Inverse designed Hamiltonians for perfect state transfer and remote entanglement generation, and applications in superconducting qubits

Basic Information

• Paper ID: 2510.13584
• Title: Inverse designed Hamiltonians for perfect state transfer and remote entanglement generation, and applications in superconducting qubits
• Authors: Tian-Le Wang, Ze-An Zhao, Peng Wang, Sheng Zhang, Ren-Ze Zhao, Xiao-Yan Yang, Hai-Feng Zhang, Zhi-Fei Li, Yuan Wu, Peng Duan, Ming Gong, Guo-Ping Guo
• Classification: quant-ph (Quantum Physics)
• Publication Date: October 16, 2025
• Paper Link: https://arxiv.org/abs/2510.13584

Abstract

Hamiltonian inverse engineering enables the design of protocols for specific quantum evolution or target state preparation. Perfect state transfer (PST) and remote entanglement generation are prominent examples, as they are key primitives in quantum information processing. However, Hamiltonians obtained through conventional methods often lack robustness against noise. With the aid of inverse engineering, the authors construct a class of Hamiltonians called the dome model by starting from noise-resistant energy spectra, significantly enhancing the system's robustness to noise. The model introduces a tunable parameter m that modifies energy level spacing and produces well-structured Hamiltonians. When m=0, it degenerates to the conventional PST model; in the large m regime, it simplifies to a SWAP model involving only two endpoint qubits. To address scalability challenges, the authors propose a cascading strategy that decomposes long-distance PST into multiple consecutive PST steps.

Research Background and Motivation

Core Problems

The core problems addressed in this research are achieving noise-resistant perfect state transfer (PST) and remote entanglement generation in quantum information processing. Specifically:

1. Noise sensitivity problem: Conventional PST and FST schemes are susceptible to coherent and incoherent noise in experiments, leading to reduced fidelity
2. Decoherence of intermediate qubits: In solid-state quantum devices, intermediate qubits maintain population during transmission, introducing multiple noise channels
3. Scalability challenges: As system size increases, coupling strength requirements grow dramatically, making long-distance transmission difficult

Significance

Perfect state transfer and remote entanglement generation are fundamental building blocks of quantum information processing, crucial for:

• On-chip quantum interconnects and modular quantum computing
• Increasing importance as quantum chip scale continues to grow
• Important applications across multiple platforms including superconducting qubits and optical waveguides

Limitations of Existing Methods

1. Conventional line model: While capable of achieving PST, it is sensitive to noise with intermediate qubits maintaining population during evolution
2. Adiabatic protocols: While capable of suppressing intermediate qubit population through dark state engineering, they require high-precision pulse timing control
3. Scalability limitations: Existing schemes face coupling strength upper bounds and excessively long transmission times in large systems

Core Contributions

1. Proposed dome model: Constructed a new class of Hamiltonians based on inverse eigenvalue methods with intrinsic noise-resistant properties
2. Unified framework: Simultaneously achieves FST (at t=0.25T) and PST (at t=0.5T) within a single evolution cycle
3. Theoretical analysis: Reveals hidden SWAP dynamics in the large m limit, providing physical intuition
4. Cascading strategy: Proposes decomposing long-distance transmission into multiple short-distance transfers, addressing scalability issues
5. Experimental feasibility: Particularly suitable for superconducting qubit platforms with tunable couplers

Methodology Details

Task Definition

• Input: Initial quantum state |1⟩ (or more generally |n⟩)
• PST output: Perfect transfer to |N⟩ (or |N-n+1⟩) at t=0.5T
• FST output: Generation of entangled state between endpoint qubits at t=0.25T
• Constraints: Hamiltonian must be tridiagonal (nearest-neighbor coupling) and mirror-symmetric

Inverse Eigenvalue Method (IEM)

The core method is based on orthogonal polynomial theory and Jacobi matrix relationships:

1. Eigenvalue spectrum design:

   λₛ(m) = s - (N+1)/2 + (s-2)(s-1)m/2
   

   
   where s = 1,2,...,N, and m is a tunable parameter
2. Hamiltonian parameters:
   • Frequency terms: ωₙ = (n-1)(N-n)mJ
   • Coupling terms: Jₙ = (J/2)√[n(N-n-1)m + n] × √[(n-1)(N-n)m + N-n]
3. Three-term recurrence relation:

   Pₙ(λ) = (λ - ωₙ)Pₙ₋₁(λ) - J²ₙ₋₁Pₙ₋₂(λ)
   

Dome Model Architecture

1. Frequency configuration: Qubit frequencies follow a dome distribution with maximum frequency at center and zero frequency at edges
2. Coupling configuration: Coupling strength reaches maximum in the central region
3. Parameter constraints: When m takes values 2,6,10,...(4k+2), FST and PST are supported; when m=4k, only PST is supported

Technical Innovations

1. Energy level separation: For large m, the system is divided into low-energy subspace (two lowest levels) and high-energy subspace
2. Effective model: In the large m limit, degenerates to an effective SWAP model between endpoint qubits
3. Noise suppression: Reduces noise channels by suppressing intermediate qubit population

Experimental Setup

Simulation Parameters

• System scale: Primarily verified on 1×5 qubit chains, extended to 2D networks and larger systems
• Evolution period: T = 200 ns, corresponding to J/2π = 5 MHz
• Parameter range: m from 2 to 102, covering evolution from dome to SWAP

Evaluation Metrics

1. Entanglement generation fidelity: F(t=0.25T) = Tr(ρ_Q1Q5 |ψ⟩⟨ψ|), where |ψ⟩ is a Bell state
2. State transfer fidelity: F(t=0.5T) = Tr(χχ_ideal), reconstructed through quantum process tomography
3. Noise robustness: Fidelity variation under different noise strengths

Noise Models

1. Coherent noise: Parameter deviations, Jₙ → Jₙ + ξₙJ, ωₙ → ωₙ + ηₙJ, where ξₙ,ηₙ ~ N(0,σ)
2. Incoherent noise: Relaxation time T₁ = 3-300 μs, pure dephasing time Tφ = 0.5-50 μs

Comparison Methods

• Line model: Conventional PST scheme when m=0
• Different noise types: Separately test sensitivity to intermediate qubit frequency, edge qubit frequency, and coupling strength

Experimental Results

Main Results

1. Dynamical evolution:
   • m=0: PST achieved only at t=0.5T
   • m=2: FST (Bell state) at t=0.25T, PST at t=0.5T
   • m=102: Significant suppression of intermediate qubit population, approaching SWAP dynamics
2. Enhanced noise robustness:
   • For intermediate qubit frequency noise: Fidelity significantly improves with increasing m
   • For coupling strength noise: Robustness clearly improves with larger m
   • For edge qubit frequency noise: Limited effect of m
3. Decoherence effects:
   • T₁ impact is relatively small (<2% improvement)
   • Tφ impact is significant (>10% difference)
   • Large m effectively reduces decoherence effects

Ablation Studies

Through analysis of energy spectrum and eigenfunction changes at different m values:

• Low-energy subspace: Two lowest levels remain unchanged
• High-energy subspace: Energy levels shift upward with increasing m
• Eigenfunction localization: Primarily concentrated at endpoints for large m

Scalability Analysis

1. 1D extension: Formula applicable to qubit chains of arbitrary length N
2. 2D extension: W-state generation achieved on 3×4 networks
3. System size effects: Larger systems perform better at fixed noise levels

Cascading Scheme Performance

For the dome model, total time for k cascaded sub-PSTs:

τ = πmN²/(8kJ_max)

This can reduce time by a factor of k compared to single PST.

Related Work

PST and FST Theoretical Foundations

• Bose scheme: Earliest proposal for unmodulated spin chain quantum communication
• Christandl et al.: Established mirror symmetry and energy level spacing conditions
• Kay et al.: Developed fractional revival theory

Experimental Progress

The paper summarizes experimental achievements by various research groups on different platforms:

• Superconducting platform: Fidelity 85.0%-99.2%, time scale 25-390 ns
• Optical waveguides: Fidelity 97.1%-98.2%
• Largest scale: 6×6 system (Xiang et al., 2024)

Inverse Engineering Methods

• Isospectral deformation: Hamiltonian transformations preserving energy spectrum
• Adiabatic channels: Suppressing intermediate state population through dark states
• Parameter optimization: Gradient-based Hamiltonian design

Conclusions and Discussion

Main Conclusions

1. Dome model successfully unifies FST and PST, achieving both functions within a single evolution cycle
2. Significantly enhanced noise resistance, particularly for intermediate qubit-related noise
3. Cascading strategy effectively addresses scalability, providing practical solutions for long-distance transmission
4. Theoretical framework is universal, applicable to multiple quantum platforms

Limitations

1. Edge qubit sensitivity: Limited improvement in robustness to endpoint frequency noise
2. Parameter constraints: m values restricted to discrete values
3. Experimental complexity: Large m requires higher coupling strength ratios
4. Cascading overhead: Shared qubits introduce additional time costs

Future Directions

1. Relaxing constraints: Exploring non-tridiagonal or non-mirror-symmetric Hamiltonians
2. Energy spectrum optimization: Investigating effects of spectrum design on dynamical properties
3. Fault-tolerant integration: Combining with quantum error correction codes to enhance cascading scheme performance
4. Multi-platform verification: Validating method effectiveness on optical, ion trap, and other platforms

In-Depth Evaluation

Strengths

1. Strong theoretical innovation: Cleverly combines inverse eigenvalue methods and orthogonal polynomial theory, providing a systematic Hamiltonian design framework
2. High practical value: Particularly suitable for superconducting qubit platforms with direct experimental feasibility
3. Thorough analysis: Reveals physical mechanisms of large m limit from effective model perspective
4. Comprehensive experimental design: Systematically tests effects of various noise types and system scales

Weaknesses

1. Theoretical completeness: Lacks deeper theoretical explanation for why this specific spectrum design provides noise resistance
2. Experimental verification: Primarily based on numerical simulations, lacking verification on real quantum devices
3. Comparative analysis: Insufficient systematic comparison with other noise-resistant schemes (e.g., adiabatic methods)
4. Optimization space: Parameter m selection primarily empirical, lacking optimal theoretical guidance

Impact

1. Academic contribution: Provides new design ideas and theoretical tools for quantum state transfer field
2. Practical value: Direct application potential for current superconducting quantum computing platforms
3. Reproducibility: Detailed method description and explicit formulas facilitate reproduction and extension
4. Inspirational value: Inverse engineering approach may inspire design of other quantum protocols

Applicable Scenarios

1. Superconducting qubits: Most suitable for platforms with tunable couplers
2. Modular quantum computing: Quantum state transfer between chips or modules
3. Quantum networks: Entanglement distribution in distributed quantum information processing
4. Quantum storage: State transfer between different storage units

References

The paper cites 95 relevant references covering PST/FST theoretical foundations, experimental progress, superconducting qubit technology, and other aspects, providing comprehensive literature review for the field. Important references include Bose's pioneering work, theoretical contributions by Christandl et al., and recent experimental verification results from various research groups.

Overall Assessment: This is a high-quality theoretical and applied quantum physics paper. The proposed dome model possesses important theoretical value and practical significance. The method demonstrates strong innovation, in-depth analysis, and significant contributions to the quantum state transfer field, particularly providing novel solutions for noise resistance and scalability.