Puzzlegram: a Serious Game Designed for the Elderly in Group Settings

Basic Information

• Paper ID: 2510.13813
• Title: Puzzlegram: a Serious Game Designed for the Elderly in Group Settings
• Author: Sunny Choi (MusEdLab, New York University)
• Classification: cs.HC (Human-Computer Interaction), cs.CY (Computers and Society)
• Publication Time/Conference: Not explicitly specified
• Paper Link: https://arxiv.org/abs/2510.13813

Abstract

This research presents an original serious game prototype called "Puzzlegram," specifically designed for elderly populations in group settings. Puzzlegram is precisely engineered to reinforce memory, auditory interaction, and tactile responses to visual signals, with music as a core component. Music is introduced as a key element in establishing game design, providing meaningful contextualized content (familiar music from the past) to set game mechanics, thereby facilitating the construction of the serious game design process. The research discusses the necessity of designing serious games to promote meaningful interactions and developing a comprehensive framework for constructing purposeful serious game design. The potential integration of artificial intelligence in Puzzlegram may involve assigning new dimensions to its existing problem-solving tasks by adapting to different cognitive functional states based on individual interactions with the game for monitoring purposes.

Research Background and Motivation

Problem Definition

1. Core Issue: Existing serious games for the elderly lack originality and rigorous game design research, with many products merely repackaging conventional games without specific design considerations for the elderly population's unique needs.
2. Significance:
   • Global population aging trends make it urgent to design effective cognitive training tools for the elderly
   • Elderly individuals face challenges of physical and cognitive function deterioration, requiring specialized interventions
   • Traditional game scoring systems cannot accurately reflect the cognitive health status of elderly players
3. Limitations of Existing Approaches:
   • Lack of specialized design for elderly populations
   • Neglect of target user group participation in the design process
   • Absence of theoretically-grounded purposeful design frameworks
4. Research Motivation:
   • Based on the capability approach theoretical framework
   • Emphasis on empowering elderly individuals rather than viewing them solely as care recipients
   • Promoting meaningful interactions through the familiarity and nostalgia of music

Core Contributions

1. Original Game Design: Created an original serious game prototype, Puzzlegram, specifically designed for elderly populations in group settings
2. Theoretical Framework Application: Successfully applied the capability approach theory to serious game design, emphasizing user capabilities and functionality
3. Multimodal Interaction Design: Integrated auditory, visual, and tactile interaction modalities, with music as a core design element
4. Collaborative Game Mechanics: Designed non-competitive team collaboration game modes that promote social interaction
5. Design Methodology Contribution: Proposed design considerations and future research directions for constructing purposeful serious games

Methodology Details

Theoretical Foundation

Capability Approach Framework: Based on Nussbaum and Sen's capability approach, emphasizing individual functional capabilities—what individuals are able to do or become—recognizing the non-material value of effective opportunities.

Game Design Principles

1. Socially Responsible Design: Design driven by the capability approach considering human diversity
2. Cultural Commonality Utilization: Promoting anticipation and expectation through autobiographical memory of music
3. Meaningful Interaction: Prioritizing player agency rather than environmental mastery

System Architecture

Hardware Design

• Controllers: Each player possesses an independent hardware controller
• Tactile Areas: 16 identical white square areas, each corresponding to specific colors and music segments
• Connection Method: Three hardware devices connected via Bluetooth

Software Design

• Display Interface: Independent monitor displaying game interface and color feedback
• Music System: Designed using digital audio workstations such as Logic Pro and Ableton
• Interaction Logic: Entirely driven by players' tactile input on the digital interface

Game Mechanics Design

Core Rules

1. Objective: Three players work as a team to reach the game endpoint, collaboratively constructing a complete familiar song
2. Non-Competitive: No ranking system; individual victory is impossible
3. Music-Driven: Plays short musical segments of well-known melodies, represented by unique solid colors
4. Collaborative Matching: All players must find and match the expected color to progress to the next segment

Music and Game Mechanics Integration

1. Music Selection: Selected popular songs immediately recognizable to elderly populations in North America
2. Music Layering: Created four different instrumental layers (melody, harmony 1, harmony 2, harmony 3)
3. Segment Division: Each instrumental layer equally divided into 16 different musical segments
4. Random Assignment: Each audio file randomly assigned an order of 1-16 and paired with tactile areas

Experimental Setup

Game Parameters

• Number of Players: 3
• Tactile Areas: 16 areas per controller
• Musical Segments: 16 segments per layer, 4 layers total
• Color System: Each tactile area corresponds to a unique color display

Design Features

1. No Formal Tutorial: Encourages players to actively explore the hardware
2. No Punishment Mechanism: Pressing incorrect areas incurs no penalty
3. Constant Difficulty: Difficulty remains unchanged throughout game progression
4. Progressive Rewards: Unlocking the next musical segment as reward

Experimental Results

Design Validation

As this is a design paper, it primarily demonstrates the design and implementation of the prototype system rather than traditional experimental results. The paper focuses on:

1. Prototype Implementation: Successfully constructed a complete system incorporating hardware controllers and software interface
2. Design Rationality: Validated the rationality of design choices through theoretical framework
3. Technical Feasibility: Demonstrated the technical feasibility of multimodal interaction and collaborative game mechanics

Design Effect Analysis

1. Central Role of Music: Music provides meaningful contextualization for the game, enhancing player engagement motivation
2. Collaborative Mechanics: Non-competitive design promotes teamwork rather than individual competition
3. Multimodal Interaction: The combination of auditory, visual, and tactile modalities provides rich sensory experience

Related Work

Serious Game Research

1. Traditional Games vs. Serious Games: Serious games aim to provide purposes beyond entertainment, such as skill development and meaning transmission
2. Serious Games for the Elderly: Primarily focus on physical and cognitive training to improve deteriorating physiological functions in elderly populations
3. Sound Design Impact: Sound design significantly influences user experience and attention in serious games

Theoretical Foundations

1. Capability Approach: Emphasizes individual functional capabilities and the non-material value of effective opportunities
2. Socially Responsible Design: Collaborative development design considering human diversity
3. Music and Emotion: Familiar music promotes emotional experience through anticipation and expectation

Conclusions and Discussion

Main Conclusions

1. Successful Prototype Design: Puzzlegram, as a serious game prototype specifically designed for the elderly, successfully integrated music, tactile interaction, and collaborative mechanics
2. Theoretical Framework Effectiveness: The capability approach provides effective theoretical guidance for serious game design
3. Critical Role of Music: Familiar music as a core design element effectively promotes meaningful interaction

Future Research Directions

1. Artificial Intelligence Integration: Adapting to different cognitive functional states through AI for monitoring purposes
2. Design Framework Development: Establishing a comprehensive framework for constructing purposeful serious games
3. User Research: Direct involvement of players in the design research process

Limitations

1. Lack of User Testing: The paper provides no actual user testing results
2. Single Music Selection: Only one song selected as prototype
3. Missing Evaluation Methods: Absence of objective effect evaluation metrics and methodologies

In-Depth Evaluation

Strengths

1. Innovative Design: Proposes an original multiplayer collaborative serious game concept with particular focus on elderly populations
2. Theoretical Support: Provides solid theoretical foundation through the capability approach framework
3. Multimodal Integration: Successfully integrates auditory, visual, and tactile interaction modalities
4. Social Value: Focuses on elderly empowerment rather than viewing them solely as care recipients, possessing significant social significance
5. Technical Implementation: Demonstrates complete system implementation combining hardware and software

Weaknesses

1. Lack of Empirical Validation: No actual user testing conducted to verify design effectiveness
2. Insufficient Evaluation Methods: Absence of objective cognitive training effect evaluation metrics
3. Limited Scalability: Designed only for three-player games; scalability remains to be verified
4. Cultural Adaptability: Music selection may have cultural limitations
5. Unknown Long-Term Effects: No exploration of long-term impacts on cognitive function

Impact

1. Academic Contribution: Provides new theoretical and practical frameworks for serious game design
2. Practical Value: Offers new technological solutions for elderly cognitive training
3. Interdisciplinary Significance: Combines game design, music therapy, cognitive science, and other fields
4. Reproducibility: Provides detailed design descriptions with certain reproducibility

Applicable Scenarios

1. Elderly Care Institutions: Suitable for use in nursing homes, community centers, and other group settings
2. Cognitive Training: Can be used for early intervention in mild cognitive impairment
3. Social Activities: Serves as a tool for promoting social interaction among elderly populations
4. Research Platform: Can serve as an experimental platform for researching elderly cognitive function

References

The paper cites 11 relevant references covering important research in serious games, capability approach theory, music and cognition, design methodology, and other fields, providing solid theoretical foundation and technical support for this research.

Summary: This is an innovative and socially valuable design research paper presenting a serious game prototype specifically designed for elderly populations. Although lacking empirical validation, its theoretical framework and design philosophy provide valuable directions and foundations for future research in this field.