Autler-Townes Spectroscopy of a Rydberg Ladder

Basic Information

• Paper ID: 2510.13150
• Title: Autler-Townes spectroscopy of a Rydberg ladder
• Authors: Tai Xiang, Yue-Hui Lu, Jacquelyn Ho, Tsai-Chen Lee, Zhenjie Yan, Dan M. Stamper-Kurn
• Classification: quant-ph physics.atom-ph
• Publication Date: October 16, 2025
• Paper Link: https://arxiv.org/abs/2510.13150
• Institutions: Department of Physics, University of California, Berkeley; Quantum Computing Challenge Research Institute; Materials Science Division, Lawrence Berkeley National Laboratory

Abstract

This paper investigates ladder-type two-photon excitation from the ground state |g⟩ to an intermediate excited state |e⟩ and subsequently to a Rydberg state |r⟩, which has broad applications in quantum information and sensing. The conventional optical detection scheme employs electromagnetically induced transparency (EIT); however, in the inverted wavelength scheme (where the ground-to-excited-state wavelength is shorter than the excited-to-Rydberg-state wavelength), EIT features are significantly diminished in Doppler-broadened media. The authors report an alternative two-photon spectroscopic feature—two-photon Autler-Townes resonance (TPAT)—observed through the upper beam. Compared to EIT signals, this feature exhibits superior signal-to-noise ratio, can resolve Rydberg resonances with principal quantum numbers up to n=80, and can be used to generate error signals for stabilizing the upper beam frequency.

Research Background and Motivation

Problem Background

1. Importance of Rydberg atoms: Rydberg atoms play crucial roles in quantum sensing, quantum simulation, and quantum computing, typically excited to high principal quantum number states through two-photon transitions
2. Limitations of conventional EIT methods: In the inverted wavelength scheme, Doppler broadening severely reduces the visibility of EIT features
3. Technical challenges: Reliable detection and localization of Rydberg state resonances in thermal atomic vapor requires new approaches

Research Motivation

• In Doppler-broadened media with inverted wavelength schemes, atoms of different velocities produce overlapping single-photon absorption features that obscure the coherent EIT transparency window
• Development of new spectroscopic techniques is needed to overcome this limitation, providing better signal-to-noise ratio and higher detection precision
• New frequency-locking schemes are required for Rydberg state laser systems

Core Contributions

1. Proposal of TPAT spectroscopy technique: First systematic study of two-photon Autler-Townes resonance features observed through probing the upper beam
2. Superior signal-to-noise ratio performance: Demonstrates that TPAT exhibits significantly lower noise compared to EIT, primarily due to suppression of atom number fluctuations
3. High-n state detection capability: Achieves resolution of Rydberg states with principal quantum numbers up to n=80, whereas EIT methods only reach n=54
4. Frequency-locking application: Demonstrates that TPAT features can generate error signals for stabilizing upper laser frequency

Methodology Details

Task Definition

Investigation of two-photon spectroscopic features in a three-level system |g⟩-|e⟩-|r⟩, where:

• Input: Two counter-propagating laser beams (lower beam 420 nm, upper beam 1012-1026 nm)
• Output: Transmitted light intensity as a function of frequency detuning
• Objective: Achieve high signal-to-noise ratio Rydberg state detection in Doppler-broadened media

Experimental Architecture

Physical System

• Atomic system: $^{87}$Rb atoms, mapped as |g⟩ = |5S₁/₂, F = 2⟩, |e⟩ = |6P₃/₂, F' = 3⟩, |r⟩ = |nS₁/₂⟩
• Laser configuration: Lower beam (420 nm, right-hand circular polarization) and upper beam (1012-1026 nm, left-hand circular polarization)
• Atomic vapor cell: Length 7.5 cm, $^{87}$Rb vapor cell at temperatures up to 96°C

Spectroscopic Mechanism Comparison

EIT Mechanism:

• Strong upper beam modifies the intermediate state; weak lower beam couples to the modified state
• Forms a dark state at two-photon resonance, producing a transparency window
• In Doppler broadening, Autler-Townes absorption features from different velocity classes overlap, masking the EIT signal

TPAT Mechanism:

• Strong lower beam splits the intermediate state; weak upper beam probes the transition
• Forms an avoided crossing structure, allowing tangent lines to be drawn at the turning point
• More velocity classes participate in the transition, enhancing signal strength

Technical Innovations

1. Velocity class analysis: Theoretical simulations reveal the separation of velocity class branches in TPAT, avoiding the overlap problem in EIT
2. Noise source identification: Systematic analysis of how atom number fluctuations affect different spectroscopic techniques, demonstrating that TPAT is less affected
3. Signal optimization: Maximizes two-photon excitation efficiency through beam shaping and power optimization

Experimental Setup

Experimental Parameters

• Vapor cell temperature: 89-96°C
• Lower beam power: 2.8-5.0 mW/mm² for EIT probing, 67-120 mW/mm² for TPAT probing
• Upper beam power: 170 mW/mm² for EIT probing, 10 mW/mm² for TPAT probing
• Measurement bandwidth: 1 MHz
• Rydberg state range: n = 30-80

Evaluation Metrics

1. Contrast:
   • TPAT: Ratio of upper beam transmission decrease to non-resonant background
   • EIT: Ratio of lower beam transmission increase to single-photon absorption
2. Signal-to-noise ratio: Ratio of signal amplitude to root-mean-square noise of non-resonant background
3. Ideal signal-to-noise ratio: Signal-to-noise ratio after removing technical noise

Comparison Methods

• Conventional EIT spectroscopy technique
• Performance comparison at different n values
• Comparison of raw and ideal signal-to-noise ratios

Experimental Results

Main Results

Signal Contrast

• TPAT contrast: Approximately 2×10⁻³ (n=30)
• EIT contrast: Approximately 6×10⁻³ (n=30)
• Lower TPAT contrast is primarily due to weak oscillator strength of the upper transition

Signal-to-Noise Ratio Performance

• TPAT: Can detect Rydberg states up to n=80
• EIT: Can only detect up to n=54
• TPAT advantage primarily stems from lower noise levels

Noise Analysis

Systematic investigation reveals that EIT noise originates from:

1. Atom number fluctuations: Follow Poisson statistics, noise ∝ √D (D is optical density)
2. Beam waist dependence: Noise ∝ 1/√w², confirming the impact of atom number fluctuations
3. Lower TPAT noise: Primarily limited by technical noise, less affected by atom number fluctuations

Ablation Studies

Temperature Dependence

• Higher temperature increases atomic density, improving TPAT signal
• However, EIT signal is simultaneously affected by stronger Doppler broadening

Power Optimization

• TPAT improves with increased lower beam intensity
• EIT improves with increased upper beam Rabi frequency
• Saturation limits exist for both

Frequency-Locking Demonstration

Using 300 kHz modulation transfer spectroscopy technique:

• Successfully generated TPAT error signals
• Lock capture range can be dynamically adjusted by tuning lower laser intensity (>8 MHz)
• Suitable for lasers with intrinsically narrow linewidth but prone to drift

Related Work

Rydberg Spectroscopy Field

• Widespread application of EIT techniques in Rydberg state detection 9,11,12
• Theoretical studies on Doppler broadening effects in different wavelength schemes 23-25
• Rydberg EIT experiments in various atomic systems 13-15,27-29

Spectroscopic Technique Development

• Fundamental theory of Autler-Townes effect
• Physical mechanisms of electromagnetically induced transparency
• Development of laser frequency stabilization techniques

Novelty of This Work

Compared to existing work, this paper is the first to:

1. Systematically study TPAT as an alternative to EIT
2. Quantitatively compare the performance of both techniques in Doppler-broadened media
3. Demonstrate TPAT advantages in high-n state detection

Conclusions and Discussion

Main Conclusions

1. TPAT technique advantages: In Doppler-broadened media with inverted wavelength schemes, TPAT exhibits better signal-to-noise ratio compared to EIT
2. High-n state detection capability: TPAT can detect Rydberg states with principal quantum numbers up to n=80
3. Practical value: TPAT can be used for laser frequency locking, particularly suitable for intrinsically narrow-linewidth lasers

Limitations

1. Lower contrast: Due to weak oscillator strength of the upper transition, TPAT has lower absolute contrast than EIT
2. Power requirements: Requires relatively high lower beam power to obtain sufficient signal
3. Linewidth limitations: Error signal is relatively broad, not as precise as ultra-low-expansion cavity references

Future Directions

1. Technical noise optimization: Reduce technical noise through improved detectors and electronics
2. Multi-pass configurations: Use multi-pass cells to increase effective optical density
3. Other atomic systems: Explore TPAT technique in new atomic species
4. Linewidth narrowing: Investigate methods to improve frequency-locking precision

In-Depth Evaluation

Strengths

1. Strong innovation: First systematic study of TPAT technique, providing new tools for Rydberg spectroscopy
2. In-depth theoretical analysis: Velocity class analysis clearly explains TPAT advantages over EIT
3. Comprehensive experiments: Systematic measurements from n=30 to n=80, quantitative noise source analysis
4. High practical value: Demonstrates frequency-locking applications, addressing real technical needs

Weaknesses

1. Simplified theoretical model: Three-level model may neglect some complex atomic structure effects
2. Incomplete parameter optimization: Optimal experimental parameters for different n values may require further refinement
3. Unverified long-term stability: Long-term stability and drift characteristics of frequency locking require more testing

Impact

1. Academic contribution: Provides new experimental techniques and theoretical understanding for atomic spectroscopy
2. Application prospects: Has practical value in quantum technology and precision measurement fields
3. Reproducibility: Relatively simple experimental setup, facilitating reproduction and promotion in other laboratories

Applicable Scenarios

1. Rydberg atom experiments: Particularly suitable for two-photon excitation in inverted wavelength schemes
2. Laser frequency stabilization: Suitable for laser systems with intrinsically narrow linewidth but prone to drift
3. Quantum sensing applications: Can be used in electric field sensors based on Rydberg atoms
4. Educational demonstrations: Provides new experimental content for atomic physics teaching

References

The paper cites 38 important references covering classical and recent research results in Rydberg atoms, electromagnetically induced transparency, quantum sensing, and related fields, providing a solid theoretical foundation and experimental reference for this work.