Using quasi-Darboux transformations to construct exceptional matrix polynomials

Basic Information

• Paper ID: 2510.13487
• Title: Using quasi-Darboux transformations to construct exceptional matrix polynomials
• Authors: Ignacio Bono Parisi, Antonio J. Durán, Ignacio N. Zurrián
• Classification: math.CA (Mathematical Analysis)
• Publication Date: October 15, 2025
• Paper Link: https://arxiv.org/abs/2510.13487

Abstract

This paper introduces two methods for constructing exceptional matrix polynomials. One method employs what the authors term quasi-Darboux transformations, which appears to be a more powerful approach for addressing non-commutativity issues arising in matrix-valued polynomials. The other method does not utilize any Darboux-type transformations. Using both methods, the authors construct five illustrative examples demonstrating the capabilities of each approach. These examples include exceptional matrix polynomials of Hermite, Laguerre, and Gegenbauer types, as well as an example with a Dirac delta weight matrix.

Research Background and Motivation

Problem Context

1. Matrix generalizations of classical orthogonal polynomials: The theory of scalar-valued orthogonal polynomials plays an important role in many areas of mathematics, particularly classical families such as Hermite, Laguerre, and Jacobi polynomials, which are eigenfunctions of second-order differential operators. M.G. Krein considered the matrix-valued version of this theory in 1949.
2. Emergence of exceptional orthogonal polynomials: Exceptional orthogonal polynomials are complete orthogonal polynomial systems that are orthogonal with respect to a positive measure and simultaneously eigenfunctions of second-order differential operators. They extend the classical Hermite, Laguerre, and Jacobi families but contain finite gaps in the degree sequence.
3. Complexity in the matrix case: Non-commutativity issues arise in the matrix setting. When applying Darboux transformations, seed functions P must satisfy additional assumptions, and eigenfunctions with scalar eigenvalues are extremely rare.

Research Motivation

• Develop more powerful methods for handling non-commutativity issues in matrix-valued polynomials
• Construct new families of exceptional matrix polynomials
• Extend the applicability of classical Darboux transformations

Core Contributions

1. Introduction of quasi-Darboux transformations: Proposes the concept of quasi-Darboux transformations with decomposition $D(y) = B(A(y)) + y\Psi(t)$, where $\Psi$ is a matrix function of $t$ rather than a constant.
2. Development of non-Darboux construction method: Presents a method for constructing exceptional matrix polynomials without using any Darboux-type transformations.
3. Construction of five concrete examples: Including exceptional matrix polynomials of Hermite, Laguerre, and Gegenbauer types, as well as an example with Dirac delta weight matrix.
4. Refinement of theoretical framework: Establishes a complete theoretical framework concerning symmetric operators, weight matrices, and exceptional polynomials.

Detailed Methodology

Problem Formulation

Construct exceptional matrix polynomials $P_n$, $n \in \mathbb{N} \setminus X$ (where $X$ is a finite set), such that they satisfy:

1. Orthogonality with respect to weight matrix $W$
2. Completeness in $L^2(W)$
3. Left eigenfunctions of a second-order differential operator

Core Concepts

Definition of Exceptional Matrix Polynomials

Definition 3: Let $X$ be a finite subset of non-negative integers. Matrix polynomials $P_n$, $n \in \mathbb{N}\setminus X$, are called exceptional (orthogonal) matrix polynomials if:

1. They are orthogonal with respect to weight matrix $W$: $\int_{\mathbb{R}} P_n(t)dW(t)P_k^*(t) = \Gamma_n\delta_{n,k}$
2. They are complete in $L^2(W)$
3. They are left eigenfunctions of a second-order differential operator of the form $D(y) = y''(t)F_2(t) + y'(t)F_1(t) + y(t)F_0(t)$

Quasi-Darboux Transformations

Core idea: In traditional Darboux transformations, the decomposition is $D(y) = B(A(y)) + y\Psi$, where $\Psi$ is a scalar constant. Quasi-Darboux transformations allow $\Psi(t)$ to be a matrix function of $t$.

Key Lemmas 6 and 7:

• Lemma 6: Provides necessary and sufficient conditions for $P = A(P)$ to be an eigenfunction of $\tilde{D}$: $A(\Psi) = A_0A_1^{-1}\Psi A_1$
• Lemma 7: For an eigenfunction $P$ and arbitrary matrix function $U$, defining $A(y) = -yU + y'(P')^{-1}PU$, the condition is automatically satisfied

Construction Methods

Method One: Quasi-Darboux Transformations

1. Selection of seed function: Choose a seed function $P$ from classical orthogonal polynomial families
2. Construction of first-order operator: Define $A(y) = -yU + y'(P')^{-1}PU$
3. Application of transformation: Obtain new polynomials $\tilde{P}_n = A(P_n)$
4. Construction of weight matrix: Construct new weight matrix via formula $\tilde{W} = (PU)^{-1}P'F_2W((PU)^{-1}P')^*$

Method Two: Without Darboux Transformations

Utilize Lemma 4: For matrices $M$ and point $t_0$ satisfying specific conditions, one can construct weight matrix $W + \xi M\delta_{t_0}$ ($\xi \geq 0$) such that exceptional polynomials are orthogonal with respect to this weight matrix.

Experimental Setup

Five Constructed Examples

Example 1: Hermite Type (One-step quasi-Darboux transformation)

• Initial weight matrix: $W_{a,\xi}(t) = e^{-t^2}e^{At}\begin{pmatrix}\xi & 0\\0 & 1\end{pmatrix}e^{A^*t}$
• Seed function: $P_{1,\xi(a)}(t) = \begin{pmatrix}2t & -a\\-a & t(2-a^2)\end{pmatrix}$, where $\xi(a) = 1-a^2$, $a^2 > 2$
• Result: Exceptional polynomials with degree gap $\{1\}$

Example 2: Hermite Type (Two-step quasi-Darboux transformation)

• Application of two-step transformation yields exceptional polynomials with degree gap $\{1,2\}$

Example 3: Laguerre Type

• Weight matrix: $W_{a,\alpha}(t) = e^{-t}t^\alpha\begin{pmatrix}t+a^2t^2 & at\\at & 1\end{pmatrix}$
• Non-polynomial seed function: $P(t) = e^t\begin{pmatrix}-(t+\alpha+2) & (t+\alpha+2)at\\0 & -(t+\alpha+1)\end{pmatrix}$

Example 4: Gegenbauer Type

• Weight matrix: $W_{a,r}(t) = (1-t^2)^{r/2-1}\begin{pmatrix}a(t^2-1)+r & -rt\\-rt & (r-a)(t^2-1)+r\end{pmatrix}$

Example 5: Non-Darboux Method

• Constructed using Lemma 4, independent of any Darboux transformation

Experimental Results

Main Findings

1. Completeness proofs: All constructed exceptional polynomials are complete in the corresponding $L^2$ spaces (as in Theorems 12, 14)
2. Orthogonality: Explicit orthogonality conditions and norm formulas are provided, such as: $\|P_n\|^2_W = \frac{n-1}{2(a^2-2)}\begin{pmatrix}1 & 0\\0 & -\frac{2}{a^2-2}\end{pmatrix}\|P_{n,\xi(a)}\|^2_{W_{a,\xi(a)}}$
3. Recurrence relations: All examples are verified to satisfy higher-order recurrence relations, such as seven-term recurrence relations: $q(t)P_n(t) = \sum_{j=-3}^{3} A_{n,j}P_{n+j}(t)$
4. Odd-order differential operators: Discovery of fifth-order symmetric differential operators in the Laguerre example, which do not exist in the scalar case.

Technical Achievements

1. Weight matrix construction: Successful construction of explicit weight matrix expressions, such as formulas (5.13) and (5.29)
2. Eigenvalue computation: Explicit eigenvalue formulas are provided (5.6)
3. Boundary condition handling: Singularity issues are avoided through appropriate parameter selection

Related Work

Historical Development

1. M.G. Krein (1949): First considered the theory of matrix-valued orthogonal polynomials
2. Emergence of exceptional polynomials: Pioneering work by Gómez-Ullate, Kamran, Milson (2007) and others
3. Darboux transformations: C. Quesne (2008) established the relationship between exceptional polynomials and Darboux transformations

Special Phenomena in the Matrix Case

1. Multiple differential operators: Matrix orthogonal polynomials can be common eigenfunctions of multiple linearly independent second-order differential operators
2. Non-uniqueness of weight matrices: Different weight matrices can correspond to the same differential operator

Conclusions and Discussion

Main Conclusions

1. Quasi-Darboux transformations provide powerful tools for constructing exceptional matrix polynomials
2. The matrix case is richer than the scalar case, with more construction possibilities
3. Non-commutativity issues can be resolved through appropriate technical approaches

Limitations

1. Incomplete picture: The authors explicitly note that the complete picture of exceptional matrix polynomials remains far from complete
2. Multi-step transformations: Implementation of arbitrary-step quasi-Darboux transformations remains challenging
3. Seed selection: How to select arbitrary numbers of seeds without introducing singularities remains an open question

Future Directions

1. Implementation of arbitrary-step transformations using quasi-determinants
2. Development of more general seed selection theory
3. Exploration of exceptional generalizations of more classical families

In-Depth Evaluation

Strengths

1. Theoretical innovation: The concept of quasi-Darboux transformations is novel and effectively addresses non-commutativity issues in the matrix case
2. Methodological diversity: Two different construction methods enhance theoretical completeness
3. Rich examples: Five concrete examples sufficiently demonstrate the effectiveness and broad applicability of the methods
4. Technical depth: Technical treatment is detailed, from differential operator theory to concrete calculations

Limitations

1. Computational complexity: Concrete construction processes involve extensive matrix calculations, potentially limiting practical applications
2. Parameter restrictions: Some examples require specific parameter ranges (e.g., $a^2 > 2$), limiting generality
3. Theoretical completeness: The authors acknowledge that the theoretical framework remains incomplete and requires further development

Impact

1. Academic value: Makes important contributions to matrix generalizations of orthogonal polynomial theory
2. Methodological significance: Quasi-Darboux transformations may have application prospects in related fields
3. Foundation for future research: Establishes a foundation for further research on exceptional polynomials

Applicable Scenarios

1. Integrable systems in mathematical physics
2. Special function theory
3. Representation theory and group theory applications
4. Orthogonal polynomial methods in numerical analysis

References

The paper contains abundant references spanning from classical work by Krein to recent research on exceptional polynomials, providing a comprehensive bibliographic foundation for related research.

Overall Assessment: This is a high-quality mathematical research paper that makes important contributions to the construction theory of exceptional matrix polynomials. The introduction of quasi-Darboux transformations is innovative, and the five concrete examples sufficiently demonstrate the effectiveness of the methods. Although the theoretical framework requires further refinement, it establishes a solid foundation for future development in this field.