based on statistical averaging over all orientations to calculate excluded volume:

Main Equation:

η(u, X₁, D) = 1 / [1 + (X₁u^D + (1-X₁)) / (1 - X₁(1-X₁)(1-f)v(u,D))]

Where:

• f: Monodisperse packing fraction
• v(u,D): Contraction function, v(u,D) = w(u,D)(u-1)²

2. Integral Geometry Method (Minkowski Integral)

Based on precise mathematical expressions of geometric measures:

Two-Dimensional Case:

V^e_{i,j} = V_{pi} + V_{pj} + (S_{pi} + S_{pj})/2

Three-Dimensional Case:

V^e_{i,j} = V_{pi} + V_{pj} + (S_{pi} + S_{pj})/4 + (M_{pi} + M_{pj})/π

Four-Dimensional Case:

V^e_{i,j} = V_{pi} + V_{pj} + (S_{pi} + S_{pj})/4 + (M_{pi} + M_{pj})/π + 12(W_{2i} + W_{2j})/π²

Technical Innovations

1. Method Equivalence Proof: Mathematical demonstration of consistency between stochastic geometry and integral geometry methods
2. Universality Extension: Generalization of theory for specific particle shapes to arbitrary convex particles
3. Dimension Independence: Establishment of a unified theoretical framework applicable to multidimensional spaces
4. Geometric Measure Integration: Unification of volume, surface area, mean curvature, and quermassintegral in excluded volume calculations

Experimental Setup

Verification Strategy

1. Theoretical Comparison: Comparison of newly derived expressions with known special cases (e.g., circles, spheres)
2. Method Consistency Verification: Verification that both geometric methods yield consistent excluded volume expressions
3. Dimensional Extension Verification: Examination of theory applicability across different dimensional spaces

Test Cases

1. Two-Dimensional Rectangles: Packing of rectangles with arbitrary aspect ratios l/d
2. Three-Dimensional Spherocylinders: Spherocylinders and cylinders with arbitrary length-to-diameter ratios
3. Four-Dimensional Hyperspheres: Hypersphere packing in four-dimensional space

Experimental Results

Main Results

1. Two-Dimensional Verification

• The rectangular excluded area derived through stochastic geometry is in complete agreement with Chatterjee's18 results
• Verification of applicability of equations (3) and (4) in the two-dimensional case

2. Three-Dimensional Verification

• The excluded volume obtained through integral geometry completely matches Onsager's spherocylinder results
• Demonstration that the equation applies to all three-dimensional convex particles

3. Four-Dimensional Extension

• For hyperspheres, theoretical predictions are consistent with known results
• For general hyperparticles, special treatment is required due to complex combinations of geometric measures

Key Findings

1. Universality of Contraction Function:
   • D=2: w(u,2) = 1
   • D=3: w(u,3) = u + 1
   • D=4: w(u,4) = u² + 10u/7 + 1
2. Dimensional Effects: The influence of bidispersity on packing fraction becomes more pronounced with increasing space dimensionality
3. Method Equivalence: In all verified cases, stochastic geometry and integral geometry methods yield identical results

Related Work

Historical Development

1. Kuhn (1934): First introduction of excluded volume concept for polymer chain research
2. Onsager (1949): Establishment of phase transition theory based on excluded volume
3. Isihara (1950-1951): Development of integral geometry method based on Minkowski integrals
4. Boublik (1975): Extension to two-dimensional convex particles

Modern Developments

1. Torquato & Jiao (2013-2022): Excluded volume research in high-dimensional spaces
2. Brouwers (2023-2025): Packing theory for binary similar particles
3. Kulossa & Wagner (2025): Geometric measure research in four and higher dimensions

Conclusions and Discussion

Main Conclusions

1. Theoretical Unification: Successful generalization of Onsager's three-dimensional theory to arbitrary convex particles in multidimensional spaces
2. Mathematical Rigor: The integral geometry method based on Minkowski integrals provides a rigorous mathematical foundation
3. Universality Verification: In 2 and 3-dimensional spaces, the theory applies to all convex particles; in 4-dimensional space, it is verified at least for hyperspheres

Limitations

1. Small Size Difference Constraint: Theory primarily applies to cases with size ratios close to unity
2. Four-Dimensional Limitation: In four-dimensional space, universality is verified only for hyperspheres
3. Monodisperse Approximation: The fundamental excluded volume method is only qualitatively correct for monodisperse cases

Future Directions

1. High-Dimensional Extension: Investigation of particle packing behavior in higher-dimensional spaces
2. Large Size Differences: Theory improvement to handle larger size differences
3. Polydisperse Systems: Extension to complex systems containing multiple sizes

In-Depth Evaluation

Strengths

1. Theoretical Contributions:
   • Establishment of a unified theoretical framework connecting two important geometric methods
   • Provision of parameter-free pure geometric theory with strong predictive power
2. Mathematical Rigor:
   • Based on rigorous Minkowski integral theory
   • All derivations are mathematically complete and verifiable
3. Universality:
   • Applicable to arbitrary convex particle shapes
   • Covers multiple space dimensions
4. Practical Value:
   • Provides important theoretical tools for materials science, colloidal physics, and related fields
   • Can be used to predict and design materials with specific packing performance

Limitations

1. Application Scope Constraints:
   • Primarily applicable to small size difference cases
   • Not applicable to non-convex particles
2. Insufficient Experimental Verification:
   • Lack of direct comparison with actual experimental data
   • Primarily based on theoretical derivation and verification against known special cases
3. High-Dimensional Complexity:
   • In four and higher dimensions, the universality of the theory requires further verification
   • Calculation of geometric measures becomes complex

Impact

1. Academic Impact:
   • Provides important theoretical foundation for particle packing theory
   • Establishes important bridge between statistical mechanics and geometry
2. Application Prospects:
   • Potential applications in materials design, drug delivery, and 3D printing
   • Provides new theoretical tools for understanding glass transitions and amorphous materials
3. Methodological Contribution:
   • Demonstrates how to generalize classical theory to more general cases
   • Provides effective methods for handling multidimensional geometric problems

Applicable Scenarios

1. Basic Research: Particle physics, statistical mechanics, geometric probability theory
2. Materials Science: Composite material design, porous materials, granular materials
3. Engineering Applications: Powder metallurgy, pharmaceutical industry, food engineering
4. Biological Systems: Protein folding, cell packing, biological assembly

References

1. Onsager, L. (1949). The effects of shape on the interaction of colloidal particles. Ann. N.Y. Acad. Sci. 51, 627.
2. Isihara, A. (1950). Determination of molecular shape by osmotic measurement. J. Chem. Phys. 18, 1446.
3. Torquato, S. & Jiao, Y. (2013). Effect of dimensionality on the percolation threshold of overlapping nonspherical hyperparticles. Phys. Rev. E 87, 022111.
4. Brouwers, H.J.H. (2023). Random packing fraction of binary similar particles: Onsager's excluded volume model revisited. Physics – Uspekhi 67, 510.

This paper makes important contributions at the intersection of theoretical physics and materials science. Through rigorous mathematical derivation, it establishes a unified theoretical framework for particle packing, providing powerful tools for understanding and predicting the structural properties of complex materials.