The local well-posedness, blow-up phenomena and ill-posedness of a new fifth-order Camassa-Holm type equation

Basic Information

• Paper ID: 2510.13164
• Title: The local well-posedness, blow-up phenomena and ill-posedness of a new fifth-order Camassa-Holm type equation
• Authors: Yiyao Lian, Zhaoyang Yin (School of Science, Sun Yat-sen University, Shenzhen Campus)
• Classification: math.AP (Partial Differential Equations)
• Publication Date: October 15, 2025
• Paper Link: https://arxiv.org/abs/2510.13164

Abstract

This paper investigates a new fifth-order Camassa-Holm type equation derived by Li. First, local well-posedness of the Cauchy problem for this equation in Besov spaces is established in the Hadamard sense. Second, blow-up criteria are obtained. Based on this, by utilizing conservation laws and establishing local boundedness, precise blow-up results that determine the exact blow-up time are derived. Finally, ill-posedness of this new fifth-order Camassa-Holm type equation in the critical Sobolev space $H^{1/2}$ is established through norm inflation arguments.

Research Background and Motivation

Problem Background

The Camassa-Holm (CH) equation is a significant nonlinear partial differential equation in fluid dynamics and integrable systems: $u_t - u_{xxt} + 3uu_x = 2u_xu_{xx} + uu_{xxx}$

This equation possesses rich mathematical structures:

1. Complete Integrability: Admits a bi-Hamiltonian structure
2. Soliton Solutions: Admits peakon solutions of the form $ce^{-|x-ct|}$
3. Wave Breaking Phenomena: Captures wave breaking phenomena

Research Motivation

In recent years, higher-order Camassa-Holm type equations have attracted considerable attention. This paper studies a new fifth-order Camassa-Holm type equation derived by Li:

$u_t - 2u_{xxt} + u_{xxxxt} + \left(2u^3 + uu_x^2 + u^2u_{xx} - 18u_x^2u_{xx} + 3uu_{xx}^2 + 4uu_xu_{xxx} + u^2u_{xxxx} + u_{xxx}^2 + 4u_xu_{xx}u_{xxx} + u_x^2u_{xxxx}\right)_x = 0$

Characteristics of this equation:

• Simultaneously contains cubic nonlinear terms and high-order dispersive terms
• Admits two fundamental invariants $E(u)$ and $F(u)$
• Admits pseudo-peakon solutions with orbital stability

Research Significance

Compared to the known mCH and FOCH equations, this new equation still has many properties worthy of in-depth investigation, particularly regarding local well-posedness in Besov spaces, blow-up phenomena, and ill-posedness analysis.

Core Contributions

1. Established local well-posedness theory: Proved well-posedness of the equation in Besov spaces $B_p^{s,r}$ where $s > \max(1/2, 1/p)$
2. Obtained precise blow-up criteria: Provided sufficient conditions for solution blow-up and exact expressions for blow-up time
3. Proved ill-posedness in critical spaces: Established ill-posedness of the equation in the critical Sobolev space $H^{1/2}$ through norm inflation arguments
4. Developed technical methods: Applied Moser-type inequalities for refined estimates, utilized conservation laws and Lagrangian coordinate transformations to establish local boundedness

Detailed Methodology

Problem Formulation

Study the mathematical properties of the following Cauchy problem: $\begin{cases} n_t + (u^2 + u_x^2)n_x = G(u) \\ n = (1-\partial_x^2)u \\ u|_{t=0} = u_0 \end{cases}$

where $G(u)$ contains complex cubic nonlinear terms.

Main Technical Methods

1. Well-posedness Proof

Employs the approximating solutions method with main steps including:

Step 1: Construction of Approximate Solution Sequences Define smooth function sequences $(n^k)_{k\in\mathbb{N}}$ inductively by solving linear transport equations: $\begin{cases} n^{k+1}_t + ((u^k)^2 + (u^k_x)^2)n^{k+1}_x = G(u^k) \\ u^{k+1} = (1-\partial_x^2)^{-1}n^{k+1} \\ u^{k+1}|_{t=0} = S_{k+1}u_0 \end{cases}$

Step 2: Uniform Boundedness Through Moser-type inequalities and product estimates in Besov spaces, prove uniform boundedness of sequences in $L^\infty([0,T];B_p^{s,r})$.

Step 3: Convergence Analysis Utilize transport equation theory and refined commutator estimates to prove sequences are Cauchy in $C([0,T];B_p^{s-1,r})$.

Step 4: Uniqueness and Continuous Dependence Establish solution uniqueness and continuous dependence on initial data through Gronwall's inequality and interpolation techniques.

2. Blow-up Analysis

Blow-up Criterion: If the maximal existence time $T$ is finite, then $\int_0^T \|u(t)\|_{W^{1,\infty}}dt = \infty \quad \text{or} \quad \int_0^T \|u(t)\|_{W^{1,\infty}}\|n(t)\|_{B_\infty^{0,\infty}}dt = \infty$

Precise Blow-up Time: Under specific initial value conditions, the blow-up time is $T_2 = \frac{1}{\sqrt{K}}\ln\frac{-2\sqrt{K} + u_{0x}(x_0)u_{0xx}(x_0)}{2\sqrt{K} + u_{0x}(x_0)u_{0xx}(x_0)}$

where $K$ is determined by the $H^2$ norm of the initial value.

3. Ill-posedness Proof

Construct special initial value sequences $\{u_0^N\}$ such that:

• $\|n_0^N\|_{H^{1/2}} \lesssim \frac{1}{\ln N}$ (very small initial values)
• Maximal existence time $T^* < N^{-1/6}$ (rapid blow-up)
• $\limsup_{t\to T^*} \|n^N\|_{H^{1/2}} = +\infty$ (norm inflation)

Technical Innovations

1. Refined Besov Space Estimates: Obtain finer results than standard estimates through Bony decomposition and Moser-type inequalities
2. Effective Utilization of Conservation Laws: Cleverly exploit energy conservation $E(u) = \int_\mathbb{R}(u^2 + 2u_x^2 + u_{xx}^2)dx$ to establish key a priori estimates
3. Lagrangian Coordinate Techniques: Track singularity development through characteristic line methods to precisely determine blow-up time
4. Norm Inflation Construction: Design clever oscillatory initial values to prove ill-posedness in critical spaces

Experimental Setup

As this is a pure mathematical theory paper, it does not involve numerical experiments but rather verifies theoretical results through rigorous mathematical proofs.

Theoretical Verification Methods

1. Functional Space Theory: Employ Littlewood-Paley decomposition and Besov space theory
2. Transport Equation Theory: Apply a priori estimates for linear transport equations
3. Harmonic Analysis Tools: Utilize Fourier analysis and interpolation inequalities
4. Differential Equation Theory: Use Gronwall's inequality and comparison principles

Main Theoretical Results

Theorem 3.1 (Local Well-posedness)

Let $1 \leq p,r \leq \infty$, $s > \max(1/2, 1/p)$, and $n_0 = (1-\partial_x^2)u_0 \in B_p^{s,r}$. Then there exists $T > 0$ such that equation (1.2) admits a unique solution in $E_p^{s,r}(T)$, and the solution depends continuously on the initial value.

Theorem 4.2 (Blow-up Criterion)

If the maximal existence time $T$ is finite, then necessarily $\int_0^T \|u(t)\|_{W^{1,\infty}}\|n(t)\|_{B_\infty^{0,\infty}}dt = \infty$

Theorem 4.4 (Precise Blow-up Time)

Under specific initial value conditions, the solution blows up at time $T_2 = \frac{1}{\sqrt{K}}\ln\frac{-2\sqrt{K} + q_0(x_0)}{2\sqrt{K} + q_0(x_0)}$ where $q_0(x_0) = u_{0x}(x_0)u_{0xx}(x_0)$.

Theorem 5.1 (Ill-posedness)

Equation (1.2) is ill-posed in the critical Sobolev space $H^{1/2}$, manifesting as norm inflation phenomena.

Related Work

Classical Camassa-Holm Equation

• Fuchssteiner-Fokas (1981): First introduced within the hereditary symmetry framework
• Camassa-Holm (1993): Explicitly derived as a shallow water wave model
• Constantin et al.: Established well-posedness theory and blow-up analysis

Modified Camassa-Holm Equation

• FORQ Equation: Camassa-Holm type equation with cubic nonlinearity
• Fu et al. (2013): Local well-posedness in $H^s$ ($s > 5/2$)
• Gui et al. (2013): Well-posedness and blow-up phenomena in Besov spaces

Higher-order Camassa-Holm Equations

• Liu-Qiao FOCH Equation: Fifth-order Camassa-Holm equation
• McLachlan-Zhang (2009): Well-posedness in $H^s$ ($s > 7/2$)
• Tang-Liu (2015): Results in critical Besov spaces

Conclusions and Discussion

Main Conclusions

1. Established complete well-posedness theory for the new fifth-order CH equation in Besov spaces
2. Obtained precise blow-up criteria and blow-up time formulas
3. Proved ill-posedness in the critical space $H^{1/2}$

Theoretical Significance

• Enriches the mathematical theory of higher-order dispersive equations
• Develops technical methods for handling complex nonlinear terms
• Provides mathematical foundations for related physical models

Technical Contributions

• Refined application of Moser-type inequalities in Besov spaces
• Effective utilization of conservation laws in blow-up analysis
• Innovative application of norm inflation techniques in ill-posedness proofs

In-depth Evaluation

Strengths

1. Theoretical Completeness: Systematically establishes a well-posedness theory framework for the new equation
2. Technical Innovation: Develops multiple new techniques for handling higher-order nonlinearities
3. Result Precision: Obtains exact expressions for blow-up time
4. Method Generality: Techniques are generalizable to other similar equations

Technical Highlights

1. Refined Estimates: Achieves optimal Besov space estimates through Bony decomposition
2. Conservation Law Application: Cleverly exploits energy conservation to establish key a priori bounds
3. Characteristic Line Method: Effectively tracks singularity development
4. Construction Techniques: Designs clever counterexamples to prove ill-posedness

Limitations

1. Scope of Applicability: Results primarily apply to one-dimensional cases
2. Initial Value Conditions: Blow-up results require relatively strong initial value assumptions
3. Critical Indices: Behavior at critical space boundaries requires further investigation

Impact

• Makes important contributions to the theory of higher-order Camassa-Holm type equations
• Provides techniques with broad application prospects
• Establishes mathematical foundations for related physical models

Application Scenarios

1. Theoretical Research: Integrable systems and dispersive equation theory
2. Applied Mathematics: Shallow water wave theory and fluid mechanics
3. Numerical Analysis: Provides theoretical guidance for numerical methods

References

The paper cites 31 relevant references, primarily including:

• Classical works on Camassa-Holm equations
• Foundational theory of Besov spaces and harmonic analysis
• Important results on transport equations and well-posedness theory
• Recent advances in higher-order dispersive equations

Overall Assessment: This is a high-quality mathematical theory paper that systematically establishes a mathematical theory framework for the new fifth-order Camassa-Holm equation. The paper exhibits high technical content, methodological innovation, precise results, and makes important contributions to the development of this field.