Dirac Quasinormal Modes in Noncommutative Reissner-Nordström Black Holes

Basic Information

• Paper ID: 2510.13701
• Title: Dirac Quasinormal Modes in Noncommutative Reissner-Nordström Black Holes
• Authors: Nikola Herceg, Nikola Konjik, A. Naveena Kumara, Andjelo Samsarov
• Classification: gr-qc (General Relativity and Quantum Cosmology), hep-th (High Energy Physics - Theory)
• Publication Date: October 16, 2025 (last revised)
• Paper Link: https://arxiv.org/abs/2510.13701

Abstract

Noncommutative (NC) geometry provides a novel approach to exploring quantum gravity effects in black hole spacetime. This study investigates the Dirac quasinormal modes (QNMs) of deformed Reissner-Nordström black holes, where noncommutativity induces an effective metric with additional (r-φ) components. Employing a semiclassical model equivalent to NC gauge theory, the dynamics of massless Dirac fields are studied, and their QNM frequencies are calculated using the continued fraction method, enhanced through Gaussian elimination to handle six-term recurrence relations. The results reveal significant shifts in oscillation frequencies and damping rates relative to the commutative Reissner-Nordström case, exhibiting unique Zeeman-like splitting in the QNM spectrum driven by NC parameters.

Research Background and Motivation

1. Problem to be Addressed: This research aims to explore quantum gravity effects of noncommutative geometry in black hole physics, particularly investigating the quasinormal mode behavior of Dirac fields in the background of noncommutative Reissner-Nordström black holes.
2. Problem Significance: With the success of gravitational wave detectors such as LIGO, Virgo, and KAGRA, black holes have become laboratories for exploring extreme gravity. Quasinormal modes, as the "fingerprints" of black holes, carry detailed information about black hole geometry and the underlying gravitational theory, providing new observational windows for detecting quantum gravity effects.
3. Limitations of Existing Methods: Traditional studies of black hole quasinormal modes are primarily based on the classical general relativity framework, lacking descriptions of quantum effects at the Planck scale. While QNM studies of noncommutative black holes for scalar and gravitational fields exist, systematic research on fermionic fields remains lacking.
4. Research Motivation: Noncommutative geometry modifies the local structure of spacetime at the Planck scale by introducing a minimum length scale. This "fuzziness" may manifest in strong gravity regions, leaving "quantum fingerprints" for detecting quantum gravity.

Core Contributions

1. First systematic study of Dirac field quasinormal modes in noncommutative Reissner-Nordström black hole backgrounds
2. Development of numerical methods for handling six-term recurrence relations, extending Leaver's continued fraction method and combining Gaussian elimination techniques
3. Discovery of Zeeman-like splitting phenomena, revealing unique effects of noncommutative parameters on fermionic QNM spectra
4. Establishment of quantitative relationships between noncommutative effects and changes in QNM frequencies and damping rates
5. Provision of new theoretical framework for probing Planck-scale physics

Methodology Details

Task Definition

Study the propagation of massless Dirac fields in noncommutatively deformed Reissner-Nordström black hole spacetime, calculate corresponding quasinormal mode frequencies, and analyze the impact of noncommutative parameters on the spectrum.

Theoretical Framework

Noncommutative Geometry Construction

Employing Drinfeld twist formalism to construct noncommutative deformation:

F = e^(-i/2 θ^αβ ∂_α ⊗ ∂_β) = e^(-ia/2 (∂_t ⊗ ∂_φ - ∂_φ ⊗ ∂_t))

where the only non-zero component of the deformation tensor is θ^tφ = -θ^φt = a, with parameter a characterizing the noncommutative strength.

Effective Metric

Noncommutative effects lead to a corrected Reissner-Nordström metric:

ds² = f dt² - f^(-1)dr² - aqQ sin²θ dr dφ - r²dΩ₂²

The key innovation is the appearance of a non-diagonal r-φ term, arising purely from spacetime noncommutativity.

Dirac Equation

The Dirac equation in curved spacetime:

(iγᵃ(∇ₐ + Aₐ) - m)Ψ = 0

Using specific γ-matrix representations and spinor decomposition, the equation is reduced to two coupled second-order radial equations.

Numerical Solution Method

Variable Separation

Employing the following separation of variables:

Ψ = e^(i(νφ-ωt)) (ψ₁(r,θ), ψ₂(r,θ))ᵀ

Six-Term Recurrence Relation

Noncommutative corrections lead to more complex six-term recurrence relations compared to the classical case:

Aₙaₙ₊₁ + Bₙaₙ + Cₙaₙ₋₁ + Dₙaₙ₋₂ + Eₙaₙ₋₃ + Fₙaₙ₋₄ = 0

Gaussian Elimination Method

Simplifying the six-term recurrence relation to three-term form:

α̃ₙaₙ₊₁ + β̃ₙaₙ + γ̃ₙaₙ₋₁ = 0

Technical Innovations

1. Extended Leaver Method: First extension of Leaver's continued fraction method to handle six-term recurrence relations
2. Gaussian Elimination Technique: Systematic simplification of complex recurrence relations
3. Nollert Tail Estimation: Improving numerical stability and accuracy
4. Linear Approximation: Systematic analysis under first-order approximation in noncommutative parameter a

Experimental Setup

Parameter Ranges

• Black hole mass: M = 1 (normalized)
• Charge ratio: Q/M ∈ [0, 1)
• Noncommutative parameter: a ∈ -0.5, 0.5 (illustrative values)
• Magnetic quantum number: ν = ±1/2, ±3/2
• Angular momentum quantum number: j = 1/2, 3/2
• Chirality: s = ±1/2

Boundary Conditions

Standard QNM boundary conditions:

• At event horizon: purely ingoing waves
• At spatial infinity: purely outgoing waves

Numerical Methods

• Continued fraction truncation: N ∼ 200 terms
• Convergence criterion: relative error < 10⁻⁶
• Nollert tail correction: improving accuracy

Experimental Results

Main Results

Zeeman-Like Splitting

Figure 1 shows linear dependence of QNM frequencies on noncommutative parameter a, with clear Zeeman-like splitting phenomena:

• Both real part ωᵣ and imaginary part ωᵢ of frequencies vary linearly with a
• Different magnetic quantum numbers ν exhibit different splitting patterns
• Splitting magnitude depends on values of j and s

Charge Coupling Effects

Figures 2-3 display QNM spectrum dependence on charge coupling qQ:

• Noncommutative effects significantly influence imaginary frequency ωᵢ (damping rate)
• Real frequency ωᵣ is affected relatively less
• Phase transition-like features observed near Q/M ∼ 0.9

Frequency Trajectory Analysis

Figure 4 shows QNM trajectories in the ωᵣ-ωᵢ plane:

• Noncommutative effects strengthen with increasing Q/M
• Trajectory shapes undergo systematic changes
• Method fails near extremal limit (Q/M → 1)

Quantitative Analysis

1. Frequency Shift: Frequency shifts relative to classical case are proportional to noncommutative parameter a
2. Damping Rate Changes: Variations in imaginary frequency are more pronounced than in real part
3. Symmetry Breaking: Breaking of azimuthal symmetry leads to splitting of ±ν modes

Physical Interpretation

Physical mechanism of Zeeman-like splitting:

• Noncommutativity introduces a preferred φ direction
• Although not a physical rotation, produces rotation-like effects
• Spontaneous breaking of azimuthal symmetry

Related Work

Main Research Directions

1. Classical Black Hole QNMs: Pioneering work by Leaver, Nollert, and others
2. Noncommutative Geometry: Theoretical foundations by Seiberg-Witten, Connes, and others
3. Quantum Gravity Phenomenology: Quantum correction effects in black hole physics

Position of This Work

• Extends noncommutative QNM studies from scalar and gravitational fields to fermionic case
• First systematic study of Dirac field noncommutative black hole QNMs
• Forms complete system with scalar and spin-2 field studies in references 7-9

Comparative Advantages

1. Method Innovation: Development of numerical techniques for handling six-term recurrence relations
2. Phenomenon Discovery: Revelation of fermionic-specific Zeeman-like splitting
3. Systematicity: Provides comprehensive parameter space analysis

Conclusions and Discussion

Main Conclusions

1. Universality of Noncommutative Effects: Fermionic QNMs similarly exhibit significant noncommutative corrections
2. Zeeman-Like Splitting: This is a universal characteristic of noncommutative black holes, independent of field spin
3. Detection Possibility: QNMs serve as effective tools for detecting spacetime noncommutativity
4. Gravitational Wave Astronomy Applications: Provides theoretical expectations for future high-precision gravitational wave observations

Limitations

1. Perturbative Approximation: Valid only under first-order approximation in noncommutative parameter a
2. Massless Restriction: Does not consider massive Dirac fields
3. Non-Extremal Restriction: Method fails near extremal black hole limit (Q/M → 1)
4. Semiclassical Approximation: Background geometry still treated classically

Future Directions

1. Massive Fermions: Extension to massive Dirac fields
2. Extremal Limit: Development of analytical methods applicable to extremal black holes
3. Higher-Order Corrections: Consideration of higher-order effects in noncommutative parameters
4. Rotating Black Holes: Investigation of noncommutative generalizations of Kerr black holes
5. Observational Constraints: Utilization of gravitational wave data to constrain noncommutative parameters

In-Depth Evaluation

Strengths

1. Theoretical Innovation:
   • First systematic study of fermionic QNMs in noncommutative black holes
   • Development of numerical methods for complex recurrence relations
   • Revelation of universal Zeeman-like splitting phenomena
2. Methodological Rigor:
   • Detailed and complete mathematical derivations
   • Reliable and stable numerical methods
   • Clear and explicit physical picture
3. Result Importance:
   • Provides new theoretical tools for quantum gravity phenomenology
   • Enriches content of black hole gravitational wave spectroscopy
   • Possesses potential observational significance
4. Writing Quality:
   • Clear structure and rigorous logic
   • Sufficient technical details
   • Intuitive and effective figures and tables

Weaknesses

1. Realism of Parameter Selection:
   • Noncommutative parameter a values are too large; should be at Planck scale
   • Lacks in-depth discussion of parameter physical meaning
2. Limitations of Approximations:
   • First-order approximation may be insufficient to capture all important effects
   • Semiclassical treatment neglects quantum corrections to background geometry
3. Observational Feasibility:
   • Insufficient discussion of observational feasibility of effects
   • Lacks comparison with existing gravitational wave data
4. Completeness:
   • Does not address massive cases and extremal limits
   • Lacks comparison with other quantum gravity models

Impact

1. Academic Contribution:
   • Provides new computational tools for noncommutative quantum gravity research
   • Advances cross-disciplinary research between black hole physics and quantum gravity
   • Provides theoretical foundation for gravitational wave astronomy
2. Practical Value:
   • Methods generalizable to other black hole backgrounds
   • Provides theoretical expectations for future observations
   • Aids in constraining quantum gravity models
3. Reproducibility:
   • Detailed and complete mathematical derivations
   • Sufficient description of numerical methods
   • Results verifiable and extendable

Applicable Scenarios

1. Theoretical Physics Research: Quantum gravity, black hole physics, noncommutative geometry
2. Gravitational Wave Astronomy: High-precision gravitational wave data analysis and theoretical expectations
3. Numerical Methods: Solution techniques for complex recurrence relations
4. Phenomenological Research: Observational characteristics of quantum gravity effects

References

The paper cites 15 important references, covering:

• Experimental progress in gravitational wave detection
• Theoretical foundations of noncommutative geometry
• Classical studies of black hole quasinormal modes
• Related noncommutative black hole QNM work

Key references include Leaver's continued fraction method, Seiberg-Witten's noncommutative geometry theory, and related prior work by the author team.

Overall Evaluation: This is a high-quality theoretical physics paper making important contributions at the intersection of noncommutative quantum gravity and black hole physics. Despite certain limitations, its theoretical innovation and methodological value make it a significant advance in the field.