Strong- vs weak-coupling lasing in polymer-film microcavities

Basic Information

• Paper ID: 2510.13384
• Title: Strong- vs weak-coupling lasing in polymer-film microcavities
• Authors: Denis A. Sannikov, Nailya M. Urazova, Maksim D. Kolker, Aleksandr V. Averchenko, et al.
• Classification: physics.optics, cond-mat.mes-hall
• Publication Date: October 16, 2025
• Paper Link: https://arxiv.org/abs/2510.13384

Abstract

Organic semiconductors are particularly attractive in polaritonics due to their large exciton binding energies and oscillator strengths. Among these, the ladder-type conjugated polymer poly(m-phenylene ethynylene) (MeLPPP) is renowned for its rigid backbone, narrow exciton linewidth, high photoluminescence quantum yield, and enhanced photostability, making it an excellent candidate for organic polariton devices. Although polariton lasing has been reported in various organic systems, systematic studies of the transition from polariton lasing to conventional photonic lasing within a single, well-controlled material platform remain limited. Understanding this crossover transition is crucial for distinguishing characteristics unique to polariton lasing from those of conventional lasing.

Research Background and Motivation

Problem Definition

The core problem addressed in this study is: how to systematically investigate and understand the transition mechanism from strong-coupling polariton lasing to weak-coupling photonic lasing in organic microcavity systems.

Significance

1. Fundamental Physics: The strong-weak coupling transition involves fundamental mechanisms of light-matter interaction, which is essential for understanding polariton physics
2. Device Applications: Low-threshold lasers have broad application prospects in optical communications, sensing, and display technologies
3. Materials Science Progress: Organic polariton materials provide new possibilities for room-temperature quantum optical devices

Limitations of Existing Approaches

1. Lack of systematic studies within a single material platform
2. Insufficient understanding of the strong-weak coupling transition mechanism
3. Inadequate investigation of vibrational-state-mediated exciton relaxation mechanisms

Research Motivation

By employing planar organic microcavities using MeLPPP as the active medium, this work systematically investigates the strong-weak coupling transition under cavity length modulation, revealing the essential differences between polariton lasing and photonic lasing.

Core Contributions

1. Established a systematic platform for studying strong-weak coupling transitions: Achieved continuous control from strong to weak coupling within a single material system by adjusting the effective cavity length
2. Revealed significant differences in lasing thresholds: Discovered that the lasing threshold increases by nearly an order of magnitude during the transition from polariton lasing to photonic lasing
3. Discovered gain-pulling effects: Emission energies in both lasing modes shift toward the polymer gain maximum
4. Confirmed the importance of vibrational-state-mediated mechanisms: Observed significant threshold reduction near vibrational mode resonance energies
5. Provided MeLPPP microcavity fabrication methods: Established reproducible organic microcavity fabrication procedures

Methodology Details

Task Definition

The research task involves achieving strong-weak coupling transitions in MeLPPP organic microcavities by adjusting microcavity geometric parameters, and systematically analyzing the differences in lasing characteristics between the two coupling modes.

Experimental Architecture

Material Preparation

• MeLPPP Synthesis: Multi-step chemical synthesis including monomer synthesis, polymerization reactions, and functionalization
• Microcavity Structure: Composed of two distributed Bragg reflectors (DBRs) sandwiching a 180 nm thick MeLPPP film
• DBR Fabrication: 12.5 pairs of alternating Ta₂O₅/SiO₂ quarter-wavelength layers with Q-factor ~2000

Cavity Length Modulation Mechanism

A one-time compression applied to upper and lower DBRs via a point-squeeze device creates a convex microcavity structure, enabling continuous cavity length adjustment from 500 nm to 1.8 μm through radial displacement.

Spectral Characterization System

• Excitation Source: 400 nm, 250 fs pulses, 500 Hz repetition rate Ti:sapphire regenerative amplifier
• Detection System: Transmission collection, momentum-space imaging, ±36° detection window
• Measurement Modes: Multi-pulse integrated imaging below threshold, single-pulse imaging above threshold

Technical Innovations

Coupling Strength Quantification

The system Hamiltonian is described using a coupled oscillator model:

$\hat{H} = \begin{pmatrix} E_{cav|k} & \hbar\Omega_1 & \hbar\Omega_2 \\ \hbar\Omega_1 & E_{X1} & 0 \\ \hbar\Omega_2 & 0 & E_{X2} \end{pmatrix}$

where $E_{cav|k}$ is the cavity mode eigenergy, $E_{X1}$ and $E_{X2}$ are the S₁⁰ and S₁¹ exciton energies, and $\hbar\Omega_1$ and $\hbar\Omega_2$ are the corresponding light-exciton coupling strengths.

Strong-Weak Coupling Criteria

• Strong Coupling: Observable upper and lower polariton branches with Rabi splitting >50 meV
• Weak Coupling: Parabolic dispersion with coupling strength approaching zero

Experimental Setup

Sample Preparation Parameters

• MeLPPP Concentration: 1 mM toluene solution
• Spin-Coating Conditions: 5000 rpm, 1 minute, 500 rpm/s ramp rate
• Film Thickness: 180 ± 20 nm
• Substrate Treatment: 15-minute plasma treatment to enhance hydrophilicity

Measurement Conditions

• Excitation Power Density: 10-10⁴ μJ/cm² range
• Excitation Spot: Gaussian distribution, ~10 μm 1/e² diameter
• Spectral Resolution: Determined by Princeton Instruments ProEM 1024BX spectrometer
• Temperature: Room temperature

Comparative Analysis Methods

• Reference Sample: 180 nm non-cavity MeLPPP film for ASE measurement
• Cavity Mode Analysis: Systematic comparison of different cavity orders (M = 3, 5, 9)
• Detuning Analysis: Cavity-exciton detuning range from -260 meV to +61 meV

Experimental Results

Main Results

Strong-Coupling Polariton Lasing Characteristics

• Threshold: P^pol_th = 62.6 μJ/cm² (M=3 mode, L=574 nm)
• Spectral Features: Nonlinear intensity growth, linewidth narrowing, blue shift
• Dispersion Features: k-space distribution contracts toward k∥=0, forming coherent macroscopic occupation state
• Rabi Splitting: Maximum value ~150 meV

Weak-Coupling Photonic Lasing Characteristics

• Threshold: P^ph_th = 245 μJ/cm² (M=9 mode, L=1768 nm)
• Threshold Increase: ~4-fold increase compared to polariton lasing
• Spectral Features: Strong nonlinear intensity growth, linewidth narrowing, red shift
• Dispersion Features: Maintains parabolic form without polariton branches

Gain-Pulling Effect

Both lasing modes exhibit emission energy shifts toward the ASE gain peak (2.545 eV):

• Polariton Lasing: Weakened blue shift
• Photonic Lasing: Enhanced red shift

Vibrational Mode Resonance Effect

Significant threshold reduction was observed near V₂ and V₃ vibrational mode resonance conditions, confirming the important role of vibrational-state-mediated exciton relaxation in polariton formation.

Cavity Length Dependence Analysis

• Strong Coupling Region: 550-1075 nm, Rabi splitting monotonically decreases with detuning
• Weak Coupling Region: >1723 nm, no obvious Rabi splitting
• Threshold Variation: Lowest polariton lasing threshold is nearly an order of magnitude lower than lowest photonic lasing threshold

Related Work

Current Status of Organic Polariton Research

1. Material Systems: Organic crystals, oligofluorenes, fluorescent proteins, molecular dyes, conjugated polymers
2. Device Applications: Light-emitting diodes, polymer lasers, photovoltaic cells, field-effect transistors
3. Functional Implementations: Tunable lasers, multi-mode lasing, all-optical transistors, logic gates, quantum simulation

MeLPPP Material Advantages

• Structural Features: Rigid rod-like backbone, methylene bridge stability
• Optical Properties: Narrow exciton linewidth, pronounced vibrational structure, small Stokes shift
• Device Performance: High PL quantum yield (30%), enhanced photostability

Innovation of This Work

Compared to existing research, this paper is the first to systematically investigate strong-weak coupling transitions within a single material platform, providing a more complete and controllable research approach.

Conclusions and Discussion

Main Conclusions

1. Successfully achieved controllable strong-weak coupling transitions: Continuous transition from strong-coupling polariton lasing to weak-coupling photonic lasing in MeLPPP microcavities was realized through cavity length modulation
2. Revealed essential differences between the two lasing modes: Polariton lasing is based on bosonic stimulation while photonic lasing is based on population inversion, leading to significant threshold differences
3. Discovered the critical role of vibrational states: Vibrational-state-mediated exciton relaxation significantly affects polariton formation efficiency
4. Confirmed the universality of gain-pulling: Both lasing modes exhibit energy pulling toward the material gain peak

Limitations

1. Insufficient temperature-dependence studies: Experiments were conducted only at room temperature, lacking temperature-dependence analysis
2. Limited time-dynamics analysis: Focus on steady-state characteristics with insufficient investigation of ultrafast dynamical processes
3. Simplified theoretical models: The coupled oscillator model employed does not account for disorder and inhomogeneous broadening effects
4. Missing device stability assessment: Systematic evaluation of long-term stability and environmental sensitivity is absent

Future Directions

1. Photonic lattice engineering: Design special cavity structures and photonic lattice configurations
2. Vibrational interaction control: Deeper investigation and control of vibrational-state-polariton interactions
3. Integrated polariton circuits: Development of room-temperature polariton devices and integrated circuits based on MeLPPP
4. Many-body physics research: Exploration of polariton-polariton interactions and many-body effects

In-Depth Evaluation

Strengths

1. Rigorous Experimental Design: Systematic study within a single material platform avoids material-related interference, providing highly convincing experimental comparisons
2. Advanced Technical Methods: The point-squeeze cavity length modulation technique is ingenious, k-space imaging technology is well-developed, and measurement precision is high
3. Clear Physical Picture: Clear elucidation of strong-weak coupling transition mechanisms with good agreement between theoretical analysis and experimental results
4. Broad Application Prospects: Provides important guidance for designing low-threshold organic lasers

Shortcomings

1. Limited Theoretical Depth: Primarily based on phenomenological coupled oscillator models, lacking deeper microscopic theoretical analysis
2. Insufficient Dynamics Studies: Inadequate investigation of temporal evolution of laser establishment and coherence properties
3. Limited Material Optimization Space: Unexplored possibilities for further optimizing MeLPPP performance through chemical modification
4. Device Implementation Challenges: Stability and reproducibility issues remain to be resolved for transition from laboratory samples to practical devices

Impact

1. Academic Contribution: Provides important experimental foundation and theoretical insights for organic polariton physics
2. Technology Advancement: Promotes development of organic photonics and polariton device technology
3. Application Potential: Offers new material platforms and design concepts for next-generation low-power photonic devices

Applicable Scenarios

1. Basic Research: Strong-weak coupling physics mechanisms, polariton many-body physics
2. Device Applications: Low-threshold lasers, all-optical logic devices, quantum optical devices
3. Materials Development: Organic semiconductor material design, optical material optimization

References

The paper cites 100 relevant references covering important works in polariton physics, organic semiconductors, microcavity photonics, and other fields, providing solid theoretical foundation and technical support for the research.

Overall Assessment: This is a high-quality experimental physics paper that deeply investigates the physical mechanisms of strong-weak coupling transitions in organic microcavities through systematic experimental design and precise measurements. The research methodology is scientifically rigorous, the results have important academic value and application prospects, and the work makes significant contributions to the development of organic polariton devices.