Changing Oneself by Teaching Others? Exploring the Protégé Effect in Digital Stress Self-Regulation

Basic Information

• Paper ID: 2510.12944
• Title: Changing Oneself by Teaching Others? Exploring the Protégé Effect in Digital Stress Self-Regulation
• Authors: Sameha Alshakhsi, Ala Yankouskaya, Dena Al-Thani, Raian Ali
• Classification: cs.HC (Human-Computer Interaction)
• Institutions: Hamad Bin Khalifa University (Qatar), Bournemouth University (UK)
• Paper Link: https://arxiv.org/abs/2510.12944

Abstract

This study explores the application of intervention methods based on the protégé effect in digital stress self-regulation. The research recruited 137 participants with moderate to high digital stress, divided into four groups for a three-week experimental period: passive protégé group (provided teaching materials), active protégé group (required to search and prepare teaching content), digital literacy group, and control group. Results demonstrate that while cognitive engagement increased, translating this into behavioral change remains challenging, particularly under the influence of persistent digital habits and social reinforcement stressors. The study provides important insights for protégé effect-based behavioral change interventions.

Research Background and Motivation

Problem Definition

With the proliferation of digital technology, over 70% of the global population owns mobile devices, with 83.7% being smartphones. Over 63% of the world's population uses social media, spending more than two hours daily on average. This hyperconnected environment has given rise to digital stress, an emerging psychological phenomenon.

Core Issues

Digital stress encompasses five dimensions:

1. Availability Demand Stress: Pressure to remain online and respond immediately
2. Approval Anxiety: Concerns about others' reactions to one's social media content
3. Fear of Missing Out (FoMO): Anxiety about missing others' experiences
4. Connection Overload: Overwhelming pressure from multi-platform notifications and information
5. Online Vigilance: Cognitive focus and psychological readiness for online connectivity

Research Motivation

Existing research indicates that digital stress correlates with negative psychological health outcomes including anxiety, depression, and reduced self-esteem. This study explores whether the protégé effect (learning by teaching) can reduce digital stress by enhancing reflection and internalizing coping strategies.

Core Contributions

1. First Application of Protégé Effect to Digital Stress Management: Explores the "learning by teaching" principle in behavioral change applications
2. Systematic Intervention Design: Develops both passive and active protégé-based intervention methods
3. Multi-Dimensional Assessment Framework: Comprehensively evaluates digital stress, problematic social media use, issue engagement, and word-of-mouth transmission intentions
4. Cultural Context Consideration: Validates intervention effects within collectivist Middle Eastern cultural contexts
5. Theoretical and Practical Insights: Reveals challenges in translating cognitive engagement into behavioral change

Methodology Details

Research Design

Employs a 4×2 mixed design with 4 experimental groups and 2 time points (pre-test and post-test):

Experimental Group Setup:

1. Passive Protégé Group: Receives complete materials and prepares teaching content
2. Active Protégé Group: Receives partial materials and must independently search for coping strategies
3. Digital Literacy Group: Reads materials and answers comprehension questions
4. Control Group: No intervention

Intervention Content

Three sessions designed targeting three core digital stress components:

• Session 1: Availability demand stress
• Session 2: Approval anxiety
• Session 3: Fear of missing out

Task Design

Protégé group participants engage in:

1. Selecting a learner role
2. Creating two scenario-strategy pairs for each session
3. Using provided PowerPoint templates
4. Receiving feedback and questions from simulated learners

Theoretical Foundation

• Protégé Effect Theory: Promotes deeper learning and reflection through teaching
• Commitment and Consistency Principle: Individuals tend to maintain consistency with committed behaviors
• Inoculation Theory: Building psychological resistance in one domain may produce protective effects in related domains

Experimental Setup

Participants

• Sample Size: 137 participants
• Demographics: 59.12% female, ages 18-35, mean age 26.82 years
• Recruitment Criteria: Middle Eastern cultural background, active social media users, moderate to high digital stress
• Recruitment Platform: Prolific online platform

Measurement Instruments

Digital Stress Scale (DSS):

• 24 items, 5-point Likert scale
• 5 dimensions: availability stress, approval anxiety, FoMO, connection overload, online vigilance
• Reliability: α = .86 (pre-test), α = .90 (post-test)

Problematic Social Media Use Scale (SMD):

• 9 items corresponding to 9 behavioral symptoms
• Reliability: α = .83 (pre-test), α = .85 (post-test)

Personal Issue Involvement Scale (PII):

• 6 bipolar adjective pairs, 7-point scale
• Reliability: α = .93 (pre-test and post-test)

Word-of-Mouth Transmission Intention Scale:

• 3 items, 7-point Likert scale

Experimental Procedure

1. Pre-Screening: Assessment of eligibility criteria
2. Pre-Test Survey: Baseline measurement
3. Intervention Phase: Three structured sessions over 17 days (on days 4, 7, and 10)
4. Post-Test Survey: Conducted on day 17

Experimental Results

Main Findings

Digital Stress Changes:

• All groups showed significant reduction in digital stress between pre- and post-tests
• Significant main time effect: F(1,133) = 44.051, p < .001, ηp² = 0.249
• No significant between-group differences: F(3,133) = 0.271, p = .846
• No significant interaction effects: F(3,133) = 0.219, p = .883

Effect Sizes by Dimension:

• Online vigilance: d = 0.54 (strongest effect)
• Overall digital stress: d = 0.61
• Approval anxiety: d = 0.49 (moderate effect)
• Connection overload: d = 0.48 (moderate effect)
• Availability demand stress: d = 0.21 (small effect)
• FoMO: d = 0.18 (small effect)

Problematic Social Media Use:

• Significant main time effect: F(1,133) = 51.730, p < .001, ηp² = 0.280
• Average reduction: MD = 7.27, Cohen's d = 0.51
• Similarly, no significant between-group differences

Issue Engagement and Word-of-Mouth Transmission:

• No significant changes in issue engagement
• Significant interaction effect for word-of-mouth transmission, but subsequent analyses revealed no significant within-group changes

Key Findings

1. Control Group Effect: Even the control group showed significant reduction in digital stress
2. Measurement Reactivity: Mere exposure to digital stress definitions and questionnaires may have produced awareness-raising effects
3. Limited Intervention Effects: Protégé-based interventions did not demonstrate additional benefits compared to the control group

Related Work

Protégé Effect Research

• Traditional applications in academic domains (mathematics, programming)
• Promotes learning through teaching expectancy effects
• Teachable agents research demonstrates enhanced learning through increased responsibility

Digital Stress Interventions

• Existing interventions primarily focus on awareness-raising
• Behavioral change interventions are relatively limited
• Social norms and cultural factors influence intervention effectiveness

Inoculation Theory Applications

• Comparisons of active versus passive inoculation strategies
• Cross-domain protective effects
• Relationship between cognitive engagement and behavioral change

Conclusions and Discussion

Main Conclusions

1. Limitations of Cognitive Engagement: While the protégé effect is effective in educational contexts, its effectiveness in digital stress behavioral change is limited
2. Role of Awareness-Raising: Simple awareness-raising (through definitions and measurement) may already produce significant effects
3. Complexity of Behavioral Change: Changing digital habits requires multi-faceted interventions beyond reflective learning

Cultural Factor Influences

In collectivist cultural contexts:

• Individuals prioritize group harmony and conformity
• Psychological costs of violating social norms may exceed pressure to comply
• This limits the effectiveness of reflective strategies

Design Recommendations

1. Enhanced Interactivity: Real peer teaching rather than hypothetical tasks
2. Personalized Interventions: Customized approaches targeting specific stressors
3. Social Support Integration: Combining peer discussions and online support forums
4. Environmental Modification: Coordinating with habit cue adjustments

In-Depth Evaluation

Strengths

1. Rigorous Research Design:
   • Randomized controlled trial design
   • Multiple control group setup
   • Standardized intervention protocols
   • Adequate sample size calculation
2. Solid Theoretical Foundation:
   • Integration of multiple psychological theories
   • Clear theoretical hypotheses
   • Systematic literature review
3. Reliable Measurement Instruments:
   • Use of validated scales
   • Good internal consistency
   • Multi-dimensional assessment
4. Cultural Sensitivity:
   • Consideration of collectivist cultural contexts
   • Intervention design tailored to specific populations

Limitations

1. Intervention Design Constraints:
   • Hypothetical teaching tasks lack authentic interaction
   • Relatively short intervention period (17 days)
   • Absence of long-term follow-up assessment
2. Measurement Limitations:
   • Complete reliance on self-report measures
   • Lack of objective behavioral measurements (e.g., actual usage data)
   • Potential social desirability bias
3. Sample Limitations:
   • Restricted to Middle Eastern cultural contexts
   • Relatively narrow age range
   • May affect generalizability of results
4. Insufficient Mechanism Understanding:
   • Limited exploration of why interventions were ineffective
   • Lack of detailed analysis of awareness-raising mechanisms

Impact

Theoretical Contributions:

• Extends the application boundaries of the protégé effect
• Reveals challenges in translating cognitive engagement into behavioral change
• Provides important insights for digital health interventions

Practical Value:

• Provides guidance for digital health application design
• Emphasizes the importance of cultural factors in interventions
• Highlights the potential value of simple awareness-raising

Methodological Contributions:

• Provides a research paradigm for digital stress interventions
• Establishes a multi-dimensional assessment framework

Applicable Scenarios

1. Digital Health Application Development: Provides intervention strategy references for app designers
2. Educational Technology Research: Explores protégé effect applications across different domains
3. Cultural Adaptation Research: Provides foundation for cross-cultural digital health interventions
4. Mental Health Services: Offers digital stress assessment and intervention insights for clinical practitioners

Future Research Directions

Methodological Improvements

1. Enhanced Interactivity: Develop authentic peer teaching platforms
2. Extended Intervention Duration: Explore cumulative effects of long-term interventions
3. Objective Measurements: Integrate smartphone usage data
4. Personalized Design: Customized interventions based on individual stress source characteristics

Theoretical Development

1. Mechanism Exploration: Deep investigation of neurocognitive mechanisms of awareness-raising
2. Cross-Cultural Comparison: Validate intervention effects across different cultural contexts
3. Developmental Trajectories: Explore intervention sensitivity across age groups

Technological Innovation

1. AI-Assisted Interventions: Utilize artificial intelligence for personalized feedback
2. Virtual Reality Applications: Create immersive teaching environments
3. Social Robots: Develop teachable agent systems

References

Key references include:

• Hall, J. A., et al. (2021). Development and validation of a multidimensional digital stress scale
• Fiorella, L., & Mayer, R. E. (2013). The relative benefits of learning by teaching and teaching expectancy
• Cialdini, R. B. (2009). Influence: Science and Practice
• Chase, C. C., et al. (2009). Teachable agents and the protégé effect

Summary: This study provides important theoretical and practical contributions to the digital health field. Although protégé effect-based interventions did not demonstrate expected effects, the research reveals the complexity and challenges of digital stress interventions, providing direction for future research. The study's rigorous design and in-depth analysis make it an important reference in the field.