Chiral Spin Symmetry

Basic Information

• Paper ID: 2510.14084
• Title: Chiral spin symmetry
• Author: L. Ya. Glozman (Institute of Physics, University of Graz, Austria)
• Classification: hep-ph hep-lat hep-th nucl-th
• Publication Date: October 15, 2025 (arXiv preprint)
• Paper Link: https://arxiv.org/abs/2510.14084

Abstract

This paper reviews the newly discovered chiral spin symmetry (CSS) in QCD, which is a symmetry of color charge and the constrained electric field component of QCD. This symmetry in the vacuum, observed through near-zero modes of the truncated Dirac operator, indicates that hadron masses in the light quark sector do not result from vacuum quark condensates, and confinement and chiral symmetry breaking are not directly related. The observation of this symmetry above the chiral symmetry restoration crossover temperature demonstrates that QCD remains in a confined state, where chirally symmetric quarks are bound into color singlets through the confining electric field. This QCD state is termed a stringy fluid. At temperatures Td far above Tch, chiral spin symmetry smoothly disappears, indicating that the confining electric field is screened and the system smoothly transitions to a quark-gluon plasma. The three-state picture is further confirmed by analyzing the Nc scaling behavior of energy density, pressure, and entropy density: Nc^0 scaling in the hadronic gas, Nc^1 in the stringy fluid, and Nc^2 in the quark-gluon plasma.

Research Background and Motivation

Core Questions

This research addresses fundamental questions regarding the origin of hadron masses and the phase structure in QCD:

1. Origin of Hadron Masses: The conventional view attributes hadron masses to spontaneous chiral symmetry breaking, but this lacks rigorous verification
2. Relationship Between Confinement and Chiral Symmetry: The interrelationship between confinement and chiral symmetry breaking remains unclear
3. QCD Phase Diagram Structure: The phase transition structure of high-temperature QCD matter is more complex than expected

Research Significance

1. Theoretical Foundation: Reexamines the fundamental mechanisms of mass generation in QCD
2. Experimental Connection: Provides new perspectives for understanding results from RHIC and LHC heavy-ion collision experiments
3. Phase Transition Physics: Reveals the fine structure of the QCD phase diagram, particularly the existence of intermediate phases

Limitations of Existing Methods

1. Traditional Models: σ-models, MIT bag model, constituent quark models all assume hadron masses originate from chiral symmetry breaking
2. Phase Transition Theory: Simple two-phase pictures (hadronic gas → quark-gluon plasma) cannot explain experimental observations
3. Lattice QCD: Lacks deep understanding of confinement mechanisms and the relationship with chiral symmetry

Core Contributions

1. Discovery of New Symmetry: Identifies and verifies chiral spin symmetry SU(2)CS in QCD and its flavor extensions SU(4) and SU(2NF)×SU(2NF)
2. Redefines Mass Origin: Demonstrates that hadron masses primarily originate from confining interactions rather than chiral symmetry breaking
3. Proposes Three-State Phase Diagram: Establishes a three-state picture of QCD: hadronic gas, stringy fluid, and quark-gluon plasma
4. Nc Scaling Theory: Provides theoretical predictions for Nc scaling behavior of thermodynamic quantities in different phases
5. Microscopic Model: Constructs explicit models demonstrating chiral symmetry restoration in confined states

Methodology Details

Definition of Chiral Spin Symmetry

Chiral spin symmetry SU(2)CS is defined through the following transformation: $\psi \rightarrow \psi' = \exp\left(i\frac{\varepsilon_n\Sigma_n}{2}\right)\psi$

where the generators are: $\Sigma_n = \{\gamma_0, -i\gamma_5\gamma_0, \gamma_5\}, \quad [\Sigma_a,\Sigma_b] = 2i\epsilon_{abc}\Sigma_c$

Symmetry Verification Methods

Low-Mode Truncation Technique

Artificially restores chiral symmetry by modifying the quark propagator: $S = S^{\text{Full}} - \sum_{i=1}^k \frac{1}{\lambda_i}|\lambda_i\rangle\langle\lambda_i|$

where $\lambda_i$ are eigenvalues of the Dirac operator and k is the number of truncated low modes.

Lattice QCD Calculations

Studies symmetry using temporal and spatial correlation functions:

• Temporal Correlation Function: $C_\Gamma^t(t) = \sum_{x,y,z} C_\Gamma(t,x,y,z)$
• Spatial Correlation Function: $C_\Gamma^s(z) = \sum_{x,y,t} C_\Gamma(t,x,y,z)$

Multiplet Classification

For J=1 mesons, the SU(4) multiplet structure comprises:

• 15-plet: Contains ρ, a₁, b₁, h₁ and other mesons
• Singlet: f₁ meson
• Complete 16-plet: Irreducible representation of SU(4)×SU(4)

Experimental Setup

Lattice QCD Simulations

• Lattice Sizes: Multiple sizes, such as 12×48³, 32×12, etc.
• Quark Masses: Physical mass parameters
• Temperature Range: From hadronic gas phase to high-temperature phase
• Dirac Operator: Chirally symmetric domain wall fermions

Evaluation Metrics

1. Degeneracy Measurement: Determines symmetry through correlation function overlap
2. Mass Evolution: Hadron mass variation with truncation parameter k
3. Thermodynamic Quantities: Temperature dependence of energy density, pressure, and entropy density
4. Conserved Charge Fluctuations: Nc scaling behavior of quark number fluctuations

Experimental Results

Symmetry Verification in Vacuum

Main Findings:

• All J=1 isovector mesons become degenerate after chiral symmetry restoration
• Observation of larger symmetry than expected: SU(4)×SU(4)
• Hadrons persist in the chirally symmetric world with substantial masses

Numerical Results:

• At truncation k=180, all J=1 meson masses converge to degeneracy
• Masses approximately 1000-1500 MeV, significantly larger than zero

Finite Temperature Results

Symmetry Emergence:

• Approximate SU(2)CS and SU(4) symmetry observed at T=220 MeV
• Both temporal and spatial correlation functions display clear multiplet structure
• Symmetry disappears above T~500 MeV

Three-State Structure Evidence:

1. Hadronic Gas (T < Tch ≈ 155 MeV): Broken chiral symmetry
2. Stringy Fluid (Tch < T < Td ≈ 300 MeV): Restored chiral symmetry + chiral spin symmetry
3. Quark-Gluon Plasma (T > Td): Chiral symmetry only

Nc Scaling Verification

Conserved Charge Fluctuations:

• Transition from Nc⁰ to Nc¹ scaling observed at Tch
• Completely consistent with theoretical predictions
• Provides independent evidence for the stringy fluid phase

Theoretical Models

Confined Chiral Symmetry Model

The author employs a 3+1 dimensional model similar to the 't Hooft model: $H = \int d³x \psi†(x⃗,t)\left(-iα⃗·∇⃗ + βm_q\right)\psi(x⃗,t) + \frac{1}{2}\int d³x d³y ρᵃ(x⃗)K^{ab}(|x⃗-y⃗|)ρᵇ(y⃗)$

Key Results:

• Critical temperature: Tch ≈ 0.084√σ
• Chiral restoration mechanism: Pauli blocking effect
• Meson size: Significantly increases at T > Tch

Related Work

Historical Development

1. Banks-Casher Relation: Connects quark condensate to Dirac operator spectral density
2. QCD Phase Transition Theory: From Hagedorn temperature to quark-gluon plasma concept
3. Lattice QCD Progress: Numerical studies of chiral crossover and confinement phase transitions

Novelty of This Work

• First systematic identification of chiral spin symmetry
• Proposes stringy fluid as a new phase state
• Establishes a complete three-state theoretical framework

Conclusions and Discussion

Main Conclusions

1. Reconceptualization of Mass Origin: Hadron masses primarily originate from confining interactions, with chiral symmetry breaking playing only a role in lifting degeneracies
2. Separation of Confinement and Chiral Symmetry: Confinement and chiral symmetry breaking are relatively independent phenomena, allowing chiral symmetry restoration within confined states
3. Complexity of QCD Phase Diagram: The QCD phase diagram contains three regions/phases, with the intermediate stringy fluid phase possessing unique properties
4. Experimental Implications: Strongly interacting matter observed at RHIC/LHC may be stringy fluid rather than quark-gluon plasma

Limitations

1. Model Dependence: Theoretical analysis depends on specific confinement models
2. Finite Size Effects: Lattice calculations contain systematic errors
3. Nc Extrapolation: Nc scaling predictions require verification through larger Nc simulations

Future Directions

1. Larger Nc Simulations: Lattice QCD calculations at Nc=5 to verify scaling behavior
2. Experimental Verification: Search for experimental signatures of the stringy fluid phase
3. Phenomenological Applications: Apply results to heavy-ion collision physics

In-Depth Evaluation

Strengths

1. Theoretical Innovation: Discovery of new symmetry represents important progress in QCD theory
2. Systematic Study: Complete picture from vacuum to finite temperature
3. Multiple Verifications: Lattice calculations, theoretical analysis, and phenomenological models mutually support each other
4. Experimental Relevance: Provides new theoretical framework for understanding heavy-ion collision experiments

Weaknesses

1. Technical Challenges: Physical interpretation of low-mode truncation method remains controversial
2. Numerical Precision: Statistical and systematic errors in lattice calculations require improvement
3. Phenomenological Verification: Lacks direct experimental evidence

Impact

1. Theoretical Impact: May change understanding of QCD phase transitions and hadron physics
2. Experimental Guidance: Provides new theoretical framework for heavy-ion collision experiments
3. Methodological Contribution: Low-mode truncation technique provides new tools for studying QCD vacuum structure

Applicable Scenarios

1. Hadron Physics: Understanding hadron mass spectra and excited state properties
2. QCD Phase Transitions: Studying phase behavior at finite temperature and density
3. Heavy-Ion Physics: Analyzing properties of matter produced in high-energy heavy-ion collisions

References

This paper cites 54 important references covering various aspects from QCD fundamental theory to lattice calculations, particularly:

• Original work on the Banks-Casher relation 1
• Theoretical foundations of chiral symmetry and QCD phase transitions 15-17
• Recent lattice QCD developments 19,20,31,32
• Series of works by the author's group 4-6,8,9,11,23-28

Overall Assessment: This is a review paper of significant theoretical importance that systematically expounds the newly discovered chiral spin symmetry in QCD and its profound implications for hadron physics and phase transition theory. Although certain technical details require further verification, the proposed three-state phase diagram concept and theoretical framework provide new perspectives for understanding the complexity of QCD.