A Wideband Composite Sequence Impedance Model for Evaluation of Interactions in Unbalanced Power-Electronic-Based Power Systems

Basic Information

• Paper ID: 2510.12914
• Title: A Wideband Composite Sequence Impedance Model for Evaluation of Interactions in Unbalanced Power-Electronic-Based Power Systems
• Authors: Zhi Liu, Chengxi Liu, Jiangbei Han, Rui Qiu, Mingyuan Liu (School of Electrical Engineering and Automation, Wuhan University)
• Classification: eess.SY cs.SY (Electrical Engineering Systems and Control, Systems and Control)
• Funding: National Natural Science Foundation of China (U22B20100), Guangdong Basic and Applied Basic Research Foundation (2023B1515250001, 2022A1515240033)
• Paper Link: https://arxiv.org/abs/2510.12914

Abstract

This paper proposes an analysis method based on the Wideband Composite Sequence Impedance Model (WCSIM) to evaluate the interactions in power-electronic-based power systems under unbalanced grid faults or unbalanced load conditions. The WCSIM method intuitively assesses the impact of small-signal interconnections between positive-sequence, negative-sequence, and zero-sequence circuits on the stability of interactions in unbalanced power systems. The effectiveness of the method is validated through a case study of a permanent magnet synchronous generator (PMSG) weak-grid system under single-phase-to-ground fault. Frequency sweep results and controller hardware-in-the-loop (HIL) testing verify the correctness of WCSIM and the effectiveness of the analysis method based on WCSIM.

Research Background and Motivation

Problem Description

With the increasing penetration of power electronic devices in power systems, interaction problems in the system become increasingly prominent. Unstable interactions may trigger oscillations, leading to equipment tripping or even system collapse. Although various methods have been developed to analyze and suppress wideband oscillations, these methods are typically limited to balanced systems.

Research Significance

For power systems experiencing unbalanced grid faults or with unbalanced loads, interactions become more complex and require further investigation. Unbalanced grid conditions may cause small-signal interconnections between positive-sequence, negative-sequence, and zero-sequence circuits, which may affect interaction stability.

Limitations of Existing Methods

1. Limited Research Scope: Existing research primarily focuses on wideband oscillation analysis in balanced systems
2. Insufficient Modeling: Research on wind power systems under unbalanced grid conditions mainly concentrates on wind turbine modeling, with limited attention to unbalanced grids
3. Sequence Component Coupling: Lack of effective methods to evaluate the impact of small-signal interconnections between sequence components on system stability

Research Motivation

The use of sequence interconnection techniques in traditional power systems for steady-state analysis during unbalanced faults raises an important question: can this technique be applied to evaluate wideband interactions in power-electronic-based power systems under unbalanced grid conditions?

Core Contributions

1. Proposed WCSIM Model: First proposes the Wideband Composite Sequence Impedance Model capable of evaluating system interactions under unbalanced conditions across a wide frequency range
2. Sequence Component Interconnection Analysis: Establishes mathematical models and analytical frameworks for small-signal interconnections between positive-sequence, negative-sequence, and zero-sequence circuits
3. Equivalent Impedance Derivation: Derives equivalent grid impedance calculation formulas considering sequence component coupling
4. Experimental Validation: Verifies the correctness and effectiveness of the method through frequency sweep and controller hardware-in-the-loop testing

Methodology Details

Task Definition

Evaluate the wideband interaction stability of power-electronic-based power systems under unbalanced grid faults (such as single-phase-to-ground faults) or unbalanced load conditions, particularly analyzing the impact of small-signal interconnections between positive-sequence, negative-sequence, and zero-sequence circuits on system stability.

Model Architecture

1. Test System Description

• System Configuration: 150 units of 2MW PMSG wind farm connected through step-up transformer, 35kV transmission line, and 220kV transmission line to an infinite bus
• Transformer Configuration: Primary winding grounded star connection, secondary winding delta connection
• Control Strategy: PMSG employs classical vector control with notch filter embedded in PLL to suppress negative-sequence components

2. WCSIM Derivation Process

Fault Boundary Conditions: For single-phase-to-ground fault on phase A, small-signal phase component boundary conditions are:

u̇fa(ω) = Rf(s)İfa(ω), İfb(ω) = İfc(ω) = 0

Sequence Component Boundary Conditions: Based on symmetrical component theory, converted to sequence component representation:

u̇fpa(ω) + u̇fna(ω) + u̇f0a(ω) = Rf(s)İf(ω)
İfpa(ω) = İfna(ω) = İf0a(ω) = İf(ω)/3

3. Equivalent Impedance Calculation

Equivalent Positive-Sequence Grid Impedance:

Zgpe(s) = Zg1(s) + [Zg2(s)Zne(s)Rf(s)Z0e(s)] / [Zg2(s) + Zne(s) + 3Rf(s) + Z0e(s)]

Where:

• Equivalent Negative-Sequence Impedance: Zne(s) = [Zwn(s)(Zg1(s) + Zg2(s))] / [Zwn(s) + Zg1(s) + Zg2(s)]
• Equivalent Zero-Sequence Impedance: Z0e(s) = [Z01(s)Z02(s)] / [Z01(s) + Z02(s)]

Technical Innovations

1. Wideband Characteristics: Unlike traditional sequence networks, WCSIM is effective across a wide frequency range but only applicable to small-signal analysis at specific operating points
2. Sequence Component Coupling: First establishes small-signal interconnection models between sequence components under fault conditions
3. Generality: Applicable not only to fault systems but also to systems with unbalanced loads
4. Intuitiveness: Directly evaluates system stability through equivalent impedance

Experimental Setup

Test System Parameters

Transmission Line Parameters (Base Capacity 300MVA)

PMSG Parameters (Base Capacity 2MVA)

• Current Controller: kpc=0.015, kic=3
• Phase-Locked Loop: kpp=0.48, kip=43
• Notch Filter: ωN=200π, ζN=1
• Filter: Lf=3mH, Cf=50μF, Rcf=1.5Ω

Validation Methods

1. Frequency Sweep: Verifies the correctness of theoretically derived WCSIM
2. Controller Hardware-in-the-Loop Testing: Validates the effectiveness of the analysis method
3. Comparative Experiments: Compares system responses with and without small-signal sequence interconnection (SSSI)

Experimental Scenarios

• Fault Location: Single-phase-to-ground fault occurs at 10% distance from wind farm side on 220kV line
• Comparative Cases:
  • Single-phase voltage sag only
  • Actual single-phase-to-ground fault

Experimental Results

Main Results

1. Frequency Sweep Verification

• Impedance Matching: Measured grid impedance Z'gpe(s) completely matches theoretical results in both magnitude and phase
• SSSI Impact: Small-signal sequence interconnection reduces grid impedance magnitude across the entire frequency range while maintaining phase unchanged
• Stability Improvement: Previously intersecting PMSG and grid impedance curves no longer intersect when SSSI is considered, increasing damping of the supersynchronous interaction mode

2. Nyquist Analysis

• Without SSSI: Nyquist curve encircles the (-1, j0) point, system is unstable
• With SSSI: Curve does not encircle the (-1, j0) point, system becomes stable

3. Hardware-in-the-Loop Test Results

• Single-Phase Voltage Sag: PCC voltage exhibits oscillation but remains stable
• Single-Phase-to-Ground Fault: PCC voltage oscillates but system remains stable
• Positive-Sequence Voltage: Positive-sequence PCC voltage Vp remains at 290V in both cases

Key Findings

1. Stabilizing Effect of SSSI: Small-signal interconnections between sequence components have a stabilizing effect, reducing system impedance
2. Theory-Experiment Consistency: Theoretical analysis highly consistent with experimental results, validating WCSIM accuracy
3. Fault Type Impact: Actual faults exhibit better stability performance compared to pure voltage sag

Related Work

Main Research Directions

1. Balanced System Analysis: Existing wideband oscillation analysis methods primarily target balanced systems
2. Wind Power System Research: Focus on PLL, active-reactive power current allocation, and impact of positive-negative sequence coupling on stability
3. Traditional Sequence Networks: Used for steady-state analysis of unbalanced faults in traditional power systems

Advantages of This Paper

1. Extension to Wideband: Extends sequence network concepts to wideband analysis
2. Power Electronic Systems: Specifically targets power-electronic-based systems
3. Small-Signal Framework: Establishes a complete small-signal analysis framework

Conclusions and Discussion

Main Conclusions

1. WCSIM Effectiveness: The proposed Wideband Composite Sequence Impedance Model accurately evaluates system interactions under unbalanced conditions
2. Stabilization Mechanism: Small-signal interconnections between sequence components have a stabilizing effect
3. Broad Applicability: The method is applicable not only to fault systems but also to systems with unbalanced loads

Limitations

1. Specific Operating Point: WCSIM depends on a specific balanced operating point and is only applicable to small-signal analysis
2. Single-Phase Faults: Current validation primarily focuses on single-phase-to-ground faults
3. Theoretical Framework: Requires further extension to other types of unbalanced conditions

Future Directions

1. Multiple Fault Types: Extension to other fault types such as phase-to-phase short circuits
2. Unbalanced Loads: In-depth investigation of applications in unbalanced load systems
3. Control Strategy Optimization: Development of improved control strategies based on WCSIM

In-Depth Evaluation

Strengths

1. Theoretical Innovation: First extension of sequence network theory to wideband analysis of power-electronic systems, with significant theoretical value
2. Practical Method: Provides an intuitive stability assessment method with strong engineering practicality
3. Comprehensive Validation: Multiple verification through theoretical derivation, frequency sweep, and hardware-in-the-loop testing
4. Mathematical Rigor: Rigorous mathematical derivation with clear physical meaning

Weaknesses

1. Limited Verification Scope: Validation only on PMSG systems; testing on more types of power electronic devices needed
2. Single Fault Type: Primarily focuses on single-phase-to-ground faults; insufficient verification of other unbalanced conditions
3. Parameter Sensitivity: Insufficient discussion on the impact of system parameter variations on WCSIM accuracy

Impact

1. Academic Contribution: Provides new theoretical tools for analysis of unbalanced power-electronic systems
2. Engineering Value: Can guide stability analysis and control design in practical power systems
3. Reproducibility: Provides detailed parameters and experimental setup for easy reproduction

Applicable Scenarios

1. Wind Farm Integration: Applicable to stability analysis of large-scale wind farms under unbalanced conditions
2. Weak Grid Systems: Particularly suitable for scenarios where power electronic devices are connected to weak grids
3. Fault Analysis: Can be used for system behavior prediction and analysis during grid faults

References

The paper cites 30 related references, primarily covering:

• Interaction analysis methods for power electronic systems
• Unbalanced operation control of wind power systems
• Sequence network theory in traditional power systems
• Small-signal stability analysis techniques

Overall Assessment: This is a high-quality academic paper with significant contributions in both theoretical innovation and practical utility. The WCSIM method fills a theoretical gap in the analysis of power-electronic systems under unbalanced conditions, providing important tools for related research. The paper has clear structure, comprehensive validation, and possesses high academic value and engineering application prospects.