Studying hard probe dynamics in QGP using effective field theory

Basic Information

• Paper ID: 2510.13942
• Title: Studying hard probe dynamics in QGP using effective field theory
• Authors: Andreas Kirchner, Berndt Mueller, Jyotirmoy Roy, Chathuranga Sirimanna (Duke University)
• Classification: hep-ph (High Energy Physics - Phenomenology), nucl-th (Nuclear Theory)
• Publication Date: October 15, 2025 (arXiv preprint)
• Paper Link: https://arxiv.org/abs/2510.13942

Abstract

This paper develops an effective field theory (EFT) framework to study the interactions of heavy quarks in strongly-coupled quark-gluon plasma (QGP). The QGP is treated as a relativistic non-dissipative colored fluid, which can be investigated using a derivative-coupled effective field theory based on previous work. Coupling this with heavy quarks provides a systematic approach to obtain the interaction between heavy quarks and phonons (fluid excitations). In particular, the authors calculate the decay width of heavy quarks to phonons in the thermal medium and phonon-heavy quark scattering.

Research Background and Motivation

Core Problems

1. QGP Fluid Behavior: The central paradigm of relativistic heavy-ion physics is that the quark-gluon plasma (QGP) behaves as a nearly "perfect" fluid, with kinematic viscosity approaching the quantum limit (ηkin = η/s ≈ 1/4π)
2. Heavy Quark Probes: Due to their large mass (M ≫ T), heavy quarks require multiple interactions with QGP constituents to significantly change their momentum, making them ideal probes for studying QGP properties
3. Effective Field Theory Approach: A systematic theoretical framework is needed to describe the collective interactions between heavy quarks and the QGP fluid

Research Significance

• Hydrodynamics applies to long-distance scales of all energy-conserving many-body systems
• The EFT method can capture the dynamical properties of many-body systems without explicitly treating microscopic details
• Important for understanding phenomenology of relativistic heavy-ion collisions

Limitations of Existing Methods

• Lack of a complete theoretical framework for systematically treating heavy quark-QGP fluid interactions
• High complexity of microscopic calculations, difficulty in handling strong coupling regime
• Need for better methods to describe competition between collective fluid-quark interactions and microscopic constituent interactions

Core Contributions

1. Established ϕ-EFT Framework: Developed phonon and heavy quark effective field theory (ϕ-EFT)
2. Systematic Coupling Scheme: Provided a systematic method for coupling heavy quarks with QGP fluid phonon excitations
3. Decay Width Calculations: First calculation of heavy quark decay width to phonons in thermal medium
4. Scattering Cross Sections: Derived analytical expressions for heavy quark-phonon scattering cross sections
5. Determined Applicability Range: Established the momentum scale range where EFT is valid (3T ≲ Λh ≲ 6T)

Methodology Details

Task Definition

Study the dynamical behavior of heavy quarks in strongly-coupled QGP, specifically:

• Input: Heavy quark four-momentum, QGP fluid parameters (temperature T, sound speed cs)
• Output: Decay width, scattering cross sections, transport coefficients
• Constraints: Momentum transfer |q⃗| < Λh, strong coupling condition Λh ≥ T

Theoretical Framework

1. Fluid Effective Field Theory Construction

The low-energy hydrodynamic degrees of freedom of QGP fluid are represented by three scalar fields:

ϕI = ϕI(t, x⃗), I = 1, 2, 3

Ground state configuration: ⟨ϕI(t, x⃗)⟩ = xI

Fluid current defined as:

Jμ = (1/3!)εμνρσεIJK∂νϕI∂ρϕJ∂σϕK

Lowest-order Lagrangian:

L = F(X), where X = JμJμ

2. Phonon Excitations

Displacement fluctuations around equilibrium:

ϕI = xI + λπI(t, x⃗)

Quadratic Lagrangian (after field redefinition):

L(2) = (1/2)(∂tπ⃗)² - (1/2)cs²(∇·π⃗)²

Sound speed: cs² = F'(1) + 2F''(1)/F'(1)

3. Heavy Quark Coupling

Extended Lagrangian includes:

L = F(X) + Zψ(X)ψ̄i/Dψ - M(X)ψ̄ψ + ZA(X)GaμνGμνa + 
    Q(X)ψ̄i←→Dμψ Jμ + R(X)ψ̄σμνψωμν

Technical Innovations

1. Systematic Gradient Expansion: Established systematic expansion scheme based on symmetry and power counting
2. UV Scale Determination: Identified UV scale Λh = ⁴√(-F'(1)) through higher-order operators
3. Dimensional Analysis: Introduced dimensionless Wilson coefficients, establishing natural suppression mechanism
4. Resonance Structure: Discovered resonance phenomena arising from spacelike dispersion relation of phonons

Experimental Setup

Physical Parameters

• Heavy Quark Mass: Charm quark mass m ≈ 1.3 GeV
• Temperature Range: T = 0.3-0.6 GeV
• Sound Speed: cs² = 1/2, 1/3, 1/4, 1/5
• UV Scale: Λh ∼ 3-6T

Computational Methods

• Perturbative calculations to leading order
• Numerical integration using adaptive Gauss-Kronrod quadrature
• Thermal distribution function effects included

Evaluation Metrics

1. Decay Width: Γ(p⃗') GeV
2. Scattering Cross Section: σ GeV⁻²
3. Dependence Relations: As functions of quark velocity, temperature, sound speed

Experimental Results

Main Results on Decay Width

1. Mach Condition: Heavy quark can only decay by emitting phonons when velocity v > cs
2. Temperature Dependence:
   • Low temperature: Γ ∝ T³ or T⁵ (limited by UV scale)
   • High temperature: Γ ∝ 1/T² (kinematic cutoff dominates)
3. Velocity Dependence: Optimal velocity exists that maximizes decay width

Scattering Cross Section Results

1. Angular Dependence:
   • Head-on collisions (large angle): σ → 0
   • Collinear limit (small angle): σ finite
   • Intermediate angles: Resonance peaks appear
2. Resonance Phenomena:
   • Peaks appear when intermediate state particles approach mass shell
   • Peak position and width depend on sound speed cs
   • Peak height ∝ 1/T
3. Momentum Dependence:
   • Resonances sharper at larger phonon momenta
   • Forms banded structure

Key Numerical Results

• For cs² = 1/3, T = 0.3 GeV case, typical decay width Γ ~ 0.1-0.5 GeV
• Scattering cross section peak σ ~ 1-3 GeV⁻²
• Resonance angle varies with sound speed: smaller cs gives broader resonance

Related Work

Hydrodynamic EFT

Based on work by Endlich et al. 1-6, this paper develops effective field theory framework for relativistic hydrodynamics, being the first to systematically extend it to include external probes.

Heavy Quark Transport

• Microscopic calculations: thermal perturbation theory 25,26 and holographic methods 22-24
• Phenomenological studies: Boltzmann equation and Fokker-Planck equation approaches
• This paper provides a bridge connecting microscopic and macroscopic descriptions

AdS/CFT Correspondence

Holographic calculations in strongly-coupled gauge theories provide benchmarks for determining Wilson coefficients, particularly results from N=4 super Yang-Mills theory.

Conclusions and Discussion

Main Conclusions

1. Successfully Established Framework: ϕ-EFT provides a systematic method for describing heavy quark interactions with strongly-coupled QGP
2. Discovered New Physics: Spacelike dispersion relation of phonons leads to rich resonance phenomena
3. Quantitative Predictions: Provided specific calculation formulas for decay width and scattering cross sections
4. Parameter Dependencies: Clarified dependence of physical quantities on temperature, sound speed, and other parameters

Limitations

1. Wilson Coefficients Undetermined: Need to be determined through experimental fitting or microscopic matching
2. Leading Order Approximation: Currently calculated only to leading order; higher-order corrections may be important
3. Ideal Fluid Assumption: Viscous effects not considered
4. Limited Applicability: Only valid for strongly-coupled regime with Λh ≥ T

Future Directions

1. Wilson Coefficient Matching: Plan to match with AdS/CFT results to determine M̃'(1)
2. Transport Coefficients: Calculate Boltzmann collision kernel and drag coefficients
3. Phenomenological Applications: Compare with experimental data to verify theoretical predictions
4. Extension to Light Quarks: Study similar processes for high-energy light quarks and gluons

In-Depth Evaluation

Strengths

1. Theoretical Innovation: First systematic EFT treatment of heavy quark-QGP interactions
2. Systematic Methodology: Rigorous theoretical framework based on symmetry and power counting
3. Complete Calculations: Full chain from Lagrangian construction to specific physical process calculations
4. Physical Insights: Discovery of new physics phenomena arising from spacelike nature of phonons
5. Clear Presentation: Detailed theoretical derivations with clear physical pictures

Weaknesses

1. Lack of Numerical Verification: Wilson coefficients undetermined, cannot directly compare with experiments
2. Approximation Level: Leading-order calculations may be insufficient for strongly-interacting systems
3. Narrow Applicability Range: Only valid for strong coupling with Λh ≥ T
4. Experimental Connection: Lacks direct comparison with existing heavy-ion collision experiments

Impact

1. Theoretical Contribution: Provides new theoretical tools for heavy quark transport theory
2. Methodological Value: EFT method can be generalized to other strongly-interacting systems
3. Practical Potential: Once Wilson coefficients are determined, can be applied to heavy-ion collision phenomenology
4. Interdisciplinary Significance: Methods may apply to probe dynamics in other fluids

Application Scenarios

1. Heavy-Ion Collisions: Heavy quark suppression and flow in RHIC and LHC experiments
2. Neutron Star Physics: Quark transport in high-density QCD matter
3. Early Universe: Heavy quark dynamics during quark-hadron phase transition
4. Cold Atom Systems: Impurity dynamics in strongly-interacting Fermi gases

References

The paper cites 37 important references, mainly including:

• Foundational work on hydrodynamic EFT 1-6
• Quasi-normal modes and holographic methods 9-11, 22-24
• QCD transport coefficient calculations 25-29
• Experimental observations 21

Overall Assessment: This is a high-quality theoretical physics paper that makes important innovations in heavy quark transport theory. Although it currently lacks direct experimental comparison, it provides new theoretical tools and physical insights for the field, possessing significant academic value and application potential.