2025-11-23T00:28:18.685801

Entanglement spectrum of gapless topological phases: a case study with topological superconductors

Banerjee, Zeng
Using bulk gapless topological superconductors in both 1d and 2d as free fermion model examples, we demonstrate the power of subsystem correlation spectrum (the spectrum of correlation matrix), or equivalently the entanglement spectrum for the case of free fermions, in characterizing the topology of the non-trivial ground state. For the systems considered, we show that signatures of the lowenergy spectrum, including both the edge modes and the bulk modes, appear in the correlation spectrum, albeit with different behaviors. This work generalizes the 2d Li-Haldane entanglement spectrum characterization of topological edge states to 2d topological systems with gapless bulk.
academic

Entanglement spectrum of gapless topological phases: a case study with topological superconductors

Basic Information

  • Paper ID: 2510.13045
  • Title: Entanglement spectrum of gapless topological phases: a case study with topological superconductors
  • Authors: Archi Banerjee, Meng Zeng
  • Classification: cond-mat.str-el cond-mat.supr-con quant-ph
  • Submission Date: October 14, 2024 (arXiv submission)
  • Paper Link: https://arxiv.org/abs/2510.13045

Abstract

This paper demonstrates the power of subsystem correlation spectrum (spectrum of the correlation matrix) or equivalently the entanglement spectrum in characterizing nontrivial topological properties of ground states, using one-dimensional and two-dimensional gapless bulk topological superconductors as examples within the free fermion model framework. For the studied systems, the authors prove that characteristic signals of the low-energy spectrum, including edge modes and bulk modes, appear in the correlation spectrum, albeit exhibiting different behaviors. This work generalizes the two-dimensional Li-Haldane entanglement spectrum characterization of topological edge states to two-dimensional topological systems with gapless bulk states.

Research Background and Motivation

Core Problem

The core problem addressed by this research is: How to characterize topological properties through entanglement spectrum in topological phases with gapless bulk states. Traditional entanglement spectrum theory primarily applies to systems with gapped bulk states, while fundamental challenges remain in the existing theoretical framework for gapless topological phases.

Problem Significance

  1. Theoretical Completeness: The entanglement spectrum is an important tool for characterizing topological phases, but its applicability in gapless systems remains incompletely established
  2. Experimental Relevance: Many practical topological materials (such as d-wave superconductors) possess nodal structures, belonging to gapless topological phases
  3. Methodological Breakthrough: New theoretical frameworks are needed to handle topological characterization of gapless systems

Limitations of Existing Methods

  1. Spectral Flattening Failure: Fidkowski's proof relies on flattening all gapped bulk bands, but in the thermodynamic limit, the spectral flattening procedure for gapless systems no longer applies
  2. Li-Haldane Correspondence: The original Li-Haldane entanglement spectrum characterization applies only to systems with gapped bulk states
  3. Theoretical Gap: Lack of systematic theory to understand the relationship between entanglement spectrum and topological properties in gapless topological phases

Core Contributions

  1. Theoretical Extension: Generalizes entanglement spectrum characterization from gapped to gapless topological phases
  2. Method Verification: Validates the correlation spectrum method through one-dimensional topological Majorana chains and two-dimensional d-wave topological superconductors
  3. Phenomenological Discovery: Reveals distinct behaviors of edge modes and bulk modes in the correlation spectrum
  4. Scaling Analysis: Provides scaling behavior analysis of degeneracy splitting in gapless systems
  5. Supplementary Tool: Introduces trace index as a complementary quantification tool for spectral flow

Detailed Methodology

Task Definition

The research task is to compute and analyze the subsystem correlation spectrum of gapless topological systems and establish its correspondence with topological edge states. The input is the free fermion Hamiltonian, and the output is the correlation spectrum and corresponding topological characterization.

Theoretical Framework

Correlation Spectrum Calculation Method

For free fermion systems, entanglement information is completely contained in two-point correlation functions. The complete correlation matrix is defined as:

\langle c_i^\dagger c_j \rangle & \langle c_i^\dagger c_j^\dagger \rangle \\ \langle c_i c_j \rangle & \langle c_i c_j^\dagger \rangle \end{pmatrix} = \begin{pmatrix} C_{ij} & F_{ij} \\ F_{ij}^\dagger & \delta_{ij} - C_{ij} \end{pmatrix}$$ where $C_{ij} = \langle c_i^\dagger c_j \rangle$ and $F_{ij} = \langle c_i^\dagger c_j^\dagger \rangle$ are the particle-particle and particle-hole correlation functions, respectively. #### Entanglement Hamiltonian The reduced density matrix $\rho_A$ can be reconstructed from the subsystem correlation matrix $G_A$: $$\rho_A = \det(1-G_A) \exp\left[\sum_{ij \in A} [\ln G_A(I-G_A)^{-1}]_{ij} \psi_i^\dagger \psi_j\right]$$ The entanglement entropy is expressed as: $$S_A = -\sum_n \xi_n \ln \xi_n + (1-\xi_n) \ln(1-\xi_n)$$ where $\{\xi_n\}$ are the eigenvalues of $G_A$. ### Model Systems #### One-Dimensional α-Chain Model Consider the Hamiltonian $H = H_1 - g H_2$, where: $$H_\alpha = i \sum_n \tilde{\gamma}_n \gamma_{n+\alpha}$$ This model exhibits quantum phase transitions at $g = \pm 1$, connecting phases with different topological numbers. #### Two-Dimensional d-Wave Topological Superconductor The BdG Hamiltonian is: $$H(k) = \begin{pmatrix} \epsilon_k - h\sigma_z + g_k \cdot \sigma & i\Delta_k \sigma_y \\ -i\Delta_k \sigma_y & -\epsilon_k + h\sigma_z + g_k \cdot \sigma^* \end{pmatrix}$$ Two types of pairing are considered: - $d_{x^2-y^2}$ pairing: $\Delta_k = \Delta(\cos k_x - \cos k_y)$ - $d_{xy}$ pairing: $\Delta_k = \Delta \sin k_x \sin k_y$ ### Technical Innovations 1. **Spectral Flow Analysis**: Identifies spectral flow characteristics of correlation spectrum in gapless systems 2. **Trace Index**: Introduces $N_A(k_y) = \langle\sum_{i \in A} c_{i,k_y}^\dagger c_{i,k_y}\rangle$ as a topological invariant 3. **Scaling Behavior**: Analyzes power-law scaling of degeneracy splitting in gapless systems: $\sim 1/L_A^\alpha$ ## Experimental Setup ### Computational Parameters - **One-Dimensional Systems**: Chain length of 100 unit cells - **Two-Dimensional Systems**: $L_x = 160, L_y = 300$, periodic boundary conditions along y-direction, open boundary conditions along x-direction - **Parameter Settings**: $t = 1, \mu = -4t, \lambda = 0.5t, h = 2t, \Delta = t$ ### Geometric Configuration Cylindrical geometry is adopted, with subsystem correlation spectrum computed through virtual cuts. For two-dimensional systems, the cut is made between the 76th and 77th unit cells in the x-direction. ### Comparative Analysis By adding $C_4$ symmetry-breaking term $d(\tau_y \otimes \sigma_y)$ to open the bulk energy gap, the correlation spectrum behaviors in gapped and gapless cases are compared. ## Experimental Results ### One-Dimensional System Results #### Gapped Bulk Case - At $g = 0.5$, winding number $\omega_1 = 1$, one 1/2 mode appears in correlation spectrum - At $g = 1.5$, winding number $\omega_2 = 2$, two 1/2 modes appear in correlation spectrum - Degeneracy splitting exhibits exponential decay: $\delta \sim e^{-L_A/\xi}$ #### Critical Point Case - At $g = 1.0$, system is at critical point, still maintains one 1/2 mode - Degeneracy splitting exhibits power-law decay: $\delta \sim 1/L_A^\alpha$ - On logarithmic length scale, splitting exhibits exponential decay: $\delta \sim e^{-\alpha \ln L_A}$ ### Two-Dimensional System Results #### $d_{x^2-y^2}$ Pairing - **Edge Modes**: Chiral Majorana zero modes appear at $k_y = 0$, correlation spectrum displays clear spectral flow - **Bulk Nodes**: Bulk nodes at $k_y \sim \pi/2$ also leave characteristic signatures in correlation spectrum - **Trace Index**: Shows quantized 1/2 jump at $k_y = 0$, confirming Majorana nature #### $d_{xy}$ Pairing - **No Edge Zero Modes**: Due to edge modes merging with bulk nodes at the same momentum, no stable edge zero modes exist - **Position Dependence**: The 1/2 mode in correlation spectrum exhibits oscillatory behavior depending on cut position - **Trace Index**: No quantized jumps, confirming absence of topological edge modes ### Quantitative Analysis | System Type | Topological Invariant | Number of 1/2 Modes | Degeneracy Splitting Scaling | |-------------|----------------------|-------------------|------------------------------| | 1D Gapped ($g=0.5$) | $\omega=1$ | 1 | Exponential decay | | 1D Critical ($g=1.0$) | $\omega=1$ | 1 | Power-law decay | | 2D $d_{x^2-y^2}$ | Nontrivial | 1 | - | | 2D $d_{xy}$ | Nontrivial | 0 (stable) | - | ## Related Work ### Development of Entanglement Spectrum Theory 1. **Li-Haldane Pioneering Work**: First discovered the correspondence between entanglement spectrum and edge states in fractional quantum Hall states 2. **Fidkowski's Proof**: Established rigorous theoretical foundation for gapped free fermion systems 3. **SPT Phase Generalization**: Extended entanglement spectrum characterization to symmetry-protected topological phases ### Research on Gapless Topological Phases 1. **Critical Topological Phases**: Recent studies on systems with gapless bulk but topologically protected edge modes 2. **Nodal Superconductors**: Theoretical studies of topological superconductors with nodal structures such as d-wave superconductors 3. **Conformal Field Theory Methods**: Analysis of entanglement properties in critical systems using conformal field theory ## Conclusions and Discussion ### Main Conclusions 1. **Universality Verification**: The entanglement spectrum method remains effective in topological phases with gapless bulk states 2. **Behavioral Differences**: Edge modes and bulk modes exhibit significantly different behaviors in the correlation spectrum 3. **Scaling Relations**: Degeneracy splitting in gapless systems follows power-law rather than exponential scaling 4. **Topological Characterization**: Quantized jumps in trace index can effectively identify topological edge modes ### Limitations 1. **Free Fermion Restriction**: Study is limited to free fermion systems; interaction effects are not considered 2. **Specific Models**: Conclusions are based on specific d-wave superconductor models; universality remains to be verified 3. **Numerical Precision**: Some fine structures may be limited by numerical computation precision 4. **Theoretical Framework**: Lacks rigorous theoretical foundation comparable to Fidkowski's proof ### Future Directions 1. **Interacting Systems**: Study the effects of weak interactions on entanglement spectrum characterization 2. **Intrinsic Interaction-Driven Topological Phases**: Explore entanglement spectrum of topological phases entirely generated by interactions 3. **Experimental Verification**: Direct measurement of entanglement spectrum in cold atom systems 4. **Theory Refinement**: Establish rigorous theoretical framework for entanglement spectrum of gapless topological phases ## In-Depth Evaluation ### Strengths 1. **Significant Theoretical Importance**: Fills important gap in entanglement spectrum theory for gapless topological phases 2. **Systematic and Complete Methods**: Systematic study from one-dimensional to two-dimensional, from gapped to gapless systems 3. **Accurate and Reliable Computation**: Leverages exact solvability of free fermion systems to obtain reliable numerical results 4. **Clear Physical Picture**: Clearly distinguishes different contributions from edge modes and bulk modes 5. **Tool Innovation**: Introduction of trace index provides new quantification tool for topological characterization ### Shortcomings 1. **Limited Theoretical Depth**: Lacks rigorous mathematical proofs comparable to gapped cases 2. **Model Limitations**: Only considers specific types of d-wave superconductors; universality is questionable 3. **Missing Interactions**: Completely neglects interaction effects, which are often important in real materials 4. **Insufficient Experimental Connection**: Weak connection to actual experiments ### Impact Assessment 1. **Academic Value**: Provides important theoretical tools and numerical verification for gapless topological phase research 2. **Methodological Contribution**: Establishes standard methods for handling entanglement spectrum of gapless systems 3. **Inspirational Significance**: Lays foundation for subsequent research on interacting systems and experiments 4. **Practical Value**: Provides theoretical guidance for identifying and characterizing new topological materials ### Applicable Scenarios 1. **Theoretical Research**: Theoretical analysis and numerical computation of gapless topological phases 2. **Material Design**: Theoretical prediction of topological superconductors with nodal structures 3. **Experimental Guidance**: Provides theoretical basis for entanglement spectrum measurements in cold atom experiments 4. **Method Development**: Serves as foundational tool for studying more complex topological systems ## References This paper cites 36 important references, covering multiple research fields including entanglement theory, topological phase transitions, and free fermion systems. Particularly, the pioneering work by Li-Haldane [4] and rigorous proof by Fidkowski [7] provide important theoretical foundations for this research.