qLOOK: A Minimal Information System for Digital Storage and Reproducible Analysis of qPCR experiments

Basic Information

• Paper ID: 2510.13520
• Title: qLOOK: A Minimal Information System for Digital Storage and Reproducible Analysis of qPCR experiments
• Author: Mirco Castoldi (Heinrich Heine University Düsseldorf, Germany)
• Classification: q-bio.QM (Biophysics - Quantitative Methods)
• Publication Year: 2025
• Paper Link: https://arxiv.org/abs/2510.13520
• Code Repository: https://github.com/mircocastoldi

Abstract

Quantitative real-time PCR (qPCR) is widely used for gene expression analysis, but inconsistencies in data storage and reporting limit reproducibility. Although the MIQE guidelines define the minimum information required for publication, they do not specify a structured digital storage format compatible with long-term reanalysis. This study proposes qLOOK (qPCR-LOg-boOK), a tool for standardized digital storage and reproducible analysis of qPCR experiments. qLOOK is an R-based modular system that extracts data from Thermo Fisher/ABI .EDS files, formats them into structured tables, performs standardized and statistical analyses, and generates log files documenting reference genes, calibrators, and analysis parameters.

Research Background and Motivation

Problem Identification

1. Data Storage Inconsistency: qPCR experimental data are typically saved as instrument-specific output files accompanied by manually compiled spreadsheets or text documents. This unstructured approach results in missing critical metadata or inconsistent records.
2. Reproducibility Challenges: Raw data may only be accessible through proprietary software, and analysis steps such as normalization or calibration are rarely documented in a reproducible manner. Even within the same laboratory, reproducing or reanalyzing experiments conducted years ago can be extremely difficult.
3. Limitations of MIQE Guidelines: While the MIQE (Minimum Information for Publication of Quantitative Real-Time PCR Experiments) guidelines define what information should be reported, they do not specify how to digitally store and preserve this data.
4. Electronic Laboratory Notebook Integration Requirements: With the adoption of electronic laboratory notebooks (ELNs) and increasing data management requirements, standardized digital storage templates are needed.

Research Significance

This tool has important implications for molecular biology and biomedical research:

• Enhances transparency and reproducibility of qPCR experiments
• Supports FAIR data principles (Findable, Accessible, Interoperable, Reusable)
• Facilitates long-term data management and scientific collaboration
• Reduces dependence on proprietary software

Core Contributions

1. Development of qLOOK System: An R-based modular tool for standardized processing and storage of qPCR data
2. Establishment of Minimal Information Model: Defines the minimum but sufficient data structure required for complete reanalysis of qPCR experiments
3. Implementation of Cross-Platform Compatibility: Supports multiple Thermo Fisher/ABI cycler models (7500, 7500Fast, StepOnePlus, Viia7, QuantStudio series)
4. Provision of Complete Reproducibility Framework: Ensures complete experimental reproducibility through structured data tables and analysis logs

Methodology Details

Task Definition

qLOOK aims to address standardized storage, processing, and reanalysis of qPCR data. The system's input is Thermo Fisher/ABI .EDS files, and the output is structured data tables and comprehensive analysis logs, ensuring complete experimental reproducibility.

System Architecture

qLOOK employs a three-module design architecture:

Module 1: Data Extraction and Formatting (qLOOK_Module1_v1.0.R)

• Function: Extracts and formats data from .EDS files
• Input: Folder containing .EDS files
• Processing Workflow:
  1. Automatically identifies and processes all available .EDS files
  2. Compiles results into structured spreadsheets (qLOOK_Data.xlsx)
  3. Generates reference gene stability reports (qLOOK_RefGenes.xlsx)
  4. Creates processing step log files (qLOOK_Summary.txt)
• Supported Algorithms: Uses ΔCq, GeNorm, and NormFinder algorithms to assess reference gene stability

Module 2: Data Normalization (qLOOK_Module2_v1.0.R)

• Function: Performs data normalization and expression quantity calculation
• Input: qLOOK_Data.xlsx file
• Processing Workflow:
  1. User selects reference genes and calibrator samples
  2. Generates normalized data (qLOOK_Norm.xlsx)
  3. Calculates relative expression levels (qLOOK_Express.xlsx)
  4. Generates distribution plots and updates logs
• Method: Uses the Livak method (2^-ΔΔCq) to calculate relative expression levels

Module 3: Statistical Analysis (qLOOK_Module3_v1.0.R)

• Function: Statistical analysis and data formatting
• Input: qLOOK_Express.xlsx file
• Analysis Methods:
  1. One-way analysis of variance (ANOVA)
  2. Paired t-tests
  3. Automatic generation of box plots
• Output: Statistical results files and GraphPad-compatible formats

Data Structure Design

qLOOK_Data.xlsx Structure

• Format: Matrix-style table
• Rows: Sample identifiers
• Columns: Target genes
• Values: Cq values
• Characteristics: Compatible with standard statistical and plotting tools

qLOOK_Summary.txt Log

Contains complete analysis records:

• Script version and timestamp
• List of processed .EDS files
• Instrument type
• Reference genes and calibrator samples
• Statistical thresholds
• Names of all generated files

Technical Innovations

1. Modular Design: Allows users to execute only relevant portions of the pipeline without redundant data extraction
2. Automatic Library Management: All required R libraries are automatically installed and loaded
3. User-Friendly Interface: Operated through graphical pop-up windows, requiring no programming experience
4. Cross-Version Compatibility: Automatically identifies and processes EDS documents with different internal structures
5. Complete Traceability: Every computational step is recorded, ensuring complete transparency

Experimental Setup

Testing Environment

• Supported Cyclers: 7500, 7500Fast, StepOnePlus, Viia7, QuantStudio6, QuantStudio3
• Software Requirements: R, RStudio, RTools
• File Format: Thermo Fisher/ABI .EDS files
• Operating System: Cross-platform support (Windows standalone executable planned)

Validation Methods

• Successful testing on multiple cycler platforms
• Verification of compatibility with EDS files generated by different software versions
• Testing of batch processing capabilities

Experimental Results

Functional Verification

1. Data Extraction Accuracy: Successfully extracts Cq values and metadata from various EDS file formats
2. Reference Gene Assessment: ΔCq, GeNorm, and NormFinder algorithms correctly implemented
3. Statistical Analysis: ANOVA and t-test results accurate and reliable
4. Reproducibility: Complete reproducibility of analysis through saved data tables and log files

Example Output Files

The paper provides specific examples of qLOOK_Data.xlsx and qLOOK_Summary.txt, demonstrating:

• Format of structured data tables
• Contents of comprehensive analysis logs
• Level of detail in metadata recording

User Experience

• Ease of Use: Usable without programming experience
• Automation Level: Minimizes manual intervention
• Processing Efficiency: Supports batch file processing

Related Work

Current State of qPCR Data Management

1. MIQE Guidelines: Establish standards for qPCR experiment reporting but lack digital storage specifications
2. Proprietary Software Dependence: Existing methods depend on instrument manufacturer software
3. Electronic Laboratory Notebooks: Lack qPCR-specific data organization templates

Advantages of This Work

1. Open Source: R-based open-source solution
2. Standardization: Provides unified data storage format
3. Extensibility: Modular design facilitates adaptation to other file formats
4. FAIR Compatibility: Conforms to FAIR data principles

Conclusions and Discussion

Main Conclusions

1. qLOOK provides a standardized method for qPCR data storage, processing, and reanalysis
2. The system ensures complete reproducibility by retaining minimum but sufficient information
3. Modular design supports future expansion to other qPCR file formats
4. The tool supports transparency, reproducibility, and long-term data management

Limitations

1. File Format Restrictions: Current version only supports Thermo Fisher/ABI .EDS files
2. Software Dependencies: Requires R, RStudio, and RTools environment
3. Metadata Scope: Currently does not include experimental metadata (e.g., operator, instrument ID)
4. User Training: Although designed to be user-friendly, still requires basic R environment setup

Future Directions

1. Format Extension: Support qPCR file formats from other manufacturers
2. Standalone Executable: Develop Windows executable files without requiring R environment
3. Metadata Enhancement: Expand metadata model to include more MIQE requirements
4. Cloud Integration: Support cloud-based data storage and analysis

In-Depth Evaluation

Strengths

1. Strong Practicality: Addresses actual needs in the qPCR field
2. Reasonable Design: Modular architecture facilitates maintenance and extension
3. High Standardization: Provides unified data format and processing workflow
4. Good Reproducibility: Complete log recording ensures analysis transparency
5. User-Friendly: Graphical interface lowers barriers to use

Weaknesses

1. Limited Format Coverage: Supports only single manufacturer file format
2. Relatively Basic Functionality: Statistical analysis features are relatively simple
3. Insufficient Validation Data: Lacks large-scale validation experiments
4. Missing Performance Evaluation: Does not provide processing speed and memory usage information

Impact

1. Academic Contribution: Provides practical tool for qPCR data standardization
2. Practical Value: Can be directly applied to daily laboratory work
3. Promotion Potential: Open-source nature facilitates widespread adoption
4. Standardization Promotion: May promote establishment of qPCR data management standards

Applicable Scenarios

1. Molecular Biology Laboratories: Daily qPCR experimental data management
2. Biomedical Research: Projects requiring long-term data preservation and reanalysis
3. Collaborative Research: Multi-laboratory data sharing and standardization
4. Teaching Environment: qPCR data analysis teaching and training

References

The paper cites key literature in the qPCR field, including:

1. Original MIQE guideline papers and 2025 revision
2. FAIR data principles
3. Reference gene stability assessment algorithms (ΔCq, GeNorm, NormFinder)
4. Livak relative quantification method

Overall Assessment: This is a practically valuable tool paper. The qLOOK system fills a gap in standardized storage and analysis of qPCR data. Although current functionality is relatively basic and supports only a single file format, its modular design and open-source nature provide a solid foundation for future expansion. This tool has positive significance for improving reproducibility of qPCR experiments and standardization of data management.