Quantumness near the Schwarzschild Black Hole Based on W-State

Basic Information

• Paper ID: 2510.13666
• Title: Quantumness near the Schwarzschild Black Hole Based on W-State
• Authors: Guang-Wei Mi, Xiaofen Huang, Shao-Ming Fei, Tinggui Zhang
• Categories: quant-ph (Quantum Physics), gr-qc (General Relativity and Quantum Cosmology)
• Publication Date: October 14, 2024
• Paper Link: https://arxiv.org/abs/2510.13666

Abstract

This paper investigates quantum properties near the Schwarzschild black hole using W-states. The study examines the effects of the Hawking effect on l₁-norm quantum coherence, first-order coherence (FOC), entanglement filling (CF), and global coherence (GC) in Schwarzschild black holes, covering systems with one, two, and three physically accessible modes. The research demonstrates that for systems with three physically accessible modes, the black hole's Hawking effect both destroys and enhances quantum entanglement while destroying quantum coherence. For systems with one or two physically accessible modes, the Hawking effect produces positive effects on both quantum coherence and quantum entanglement. Additionally, the combined effects of the Hawking effect and environmental noise (AD channel) on relevant quantum properties are investigated.

Research Background and Motivation

Research Problem

The core problem addressed in this paper is: In the background of a Schwarzschild black hole, how does Hawking radiation affect the coherence and entanglement properties of quantum systems based on W-states?

Significance

1. Theoretical Significance: The combination of quantum mechanics and general relativity represents a frontier in modern physics. Understanding quantum information processing in curved spacetime has important theoretical value.
2. Practical Value: Quantum coherence and entanglement are fundamental resources for quantum information technology. Studying their behavior in extreme environments provides guidance for quantum technology development.
3. Scientific Verification: The publication of M87* and Sgr A* black hole images in 2019 and 2022 further validated general relativity, providing experimental foundations for related theoretical research.

Limitations of Existing Methods

1. Existing research is primarily based on GHZ states, lacking systematic study of W-state behavior in black hole environments.
2. Comprehensive analysis of quantum property changes under different numbers of physically accessible modes is lacking.
3. Research on the combined effects of environmental noise and Hawking effect is insufficient.

Research Motivation

Based on the unique symmetry and entanglement structure of W-states, this work systematically investigates the evolution of quantum properties near Schwarzschild black holes, providing new theoretical perspectives for quantum gravity theory and the black hole information paradox.

Core Contributions

1. First systematic study of W-state quantum properties in Schwarzschild black hole backgrounds, including multiple quantum metrics such as l₁-norm quantum coherence, FOC, CF, and GC.
2. Discovery of behavior patterns different from GHZ states: For three physically accessible modes, W-states exhibit complex behavior where the Hawking effect both destroys and enhances entanglement.
3. Establishment of a complete analytical framework: Covering all possible cases with one, two, and three physically accessible modes.
4. Investigation of combined environmental noise effects: Analysis of the joint action of AD channel and Hawking effect.
5. Provision of quantitative analysis: Specific mathematical expressions for various quantum metrics as functions of Hawking temperature.

Methodology Details

Task Definition

Investigation of the evolution of coherence and entanglement properties of W-state quantum systems near Schwarzschild black holes. Input: initial W-state and black hole parameters; Output: relationships between various quantum metrics and Hawking temperature.

Theoretical Framework

1. Dirac Field Quantization in Schwarzschild Spacetime

Schwarzschild metric:

ds² = -(1-2M/r)dt² + (1-2M/r)⁻¹dr² + r²(dθ² + sin²θdϕ²)

Positive frequency solutions of Dirac equation:

• Outer horizon solution: Φ⁺ₖ,out = ξe⁻ⁱωμ
• Inner horizon solution: Φ⁺ₖ,in = ξeⁱωμ

2. Bogoliubov Transformation and Hawking Radiation

Kruskal vacuum and excited states:

|0⟩ₖ = (1/√(e⁻ω/T + 1))|0⟩out|0⟩in + (1/√(eω/T + 1))|1⟩out|1⟩in
|1⟩ₖ = |1⟩out|0⟩in

where T = 1/(8πM) is the Hawking temperature.

3. W-State Evolution in Black Hole Background

Initial W-state:

|W⟩ABC = (1/√3)(|001⟩ + |010⟩ + |100⟩)

After Bob and Charlie approach the event horizon, the system evolves to:

|W⟩ABbCc = (1/√3)[α|00010⟩ + β|01110⟩ + α|01000⟩ + β|01011⟩ 
           + α²|10000⟩ + β²|11111⟩ + αβ(|10011⟩ + |11100⟩)]

where α = 1/√(e⁻ω/T + 1), β = 1/√(eω/T + 1).

Quantum Metric Definitions

1. l₁-Norm Quantum Coherence

Cl₁(ρ) = Σᵢ≠ⱼ |ρᵢⱼ|

2. First-Order Coherence (FOC)

D(ρxyz) = √[D²(ρx) + D²(ρy) + D²(ρz)]/3

where D(ρᵢ) = √(2tr(ρᵢ²) - 1)

3. Global Coherence (GC) and Entanglement Filling (CF)

Q(ρxyz) = (1/2)[C²x(yz) + C²y(zx) + C²z(xy)]
F(ρxyz) = {(16/3)Q(ρxyz)[Q(ρxyz) - C²x(yz)][Q(ρxyz) - C²y(zx)][Q(ρxyz) - C²z(xy)]}^(1/4)

Technical Innovations

1. Multi-mode Analysis: Systematic consideration of all cases with physically accessible modes ranging from 1 to 3.
2. Combined Effects Study: Integration of dual influences from Hawking radiation and AD channel.
3. Quantitative Relationship Establishment: Precise functional relationships between quantum metrics and Hawking temperature.
4. Comparative Analysis: Comparison with existing GHZ-state-based results, revealing unique W-state properties.

Experimental Setup

Theoretical Computation Framework

• Parameter Settings: ω = 1 (monochromatic frequency), Hawking temperature T as variable
• Mode Classification:
  • Physically accessible modes: fermionic modes outside the event horizon
  • Physically inaccessible modes: anti-fermionic modes inside the event horizon
• Environmental Noise: AD channel parameter γ values: 1/3, 1/2, 2/3

Analysis Scenarios

1. Case 1: Three physically accessible modes (A, B, C)
2. Case 2: One physically accessible mode (A) and two inaccessible modes (b, c)
3. Case 3: Two physically accessible modes (A, B) and one inaccessible mode (c)

Computational Methods

• Reduced density matrices obtained through partial trace operations
• Numerical calculation of quantum metric variations with Hawking temperature
• Analysis of trade-off relationships: D²(ρ) + F(ρ) ≤ 1

Experimental Results

Main Results

Case 1: Three Physically Accessible Modes

• Quantum Coherence: Cl₁(ρABC) = (2/3)(α² + 2α) decreases monotonically with T
• Quantum Entanglement: Q(ρABC) and F(ρABC) exhibit non-monotonic behavior, increasing then decreasing
• FOC: D(ρABC) decreases then increases
• Trade-off Relationship: D²(ρABC) + F(ρABC) ≈ 1, approaching perfect trade-off

Case 2: One Physically Accessible Mode

• All Quantum Metrics: Cl₁(ρAbc), Q(ρAbc), F(ρAbc) increase monotonically with T
• FOC: D(ρAbc) decreases monotonically with T
• Initial Value Properties: Cl₁(ρAbc)min = 0, Q(ρAbc)min = 4/9

Case 3: Two Physically Accessible Modes

• Consistent Trends: Similar to Case 2, quantum coherence and entanglement both enhance with T
• Numerical Differences: Specific values differ from Case 2, but overall trends remain similar

AD Channel Effects

Under Three Physically Accessible Modes

• Quantum Coherence Destruction: Cl₁ and D decrease with T
• Entanglement Enhancement: Q and F increase with T
• γ Parameter Influence: Increased γ leads to overall decrease in quantum properties

Other Cases

• Conclusions essentially consistent with noise-free cases
• AD channel primarily acts as overall suppression

Important Findings

1. W-State vs GHZ-State Differences: W-states under three accessible modes exhibit dual Hawking effects (both destroying and enhancing entanglement), contrasting with the pure destruction effect of GHZ states in reference 40.
2. Critical Role of Mode Number: The number of physically accessible modes significantly affects the manner of Hawking effect operation.
3. Robustness of Quantum Properties: Even as Hawking temperature approaches infinity, quantum entanglement and coherence do not completely disappear.

Related Work

Main Research Directions

1. Quantum Information in Non-Inertial Reference Frames: Investigation of acceleration effects on quantum states
2. Quantum Field Theory in Curved Spacetime: Study of quantum state evolution in black hole backgrounds
3. Quantum Coherence and Entanglement Measures: Development of quantitative descriptions for various quantum resources

Relationship to Related Work

• Continuity: Based on theoretical frameworks by Alsing et al. 27 and Wang et al. 28-29
• Contrast: Forms comparison with GHZ-state-based research by Ali et al. 40
• Extension: Incorporates FOC-CF trade-off theory by Dong et al. 23

Relative Advantages

1. Systematicity: First systematic study of W-state behavior in black hole environments
2. Comprehensiveness: Considers all possible mode combinations
3. Novelty: Discovers unique Hawking effect response patterns of W-states

Conclusions and Discussion

Main Conclusions

1. Complexity of Hawking Effect: The Hawking effect exhibits distinctly different operational modes for different numbers of physically accessible modes.
2. Uniqueness of W-States: Compared to GHZ states, W-states under three accessible modes exhibit dual Hawking effects.
3. Persistence of Quantum Resources: Quantum coherence and entanglement can partially persist under extreme conditions.
4. Modulation Effect of Environmental Noise: The AD channel primarily acts as overall suppression without altering fundamental trends.

Limitations

1. Theoretical Assumptions: Based on idealized Schwarzschild black hole models; actual black holes may be more complex.
2. Parameter Restrictions: Only considers specific frequency settings (ω=1).
3. Noise Model: Only investigates AD channel; other types of environmental noise are not addressed.
4. Experimental Verification: Lacks analysis of experimental verification possibilities.

Future Directions

1. Other Black Hole Types: Extension to Kerr black holes, Reissner-Nordström black holes, etc.
2. Multi-Particle Systems: Investigation of W-states with more particles and other multi-body entangled states.
3. Experimental Schemes: Design of possible experimental verification schemes.
4. Application Exploration: Exploration of application potential in quantum information processing.

In-Depth Evaluation

Strengths

1. Theoretical Rigor: Rigorous mathematical derivations with clear physical imagery.
2. Research Completeness: Systematic consideration of all possible mode combinations.
3. Innovative Findings: Revelation of unique W-state behavior in black hole environments.
4. Quantitative Analysis: Provision of precise mathematical expressions and numerical results.
5. Comparative Study: Comparison with existing GHZ-state results enhances credibility of conclusions.

Weaknesses

1. Experimental Feasibility: Insufficient discussion of practical experimental verification.
2. Physical Interpretation: Insufficient depth in explaining physical mechanisms behind W-state and GHZ-state differences.
3. Parameter Sensitivity: Limited sensitivity analysis for key parameters.
4. Application Prospects: Insufficient discussion of practical application value.

Impact

1. Academic Contribution: Provides new theoretical perspectives for quantum gravity and black hole physics.
2. Methodological Value: Established analytical framework can be generalized to other quantum states and spacetime backgrounds.
3. Inspirational Significance: Provides important reference for subsequent related research.
4. Interdisciplinary Value: Bridges quantum information and gravitational physics.

Applicable Scenarios

1. Theoretical Research: Fundamental theoretical problems in quantum gravity and black hole information paradox.
2. Quantum Information: Protection and utilization of quantum resources in extreme environments.
3. Cosmological Applications: Quantum effects in early universe and black hole evaporation processes.
4. Technology Inspiration: Provides theoretical foundation for future quantum technology applications in extreme environments.

References

This paper cites 55 important references, covering:

• Fundamental black hole physics theory (Schwarzschild 1, Hawking 2-4, etc.)
• Quantum information metric theory (Baumgratz et al. 19, Meyer & Wallach 24, etc.)
• Curved spacetime quantum field theory (Fuentes-Schuller & Mann 26, Alsing et al. 27, etc.)
• Related numerical studies (Ali et al. 40, Wu et al. 41, Kim et al. 42)

Overall Assessment: This is a high-quality theoretical physics paper making important contributions at the intersection of quantum information and gravitational physics. The research methodology is rigorous, results are innovative, and it provides new theoretical perspectives for understanding quantum phenomena in extreme environments. While there is room for improvement in experimental verification and application prospects, its theoretical value and academic significance are substantial.