Turn-on of Current-Induced Spin Torque upon Noncollinear Antiferromagnetic Ordering in Delafossite PdCrO2

Basic Information

• Paper ID: 2510.14103
• Title: Turn-on of Current-Induced Spin Torque upon Noncollinear Antiferromagnetic Ordering in Delafossite PdCrO2
• Authors: Xiaoxi Huang, Qi Song, Gautam Gurung, Daniel A. Pharis, et al. (from Cornell University, University of Nebraska, and other institutions)
• Classification: cond-mat.mtrl-sci (Condensed Matter Physics - Materials Science)
• Submission Date: October 15, 2025 to arXiv
• Paper Link: https://arxiv.org/abs/2510.14103

Abstract

This paper reports measurements of current-induced spin torque generated in the delafossite antiferromagnet PdCrO2, which acts on an adjacent ferromagnetic permalloy layer. The spin torque is significantly enhanced when temperature is lowered through the Néel temperature, at which point PdCrO2 transitions from a paramagnetic phase to a noncollinear antiferromagnetic state. These results are qualitatively consistent with density functional theory calculations, demonstrating the impact of antiferromagnetic ordering on spin current generation in PdCrO2.

Research Background and Motivation

Research Questions

Conventionally, the generation of current-induced torque requires strong spin-orbit coupling (SOC), which limits potential material candidates. This research aims to explore whether antiferromagnetic ordering can generate transverse spin currents without strong SOC.

Significance

1. Expanding the Material Palette for Spintronics: Traditional spin torque materials rely on strong SOC, limiting material choices
2. Theoretical Verification: Validating theoretical predictions that noncollinear and collinear antiferromagnetic ordering can generate transverse spin currents
3. Device Applications: Providing new strategies for improving magnetization control efficiency in spintronic devices

Existing Limitations

• Most antiferromagnets contain SOC, making it difficult to clearly identify systems where spin currents are generated primarily by antiferromagnetic ordering
• Lack of direct experimental evidence demonstrating the decisive role of antiferromagnetic ordering in spin torque generation

Research Motivation

PdCrO2 possesses a unique layered structure containing highly conductive palladium layers and Mott insulating CrO2 layers, where chromium sites form a 120° noncollinear structure, providing an ideal platform for investigating the effects of antiferromagnetic ordering on spin torque.

Core Contributions

1. First experimental demonstration that spin torque generation in PdCrO2 primarily depends on antiferromagnetic ordering rather than spin-orbit coupling
2. Discovery of significant temperature dependence: Spin torque is dramatically enhanced upon crossing the Néel temperature
3. Provision of theoretical support: Density functional theory calculations validate the experimentally observed phenomena
4. Revelation of thickness dependence: Demonstrating the bulk-origin characteristics of spin current generation

Methodology Details

Task Definition

Measuring current-induced spin torque generated by the delafossite antiferromagnet PdCrO2 on an adjacent ferromagnetic layer, and investigating its temperature and thickness dependence.

Experimental Architecture

1. Sample Preparation

• Thin Film Growth: Epitaxial PdCrO2 thin films grown on (0001) sapphire substrates using molecular beam epitaxy (MBE)
• Device Structure: PdCrO2/Permalloy (Py) bilayer structure
• Thickness Range: PdCrO2 thickness of 2.7-7 nm, Py thickness of 5 nm

2. Measurement Techniques

Second Harmonic Hall Measurement:

• Applied oscillating current: $I_0 = 10$ mA (peak), frequency $\omega = 17$ Hz
• Hall voltage expression: $V^{2\omega}_{XY} = D_Y \cos(\phi) + F_Y \cos(\phi)\cos(2\phi) + C$

where $D_Y$ contains damping-like torque contributions and $F_Y$ contains field-like torque contributions.

Spin Torque Ferromagnetic Resonance (ST-FMR):

• Mixed voltage expression: $V_{mix} = \frac{I_{rf}R_{AMR}}{2\alpha\omega_+} \sin 2\phi \cos\phi \times (F_S(H_{ext})\tau^0_{DL} + F_A(H_{ext})\frac{\omega^2}{\omega}\tau^0_z)$

3. Theoretical Calculations

Density functional theory (DFT) calculations of electronic band structures and spin Hall conductivity of PdCrO2 in both paramagnetic and antiferromagnetic states.

Technical Innovations

1. Material Selection: The layered structure of PdCrO2 provides a unique platform for studying antiferromagnetic ordering effects
2. Multiple Verification: Combining second harmonic Hall measurement and ST-FMR techniques for mutual verification
3. Temperature Control: Achieving paramagnetic-antiferromagnetic phase transition through temperature control for direct comparison of spin torque in both states

Experimental Setup

Sample Characteristics

• Structure: Delafossite structure, space group R3̄m
• Resistivity: 93 μΩ·cm at room temperature, 60.5 μΩ·cm at 2K
• Néel Temperature: Approximately 22-30K in thin films (37.5K in bulk material)

Measurement Conditions

• Temperature Range: 2-60K
• Magnetic Field Strength: Up to 9T
• Device Dimensions: Hall bar width 20 μm, Hall probe width 5 μm

Evaluation Metrics

• Damping-like Spin Torque Efficiency: $\xi^Y_{DL} = \frac{2e}{\hbar}\frac{\Delta B_{DL}}{J_{AF}}M_s t_{Py}$
• Spin Hall Ratio: $\xi_{SH} = 0.027$ (for 2.7 nm PdCrO2)
• Spin Hall Conductivity: $\sigma_{SH} = 6.8 \times 10^3 (\hbar/2e)\Omega^{-1}m^{-1}$

Experimental Results

Main Results

1. Temperature Dependence

• Key Finding: Spin torque is dramatically enhanced upon crossing the Néel temperature (~25-30K)
• Comparative Data:
  • 10K (antiferromagnetic state): Significant nonlinear $D_Y$ dependence on $B_{ext}$
  • 50K (paramagnetic state): Approximately linear relationship, damping-like torque near zero

2. Thickness Dependence

Experimental findings show that spin torque efficiency increases with PdCrO2 thickness:

• 2.7 nm < 5 nm < 7 nm
• Indicating bulk-origin mechanism with spin diffusion length of several nanometers

3. ST-FMR Verification

ST-FMR measurements confirm the results of second harmonic Hall measurements, with $\xi_{DL}/\xi_{FL}$ ratio significantly increasing at low temperatures.

Theoretical Calculation Results

Density Functional Theory Predictions

• Antiferromagnetic State: $\sigma_{SH} = 8.2 \times 10^3 (\hbar/2e)\Omega^{-1}m^{-1}$
• Paramagnetic State: $\sigma_{SH} = 3.3 \times 10^3 (\hbar/2e)\Omega^{-1}m^{-1}$
• Ratio: Antiferromagnetic state approximately 2.5 times higher than paramagnetic state

Spin Berry Curvature Analysis

The antiferromagnetic phase exhibits larger spin Berry curvature hotspot regions, explaining the experimentally observed enhancement of spin Hall conductivity.

Experimental Findings

1. Phase Transition-Driven Spin Torque: Spin torque generation is primarily driven by magnetic ordering rather than spin-orbit coupling
2. Symmetry Constraints: For (0001)-oriented PdCrO2, damping-like torque is limited to in-plane and perpendicular to charge current directions
3. Temperature-Independent Field-Like Torque: Field-like torque exhibits negligible temperature dependence near the Néel temperature

Related Work

Antiferromagnetic Spintronics

• Theoretical Foundation: Železný et al. predicted that noncollinear antiferromagnetic ordering can generate spin currents
• Experimental Progress: Spin torque studies in materials such as Mn₃Ir and Mn₃Sn
• Advantages of This Work: First clear demonstration of the dominant role of antiferromagnetic ordering

Delafossite Materials

• Structural Features: Unique structure with alternating highly conductive and magnetic insulating layers
• Physical Phenomena: Quantum oscillations, anomalous Hall effect, and other exotic physics
• Contribution of This Work: First report of spin torque characteristics in PdCrO2

Conclusions and Discussion

Main Conclusions

1. Antiferromagnetic Ordering Dominates: Spin torque generation in PdCrO2 primarily depends on antiferromagnetic ordering rather than SOC
2. Significant Phase Transition Effects: Spin torque is dramatically enhanced upon crossing the Néel temperature
3. Theory-Experiment Consistency: DFT calculations are qualitatively consistent with experimental results

Limitations

1. Thickness Constraints: Due to spin diffusion length limitations, maximum efficiency of thicker samples could not be measured
2. Field-Like Torque Separation: Difficulty in completely separating field-like spin-orbit torque and Oersted field contributions
3. Temperature Range: Experiments primarily concentrated in the low-temperature regime

Future Directions

1. Material Optimization: Exploring similar materials with higher Néel temperatures
2. Device Applications: Developing practical devices based on antiferromagnetic spin torque
3. Mechanism Deepening: Further understanding the microscopic mechanisms of spin current generation from antiferromagnetic ordering

In-Depth Evaluation

Strengths

1. Strong Innovation: First clear demonstration of the dominant role of antiferromagnetic ordering in spin torque generation
2. Rigorous Experiments: Mutual verification using two independent measurement techniques
3. Theoretical Support: DFT calculations provide strong theoretical backing
4. Systematic Study: Comprehensive investigation across multiple dimensions including temperature and thickness

Weaknesses

1. Limited Temperature Range: Primarily concentrated at low temperatures, limiting room-temperature applications
2. Relatively Low Efficiency: Compared to traditional SOC materials, efficiency still has room for improvement
3. Mechanism Explanation: Microscopic mechanism interpretation requires further investigation

Impact

1. Academic Value: Provides important experimental evidence for the antiferromagnetic spintronics field
2. Application Prospects: Provides material basis for developing novel spintronic devices
3. Methodological Contribution: Establishes standard experimental methods for studying antiferromagnetic spin torque

Applicable Scenarios

1. Basic Research: Investigation of spin transport properties in antiferromagnetic materials
2. Device Development: Material selection for low-power spintronic devices
3. Theory Verification: Validating theoretical predictions in antiferromagnetic spintronics

References

The paper cites 48 important references covering key works in spin-orbit torque, antiferromagnetic spintronics, delafossite materials, and related fields, providing a solid theoretical foundation and experimental comparison for the research.

Overall Assessment: This is a high-quality experimental physics paper that makes important contributions to the field of antiferromagnetic spintronics. Through carefully designed experiments and theoretical calculations, it successfully demonstrates the dominant role of antiferromagnetic ordering in spin torque generation, providing important experimental evidence and theoretical guidance for the development of this field.