The 2025 Failed Outburst of IGR J17091-3624: Spectral Evolution and the Role of Ionized Absorbers

Basic Information

• Paper ID: 2510.14134
• Title: The 2025 Failed Outburst of IGR J17091-3624: Spectral Evolution and the Role of Ionized Absorbers
• Authors: Oluwashina K. Adegoke, Javier A. García, Guglielmo Mastroserio, Elias Kammoun, Riley M. T. Connors, James F. Steiner, Fiona A. Harrison, Douglas J. K. Buisson, Joel B. Coley, Benjamin M. Coughenour, Thomas Dauser, Melissa Ewing, Adam Ingram, Erin Kara, Edward Nathan, Maxime Parra, Daniel Stern, John A. Tomsick
• Classification: astro-ph.HE (High Energy Astrophysics)
• Publication Date: Draft version October 17, 2025
• Paper Link: https://arxiv.org/abs/2510.14134

Abstract

IGR J17091-3624 is the only black hole X-ray binary candidate, besides the renowned GRS 1915+105, observed to exhibit extensive structured variability patterns. In 2025, this source underwent a "failed" outburst: it brightened in the hard state but returned to quiescence within weeks without transitioning to the soft state. The research team analyzed the spectral evolution and timing characteristics during the outburst using six NuSTAR pointed observations. For the first time, intense flux dip phenomena lasting approximately 4 kiloseconds were detected in this source, attributed to partial obscuration by ionized material with a column density of approximately $2.0 \times 10^{23} \, \mathrm{cm^{-2}}$.

Research Background and Motivation

Scientific Questions

1. Outburst Mechanisms in Black Hole X-ray Binaries: Understanding how black hole binary systems evolve from the hard state to the soft state, and the physical mechanisms underlying "failed" outbursts
2. Uniqueness of IGR J17091-3624: As the only black hole candidate displaying complex variability similar to GRS 1915+105, its study is crucial for understanding extreme accretion processes
3. Origin of Obscuration Phenomena: The flux dip phenomenon observed for the first time in this source requires in-depth analysis of its physical mechanisms

Research Significance

• IGR J17091-3624 serves as a bridge connecting "normal" black hole binaries and the extreme source GRS 1915+105
• This source is 20-30 times fainter than GRS 1915+105 yet displays similar complex variability, challenging existing high-accretion-rate theoretical models
• The system's mass, distance, and orbital parameters remain poorly constrained, limiting understanding of its physical properties

Limitations of Existing Approaches

• Previous observations primarily focused on complex variability studies in the soft or intermediate states
• Lack of systematic spectral analysis of hard state evolution processes
• Obscuration phenomena had never been reported in this source previously

Core Contributions

1. First Systematic Analysis of IGR J17091-3624's Hard State Evolution During Failed Outburst: Tracking 9 weeks of spectral evolution through six NuSTAR observations
2. First Detection and Analysis of Obscuration Phenomena in This Source: Intense flux dips observed in the fifth epoch, determined to be caused by ionized absorbers
3. Provision of System Parameter Constraints: Constraining the system's mass, distance, and orbital period based on spectral-photometric correlations and obscuration analysis
4. Revelation of Coronal Property Evolution: Discovery that coronal properties evolve with luminosity while accretion disk reflection features remain stable across the first five epochs

Methodology Details

Observational Data and Processing

NuSTAR Observations:

• 6 pointed observations spanning February 16 to April 20, 2025
• Exposure times: 18.9-33.6 kiloseconds
• Energy range: 3-79 keV
• Data processing using nustardas v.2.1.4a and caldb v20250317

Spectral Extraction:

• Source region: circular region with radius 100-150"
• Background region: source-free region of equal size
• Spectral grouping: minimum 40 counts per bin using "optmin" flag

Spectral Analysis Methods

Base Model:

cons*TBabs(simplcut*diskbb+relxilllpCp)

Model Components:

• TBabs: Interstellar medium photoelectric absorption (NH = 1.1×10²² cm⁻²)
• simplcut: Empirical Comptonization model
• diskbb: Multi-temperature blackbody accretion disk model
• relxilllpCp: Relativistic reflection model (lamppost geometry)

Key Parameters:

• Inclination angle i: 37°±4° from joint fitting
• Spin parameter a*: 0.947±0.045
• Coronal height h: 3-4 rg for the first 5 epochs, 13.9 rg for epoch 6

Obscuration Analysis

XSTAR Modeling:

• XSTAR-generated ionized absorber grids
• Parameter ranges: NH = 10¹⁸-10²⁴ cm⁻², log ξ = -1 to 4
• Gas density assumption: 10¹⁴ cm⁻³
• Source luminosity: 10³⁸ erg s⁻¹

Fitting Results:

• Absorber column density: NH ≈ 2×10²³ cm⁻²
• Ionization parameter: log ξ ≈ 2.2 erg cm s⁻¹

Timing Analysis

Power Density Spectrum Analysis:

• Time resolution: 0.001 seconds
• Segment length: 100 seconds
• Frequency range: 0.01-500 Hz
• Analysis performed using the Stingray software package

Experimental Results

Spectral Evolution

Coronal Property Evolution:

• Photon index Γ decreases from 1.65 (epoch 1) to 1.56 (epoch 6)
• Coronal temperature kTe rises from ~25 keV (epochs 1-5) to 155 keV (epoch 6)
• Exhibits a "harder when brighter" positive correlation

Reflection Features:

• Reflection strength Rstr remains at ~20% for the first 5 epochs
• Significantly decreases to ~13% in epoch 6
• Iron Kα emission line and Compton hump features clearly visible

Flux Evolution:

• 2-10 keV flux decreases from 4.55×10⁻¹⁰ (epoch 1) to 1.02×10⁻¹⁰ erg cm⁻² s⁻¹ (epoch 6)
• Overall decline of approximately 4.5 times

Obscuration Phenomena Analysis

Light Curve Characteristics:

• Five dip events observed in epoch 5
• Flux decreases to 15% of the persistent level at deepest points
• More pronounced decreases at lower energies, resulting in spectral hardening

Spectral Modeling:

• Persistent spectrum consistent with epoch 4
• Dip spectrum requires additional ionized absorber
• Fitting quality: χ²/dof = 567/546

Timing Characteristics

Quasi-Periodic Oscillations (QPOs):

• Stable ~0.21 Hz QPO detected in all first 5 epochs
• No QPO detected in epoch 6 (possibly due to low flux)
• QPO frequency remains unchanged during dip periods

Power Spectrum Evolution:

• Integrated rms amplitude remains at 24.5%-28.2%
• Low-frequency variability enhanced during dip periods

System Parameter Constraints

Mass-Distance Relation

Based on Γ-LX/LEdd correlation:

• Positive Correlation Branch: Distance >10 kpc excluded (corresponding to black hole mass >30 M☉)
• Negative Correlation Branch: Allows larger distances
• 10 M☉ Black Hole: Predicted distance 6-11 kpc
• Neutron Star Mass Limit: Distance 3-5 kpc

Orbital Period Constraints

Based on companion star irradiation model:

• 3-day Period: Significant mass loss occurs at distance >7 kpc
• 0.05-day Period: Mass loss occurs at distance >2 kpc
• NICER Data: Suggests approximately 3-day orbital period

Obscuration Mechanism Discussion

Possible Origins

Companion Star Stripping Model:

• X-ray irradiation causes outer layers of companion star to be stripped
• Stripped material forms clumpy structures
• Irradiation flux must reach 10¹¹-10¹² erg cm⁻² s⁻¹

Accretion Stream Impact Model:

• Material stream collides with outer disk producing thick structures
• Ionization instabilities form cold dense clouds
• Clouds periodically obscure the X-ray source

Geometric Constraints

Inclination Angle Discrepancy:

• Reflection modeling: inclination ~40°
• Obscuration phenomena: typically require high inclination (60-80°)
• Possible explanation: inner-outer disk misalignment or unique intermediate inclination range

In-Depth Evaluation

Strengths

1. High-Quality Observational Data: NuSTAR's broad energy coverage and high time resolution provide excellent data
2. Advanced Analysis Methods: Utilization of state-of-the-art relativistic reflection models and ionized absorption modeling
3. Important First Discovery: First detection of obscuration phenomena in IGR J17091-3624, providing new clues for understanding system geometry
4. Systematic Study: Complete tracking of failed outburst evolution process

Limitations

1. Model Dependency: System parameter constraints depend on empirical correlations with inherent uncertainties
2. Unresolved Inclination Angle Discrepancy: Significant differences between inclination angles implied by reflection modeling and obscuration phenomena
3. Single Obscuration Event: Obscuration observed in only one epoch, limiting statistical analysis
4. Uncertain Orbital Period: 3-day orbital period results from NICER not detailed in this paper

Scientific Impact

1. Theoretical Significance: Provides important observational constraints for understanding failed outburst mechanisms in black hole binaries
2. Methodological Contribution: Demonstrates the power of multi-wavelength, multi-epoch observations in constraining system parameters
3. Future Research Directions: Provides foundation for subsequent NICER data analysis and multi-wavelength observations

Applicable Scenarios

• Spectral evolution studies of black hole X-ray binaries
• Physical mechanism analysis of obscuration phenomena
• System parameter constraint methodology research
• Relativistic reflection spectroscopy applications

Conclusions and Prospects

Through systematic analysis of IGR J17091-3624's 2025 failed outburst, this study reveals the evolution patterns of coronal properties during hard state evolution, and detects and analyzes obscuration phenomena in this source for the first time. The research results are significant for constraining the system's fundamental parameters and provide new observational evidence for understanding the physical properties of such unique celestial objects. Future combination with observations from other telescopes such as NICER is expected to further refine our understanding of this system.

References

This paper cites extensive related research, primarily including:

• Historical observations of IGR J17091-3624 (Kuulkers et al. 2003; Altamirano et al. 2011)
• Black hole binary outburst theory (Done et al. 2007; Belloni et al. 2011)
• Relativistic reflection models (Dauser et al. 2014; García et al. 2014)
• Comparative studies of similar sources such as GRS 1915+105