Non-separable graphs meet Ledoux's polynomials

Basic Information

• Paper ID: 2510.14039
• Title: Non-separable graphs meet Ledoux's polynomials
• Author: Paul Mansanarez
• Classification: math.CO (Combinatorics)
• Publication Date: October 15, 2025
• Paper Link: https://arxiv.org/abs/2510.14039

Abstract

This paper investigates the combinatorial structure of multivariate polynomials $(R_n)_n$ involved in the integral representation of entropy derivatives of probability measures along heat flow, as established by Ledoux in his seminal work. These integral representations have important applications in information theory (such as entropy power inequality and monotonicity of Fisher information) and estimation theory (through the connection between entropy derivatives and minimum mean-square error (MMSE) in Gaussian channels). Although these polynomials arising from the Lie algebra framework play a central role, their combinatorial structure remains only partially understood. This paper proves that the number of monomials in $R_n$ equals the number of degree sequences with degree sum $2n$ that admit non-separable graph realizations, thereby resolving a conjecture in reference 8 and establishing an interesting connection between these two domains.

Research Background and Motivation

Problem Background

1. Integral representation of entropy derivatives: Ledoux established in reference 4 the integral representation of the n-th time derivative of entropy of a probability measure along heat flow: $\partial^n_t H(X + \sqrt{2t}N) = (-2)^{n-1} \int_{\mathbb{R}} \tilde{R}_n(u^{(2)}_t, \ldots, u^{(n)}_t)(x) dx$
2. Importance of polynomials: These representations involve multivariate polynomials $\tilde{R}_n = X_n^2 + R_n$, where $R_n$ is defined through recursive relations and has widespread applications in information theory and estimation theory.
3. Unclear combinatorial structure: Although these polynomials are theoretically important, their combinatorial structure remains incompletely understood.

Research Motivation

The authors of reference 8 proposed a conjecture while studying these polynomials: the number of monomials in $R_n$ equals $dns(n)-1$, where $dns(n)$ is the number of degree sequences with degree sum $2n$ that admit non-separable graph realizations. This paper aims to prove this conjecture and establish a connection between polynomial theory and graph theory.

Core Contributions

1. Proof of the main conjecture: Proved that the number of monomials in $R_n$ exactly equals $dns(n)-1$
2. Establishment of cross-disciplinary connections: Established profound combinatorial connections between Ledoux polynomial theory and non-separable graph theory
3. Constructive proof: Provided a constructive proof through analysis of the recursive structure of polynomials and properties of degree sequences in graph theory
4. Resolution of open problem: Resolved the combinatorial conjecture posed in reference 8

Detailed Methodology

Problem Definition

Prove that for integer $n > 2$, the number of terms in polynomial $R_n$ equals $dns(n)-1$, where $dns(n)$ denotes the number of non-separable graph degree sequences with degree sum $2n$.

Core Definitions and Notation

Recursive Definition of Polynomial $R_n$

$R_n$ is defined through the following recursive relation:

• $R_2 = 0$
• $R_{n+1} = A_n + L(R_n) + H(R_n)$

where:

• $A_n = -\sum_{k=1}^{n-1} \binom{n}{k} X_{1+k}X_{1+n-k}X_n$
• $L(X^{\alpha_1}_1 \cdots X^{\alpha_r}_r) = \sum_{1 \leq i < j \leq r} X^{\alpha_1}_1 \cdots X^{\alpha_i+1}_i \cdots X^{\alpha_j+1}_j \cdots X^{\alpha_r}_r$
• $H(X^{\alpha_1}_1 \cdots X^{\alpha_r}_r) = -\frac{1}{2} \sum_{k=1}^r \sum_{l=1}^{\alpha_k-1} \binom{\alpha_k}{l} X_{1+l}X_{1+\alpha_k-l} \prod_{i \neq k} X^{\alpha_i}_i$

Non-separable Graph Degree Sequences

Define $DNSG(n)$ as the set of finite sequences $d = (d_1, \ldots, d_r)$ satisfying:

1. $d_1 \geq \cdots \geq d_r \geq 2$
2. $\sum_{k=1}^r d_k = 2n$
3. $d_1 \leq d_2 + \cdots + d_r - 2r + 4$ (Hakimi condition)

Proof Strategy

Main Approach

Prove by induction that $I^*_n = DNSG(n)$, where $I^*_n$ denotes the index set corresponding to non-zero coefficients in $R_n$.

Key Lemma

Lemma 2.4: $I^*_{n+1} = \bigcup_{\alpha \in I^*_n} T_{n+1}(\alpha)$

This indicates that polynomial $A_{n+1}$ does not introduce more monomials to $R_{n+1}$ than $L(R_n)$ and $H(R_n)$.

Technical Innovations

1. Recursive structure analysis: Deep analysis of the correspondence between the recursive definition of polynomials and the construction of graph-theoretic degree sequences
2. Bidirectional inclusion proof: Proved both $DNSG(n+1) \subseteq \bigcup_{\alpha \in DNSG(n)} T_{n+1}(\alpha)$ and the reverse inclusion through two key lemmas
3. Combinatorial correspondence: Established precise correspondence between polynomial operations $L$ and $H$ and degree sequence transformations in graph theory

Experimental Setup

Theoretical Verification

This paper is primarily theoretical work, verified through concrete small examples:

Specific Examples

• $R_3 = -2X_2^3$
• $R_4 = -12X_2X_3^2 + 6X_2^4$
• $R_5 = -20X_2X_4^2 - 30X_3^2X_4 + 120X_2^2X_3^2 - 24X_2^5$

Degree Sequence Verification

For $n=3$ (degree sum equals 6), there are two non-separable graph degree sequences:

• $(3,3)$ corresponding graph: triple edge between two vertices
• $(2,2,2)$ corresponding graph: triangle

This is consistent with $R_3$ having only one monomial ($dns(3)-1 = 2-1 = 1$).

Experimental Results

Main Results

Theorem 1.1: For integer $n > 2$, the number of terms in $R_n$ equals $dns(n)-1$.

Proof Completeness

Complete proof was achieved through the following two key lemmas:

Lemma 3.1: For each $d \in DNSG(n+1)$, there exists $\alpha \in DNSG(n)$ such that $d \in T_{n+1}(\alpha)$

Lemma 3.2: For each $\alpha \in DNSG(n)$, we have $T_{n+1}(\alpha) \subseteq DNSG(n+1)$

Constructive Proof

The proof not only establishes quantitative equivalence but also provides a concrete construction method, demonstrating how each monomial in the polynomial corresponds to a specific non-separable graph degree sequence.

Related Work

Graph Theory Foundations

1. Hakimi's Theorem (1962): Characterizes which degree sequences admit non-separable graph realizations
2. Rødseth-Tverberg-Sellers Result: Provides explicit formula for $dns(2m)$: $dns(2m) = p(2m) - p(2m-1) - \sum_{j=0}^{m-2} p(j)$

Polynomial Theory

1. Ledoux's seminal work: Established integral representations of entropy derivatives
2. Γ-calculus framework: Applications of polynomials in iterated gradient theory of Markov diffusion operators
3. MMSE conjecture: Information-theoretic conjecture related to minimum mean-square error

Conclusions and Discussion

Main Conclusions

This paper successfully proved the exact correspondence between the number of monomials in Ledoux polynomial $R_n$ and the number of non-separable graph degree sequences, resolving the open conjecture in reference 8.

Theoretical Significance

1. Cross-disciplinary connections: Established profound connections between seemingly unrelated mathematical domains
2. Combinatorial insights: Provided new combinatorial perspectives for understanding the structure of these important polynomials
3. Methodological contributions: Demonstrated how to establish such correspondences through recursive structure analysis

Future Directions

1. Further explore relationships between polynomial coefficients and graph-theoretic properties
2. Investigate implications of this correspondence in information-theoretic applications
3. Seek other similar cross-disciplinary combinatorial correspondences

In-Depth Evaluation

Strengths

1. Problem importance: Resolves an open conjecture with theoretical significance
2. Rigorous proof: Provides complete constructive proof
3. Cross-disciplinary value: Establishes unexpected connections between polynomial theory and graph theory
4. Clear methodology: Proof strategy is clear with appropriate technical handling

Limitations

1. Limited applications: Primarily theoretical results; practical application value requires further exploration
2. Generalizability: Currently specific to Ledoux polynomials; generalization to other similar structures remains unclear
3. Computational complexity: Does not address computational complexity of related problems

Impact

1. Theoretical contribution: Provides new perspectives for cross-disciplinary research between combinatorics and information theory
2. Methodological value: Demonstrates effective methods for establishing cross-disciplinary connections through recursive structure analysis
3. Future research: May inspire further research on combinatorial structures of polynomials

Applicable Scenarios

1. Theoretical research: Theoretical research in combinatorics, graph theory, and information theory
2. Educational applications: Excellent example for demonstrating connections between different mathematical branches
3. Further research: Provides methodological reference for research on related polynomials and graph-theoretic problems

References

This paper primarily cites the following key references:

• 4 M. Ledoux, Heat Flow Derivatives and Minimal Mean-Square Error in Gaussian Noise
• 8 P. Mansanarez, G. Poly, Y. Swan, Derivatives of entropy and the MMSE conjecture
• 9 S. L. Hakimi, On realizability of a set of integers as degrees of the vertices of a linear graph
• 11 Ø. J. Rødseth, J. A. Sellers, and H. Tverberg, Enumeration of the degree sequences of non-separable graphs

Through rigorous mathematical proof, this paper successfully establishes profound connections between two seemingly unrelated mathematical domains, demonstrating the important value of cross-disciplinary thinking in mathematical research. Although primarily theoretical work, it provides new perspectives and methods for understanding the combinatorial structure of important mathematical objects.