Totally Anti-symmetric Spinor Tensors in Minkowski Space

Basic Information

• Paper ID: 2510.13531
• Title: Totally Anti-symmetric Spinor Tensors in Minkowski Space
• Authors: Peng Liu (Beijing Information Science & Technology University), Tanweer Sohail (University of Jhang, Pakistan), Xiaoyu Jia (Beijing Institute of Education)
• Classification: math-ph math.MP
• Publication Date: October 16, 2025
• Paper Link: https://arxiv.org/abs/2510.13531

Abstract

This paper investigates totally anti-symmetric spinor tensors in Minkowski space. The spinor tensor $\varepsilon_{AB}$ possesses special properties, with its elements expressible as algebraic expressions of indices. All totally anti-symmetric tensors in Minkowski space can be expressed in terms of $\varepsilon_{AB}$. Utilizing this property, the authors provide a simple proof of the total anti-symmetry of the volume spinor tensor.

Research Background and Motivation

1. Problem to be Addressed: In four-dimensional Minkowski space, it is necessary to prove the total anti-symmetry of the volume spinor tensor. This plays a foundational role in solving Maxwell's equations in spinor form and in studying topological solutions of electromagnetic fields, such as knot solutions.
2. Significance of the Problem:
   • Spinor representation offers profound conceptual and computational advantages over tensor representation in describing physical quantities
   • Maxwell's equations in spinor form can be simplified to a single equation
   • Self-dual and anti-self-dual solutions are more concise in spinor form
   • Spinor representations of knots and links as stable electromagnetic field solutions are becoming increasingly fundamental
3. Limitations of Existing Methods: In the work of Penrose, Rindler, and others, concise formulas for the volume spinor tensor have been provided, but proofs of its total anti-symmetry have not been supplied.
4. Research Motivation: By representing spinor tensors as algebraic expressions of their indices, the proof of anti-symmetry properties can be reduced to direct algebraic computation.

Core Contributions

1. Proposed an algebraic expression method for spinor tensors: Discovered the representation $\varepsilon_{AB} = B - A$, where A and B are indices taking values 0 or 1
2. Constructed a complete basis of totally anti-symmetric tensors in Minkowski space:
   • 6-dimensional basis for (0,2)-type anti-symmetric tensors
   • 4-dimensional basis for (0,3)-type anti-symmetric tensors
   • 1-dimensional basis for (0,4)-type anti-symmetric tensors
3. Provided a concise proof of the total anti-symmetry of the volume spinor tensor: Utilized the algebraic expression method to reduce complex tensor operations to elementary algebraic operations
4. Established a systematic theoretical framework: Demonstrated that all totally anti-symmetric tensors can be expressed in terms of the fundamental spinor tensor $\varepsilon_{AB}$

Detailed Methodology

Task Definition

Prove the total anti-symmetry of the volume spinor tensor: $e_{AA'BB'CC'DD'} = i(\varepsilon_{AB}\varepsilon_{CD}\bar{\varepsilon}_{A'C'}\bar{\varepsilon}_{B'D'} - \varepsilon_{AC}\varepsilon_{BD}\bar{\varepsilon}_{A'B'}\bar{\varepsilon}_{C'D'})$

Theoretical Framework

1. Construction of Spinor Space

• Define an anti-symmetric bilinear function $\varepsilon_{AB} = -\varepsilon_{BA}$ on the two-dimensional complex vector space $W$
• Establish spinor space $(W, \varepsilon_{AB})$, where the group of linear transformations leaving $\varepsilon_{AB}$ invariant is $SL(2,\mathbb{C})$
• Spinor representation of a Minkowski space point $(t,x,y,z)$: $\begin{pmatrix} t+z & x+iy \\ x-iy & t-z \end{pmatrix} = \sqrt{2}\begin{pmatrix} \xi^0 \\ \xi^1 \end{pmatrix}(\bar{\xi}^{0'}, \bar{\xi}^{1'})$

2. Key Innovation: Algebraic Expression Method

• Core Discovery: $\varepsilon_{AB} = B - A$, where $A, B \in \{0,1\}$
• This implies: $\varepsilon_{00} = 0$, $\varepsilon_{01} = 1$, $\varepsilon_{10} = -1$, $\varepsilon_{11} = 0$
• Similarly: $\bar{\varepsilon}_{A'B'} = B' - A'$

3. Systematic Construction of Totally Anti-symmetric Tensors

(0,2)-type Tensors (6-dimensional basis):

• $\{oo\varepsilon + \varepsilon oo, i(oo\varepsilon - \varepsilon oo), 2i(\iota o\varepsilon - \varepsilon\iota o), \iota o\varepsilon + \varepsilon o\iota, i(\varepsilon\iota\iota - \iota\iota\varepsilon), \varepsilon\iota\iota + \iota\iota\varepsilon\}$

(0,3)-type Tensors (4-dimensional basis): Contains more complex combinations of $\varepsilon$ tensors, such as $\varepsilon_{AB}o^C(\varepsilon_{A'C'}\iota^{B'} + \varepsilon_{B'C'}\iota^{A'})$ and similar forms

(0,4)-type Tensors (1-dimensional): Spinor representation of the volume form $e_{abcd}$

Technical Innovations

1. Index Algebraization: Transforms abstract spinor indices into concrete numerical operations (0 and 1)
2. Computational Simplification: Complex tensor anti-symmetry verification is converted to simple algebraic identity verification
3. Unified Framework: All totally anti-symmetric tensors of various dimensions are incorporated into a unified representation system

Main Theorems and Proofs

Theorem II.3 (Total Anti-symmetry of the Volume Spinor Tensor)

Theorem Statement: $e_{AA'BB'CC'DD'} = i(\varepsilon_{AB}\varepsilon_{CD}\bar{\varepsilon}_{A'C'}\bar{\varepsilon}_{B'D'} - \varepsilon_{AC}\varepsilon_{BD}\bar{\varepsilon}_{A'B'}\bar{\varepsilon}_{C'D'})$ is a totally anti-symmetric spinor tensor.

Proof Strategy:

1. Utilize $\varepsilon_{AB} = B - A$ and $\bar{\varepsilon}_{A'B'} = B' - A'$
2. Transform the tensor expression into an algebraic expression: $e_{AA'BB'CC'DD'} = i[(B-A)(D-C)(C'-A')(D'-B') - (C-A)(D-B)(B'-A')(D'-C')]$
3. Verify three fundamental anti-symmetry relations:
   • $e_{AA'BB'CC'DD'} + e_{BB'AA'CC'DD'} = 0$
   • $e_{AA'BB'CC'DD'} + e_{CC'BB'AA'DD'} = 0$
   • $e_{AA'BB'CC'DD'} + e_{DD'BB'CC'AA'} = 0$
4. Confirm each equality through direct algebraic computation

Experimental Verification

Algebraic Verification Example

Taking the first anti-symmetry relation as an example: $e_{AA'BB'CC'DD'} + e_{BB'AA'CC'DD'} = i[(B-A)(D-C)((C'-A')(D'-B') - (C'-B')(D'-A')) - (B'-A')(D'-C')((C-A)(D-B) - (C-B)(D-A))]$

$= i[(B-A)(D-C)(C'-D')(A'-B') - (B'-A')(D'-C')(C-D)(A-B)] = 0$

Computational Complexity Analysis

• Traditional method requires verification of $4! = 24$ permutation anti-symmetries
• New method requires verification of only 3 fundamental relations
• Each verification is a simple algebraic identity

Related Work

1. Penrose & Rindler: Established the foundational theoretical framework for spinors and spacetime, but did not provide proofs of volume tensor anti-symmetry
2. Wald: Provided concise formulas for the volume form in general relativity
3. Topological electromagnetic field solutions research: Work on knot solutions by Bode, Bialynicki-Birula, and others provides application context for this research
4. Authors' prior work: The fundamental property $\varepsilon_{AB} = B-A$ was discovered during research on spinor descriptions of knot solutions

Conclusions and Discussion

Main Conclusions

1. Successfully established a unified spinor representation of totally anti-symmetric tensors in Minkowski space
2. Provided a concise proof of the total anti-symmetry of the volume spinor tensor
3. Discovered the algebraic expression method for spinor tensors with universal applicability

Theoretical Significance

• Provides new computational tools for spinor theory
• Simplifies verification of complex tensor properties
• Provides theoretical foundation for research on topological solutions of electromagnetic fields

Limitations

1. The method is primarily applicable to four-dimensional Minkowski space
2. Depends on specific choices of spinor basis
3. Generalization to higher-dimensional spaces requires further research

Future Directions

1. Explore applications of this method in describing topological properties of knots and links
2. Investigate generalizations to other spacetime backgrounds
3. Develop a spinor calculation system based on algebraic expressions

In-Depth Evaluation

Strengths

1. Strong methodological innovation: The discovery of $\varepsilon_{AB} = B-A$, though simple, is extremely fundamental and important
2. Computational elegance: Transforms complex tensor operations into elementary algebraic operations
3. Theoretical completeness: Systematically constructs bases of anti-symmetric tensors of various dimensions
4. High practical value: Provides useful tools for electromagnetic field theory and general relativity

Weaknesses

1. Limited scope of application: Primarily restricted to four-dimensional Minkowski space
2. Insufficient physical interpretation: Limited discussion of the physical meaning of the algebraic expression method
3. Lack of generalization discussion: Insufficient exploration of possibilities for generalization to other spacetimes

Impact

1. Theoretical contribution: Provides a new computational paradigm for spinor theory
2. Application prospects: Possesses potential application value in research on topological solutions of electromagnetic fields and general relativity
3. Reproducibility: The method is simple and explicit, easy to verify and apply

Applicable Scenarios

1. Solving Maxwell's equations in spinor form
2. Research on topological solutions of electromagnetic fields
3. Tensor calculations in general relativity
4. Spinor operations in quantum field theory

References

The paper cites the following important literature:

1. Penrose & Rindler: "Spinors and space-time" - Foundational spinor theory
2. Wald: "General relativity" - Volume forms in general relativity
3. Recent work on topological electromagnetic solutions: Research by Bode, Bialynicki-Birula, and others
4. Authors' prior work on electromagnetic knot solutions

Although this paper is not lengthy, it proposes a fundamental and important theoretical tool. The seemingly simple expression $\varepsilon_{AB} = B-A$ actually provides a powerful algebraic tool for spinor calculations, possessing significant theoretical value and application prospects.